Status
Description
Fiction. Literature. Suspense. Thriller. Imagine that your husband wrote you a letter, to be opened after his death. Imagine, too, that the letter contains his deepest, darkest secret - something with the potential to destroy not just the life you built together, but the lives of others as well. Imagine, then, that you stumble across that letter while your husband is still very much alive... Cecilia Fitzpatrick has achieved it all - she's an incredibly successful businesswoman, a pillar of her small community, and a devoted wife and mother. Her life is as orderly and spotless as her home. But that letter is about to change everything, and not just for her: Rachel and Tess barely know Cecilia - or each other - but they too are about to feel the earth-shattering repercussions of her husband's secret.… (more)
User reviews
Two news stories this week sickened me and highlighted how repellent a message Moriarty is advancing.
Near Santa Barbara an over-privileged young man who looked at women as things, like cars or video games, killed 7 people. He did this because girls chose to have sex with men that were not him. Some people seemed to think this was unfortunate but understandable. Because women apparently exist to serve men, and any rejection of a man might reasonably end in death. (Though all seem to agree it is better when murder does not occur.) An old quote from Margaret Atwood made its way into the online discussion of this story: "Men are afraid that women will laugh at them. Women are afraid that men will kill them." So sad and so true. So of course this is exactly what happens in the book. And though everyone is careful to state that Janie's laughter is no excuse for her murder, it somehow seems that the fact of the laughter makes them understand the murder. Once they know that Janie told John Paul she did not want to be his girlfriend and that laughed at him, they saw it was one horrible mistake caused by his feeling of rejection, and his own sense of guilt was punishment enough. Even Janie's own mother seems to come to this conclusion after she does something malicious and potentially deadly in a moment of rage and impotence. What?! Most murders are one mistake in a moment of anger. There would be a lot of murderers roaming free if we all got a mulligan for that first murder. So sure is this book that laughing at a man makes a woman (or in this case a girl) culpable in her own murder that the book seeks to absolve Janie of that perceived guilt by stressing that she laughed from nervousness. Of course she would never have laughed at a boy other than from nervousness. Because the laugh was involuntary we should feel bad about her murder, where we might not if she was a bitch. This is so offensive, so sexist, so dangerous that it brings tears to my eyes. But, of course the book does have John Paul pay for his crime in a way, and that way makes me even a little sicker.
The theory here is that John Paul's punishment comes in the form of the maiming of his young child by the mother of his victim. So...the second news story this week that tied into this book was Toni Braxton stating that God had made her child autistic because she had had an abortion. This book uses the same theory, that God punished the parent by hurting an innocent child. My horror at this is limitless, but I will say only two things. First, I am a person of faith, but if I had been taught that God hurts children to exact retribution on their parents I would be an atheist for sure. Second, the State should step in and remove children from any parent that believes that their children are a punishment from God.
So in sum, this book is not particularly well written, but is also not poorly written, and is a light enough read if you have time to waste as long as you don't give a moment's thought to the sick, foul, festering "moral" of the story.
It tells the stories of three women whose lives connect in ways they never could have imagined and it all
It was spoiled at times by the language, is it really necessary to have so much swearing and the sex scenes were frequently there just for effect and not needed.
However this is a really interesting premise to base a book on although the secret isn't particulary difficult to work out and comes relatively early in the book. How the secret is dealt with and the fallout from is very cleverly done and we are drawn in to the lives of these very ordinary seeming women.
The ending is very cleverly done with making you think about how our actions can have long lasting consequences/
I will look out for this author in the future.
The characters are established in the first three
I highly recommend this very entertaining novel.
Rachel becomes convinced she knows the identity of her daughter’s killer. The women’s reactions to these pivotal “realizations” impact the lives of many others.
I chose this book to read during an 8-hour plane flight and, by sheer chance, I chose well. It is a light read that does require much thought. I could put it down and pick it up easily three weeks later when I was taking a return 8-hour flight. It maintained my interest sufficiently so I did actually finish it, but it is fluff.
None of the three women is particularly likeable because of the decisions they make. Though a reader may feel some sympathy for the situations in which the women find themselves, it is impossible not to see that the women also bear some responsibility for what befalls them – the murder of Rachel’s daughter being an obvious exception. And inaction, infidelity, and impulsiveness do not endear these women to this reader. The author made an attempt to portray them as dynamic characters who learn something about themselves, but what they learn would be evident to virtually everyone. One of the women, for example, realizes that love after years of marriage is “an entirely different feeling from the uncomplicated, unstinting adoration she’d felt as a young bride.” Really?!!
The epilogue left me shaking my head. In it the author reveals some secrets about the characters, secrets which, had they been known, would have changed people’s lives. She concludes with this paragraph: “None of us ever know all the possible courses our lives could have and maybe should have taken. It’s probably just as well. Some secrets are meant to stay secret forever. Just ask Pandora.” This suggests, again, that the author tried to write interpretive fiction, but missed the lesson about letting the work speak for itself.
This would be a perfect book to serialize in a women’s magazine, were such things still done.
Eh. I doubt I would've finished this if it wasn't a book club selection. I just didn't care about any of the characters or how the story was going to end.
It's definitely not going into the stack of books I consider to be riveting. ;-) I'd throw it in the stack of stories
I don't agree with any of the choices made by the characters. I don't think real people would make the decisions these characters made.
I find it hard to believe that forgiveness could be given so quickly in some of the instances in the story. I mean, come on, someone does something that drastically changes your life completely in a negative way...you're not going to forgive them within a few days or 50 pages at the end of a book.
Someone murders your child & you sit around angry for 20+ years...you find out who...you're not going to sit around thinking about what you should do. I'm pretty sure you'll decide 1 of 2 things: either you're going to murder that person or you're going to tell the police.
You find out that your husband murdered someone when he was 17? You don't stay with him or keep his secret for the sake of your children. You leave that psycho & turn him in to the police. Especially if the only reason he can come up with for murdering the person is "She laughed at me & I got angry." Really? You're going to take your chances with that kind of person in your life. Really? Anytime he did something stupid & you wanted to laugh...you'd have that voice in the back of your head saying "Don't laugh. Remember what happened to that one girl that laughed at him?"
Your best friend who is also your cousin steals your husband? You're not going to forgive her or your husband within a week. You just don't allow people like that to remain in your life. So what if she was your one & only friend? You go find better friends. So what if your kid is going to be sad if you get a divorce? You don't sacrifice your self respect so that your kid can grow up in a home with married parents. I mean, seriously...if your husband thinks it's a fantastic idea for him to move his new love into your home so you can be one big happy family...you run for the hills or suggest that he move to a compound where it's acceptable to have multiple wives. Sure, it starts with him just moving her in...next thing you know...you have the hair style & fashion sense of Nikki from Big Love. You don't forgive him a week later when he claims that he made a mistake & really loves you...not your best friend/cousin. If he really loved you, he never would've suggested that you move into the guest bedroom while your best friend/cousin takes your place in the master bedroom. "Normal" people don't suggest that you let the other woman move in & play house with you.
Basically...it's a story full of selfish people making selfish decisions while pretending to care about the people they hurt while making selfish decisions. The only decision I agreed with that these characters made was to eat hot cross buns for breakfast...and only because they were drenched in butter...and damn...I love butter.
Imagine your husband wrote you a letter, to be opened after his death. Imagine, too, that the letter contains his deepest, darkest secret—something with the potential to destroy not only the life you have built together, but the lives of others as well. And then imagine that you
Cecilia Fitzpatrick has achieved it all—she’s an incredibly successful businesswoman, a pillar of her small community, a devoted wife and mother. Her life is as orderly and spotless as her home. But that letter is about to change everything—and not just for her. There are other women who barely know Cecilia—or each other—but they, too, are about to feel the earth-shattering repercussions of her husband’s secret.
After reading Big Little Lies and loving it, I finally got around to picking up The Husband's Secret. A lot of people seem to prefer The Husband's Secret over her newer book, but I happen to disagree. Although I really quite enjoyed this one, it didn't have as much of a surprise factor for me as Big Little Lies. I had a hunch pretty early on that
There are three women at the heart of the story: Cecilia, who finds a letter from her
The mystery of the letter takes a long time to be revealed, and to be honest I'd guessed what it was going to be by the time I read it, but that didn't matter. The characters were well-written and the story contained interesting moral dilemmas that made me think about what I would do in those circumstances. The ending of the book is particularly clever in that respect.
I found this to be a page-turner, a nice easy to read story and very enjoyable indeed.
Although fairly sedate at the start while the author introduces us to the three main characters – Cecilia, Tess and Rachel – it is not long, however, before this book gathers momentum, rapidly picks up speed and “literally” grabs you!
A startling and
What is revealed is so startlingly unexpected I audibly gasped!!! I did not see that coming AT ALL!!
From then on the author deftly inter weaves the lives of all the characters together and, through the use of cleverly crafted short chapters, manipulates the reader to keep turning the pages.
It is a story synonymous with that of Pandora’s Box; it’s a story of the far-reaching effects of opening a small, and seemingly innocuous, letter. How secrets can change and unravel so many lives. It is about accountability, responsibility, trust, love and forgiveness; it’s about the things we know and about the things we don’t know: about the twists and turns of fate and whether we truly get to decide our direction in life.
This is the first of Liane Moriarty’s books that I have read and I shall certainly be reading more of her books. A real page turner and a brilliant read! Engrossing, gripping and wholeheartedly absorbing - you will simply NOT want to put this book down!
Ultimately, the ending turned out to be surprising, yet very satisfying. It’s hard to go into detail without spoiling the plot. The Husband’s Secret would be an awesome book club pick – there is so much to discuss. And I think most women will relate to at least one of the three women in the book and wonder what the heck they would do if put into the same situation as Rachel, Tess or Cecilia. With this book, Ms. Moriarty has earned a spot in my list of favorite authors – I can’t wait to see what she comes up with next.
The Husband's Secret centers around three women: Cecilia Fitzpatrick, Tess O'Leary, and Rachel Crowley. All three are tangentially related via the secret but when the novel opens they don't know that yet. The husband referred to in the title is the husband of Cecilia, John-Paul (fyi, I don't know why, but reading this hyphenated name over and over again really drove me crazy. Just call him JP people!). Cecilia and JP have three daughters and live a very happy, very suburban life. However, one day when JP is on a business trip, Cecilia stumbles upon a letter that was written to her when their first daughter was born by her husband to Cecilia to only be opened in the event of his death. Cecilia is shocked to find this letter and asks JP about it. Having made the decision not to open it already, when she talks to JP he is so weird about the whole thing that she knows what is in the letter has to be damaging so now she really wants to open it. Contained within is the secret and holey moley people, what an earth-shattering secret it is!
Meanwhile, Rachel Crowley works at the school where Cecilia's three daughters go. Rachel's daughter used to attend this same school as well, but then she was murdered when she was just a teenager. They never caught the murderer and Rachel has been haunted by this the rest of her life. She is consumed by it.
Finally, we have Tess O'Leary. She too is happily married with one young son. One day her husband and her best-friend/cousin, Felicity, announce to Tess that they have fallen in love. Naturally, this shatters her world and she grabs her son and flees to her mother's house and quickly enrolls her son in the same school where Rachel works and Cecilia's children attend.
All three stories I found equally fascinating and once the secret is revealed you really want to understand how the women deal with it. Who knows how you would react to something equally earth-shattering. It's hard to explain how emotional this book is without revealing too much but I am trying to do my best. Let's just say when you read it, you want to talk about it. I was telling my husband the plot and his eyes were getting bigger as he was finding it more and more fascinating and twisted. This book would be perfect for a movie! Please, I urge you, read this book, you will not be disappointed!
This book follows three different women;
Cecilia's husband's secret is not that hard to figure out but I feel like the story is still interesting. I love that the story switched the point-of-view between the three women. I really enjoyed all of the women's stories and liked how they sort of intertwined. I was so hooked in this book and just didn't want to put it down. I just felt this spark of electricity run through me as I read this book.
I absolutely loved the ending and how it showed what could have happened if certain characters had taken different actions. I would highly recommend this book, especially to book clubs.
I enjoyed The Husband’s Secret. It’s not a whodunit because the reader finds out way before the end of the novel. I think it’s more a whatwouldyoudo? That makes it a perfect choice for book
I enjoyed this entertaining novel. One minute it’s dramatic and the next it’s quite funny. Liane Moriarty is a gifted story teller (I loved What Alice Forgot) and I look forward to reading more of her novels. Recommended.
The basic premise, the one that the blurb points to, is a sort of retelling of Pandora's box, a woman's life transfigured when she opens something she perhaps oughtn't. On a basic level, this is true. Cecilia Fitzpatrick does find a letter addressed to her to be opened on the event of her husband John-Paul's death. She calls him to ask about it, and he makes her promise not to open it. She agrees, but secrets it away curious. When John-Paul comes home early from his business trip and ventures in the middle of the night into the attic, which he avoids due to claustrophobia, to claim the letter, Cecilia pulls it from its hiding place and reads. From this moment, a certain chaos does enter the world, and lives and marriages are tested.
What the blurb only barely hints at is that this story is not just about Cecilia. Tess and Rachel are but a footnote of the blurb, but they have equal share in the story of The Husband's Secret. Though initially not tied together seemingly in any way, the lives of the three weave together inexorably as the pages pass. The story is a dark one, moving and gorgeously-written.
Though the subject matter may be a bit melodramatic, I found the story endlessly compelling and it almost made me cry, which is the equivalent of saying most readers will want to keep a box of tissues handy; I am not one who cries easily. Despite the scale of the drama within, The Husband's Secret actually feels quite down to earth, thanks to the personalities of these three women who inhabit its pages. Rachel, Tess, and Cecilia are all good women, whose lives have been thrown off kilter by personal tragedies, past or present.
Cecilia does it all. She's a brilliant wife, mother, homemaker, and brings in a hefty income doing Tupperware parties. She appears to other women, like Rachel and Tess, as one of those women who has everything together, and who has been blessed in life. Cecilia's three daughters are bright and affectionate. She and her husband love one another deeply, and have, until very recently, always had a very satisfying sex life. Opening the later, though, must change everything, one way or another. And, no, the letter's not about a secret affair.
Tess, like Cecilia, is a woman of vast achievement. She's a successful account manager for the advertising company she runs with her husband, Will, and cousin (also best friend) Felicity. Her son, Liam, is the source of some concern, as he is being bullied at school, but otherwise life is happy. One day, out of the blue, Will and Felicity sit her down to explain that they've fallen in love. Tess, questioning both of her relationships, leaves their home in Melbourne and takes Liam to Sydney, where they stay with her mother and he can attend a school his bully does not attend. In this break from her day-to-day life, Tess has space to evaluate what role Felicity has always played in her life and what she wants her life to be from here on out.
Rachel, a grandmother, has been a largely unhappy woman ever since her daughter Janie was murdered, strangled to death and left in a park, the murderer never located and brought to justice. She's always suspected Connor Whitby, but has no proof. Her one small joy in life, her grandson, will soon be wrested from her, as her son, Rob, and daughter-in-law, Lauren, are moving to New York City. With this announcement, Rachel descends even more heavily into her desire for closure in Janie's case.
All three women are likable and sympathetic, even when they make choices that aren't necessarily good ones. They face moral dilemmas with no good solution, and just try to muddle through. The Husband's Secret really considers whether choices should be made to protect the children or because they are morally right. Though I can't say that I'm necessarily in agreement with the way that each storyline wrapped up, each woman is so well-characterized that the routes they take do make sense.
Powerful, heart-wrenching literary fiction with a focus on women, The Husband's Secret is a lavish novel. Bear the warning of the Pandora comparison in mind, for the the tale is not a happy one. Liane Moriarty's writing and characterization have convinced me to add the rest of her adult novels to my to-read list. I can only hope I find them as moving and well done as this one.
What harm would be done by opening the letter? Cecelia was dying to open it, but the message John-Paul wrote
Hints about the contents of the letter will peak your curiosity as it did Cecelia’s. When she did open the letter and found out what John-Paul had written, she couldn't believe it. How could this be true? Cecelia the perfect wife and fixer of everything couldn't fix this.
Cecelia was the perfect wife, mother, and town citizen. She knew everyone in town, and she knew everything about the city residents. She remembered Tess when she came back to her childhood town because her husband didn't love her any more. Rachel was also part of Cecelia's circle. Rachel had a few heartbreaking situations in the past. But…what Cecelia found in that letter was going to be more than a heartbreak for Rachel.
THE HUSBAND'S SECRET was focused on this letter, Tess, Rachel and Cecilia. The letter’s secret had to do with an unknown connection between Tess, Cecelia, and Rachel and something that happened in the past that linked them together and something in the present that caused more heartache and pain.
When the book begins, you will think it is going to be a book about a husband’s affair, but it is more sinister than that. It actually is a tragic secret.
THE HUSBAND’S SECRET is about more than keeping secrets, though. It deals with a parent’s love for his/her child and about the lengths parents go to in order to protect their children. It deals with right and wrong, and it deals with the thought - do we really know our spouse or significant other?
Don’t be mislead into thinking it is simply a book about secrets between a husband and his wife. It is far more than that. It is a book about secrets whether they are large or small and about our decisions to reveal the secret or to not reveal the secret.
THE HUSBAND’S SECRET is an excellent read that will keep you pondering life, pondering the decisions we make, and thinking about the secrets most of us have. What is your secret? 5/5
This book was given to me free of charge and without compensation by the publisher and LibraryThing in exchange for an honest review.