Status
Description
Set largely between Hong Kong and the Scottish Highlands, Maggie O'Farrell's third novel is a story about family and emigration - and the way you can never escape your family, or their history, no matter how far you travel. Stella - spirited, witty and passionate - has fled London to confront the childhood secret which has marked her life, and twinned her destiny with her sister's. A set of tragic circumstances and a hasty marriage bring Jake from Hong Kong to Britain, where he embarks upon a quest for the father he never knew. When Jake and Stella meet, both their lives are changed forever, but not before Stella's past is brought painfully out into the open. THE DISTANCE BETWEEN US is a loving, immensely moving and often very funny look at the way families work, which will live with the reader forever, and bring Maggie O'Farrell to her widest readership yet.… (more)
User reviews
At the beginning of the book we are introduced to the main characters. Jake is living in Hong Kong, finding
From here, we meet various other characters, including both families. Maggie also takes us to various time settings, exploring not only Stella and Jake's childhood, but their parents history too.
These strands gradually start to wind together, as the story evolves.. history and present coming together, as Jake and Stella come together too.
This kind of story telling could very easily be confusing, especially to someone like me, who gets lost very easily, and yet it doesn't. The developments of the past gradually add to the present story, until everything comes together.
The characters are believable, and Maggie's writing is down to earth, whilst flowing well. I found myself wanting to keep reading, whilst not wanting it to end!
What this book has going for it that a Mills & Boon romance doesn't have is another, perhaps more interesting story underlying the romance. This underlying story is one of an Italian family in Scotland, focusing on the two sisters, one of whom is the "girl" in the romance. It looks at how isolating it can be to be from a different culture to the one in which you live. Further, the issue of disability is added to that cultural conflict, together with unresolved feelings of guilt left over from childhood. This last issue is probably the most interesting (for me), and yet receives the least attention. What a shame.
It's a reasonably long book but is quite easy reading, and would be ideal to read while traveling on a plane and heading for a new and different culture. In fact, the edition I read is called the "airport/export" edition!!
I loved this. The bond between the sisters was so strong and real, and O’Farrell seems to have the knack of coming up with seemingly insignificant anecdotes which touch on the core of what she’s trying to convey – in this case, the protectiveness of a bigger (though younger) sister, teenage rebellion, different attitudes to life and love and yet that unswerving loyalty to one another.
Like in The Hand That First Held Mine, we have Europeans living in Britain, learning to be bicultural, touches of another language thrown in haphazardly – which appeals to me so much because it’s exactly what I have lived. According to Wikipedia, a stint working in Hong Kong (which she draws on in this novel) is O’Farrell’s only “foreign” experience, so I wonder where she got this bilingual slant from. Anyway, I think it’s fabulous.
Also as in THTFHM, there was a sort of mystery to be solved, or an undisclosed event which was revealed towards the end and had a transformative effect on the characters’ lives, but finding it out wasn’t really the aim of the book, which was quite pleasant. The deed in question was pretty clearly signposted but I didn’t think that detracted from it.
The reason this doesn’t get 10/10 is because the ending was a bit disappointing and twee – too neatly wrapped up. But I guess that’s a matter of personal taste.
I think "After you'd Gone" , by the same author is a much stronger story. Although both have similar
I absolutely loved After You'd Gone, my first Maggie O'Farrell book, but when I followed that soon after, with My Lover's Lover, I was disappointed. Three years later, I decided to try another of the author's books and was pleasantly surprised with The Distance Between Us. There
I was particularly drawn to the character of Jake, who lived all his life in Hong Kong, with a British mother. I found myself identifying with him, as I have raised four children as expats in Dubai. Although he is comfortable with the Chinese, he can never quite fit in to the Chinese community. As a result of a tragic accident, he finds himself married to a girl he has no feelings for, back in a country he cannot identify with. So he runs away to Scotland on a search for his unknown father.
There are similarities in the situation in which Stella finds herself. She lives in Britain but is of Italian extraction. She is very close to her sister Nina but is alienated by the other children. She is also running away, though it's not until near the end of the book that we actually find out what she is running from.
Inevitably, Jake and Stella meet up, sparks fly and explanations are finally given. While somewhat formulaic in this respect, the wonderful descriptions and the time spent in Hong Kong, made this an excellent read.
Also read by Maggie O'Farrell:
After You'd Gone (5 stars)
My Lover's Lover (3 stars)
The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox (5 stars)
Hand That First Held Mine (5 stars)
This book is written in what I always think of as "jigsaw piece"
I liked the book despite finding the writing a bit over the top at times, and I liked that the story didn't explain everything in the end but didn't leave you feeling cheated by that either.
On the minuis side, the accurate & detailed description of the immediate environment, that at times I found too long. Also the overly detailed background stories of everyon's grandmother and mother. Was she trying to build up the psych profile of Nina and Stella. Not successful there, I felt they were just separate stories.
In any case as one of the reviewers said, she makes you care passionately about her characters and I did as she focused on them in the latter parts of the book, staying up to read if and how Jake and Stella get together.