Status
Description
Fiction. Literature. HTML:#1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER â?˘ From the author of Small Great Things and A Spark of Light comes a â??powerfulâ?ť (The Washington Post) novel about the choices that alter the course of our lives. NAMED ONE OF THE BEST BOOKS OF THE YEAR BY MARIE CLAIRE Everything changes in a single moment for Dawn Edelstein. Sheâ??s on a plane when the flight attendant makes an announcement: Prepare for a crash landing. She braces herself as thoughts flash through her mind. The shocking thing is, the thoughts are not of her husband but of a man she last saw fifteen years ago: Wyatt Armstrong. Dawn, miraculously, survives the crash, but so do all the doubts that have suddenly been raised. She has led a good life. Back in Boston, there is her husband, Brian, their beloved daughter, and her work as a death doula, in which she helps ease the transition between life and death for her clients. But somewhere in Egypt is Wyatt Armstrong, who works as an archaeologist unearthing ancient burial sites, a career Dawn once studied for but was forced to abandon when life suddenly intervened. And now, when it seems that fate is offering her second chances, she is not as sure of the choice she once made. After the crash landing, the airline ensures that the survivors are seen by a doctor, then offers transportation to wherever they want to go. The obvious destination is to fly home, but she could take another path: return to the archaeological site she left years before, reconnect with Wyatt and their unresolved history, and maybe even complete her research on The Book of Two Waysâ??the first known map of the afterlife. As the story unfolds, Dawnâ??s two possible futures unspool side by side, as do the secrets and doubts long buried with them. Dawn must confront the questions sheâ??s never truly asked: What does a life well lived look like? When we leave this earth, what do we leave behind? Do we make choices . . . or do our choices make us? And who would you be if you hadnâ??t turned out to be the p… (more)
User reviews
Dawn Edelstein is a Death Doula. Her job is to help guide the dying and their families through the process in order to make it less stressful and more manageable. She carries the burden so the family can let it go. She becomes a part
As a student at Yale, Dawn studied Egyptology. While studying in Egypt, she met Wyatt Anderson. They were both researching “The Book of Two Ways”, found under the bodies in the ancient tombs. It outlined the paths of life and death and contained spells to guide the dead. This part of the book was often difficult as an audio, as many of the technical terms and words were hard to understand. I recommend the print version so that the pronunciation of strange words does not interfere with the reading of the book. Visually, it will be easier.
Wyatt and Dawn, both young and vying for the same recognition, compete and spar with each other. Then, somehow, they fall madly in love. They are like two sides of the same coin. When Dawn’s mother enters hospice, she must return home. She tells no one. She simply disappears. Wyatt cannot find her. Dawn is overwhelmed. She had not known that her mother was ill. There is no money for her to return to school and no one else to care for her minor brother, Kieran. She has to work. While her mother is in hospice, she meets Brian Edelstein, a Quantum Physicist, and they move in together. After the birth of their daughter, Meret, they marry. Fifteen years later, Dawn is one of only 36 survivors of a plane crash. The novel begins with the crash.
The novel’s timeline is confusing. As it progresses back and forth, Dawn’s life is revealed and the threads are often disjointed. At first, the reader learns a great deal about Egyptology as the author has obviously done extensive research. At times, the narrative is like a text book. Some of the information seems incomprehensible. Some of the words and hieroglyphics were too obscure and opaque for me. When Dawn’s life as a Death Doula is explained, the novel becomes clearer, although the job seems profoundly sad, even if it serves an admirable purpose.
Throughout the book, humor is injected into the dialogue, especially between Dawn and Wyatt. This takes some of the darkness from the novel, but it is, overall, depressing. Current social and political issues are introduced, including the author’s own personal political views when she indicates that Dawn wishes that Hillary was President. Because of Dawn’s sacrifice, Kieran was able to study medicine, although it doesn’t seem that enough time has passed. He is also gay. Meret was larger than most children her age and has been bullied. Brian is accused of being disloyal, but honestly, it seemed to be a non-issue. He really did nothing wrong. Dawn, on the other hand, took infidelity to an art form. I did not find Dawn likeable. She seemed selfish and arrogant, often believing she was the smartest one in the room and behaving without thinking about others or the effect her behavior would have on others. I believe she was a very flawed character.
The major theme of the book was about how we live and how we die. All of the questions that arise at the moment we learn of our impending death and the days that follow are examined. As a Doula, Dawn tries to make the experience of death more tolerable so that the person dies with dignity and is free to let go when the time comes. She assists the family members as well and essentially, becomes a part of the family. She will grant them any wish she can to make the journey easier. How do we face death? How have we lived? When we discover we are dying do we live what is left of our lives differently? Are some things more important than others? Are there scores to settle? Can we go back and relive parts of our lives to capture what we have lost or been forced to give up? These are some of the questions being tackled.
Since Dawn was researching “The Book of Two Ways” which contained the spells that were buried with the dead, it did seem fitting that she should choose to be a Death Doula when she could no longer continue her studies.
I have enjoyed most books by this author, but this was not one of them. The themes were overdone and seemed contrived. The book was too long and needed editing. It was hard to determine whether or not Dawn was reliving the past or was living in the present as her story was told. The resolution of the issues was unsatisfying and unrealistic. Dawn was impulsive and rash, resented male superiority and seemed dissatisfied with her life. She wanted a redo. Although she took responsibility for her actions she didn’t seem to learn from them. The sex scenes seemed too explicit and seemed out of place in what seemed to be a serious book. The profane language seemed unreasonable and unnecessary.
Despite the above criticism, I enjoyed the book and found it thought-provoking. I think it would make a wonderful choice for book discussion groups.
After surviving
Thus we are introduced to the theory of parallel universes, and so, the chapters alternate, beginning with Dawn choosing to return to Egypt to explore the what-if she left behind. In the other chapters, Dawn returns to her home in Boston, and the familiar struggles of marriage and motherhood. Or is that what's going on? There's a twist (don't expect me to give it away!) and in typical Picoult fashion, there are no clear right answers.
Picoult is not coy about what she's setting up. Dawn's husband is a physicist who explores just that topic. As a graduate student in Egyptology, Dawn's thesis was on The Book of Two Ways, an ancient Egyptian text that essentially posited that, after death, one's soul can take one of two routes, but will end up in the same place, feasting with Osiris. But sometimes, Picoult gets a little heavy-handed, such as having one of Dawn's clients face a very similar dilemma, and having Dawn learn a lot about her own life as she works things through with her client.
In Picoult's hands, even this last doesn't seem like much of a flaw, and if it is one, it's easily forgiven for the pleasure of the rest of the book. This is the kind of book that you want to read again as soon as you've finished it, that will make you want to go out and learn all about hieroglyphics, and that you'll recommend to everyone you know.
I always jump at the chance to read a Jodi Picoult book. Whether you agree or disagree with the storyline, she always makes you see both sides of the story. I will say I am a huge fan of the early JP books, versus the newer ones.
This book just had too much packed in it for me! Egyptologist
I enjoyed the storyline and the triangle of Dawn/Brian/Wyatt. As someone who is in the process of watching someone die, I found the death doula addition interesting and very enlightening. Parts of this were very emotional for me to read. For my ease in reading, I dislike long chapters but in this case, they work to get into the separate scenarios. There is a lot of back and forth within the chapters themselves. I can usually fly thru a JP book, but I found this one more difficult, stopping and starting very often. This might have been due to the overload of information and the Egyptology storyline. I prefer a neater ending than the one written, and did feel a little let down. As with all Ms. Picoult’s books, she will make you think outside the box or your comfort zone.
I love Ms. Picoult’s earlier works, and the triangle storyline reminded me of these. I went back and forth between really liking and disliking this book. I will always be a fan and always jump at the chance to read one of Ms. Picoult’s books. I appreciate her research, her attention to detail and the honing of her craft. But, I miss the Plain Truth, My Sister’s Keeper, and 19 Minutes Stories!
Thanks to Ms. Picoult, Random House Publishing/Ballantine and Net Galley for this ARC. Opinion is mine alone.
This book is so well written and I loved it! Now, it is totally out of this author’s normal type of book. It is what I call a “smart read”. It is full of science and historical Egyptian references. Not sure everyone will feel the same way I do. But, I was so captivated by Dawn and her Egyptology and throw in her husband and his quantum physics with parallel universes and I was hooked.
But, that is not what made this book for me. The characters and their plight and the unique way Picoult wove the tale together is absolutely amazing. You do not want to miss this one! Makes you think…in more ways than one!
I received this novel from the publisher for a honest review.
Dawn is a death doula, which means she is there to do anything that helps a person to pass away. That doesn't mean
This is not a Sliding Doors sort of story and we don't see both possible lives as they would have played out, but it does bring forth the question of what would happen if we had taken that other path. Where would we be now? What would we be doing? I really liked that aspect of the story.
There were some very thoughtful and moving sections. Picoult has never shied away from moral and ethical dilemmas and putting her characters in provocative situations. The parts where Dawn talks about her experiences as a death doula often brought tears springing to my eyes. But I'm afraid I struggled with the parts where Egyptology is at the forefront and I'd have preferred there to be a lot less of it.
As always, the author has obviously done a lot of research and she's produced something quite remarkable. As a whole it didn't really work for me and I think the death doula storyline on its own could have made for a really compelling read, but there were segments that really drew me in, not just the doula parts but also Dawn's family life and how the plane crash affects her.
The Book of Two Ways wasn't quite what I was hoping for and I think it will divide readers, but nevertheless I still enjoyed the writing and much of the story.
While I did enjoy the last quarter immensely, I just could not sustain interest in the in between. I just didn’t care enough about her unhappiness with her husband or her endless talk of archaeology in Egypt so I skimmed through that part. The
If you’re debating whether or not to finish it... DO!!!
Using opposing chapters, Picoult explains the background between Dawn and her former lover, Wyatt, and the fact that she has a husband and daughter back home in Boston. We also learn that Dawn gave up archaeology to become a death doula and we are taught what a doula is and why their services are important to some people. We spend many pages of the novel with Dawn in her doula role.
It Is true that this a multilayered love story but it is also an education in Egyptology, Ancient Egyptian tombs and death practices much of which I had previously learned when I read The Egyptian by Mika Waltari many years ago. Dawn also covers the dynamics of having an affair and discovering you love both individuals but know you are willing to give up everything including possibly children for one and the pain that everyone experiences as the crisis is resolved.
This is a story about visiting one's past and regrets and at the same time wondering how life might have turned out if different life choices had been made. Dawn's journey to confront some of the questions about her past while
I have a huge admiration for the amount of research that the author has made to actually write this book. It was extremely well written but I could not enjoy the book as much as I would have liked to because it is not my area of interest. Hopefully, some day later on in life when I do get interested in some of the topics covered in this book, I will be able to re-read it and truly appreciate it to the fullest.
Thank You to NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for this ARC!
The majority of Jodi Picoult's novels deal with controversial topics. This one, however, breaks from the mold a bit and explores parallel universes, so to speak. In some ways this novel was all over the place, both literally and figuratively, and I will admit I had trouble following the timeline throughout the majority of the book. I wasn't initially engaged with this story and I was really back and forth with this one -- there were parts that I liked and parts that I disliked. The main character was not necessarily likeable in that she often appeared selfish and made questionable decisions. It bothered me that the story began by capturing the reader's attention with a plane crash, but then there were seemingly no lasting effects or references to it throughout the bulk of the story, which I didn't feel was very realistic at all (though this was remedied later in the book). I liked the Egyptian references, though at times they were dry and too academic for the general feel of the novel. I think the part that appealed to me most was the idea of a death doula, a sort of super-person who aids the dying and their loved ones in all sorts of ways -- emotional & practical -- and it made me wonder why such people are not more well known and utilized in today's world. All in all, this was a decent book, though it had some weaknesses. It would be good for group discussion, however.