Status
Genres
Description
Fiction. Literature. Humor (Fiction.) HTML: An unassuming scientist takes an unbelievable adventure in the Middle East in this "extraordinary" novel�??the inspiration for the major motion picture starring Ewan McGregor (The Guardian). Dr. Alfred Jones lives a quiet, predictable life. He works as a civil servant for the National Centre for Fisheries Excellence in London; his wife, Mary, is a determined, no-nonsense financier; he has simple routines and unassuming ambitions. Then he meets Muhammad bin Zaidi bani Tihama, a Yemeni sheikh with money to spend and a fantastic�??and ludicrous�??dream of bringing the sport of salmon fishing to his home country. Suddenly, Dr. Jones is swept up in an outrageous plot to attempt the impossible, persuaded by both the sheikh himself and power-hungry members of the British government who want nothing more than to spend the sheikh's considerable wealth. But somewhere amid the bureaucratic spin and Yemeni tall tales, Dr. Jones finds himself thinking bigger, bolder, and more impossibly than he ever has before. Told through letters, emails, interview transcripts, newspaper articles, and personal journal entries, Salmon Fishing in the Yemen is "a triumph" that both takes aim at institutional absurdity and gives loving support to the ideas of hopes, dreams, and accomplishing the impossible (The Guardian… (more)
User reviews
Living in the Middle East, I'd hoped to find more to enjoy in this book. Whilst the characters behaved quite believably, the newspaper style format detracted from the content and I found the ending quite a disappointment.
The rest of my book group, however, thought it was excellent and
Alfred Jones, fisheries scientist, is horrified at the request to export thousands of salmon to swim in the wadis of Yemen. Forced to go along with the plan, he immerses his whole being into the project, even starting to believe that it might be possible.
When British politics become involved and even the PM wants a look-in, things start to get out of hand. As Alfred's love life starts to spiral downwards and the Sheikh's absolute faith begins to thaw Alfred's cold heart, we start to see another side to his character.
For me this book was spoiled by the rambling memos between government departments and the dry records of parliamentary proceedings. In addition, the ending was a disappointing anticlimax. With a different ending and improved format, it could have been an excellent book.
An unusual choice for a Richard and Judy Summer read.
This last fortnight I have been laid low with a horrendous flu-like virus which seems to have been doing the rounds, and a friend dropped a copy of SFinTY round to distract me and stop me feeling so sorry for myself! It was the perfect tonic, and I am so glad it did not pass me by.
Dr Alfred Jones is a fisheries scientist employed by a government department. He is married, without children, to a very bossy, high-handed woman who earns more than he does and patronises him in every possible way. Out of the blue, Dr Jones is approached to do a feasibility study for a project to create a salmon river in the Yemen, something he initially dismisses out of hand as a completely daft idea. However, the scheme has come to the notice of various politicians who want the project to go ahead for a variety of self-serving political reasons. Dr Jones ends up being forced to take on the scheme, and to try to figure out hour to get 10,000 salmon out to the Yemen, and how to get water in a Yemeni wadi to meet the conditions necessary for their survival.
The whole crazy plan changes Dr Jones in more ways than he could have envisaged and the reader becomes as anxious as he does that the scheme should succeed.
The book is written as a series of letters, emails, diary entries and answers to a Parliamentary Inquiry, and apart from telling a hilarious tale, satirises the bureaucratic nonsense that often passes for governance in Britain today, and the horrible culture of “spin” which has been adopted by our politicians.
I know a lot
I ususally like books that are made up of articles, emails, letters, interviews etc. but in this book I thought that didn't work. I can
In the end, even though the characters grew on me, the story just didn't grab me. This isn't surprising, since I don't consider myself spiritual.
The books begins with Dr. Alfred, a very dedicated and staid scientist who works for the NCFE
(national center for fishery exelence) and is requested to head a project funded by a Yemeni Sheik to introduce Salmon into a wadi in the Yemen. He refused, as he says the idea is unfesable, but is strong armed into it by government pressure. Amazing things happen as the faith of the sheik changes those around him, especially Dr. Alfred.
The book was written entirely in diary entries, e-mails, memo's, interveiws, and notes from the house of commons. Not the usual novel style, which helped to make it such a remarkable work.
I will be anxiously awaiting further work by the author. An amazing first novel.
The book left me with just one question: is there really a NCFE in the UK?
Along the way, we get to know Dr. Jones, his distant wife Mary, and his co-worker on the
It's a wonderfully funny book, espcially early on. Anyone familiar with bureaucracy and politics will appreciate the wit and satire of the story. Unfortunately, the book gets less interesting as it goes on; the ending is somewhat weak. It's like the author didn't quite know how to wrap it up -- maybe because so few things in politics actually "end" in any concrete manner.
Not an insightful satire. The characters are almost dead, and the tedious method of exposition---trying to shoehorn the
Entertaining and funny.
The book deals with the ideas of a sheik from Yemen who wants to create a river full of salmon in his native land, where he and his fellow countrymen (and tourists) can come to fish. Alfred Jones, a fishing scientist, is at first dismissive of the idea, but departmental and even national politics force him to take on the project. The book describes the process. It's a fun and easy read.
What makes this gem of a book work is that the
Torday , a keen River Tyne salmon angler himself, weaves his story around his undoubted in depth knowledge of wild salmon. Whether he is describing the physical geography of Yemeni wadis, poking fun at the machinations of the Civil Service, exposing the farce of political spin or commiserating with the death throes of a failing marriage, Torday keeps a light touch throughout and keeps the reader engaged.
A book for romantics (like me)!
In a satire ; vices, foibles, abuses and short comings are held
Alfred Jones a scientist working in the Department of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs is asked for a feasibility study on introducing salmon and salmon fishing into the Yemen. He correctly points out that such a project would be laughable; there are no suitable rivers, the climate is too hot for the fish and they would not be able to reach their breeding grounds in the North Atlantic. Poor Alfred is blissfully unaware that a powerful Sheikh will bankroll such a project and the British Government desperate for a good news story in the Middle East see it as a vote winner. Alfred is made to change his mind and his scientific pride leads him to involve himself fully in the impossible project. He is spurred on by the charismatic Sheik and his crush on Harriet who works for the company that represents the Sheik's interest. What happens when a crazy project is fueled by enough money and the political will? It succeeds of course.
The story is told in a series of diary entries, correspondence, e mails, interviews by a parliamentary subcommittee, an unpublished novel and extracts from Hansard. Torday is skillful enough to weave these disparate elements into a very readable narrative format. Torday has a lightness of touch about everything he writes here and never loses sight of his story or his need to make the reader smile.
The novel succeeds for me because there is very little exaggeration in the workings of a government department. I kept thinking I have seen these sorts of things happen or worse. Almost everything else has a ring of credibility about it. Tordays most savage satire is reserved for Peter Maxwell who is a Director of Communications (spin doctor) and works closely with the Prime Minister. This characteris probably based on Alastair Campbell and his work with Tony Blair. One scene stands out particularly for me. Maxwell desperate for a good news story to offset the casualties being reported from Iraq has an idea for a new TV game show. It will be set in one of the villages partially destroyed by rocket and mortar fire and will feature actual villagers as contestants, who will stand to win glamorous prizes. He presents this idea to the usual Friday evening get together of the PM and his cabinet cronies who are sipping wine. After the presentation one of the members remarks "Peter you ought to get out more". Maxwell is close to tears he can't believe that his brilliant idea has been given such short shrift. Torday I think has been cever hear, he finally presents a scenario that is ridiculous and has his characters reject it out of hand. This leads the reader to think that all the other stuff that has gone before could well happen in real life.
This is a funny humorous book, but the sting in the tail for me is that so much of it could and probably does happen and we all blithely have to accept it. This novel should be read by all government workers, lets just hope you don't see yourselves here
Dr Alfred Jones, fisheries specialist, is outraged when he is forced to seriously consider the feasibility of a crack-pot scheme to introduce salmon fishing to the
This audiobook kept me thoroughly entertained for much of January, and it’s a shame I’m only writing about it now. I absolutely loved it… until the last half hour, but we’ll get back to that.
Dr Jones is spectacular. He’s highly intelligent, a little baffled by social norms, but underneath it all a general good egg and capable of great passion for his chosen subject. Harriet is lovely and strong and fragile and generally like so many City women I know, being terribly successful but hiding something a bit darker. The Sheikh was a fascinating character – seemingly omniscient and ever-patient, but sympathetic and the source of many quotes (including the one at the top of this review). As for Mary Jones – she’s a witch! But I can’t pretend I don’t see a tiny bit of myself in her: to her it’s all planned out and the silly man is just ruining it all by not following the plan!
The plot is wonderful. The political nonsense that goes on is wonderful – while the novel is ostensibly about salmon fishing and optimism and tolerance and all sorts of other lovely things with ribbons on, the satire is biting and very, very funny. The dynamic between the three leads is beautiful and fragile and develops so slowly that it is really quite suspenseful.
I was disappointed by the end – it suddenly explained why the book was written in “evidence” form (emails, interviews, minutes of Government meetings), but it felt rushed and unnecessarily tragic. Bathetic, if you will.
There were some gorgeous touches to the writing which really came out beautifully in audio:
- the righteous indignation of the local newspaper when one of their stories is picked up by a bigger paper and derided as a hoax
- the interview with Andrew Marr, political commentator extraordinaire, and the garbage that falls out of Peter Maxwell’s self-aggrandising face
I cannot believe (a) they’re making a movie of this book (b) that it stars Ewan McGregor, Emily Blunt and Kristen Scott Thomas are going to be in it (c) that Ewan McGregor is actually going to keep his Scottish accent in this film for once. It’s like all my Christmases have come at once. I will be there in the first week.
The book is about a fish specialist who ends up putting in salmon into the yemen. But what it is really about
Hilarious
Its not serious, it doesnt try to be pretentious, its just a good read. A definite holiday novel.