Status
Available
Call number
Genres
Collection
Publication
Toronto ; London : University of Toronto Press, 1989.
Description
This book will interest those who have already made some study of the subject of witchcraft but will also intrigue the educated non-specialist. Closely reasoned, it is also written with a rare wit, which makes it difficult to put down.
User reviews
LibraryThing member g026r
Richard Kieckhefer, in his foreward to the edition I read, makes a decent point regarding A Razor for a Goat: at the time, given the information available, Razor could be seen as a revolutionary, overturning-the-old-order work. With time, and the appearance (and, in one important case,
Rose is at his best when he's attacking Margaret Murray's theory of the European witch-cult as a representation of continuous pagan survival, pointing out areas where her theories run afoul of Occam's Razor. Spots where, with lack of any concrete evidence, her constructions multiply the number of coincidences and complexities needed over simpler interpretations and theories.
He's at his worst, however, when he tries to formulate alternate theories for the witch-hysteria of the Middle Ages. So often he comes close to the truth, but shies away — never willing to take that final step and discount the entire theory of the witch-cult, and thereby coming up with his own theories that, to borrow a phrase of his, are in need of shaving. He's not helped in this regards by the fact that, due to the period when this work was written, he relies on outdated and occasionally even unknowingly on forged evidence. (Revelations that, in the latter case, wouldn't come to light until a few years later.)
As the first major step away from the theories of Murray and company, it's an important historical work. As a source of history, of potentially valid historical theories, it's complete and absolute rubbish. At most it's a one and a half to two star work, but it gains an extra half to full star because I'm willing to admit to occasionally being a petty man, and I'll never say no to watching the theories of Murray (and Frazer, and Graves) getting a good kicking.
Show More
disappearance) of more evidence shedding further light on events, it's less revolutionary, more revisionary — a step away from the earlier theories, but only just a step.Rose is at his best when he's attacking Margaret Murray's theory of the European witch-cult as a representation of continuous pagan survival, pointing out areas where her theories run afoul of Occam's Razor. Spots where, with lack of any concrete evidence, her constructions multiply the number of coincidences and complexities needed over simpler interpretations and theories.
He's at his worst, however, when he tries to formulate alternate theories for the witch-hysteria of the Middle Ages. So often he comes close to the truth, but shies away — never willing to take that final step and discount the entire theory of the witch-cult, and thereby coming up with his own theories that, to borrow a phrase of his, are in need of shaving. He's not helped in this regards by the fact that, due to the period when this work was written, he relies on outdated and occasionally even unknowingly on forged evidence. (Revelations that, in the latter case, wouldn't come to light until a few years later.)
As the first major step away from the theories of Murray and company, it's an important historical work. As a source of history, of potentially valid historical theories, it's complete and absolute rubbish. At most it's a one and a half to two star work, but it gains an extra half to full star because I'm willing to admit to occasionally being a petty man, and I'll never say no to watching the theories of Murray (and Frazer, and Graves) getting a good kicking.
Show Less
Subjects
Language
Original publication date
1962
Physical description
257 p.; 23 cm
ISBN
0802067689 / 9780802067685
Local notes
New Foreward by Richard Kieckhefer.
Other editions
Similar in this library
Voices from the Pagan Census: A National Survey of Witches and Neo-Pagans in the United States (Studies in Comparative Religion) by Helen A. Berger
Malleus Maleficarum: The Original Medieval guide to the catching and burning of Witches! by Heinrich Kramer
Forbidden rites: a necromancer's manual of the fifteenth century (Magic in History Series) by Kieckhefer
Real magic : an introductory treatise on the basic principles of yellow magic by Philip Emmons Isaac Bonewits
The night battles : Witchcraft & agrarian cults in the sixteenth & seventeenth centuries by Carlo Ginzburg
Conjuring spirits: texts and traditions of medieval ritual magic (Magic in History Series) by Claire Fanger