Status
Collection
Publication
Description
Fiction. Science Fiction. HTML:NO ONE COULD STOP THEM-- NOT STALIN, NOT TOGO, NOT CHURCHILL, NOT ROOSEVELT . . . The invaders had cut the United States virtually in half at the Mississippi, vaporized Washington, D.C., devastated much of Europe, and held large parts of the Soviet Union under their thumb. But humanity would not give up so easily. The new world allies were ruthless at finding their foe's weaknesses and exploiting them. Whether delivering supplies in tiny biplanes to partisans across the vast steppes of Russia, working furiously to understand the enemy's captured radar in England, or battling house to house on the streets of Chicago, humankind would never give up. Yet no one could say when the hellish inferno of death would stop being a war of conquest and turn into a war of survival--the very survival of the planet . . . From the Paperback edition..… (more)
User reviews
Earlier this year I saw the first 4 books at a thrift store and decided to give them a try. The first book was
Turtledove has a really bad tendency of repeating himself. Repeating descriptions every single time he switches the POV character. But that's not even the worst of it. The paperback is nearly 600 pages. The first 3 books of Southern Victory were about 300-400 and hit a really good sweet spot in length. The 600 pages wouldn't be an issue, except it feels like almost nothing happens for the whole book.
The book also struggles with the whole idea of a "World War", as Turtledove is constantly shuffling around characters in order to have events happen around them. The only characters that feel like they stand on their own are all characters who stay in the same general area. Sam Yeager, a former American baseball player who is a liaison with lizard POWs on the American Nuclear project, Ludmila Gorbunova a female Russian pilot whose antiquated plane manages to annoy the Aliens, and Mutt Daniels, Sam Yeager's former coach, a WW1 vet and a front line fighter on the American front and Liu Han, a Chinese peasant who is abducted by the aliens and then put in a POW camp.
Even with this going on, the book still struggles to tell a coherent story about the War. Which isn't all that surprising, while Turtledove's vision of a WW1 between the Union and Confederacy managed to be very immersive, the WW2 between both sides sputtered considerably. It was as though he had an overall image of the story he wanted to tell, but struggled to fill in the details in both cases. This despite the books ballooning in size.
I might continue the series just to get through the WorldWar section of these books, but even then they are definitely getting put on the backburner after I struggled so hard to make my way through this book.