David, King of the Jews, possessed every flaw and failing a mortal is capable of, yet men and women adored him and God showered him with many more blessings than he did Abraham or Moses. His sexual appetite and prowess were matched only by his violence, both on the battlefield and in the bedroom. A charismatic leader, exalted as "a man after God's own heart," he was also capable of deep cunning, deceit, and betrayal. Now, in King David: The Real Life of the Man Who Ruled Israel, bestselling author Jonathan Kirsch reveals this commanding individual in all his glory and fallibility. In a taut, dramatic narrative, Kirsch brings new depth and psychological complexity to the familiar events of David's life--his slaying of the giant Goliath and his swift challenge to the weak rule of Saul, the first Jewish king; his tragic relationship with Saul's son Jonathan, David's cherished friend (and possibly lover); his celebrated reign in Jerusalem, where his dynasty would hold sway for generations. Yet for all his greatness, David was also a man in thrall to his passions--a voracious lover who secured the favors of his beautiful mistress Bathsheba by secretly arranging the death of her innocent husband; a merciless warrior who triumphed through cruelty; a troubled father who failed to protect his daughter from rape and whose beloved son Absalom rose against him in armed insurrection. Weaving together biblical texts with centuries of interpretation and commentary, Jonathan Kirsch brings King David to life in these pages with extraordinary freshness, intimacy, and vividness of detail. At the center of this inspiring narrative stands a hero of flesh and blood--not the cartoon giant-slayer of sermons and Sunday school stories or the immaculate ruler of legend and art but a magnetic, disturbingly familiar man--a man as vibrant and compelling today as he has been for millennia.
This book is good for a layperson who wants to know more about how the bible was written and overwritten. The different books in the bible give different accounts of David and his life. There are, I think, three different accounts of how David met Saul. Kirsch’s book gives a pretty simplified version of biblical scholarship, but for me, that’s perfect because I don’t have the patience for a lot more.
I ended up deciding that there was a real David, and that Leonard Cohen is the one who got him right in his song, Hallelujah. Not so much because of the secret chord that pleased the lord, though that seems to be true, but because it ends with a “cold and broken hallelujah.”
The author's desire to prove that David was just a mensch, and the Israelite God & his prophets were frauds, made him
The book has a semblance of scholarship, but consists mostly of assertions and contortions.
Kirsch may have thought he was just making current biblical scholarship accessible to the lay public, but without some citation more detailed than "this is an interpolation from a later source" and "this may have been an original folktale" he makes a mishmash of both the scriptures and the literary criticism.
In addition, he appears to be grossly ignorant of anthropological parallels to David's time (for instance, the Welsh Chronicles for tribal infighting) and misstates or ignores any interpretations of history, the scriptural account, character and behavior that either don't agree with his, or present a view other than the straw-man arguments he "demolishes" -- generally with sarcasm rather than proofs.
*cf The prophet Nathan is described on page 167 as "one of those cranky old men," when he presents the "case" of the rich man and the poor man in order to make David self-indict himself for adultery with Bathsheba & murder of her husband, as told in 2 Sam 12.
Kirtsch says that Nathan "suddenly confronted" David, as if they had never met. However, on page 144, David had previously consulted Nathan about building a House for God and was counseled that this was not God's will (2 Sam 7).