In this deeply moving and empowering true story, young readers will trace the life of the Gay Pride Flag, from its beginnings in 1978 with social activist Harvey Milk and designer Gilbert Baker to its spanning of the globe and its role in today''s world. Award-winning author Rob Sanders's stirring text, and acclaimed illustrator Steven Salerno's evocative images, combine to tell this remarkable - and undertold - story. A story of love, hope, equality, and pride. PRAISE FOR PRIDE! "Pride The Story of Harvey Milk and The Rainbow Flagbeautifully tells the history of both Uncle Harvey's dream and his collaboration with Gilbert Baker to create a global symbol of equality and inclusion. This book tells a history that all children will cherish, and will inspire the next generation of hope givers, our world's youth" - Stuart Milk, Founder and President of the Harvey Milk Foundation "Harvey Milk and Gilbert Baker showed LGBTQ people that they should be proud of who they are and who they love. That is exactly what we do at The Trevor Project for LGBTQ youth in crisis. We're thrilled that more young people will learn the story behind the original rainbow flag." - Amit Paley, Trevor Project CEO and Executive Director
I also have a couple of issues with it.
First, wording is important—especially in books, especially in books that are supposed to be focusing on equality. This sentence stopped me: "Harvey dreamed that everyone—even gay people—would have equality."
"Even", when used as an adverb, means "used to emphasize something surprising or extreme." So rights for equality for gay people is extreme? "Even" has implications, implications that perhaps the specified person/group may not deserve to be included. Seriously, think about how we use that word in day-to-day life. "Everyone is invited to the party." "Oh god. Everyone? Even my ex?" "Including" would have been a much better choice. I have to wonder where the editor was for that one.
Second, I would have liked to have seen a greater artistic effort made to represent the full diversity of the LGBTQIA community in the drawings of crowds. Transfolks and POC were at the forefront of the movement, and I would love to see greater representation of them and their contributions in history books.
Although I tend to agree with those online reviewers who have found Pride: The Story of Harvey Milk and the Rainbow Flag insufficient, as a biography of Milk, I still think the book has great value, in introducing a moment in American history, and the power of the symbol created in that moment. I too would like a more in-depth exploration of Milk's life story - his childhood, his relationships, the people who influenced him, his ideas and beliefs - but I think Rob Sanders' title was intended more as an exploration of his role in one specific historical circumstance (i.e.: the creation of the Pride Flag), than as a full biography. In that sense, it accomplishes exactly what it set out to do, showing Milk's influence on the flag's creator, Gilbert Baker, and the influence of his death on the adoption of that flag by LGBT people. The artwork by Steven Salerno is vibrantly (and appropriately) colorful, creating an immediacy in the illustrations that is striking and powerful. All in all, I think this is an engaging first book for younger children, about the struggle of LGBT people to win full civil rights for themselves, and would recommend it to anyone looking for picture-books about Pride, and the LGBT community and its history.