Description
Fiction. Literature. HTML:NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER � Wonderfully tender and hilariously funny, Eligible tackles gender, class, courtship, and family as Curtis Sittenfeld reaffirms herself as one of the most dazzling authors writing today. NAMED ONE OF THE BEST BOOKS OF THE YEAR BY NPR AND THE TIMES (UK) This version of the Bennet family�and Mr. Darcy�is one that you have and haven�t met before: Liz is a magazine writer in her late thirties who, like her yoga instructor older sister, Jane, lives in New York City. When their father has a health scare, they return to their childhood home in Cincinnati to help�and discover that the sprawling Tudor they grew up in is crumbling and the family is in disarray. Youngest sisters Kitty and Lydia are too busy with their CrossFit workouts and Paleo diets to get jobs. Mary, the middle sister, is earning her third online master�s degree and barely leaves her room, except for those mysterious Tuesday-night outings she won�t discuss. And Mrs. Bennet has one thing on her mind: how to marry off her daughters, especially as Jane�s fortieth birthday fast approaches. Enter Chip Bingley, a handsome new-in-town doctor who recently appeared on the juggernaut reality TV dating show Eligible. At a Fourth of July barbecue, Chip takes an immediate interest in Jane, but Chip�s friend neurosurgeon Fitzwilliam Darcy reveals himself to Liz to be much less charming. . . . And yet, first impressions can be deceiving. Praise for Eligible �Even the most ardent Austenite will soon find herself seduced.��O: The Oprah Magazine �Blissful . . . Sittenfeld modernizes the classic in such a stylish, witty way you�d guess even Jane Austen would be pleased.��People (book of the week) �[A] sparkling, fresh contemporary retelling.��Entertainment Weekly �[Sittenfeld] is the ideal modern-day reinterpreter. Her special skill lies not just in her clear, clean writing, but in her general amusement about the world, her arch, pithy, dropped-mike observations about behavior, character and motivation. She can spot hypocrisy, cant, self-contradiction and absurdity ten miles away. She�s the one you want to leave the party with, so she can explain what really happened. . . . Not since Clueless, which transported Emma to Beverly Hills, has Austen been so delightedly interpreted. . . . Sittenfeld writes so well�her sentences are so good and her story so satisfying. . . . As a reader, let me just say: Three cheers for Curtis Sittenfeld and her astute, sharp and ebullient anthropological interest in the human condition.��Sarah Lyall, The New York Times Book Review �A clever, uproarious evolution of Austen�s story.��The Denver Post �If there exists a more perfect pairing than Curtis Sittenfeld and Jane Austen, we dare you to find it. . . . Sittenfeld makes an already irresistible story even more beguiling and charming.��Elle �A playful, wickedly smart retelling of Jane Austen�s Pride and Prejudice.��BuzzFeed �Sittenfeld is an obvious choice to re-create Jane Austen�s comedy of manners. [She] is a master at dissecting social norms to reveal the truths of human nature underneath.��The Millions �A hugely entertaining and surprisingly unpredictable...… (more)
Series
Genres
Collection
Publication
Pages
User reviews
The problem for me was that this novel is contemporary chick lit, plain and simple--and that's not a genre I often read and even less often enjoy. I know, I know, Austen's original is chick lit of a sort, but it also brims with social commentary and the characters are much more complex and more deeply developed. Men also delighted in her novels when they were originally published, and I can't think of a single man I know that would delight in Eligible. It just doesn't have an edge beyond chick lit.
That said, if you like Jane Austen AND contemporary chick lit, this might be the book for you. Sittenfeld fairly faithfully follows the plot of , and most of the characters bear at least one primary trait of the originals. Jane is pretty and sweet, Lizzie is the clever one and the family "fixer," Mary is a perpetual scholar who spurns society, Kitty and Lydia are pretty young things still living at home (except when they are at Crossfit, which is a lot of the time). There is a Charlotte Lucas, plump and pining for a husband; a geeky rich cousin who visits in hope of finding a wife; a bitchy sister, Caroline Bingley; and a sweet, anorexic sister, Georgie Darcy. Wickham has transformed into Lizzie's coworker and longtime on again/off again married boyfriend, a former Stanford classsmate of brain surgeon Fitzwilliam Darcy with a secret waiting to be revealed--but Lydia elopes with someone else entirely. And Darcy--well, I found him terribly disappointing here compared to Austen's original.
So: chick lit fans, go for it, you'll probably enjoy it. Austen fans, I'd skip this one unless curiosity gets the better of you.
Darcy in this version is a surgeon while Chip Bingley is a reality TV star on a TV show much like "The Bachelor." The younger Bennett sisters don't seem to work. Instead Lydia (who is unspeakably vulgar) and Kitty spend their days in crossfit training, while Mary is working on her third post graduate degree. Mrs. Bennett has gone beyond being a silly woman and is now selfish, homophobic and racist while Mr. Bennett is also much more clueless than in the original version. And the whole sub-plot of Lydia and Mr. Wickham seems to have been thrown into the trashcan. The whole book is much more mean spirited than the original. I expected butter from Ms. Sittenfeld.
The Bennett sisters are just as I remember them from P&P, even down to the immature younger Bennetts I found myself wanting to reach through
I did find the first portion of the story a little forced. Maybe it was that Mr. Bingley had been on the reality TV show. As the story progressed it flowed better.
If you read a light read this is a book book for you.
This is an ultra-modern tale of a reality TV star and physician Chip Bingley, who was unable to find his true love on the dating show "Eligible (i.e. The Bachelor)." Meanwhile, back in the burbs of Cincinnati, Mr. and Mrs. Bennett are living with their 5 unmarried adult daughters wondering why they can't get them married off and out of their home. Their two oldest, Liz and Jane, have recently returned from New York City to care for Mr. Bennett, who had a heart attack. At Mrs. Bennett's insistence and canoodling, she arranges to have the girls attend a party where Chip Bingley will be in attendance. Jane and Chip do indeed seem to hit it off, but Liz falls into immediate conflict with Dr. Fitzgerald Darcy, whom Liz overhears berating the qualities of the women of Cincinnati. When Liz discovers her family's dire financial situation, she becomes intent on getting her dysfunctional family back on track while maintaining a love/hate relationship with Darcy, who seems to be everywhere Liz goes (Skyline Chili, running in the neighborhood, etc.).
I LOVED this book. Not only was it well written, the dialogue was sharp, witty, and filled with sexual tension. The author completely modernized this story including very current technology, reality television, and recent slang (hate sex, selfies, etc.) This is the ultimate summer read, mixing snarky, intelligent pop culture with characters you come to care about. And now that I've read it, I no longer feel obligated to read P&P. Win-Win.
"Well before his arrival in Cincinnati, everyone knew that Chip Bingley was looking for a wife."
Said Chip had been on the television reality show Eligible, hoping to find love, and broke all the
For Mrs. Bennet, Chip's arrival in Cincinnati was perfect timing. The two eldest Bennet daughters, Jane nearly forty and Liz not far behind, were returning home to help out after Mr. Bennet's coronary artery bypass surgery. After all, Mrs. Bennet couldn't handle an invalid AND chair the Women's League fundraising luncheon. As far as Mrs. Bennet was concerned, having a medical man in the family would be a perk.
Only Liz knows that Jane opted for artificial insemination after the break up of her last relationship. Liz writes for a magazine and has no plans for children. But she has been in love with her 'best friend' Jasper Wick for years, although they never became a 'couple' until after Jasper's married. Fourteen years Liz waited for him to realize they were meant for each other. Jasper had no intention of divorcing his wife, so Liz becomes his 'best friend' with benefits.
Liz soon discovers not only mom but dear old dad needs 'handling,' beginning with mom's shopping addiction and the huge medical bills piling up because dad was uninsured. Living at home still are Mary, in graduate school, and freeloaders Kitty and Lydia, in their early twenties.
The Bennet family are invited to the Lucas's house to meet Chip, where, of course, his friend Darcy snubs Liz. Meanwhile, 'cousin Willie' has made millions and shows up looking for a wife, and a snarky Caroline Bingley warns Liz off.
You know the story--just not this version of the story. Everything is updated: the daughter's ages, their sex lives, and the problems they face are very 21st c. Racism, sexual orientation, transgender issues, and the artificial reality of television make appearances.
It is a very funny novel, and overall a very clever updating of Austen. I especially loved Sittenfeld's version of Mr. Bennet.
"I don't suppose that any of you can appreciate the terror a man might feel being so outnumbered," Mr. Bennet said. "I often weep, and there are only six of you."
I thought the updated scene of Liz trying to get to an ailing Jane was handled well; in the original, Liz walks through dirty lanes and fields, arriving in most unfashionable condition. Sittenfeld has Liz jog across town, arriving drenched in sweat. Each version of Liz shows how she places family bonds above social approbation, and in each she proves herself to be healthy, active, fit, and glowing.
Showing my age, and early monogamy, it was discomforting to read about all the premarital sex going on. All the sexual tension between Darcy and Elizabeth? I sure missed that. And where Austen's Liz has her own pride, Sittenfeld's Liz is a terrible drunk. Not my favorite handling of this character.
Eligible also misses the darker side of Austen: the soldier's camp gathered because of the looming war with France, Liz's challenge to the social hierarchy by not kowtowing to her social superiors, the church held in thrall by those who hold the living to the point of the Rev. Mr. Collins being instructed on what to preach. And Wick is an almost comic philanderer, Liz willing to settle for his terms, when Wickham was a seducer of a young heiress, a liar, a gambler, and an gold-digging opportunist--very evil qualities in Austen's day.
But I applaud Sittenfeld's novel for picking up on Austen's witty social jabs and the bright and sparkling aspect of the original.
I obtained a copy of the book through my local public library.
I think Sittenfeld did a great job of keeping the tone of the original, while updating both characters and situations to suit current times – some
Liz and Darcy’s relationship feels a little more natural, if not slightly more awkward thanks to Liz’s big mouth (which I found funny) and there’s finally some action! –wink wink- Jane is pushing forty, single and trying to have a baby via artificial insemination. Chip Bingley spent time on a Bachelor-esque show trying to find love and Darcy is a neurosurgeon. Kathy de Bourgh shines as a feminist icon and (sadly) Mary is more selfish and annoying than I’ve ever seen her portrayed before. Sittenfeld even includes some LGBT characters.
I wished Mary had been likable (for once!), but overall I was happy with how all the characters played out and the pacing kept me saying “just one more chapter” over and over – it helps that the chapters aren’t more than a few pages each.
I do think the story concluded on a weird note. Not the actual plot of the ending, but the last two pages had an odd tone that didn’t feel like a conclusion for me and brought the focus back to Mary, rather than Liz and Darcy. Rather than finishing with a smile I was left scratching my head.
I recommend this to anyone looking for a modern adaptation of Pride and Prejudice, if only for some scenes where Liz and Darcy actually make physical contact! Jokes aside, this is a solid adaptation and I enjoyed it as much as I enjoyed the updated rendition of Northanger Abbey.
I've won a few P&P retellings from Goodreads so far and they have all been amazing. My only complaint about this one was that some parts felt long winded or like they didn't need to be there? But overall I really loved it. A
I'm a Janeite through and through and I've enjoyed many contemporary adaptations of Austen's works; Eligible has quickly joined my favourites. Sittenfeld does a brilliant job of bringing the Bennets and their social circle into the 21st century. Not once did the characters feel like they had diverged widely from their original templates. I greatly appreciated that Sittenfeld also brings along all of the major plot points of the original tale into the modern period and makes them utterly believable and compelling reading even though I knew roughly how things would be resolved. A must-read for any Austen and/or P&P fan.
Ms. Sittenfeld is an
But I do love P&P and I just had such a hard time with Elizabeth and Darcy (and the fact that there was zero chemistry other than quick beddings). And in this version Elizabeth has apparently lost any type of intelligence and is sleeping with a sleezeball that she's been in love with forever (why is it that "modern" equals women having meaningless sex and sleeping with married men?).
Sittenfeld adds her own modern twists to the original story, and I think it was very well done. She addresses issues in our society regarding feminism, racism, and the LGBT community that really speak to modern
So overall, it was an interesting retelling that made me laugh out loud multiple times.