The Big Umbrella

A cheery red umbrella, initially held by one child during a rain shower, grows and grows as more people (and animals) seek shelter underneath its benign aegis. No matter how many newcomers join, the red umbrella always has room for them...

Pairing a simple text - one sentence per two-page spread -

Show More

with lovely artwork done in watercolor, gouache and pencil, The Big Umbrella is a deceptively simple picture-book. It's clear that the story is meant to be read allegorically, and that it addresses the issues of immigration and tolerance, making an argument that there is room for all. Although most likely not the intention of the creators - mother-daughter team Amy June and Juniper Bates - I think it could also be read as an exploration of the idea of the "big tent," referencing a political party or movement's tolerance of a wide variety of viewpoints within their membership, something that seems to have fallen out of favor recently, but that could use a widespread revival. Leaving that aside, although I think that this is a book with its heart in the right place, when it comes to its overall message of inclusivity, when it is read as an allegory of immigration, it is not without flaw. I am certainly in agreement with the idea that immigration is a net positive, and that a diverse array of newcomers should be welcomed, but I think the argument that "there is always room" (the final words of the book) is a false one. Every country in the world has immigration controls, as is their right, and these controls are usually based around the needs of the citizens, and the existing resources available. Sometimes there isn't more room - and that's OK. With the proviso that adults be aware of its shortcomings, as an exploration (however oblique) of the issues around immigration, this is one I would recommend as a general "inclusivity is a good thing" kind of story. I would also recommend it to fans of Amy June Bates' artwork, in whose number I count myself.

Show Less