Misreading Scripture with Western Eyes: Removing Cultural Blinders to Better Understand the Bible

by E. Randolph Richards

Paperback, 2012

Status

Available

Call number

Mission Ric

Collection

Publication

IVP Books (2012), Edition: 1, 240 pages

Description

What was clear to the original readers of Scripture is not always clear to us. Because of the cultural distance between the biblical world and our contemporary setting, we often bring modern Western biases to the text. For example, when Western readers hear Paul exhorting women to "dress modestly," we automatically think in terms of sexual modesty. But most women in that culture would never wear racy clothing. The context suggests that Paul is likely more concerned about economic modesty-that Christian women not flaunt their wealth through expensive clothes, braided hair, and gold jewelry. By the same token, Western individualism leads us to assume that Mary and Joseph traveled alone to Bethlehem. What went without saying was that they were likely accompanied by a large entourage of extended family. Biblical scholars Brandon O'Brien and Randy Richards shed light on the ways that Western readers often misunderstand the cultural dynamics of the Bible. They identify nine key areas where modern Westerners have significantly different assumptions about what might be going on in a text. Drawing on their own cross-cultural experience in global mission, O'Brien and Richards show how better self-awareness and understanding of cultural differences in language, time, and social mores allow us to see the Bible in fresh and unexpected ways.… (more)

User reviews

LibraryThing member TnTexas
Definitely an eye-opening, challenging book. Would recommend it to anyone who is interested in understanding how cultural bias affects everything we do - even how we interpret/view the Bible.
LibraryThing member gdill
It seemed to me the authors focused more on the many cultural differences (mores) of the world rather than the misreading of Scripture. As a cross-cultural worker living in a different country I appreciated the many illustrations and stories the authors used to compare the differences between
Show More
eastern and western cultures. They did give plenty of examples of how often we inject our own cultural mores into our interpretations of Scripture, which too was very helpful. Ironically, much of the Bible was written from a people of eastern culture, which after having understood that culture more, the Bible seems to come more alive for me. Excellent book that I highly recommend especially to western missionaries doing cross-cultural ministry in eastern cultures.
Show Less
LibraryThing member thornton37814
The authors of this book challenge their readers to identify prejudices that are brought to their reading of Scripture simply because of their Western worldview. Citing numerous examples, they show how other cultures read Biblical stories differently because of cultural differences. The book is
Show More
highly readable for both laity and Biblical scholars and will generate good discussion whether used in a Sunday School or in a college classroom.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Chris_El
An excellent reminder for people to think about their cultural assumptions and how they shape how they read the bible. Our modern ways of thinking are not always similar to the cultural ways people often thought in the time scripture was written. Worth the read if this is a subject that interests
Show More
you.
Show Less
LibraryThing member OJSchrock
This is an easy reading book dealing with the challenges of properly understanding the Bible from a foreign culture. This is not at all about being “culturally relevant,” but it is a study of the fact that, "reading the Bible is a cross-cultural experience."

Living in a third-world country, I
Show More
can now understand better just how much a difference “culture” can make in how a person interprets what he sees, reads, or hears! Before living here in Brazil, I would probably have laughed at many of the cultural differences he discusses - our tendency is to assume we are right and others are just “ignorant.” For example, Brazilian inefficiency and lack of time management has driven me crazy, but to a Brazilian, Relationship trump schedules and it’s far more important to “be friendly and neighborly” by stopping to chat than to “rudely" hurry past a friend in order to get where you’re going on time! So, who is right? :) Instead of just scorning the “unlearned natives” I have to admit that many times they do have an equally valid point.

The authors focus on cultural aspects that “just go without needing to be said.” It’s these areas where we can easily mis-read the Bible by assuming the characters involved had the same values that we do. You can understand better the difficulty when you consider the phrase, “Fido was a good dog.” If you live in the Scottish Highlands you’ll interpret that to mean that Fido handled sheep well; if you live in America, you’ll understand that Fido didn’t chew your slippers; if you live in Indonesia, you’ll acknowledge that Fido was perfectly seasoned...

There are many “values” that are so revered for us as americans (Efficiency, Individuality, Planning, Predictability, Self-Sufficiency, Free Market) that we read them into scriptures and determine they must be “right,” but many of these are foreign concepts to other cultures and the culture of the Bible! (Has it ever occurred to you that Paul was completely unfamiliar with, and would have probably opposed, the idea of a free-trade market?)

Of course I have to write a disclaimer. The book has a few heresies, (at one point he seems to argue that David was not bothered by an internal conscience but only by external shame. I understand David’s greater emphasis on the public shame, but based on Ps. 32:3 and 51:2, I argue David did have an internal guilt as well)

But I think the book can be helpful if read, not as a source of new doctrine or a radical change from what you believe (they even warn against that) but as a challenge to your way of thinking. Having grown up in church, it’s so easy for us to look at a passage and mentally “sum it up,” but I think it’s good to take another look and reconsider what it meant to the original readers at that time. So, this book is definitely a good place to start challenging yourself to understand the Bible as it was written - not merely as a 21st century middle-class american.
Show Less

Original publication date

2012-07-31
Page: 0.1229 seconds