A boy named Daniel selects a novel from a library of rare books, enjoying it so much that he searches for the rest of the author's works, only to discover that someone is destroying every book the author has ever written. Barcelona, 1945-just after the war, a great world city lies in shadow, nursing its wounds, and a boy named Daniel awakes on his eleventh birthday to find that he can no longer remember his mother's face. To console his only child, Daniel's widowed father, an antiquarian book dealer, initiates him into the secret of the Cemetery of Forgotten Books, a library tended by Barcelona's guild of rare-book dealers as a repository for books forgotten by the world, waiting for someone who will care about them again. Daniel's father coaxes him to choose a volume from the spiraling labyrinth of shelves, one that, it is said, will have a special meaning for him. And Daniel so loves the novel he selects, The Shadow of the Wind by one Julian Carax, that he sets out to find the rest of Carax's work. To his shock, he discovers that someone has been systematically destroying every copy of every book this author has written. In fact, he may have the last one in existence. Before Daniel knows it his seemingly innocent quest has opened a door into one of Barcelona's darkest secrets, an epic story of murder, magic, madness and doomed love. And before long he realizes that if he doesn't find out the truth about Julian Carax, he and those closest to him will suffer horribly. As with all astounding novels, The Shadow of the Wind sends the mind groping for comparisons- The Crimson Petal and the White? The novels of Arturo Peacute-Reverte? Of Victor Hugo? Love in the Time of Cholera ?-but in the end, as with all astounding novels, no comparison can suffice. As one leading Spanish reviewer wrote, ldquo. The originality of Ruiz Zafoacute's voice is bombproof and displays a diabolical talent. The Shadow of the Wind announces a phenomenon in Spanish literature. An uncannily absorbing historical mystery, a heart-piercing romance, and a moving homage to the mystical power of books, The Shadow of the Wind is a triumph of the storyteller's art.
"About accursed books, about the man who wrote them, about a character who broke out of the pages of a novel so that he could burn it, about a betrayal and a lost friendship. It's a story of love, of hatred, and of the dreams that live in the shadow of the wind."
These words appear just under halfway through The Shadow of the Wind, and are spoken by Daniel Sempere, its narrator. 178 pages earlier, as the story opens, Daniel is taken by his bookseller father to the Cemetery of Forgotten Books. Part of this rite of passage is that Daniel must select a book--or, to be more accurate, he must allow a book to select him. With this selection comes the responsibility to keep the book alive, to make sure that it is not forgotten. The book he selects is The Shadow of the Wind, by the mysterious Julian Carax. Daniel reads the novel in one delerious, heated night, and spends the next decade pursuing its author and his story.
But no synopsis could do justice to this rich, gorgeous feast of a novel. Set in post-Civil War Barcelona, The Shadow of the Wind is full of Gothic settings, Victorian characters, Magical Realist flourishes. There are crumbling mansions and equally crumbling aristocratic families, brutal fascist police officers and the political refugees they pursue, girls as beautiful as angels and men so horribly deformed that no one can look them in the face. But, more than anything, there are words.
Ruiz Zafon has an ease with language that most can only envy. Open the book to any page and you will find gorgeous turns of phrase which in lesser hands (and with a lesser translator, one must imagine) would be merely trite and over-written.
Everything good that you've heard about The Shadow of the Wind is true...anything negative must have been said by someone without a touch of whimsy anywhere in his life.
The language flowery and verbose is incredibly distracting to anything that's going on in the plot. The plot while interesting at first, quickly starts to feel like a lead weight that the author uses to blugeon his readers with. Read The Ghost Writer by John Harwood, if you are in the mood for secrets, betrayal, books, and intrigue.
I honestly can't find anything positive to say about this book, which is rare. But it does solidify my suspicion that sometimes critics don't read every book to completion, especially if the plot sounds enticing and you can use the names Borges, Dickens, Eco, and Marquez in one breath to describe it. If any of the critics that reviewed this book so enthusiasically actually bothered to finish it, then I'd be highly suspicious of their critical reading skills. (One caveat is that my preference is not for classics, which this book reminds me of. But I find many classics to be nuanced while this book is just a shallow imitation with all the bad qualities such as flowery prose).
In a broad, all-encompassing tale of life in Barcelona more than half a century ago, in a time of great political upheaval and social distress, it is the story of Daniel Sempere; whose mother died from cholera when he was six, and whose father, the owner of a book store of rare treasures and second-hand collectibles, valiantly strives to nurture his child in a difficult world. At the age of ten, Daniel – in an attempt to assuage his still-lingering grief – is brought one morning, by his father, to the Cemetery of Forgotten Books; to follow a long-standing tradition of adopting a book and therefore “keeping it alive, for life.” The book he chooses is The Shadow of the Wind by Julián Carax, a little-known and scarcely-published author; but whose book affects Daniel to such a degree that he is driven to find his other writings. And here lies the rub: for someone is steadily and methodically, and by any means, destroying every book this author has ever written; an ominous character even approaching Daniel upfront to buy his copy, otherwise threatening dire consequences. Yet he will not part with the work he feels has chosen him, instead hiding it again in the Cemetery of Forgotten Books.
Thus Daniel’s adventure begins: as he searches for the answers to his beloved book’s mystery, and that of its author, he learns, simultaneously, over the next ten years, the answers to many of life’s complexities. And it is within this potent mix that the truth is realised, as the world of Daniel, and his friends, coalesces around this book, and the sordid past inherent in its creation.
Carlos Ruiz Zafón constructs, within this tale, a cacophony of irrepressible characters, full of personality and wit, and incredible strength-of-mind and ability to overcome difficult situations; though suffering daily, none are willing to give up or give in. Foremost of these is Fermín Romero de Torres, an incorrigible romantic with a pearl of wisdom, and a very true depth of understanding, for nearly every instance of life; and who is pivotal in unravelling the story behind Julián Carax, and in Daniel’s maturity through his painful adolescent years. Almost, it seems, Fermín is the author’s instrument in disclosing the political and social injustices during, and after, the Spanish civil-war, but tempering the darkness with an exuberance and optimism that is contagious, and life-affirming, despite the conditions of the times. His acumen, in many cases, is worthy reading alone!
The Shadow of the Wind is a concoction of many things: part mystery, part fantasy, part history; it mingles strong desires and passions of life alongside basic bodily functions with such skill, and with such humour, pathos and understanding, that is riveting. Essentially though, to me, it pays homage to the written word, and the power inherent in the pages of a book. And to a reverence for books: where “in truth books have no owners. Every book you see here has been somebody’s best friend.” And in choosing a book "...we adopt it, making sure it will never disappear, that it will always stay alive” even as all else “disappears in the shadow of the wind.” May I find many friends as remarkable, and impressive, as this one, for the rest of my reading life.
We're treated to Zafon's relentless metaphor/simile attack throughout the book -- and these are metaphors that would give the instructors at the Iowa Writers' Workshop reason to scold, and scold harshly, once they were through gagging. "I could distinguish the shape of the blue tram, moving away through folds of violet mist." "...conjuring up a halo of amber light that seemed to float in the air like a cobweb trapped between mantles of impenetrable darkness." "...and revealed the dancing shapes of the walls that wept with tears of dampness, the fallen ceilings and dilapidated doors." Those can all be found on one page: 299.
Sometimes this lurid prose fails to make any sort of sense: "The stone, dark and slimy with rain, shone like the skeleton of a huge reptile." (page 415) Richard Eder of the New York Times is the one who praised this book and made the comparisons with Eco, Borges, and Garcia-Marquez. He should know better.
Could the joke be on us? That's what Jennie Yabroff muses about in her review in San Francisco Chronicle. A satire on potboilers? But she has to conclude that Zafon wants us to take him seriously. She calls it a tiring, meandering tale, and I wholeheartedly agree. It consists mostly of one colorful character after another relating their piece of the story, usually in a lengthy remembrance with plenty of non-essential subplots thrown in that puts a halt to any shred of momentum that might build. It just wears the reader out.
Along the way, as Daniel encounters numerous fascinating characters, we are taken back to Julián Carax's youth when, as a poor hatmaker's son, he was taken under the wing of a powerful businessman, and fell in love with at first sight with the man's daughter on his first visit to his sponsor's haunted mansion, thus setting in motion the train of events which Daniel uncovers, as he finds one clue after another. A tale of love, loss and obsession, about the bonds of friendship and the quest for revenge, truth and redemption, this is a richly told, multilayered story which satisfies at every page.
Please note the only reason I didn't give this book five stars is that I found the English translation wanting, though this is no fault of the translator; I look forward to reading the story again in the French translation, which will presumably better express the latin passion and immediacy of the original Spanish text. Regardless, the story itself transcends language, and I can't recommend this novel strongly enough.
The book opens with the young narrator’s father taking him to the Cemetery of Forgotten Books. The father explains to the boy that visitors are allowed to choose a book only if they pledge to keep it alive. Ten-year-old Daniel chooses The Shadow of the Wind by Julian Carax. He falls in love with the book and becomes obsessed with finding out as much as he can about its enigmatic author. So our book becomes a mysterious quest to find the truth about Carax—how The Shadow of the Wind came into existence, and ultimately made its way into the Cemetery of Forgotten Books. It is also a captivating coming-of-age tale.
At one point in the novel the main character Daniel, tries to explain to his girlfriend Beatriz his obsession with Carax. He tells her that his obsession is all “about accursed books, about the man who wrote them, about a character who got out of the pages of a novel so that he could burn it, about a betrayal and a lost friendship. It’s a story of love, of hatred and of the dreams that live in the shadow of the wind.” Beatriz teases Daniel, saying that he talks like “a jacket blurb of a Victorian novel.” And how right she is!
This work does read like a Victorian novel, yet it is set in the period just after the Spanish Civil War. The book delivers a maze of stories within stories most with mysteries behind every revelation. The reader will be reminded of the styles of many long-gone literary giants. But don’t be lulled into expecting too much on account of the novel's florid literary style—if you do you may be disappointed and miss the fun! This is a work of contemporary fiction, not a literary masterpiece. Also, it is not a realistic drama, but melodrama. To enjoy it, you’ll need to turn off your reality sensors and step into a world where good and evil are clear, and characters are larger than life. I am not suggesting that there is fantasy, or surrealism here, merely the exaggerated perceptions of a young man who has not yet reached maturity, a boy who has spent his life reading perhaps a little too much fiction. In this fashion, Daniel’ naïve view of life reminds me of the young Catherine Morland in Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey.
There is much in Záfon’s prose that delights; there is also much that I found poorly executed and over-the-top—but on the whole, the novel is far better than most popular fiction. There is plenty to enjoy in this almost-500-page novel…but if you prefer, listen to the sumptuous unabridged audio version (16 CDs, 19 hours) where the reading is frequently accompanied by original music composed by the author to enhance the mood and adds to the melodrama. The reader, Jonathan Davis, is outstanding. Listening to this novel accentuates its sensory experience!
Although Záfon was born in Barcelona, he has spend almost the last two decades living in Los Angeles, making a living as a television screenwriter. This is his debut novel. Originally written in Spanish and published in Spain, the book was translated into English by the talented Lucia Graves, daughter of the famous British literary giant, Robert Graves. Záfon admits that he has a lifelong fascination for 19th-century English literature. But his first love is great storytelling, wherever he finds it—in books, television, or movies. He has spent a great deal of time painstakingly deconstructing the world’s best storytellers to discover their secrets.
This novel has become an international bestseller because the author learned his lessons well and does seem to possess some magical inside track to the art of great storytelling. With time, he should get even better. I recommend this book highly and look forward to the author’s next novel.
The whole thing feels like it desperately wants be seen as some kind of profound parable, but the only result is that the characters are just implausible symbols. They are too bland even to hate – unlike the book itself, which I loathed.
About an hour back in the book, the question** occured to me; Is this completely devoted, self-sacrificing exhibit of love actually real, or does it only exist in the make-believe? Could you starve yourself of all life and passion save that of the one person to whom your heart is devoted to.
**I have begun to believe that when a book is good, it leaves me with a thoughtful, insightful, contemplative question or conviction.
Man! I'll tell you - Don't think you have the book figured out until you have reached the last page, I don't care how good you think you are. I kept thinking I could see the bends and twists in the plot ahead of time, but I don't think I got any of them right.
And such a variety of characters - noble & self-sacrificing, greedy, naive, bitter & jealous, twisted & sadistic... you see it all, and there is a little bit of everything in the plot - love, romance, mystery, frustration, anger... passion, heartache, emotion, uncertainty, and intrigue.
I recommend this book without hesitation.
What a perfect, and beautiful circle of a story.
The writing itself is excellent – “flashing a mysterious smile probably borrowed from the pages of one of his worn Alexandre Dumas romances” is one of my favourite phrases of the book. Zafón distinguishes well between the voices of different characters (which, given the number of flashbacks and retellings of events by other characters, is pretty important) and while the characters are all very individual, none of them is ridiculous.
Similarly, I loved the fact that I could follow the places in the book – I’ve been to Barcelona (only once, and only for a week), but fortunately the book was mostly set in the centre of town and out towards the area where I stayed when I was there, so I recognised many of the place names and the character of the city, which Zafón represents very well.
I struggled with the plot – the sheer number of childhood romances and implausible pregnancies bugged me, as did the jumpy timeline. The book is full of adventure and intrigue and all those wonderful plot ingredients, which I can see appealing to both male and female readers of all ages. I can certainly understand why this is a favourite with readers the world over, and I enjoyed the book, but it’s not right up there in the “I’m going to bully everyone I know into reading this” category.
Zafon captures the reader quickly. When Daniel, a ten year old boy, is brought to a mysterious place called The Cemetery of Books, his father swears him to secrecy and then explains: "According to tradition, the first time someone visits this place, he must choose a book, whichever one he wants, and adopt it, making sure that it will never disappear, that it will always stay alive. It's a very important promise. For life," explained my father. "Today it's your turn."
Daniel chooses a book - or perhaps the book chooses him. It is a book entitled The Shadow of the Wind, written by Julian Carax and it entrances the boy and takes him on a convoluted journey which is swathed in mystery. Who is the man with no face who has set out to destroy every book every written by Julian Carax? What became of the author?
Zafon's novel is filled with memorable characters - my favorite being Fermin Romero de Torres, a homeless man saved from the gutter by Daniel and his father and who comes with a dark and cryptic history of his own. Fermin's wonderful philosophy of life, filled with bawdy humor made me laugh out loud at times.
The novel's plot is twisting - weaving back in time and making unexpected turns. No one is who they seem to be. Characters in Daniel's found novel become intertwined with people he knows or has known. Zafon keeps the reader guessing with his compelling and dramatic story filled with betrayal, murder, missing people and romance.
The Shadow of the Wind is a giant of a book and a must read for bibliophiles and those who love epics with a Gothic flavor.
But I detected the whiff of musty rotting lace even stronger than that. Dickens’s Great Expectations seemed to me a much closer relative to “The Shadow of the Wind”. The sense of the past being relived in the future, the idea that the young characters whose lives are ostensibly the focus of the book being only the newer versions of those who have gone before them…not to mention the constant theme of forbidden love.
This book in all senses is a book about time gone by. It is about passions that are larger than life, all consuming hatred, soul destroying despair. Nothing is small; no character is simply a bystander, no event without meaning. The writing drips with color without being too flowery, the words evoke one’s senses while still allowing the reader to bring his/her own imagination to the table. One feels as if this is a story that has always existed, has always been played out…I could almost feel the dust on the book jacket of my brand new copy of this novel.
I appreciate, too, the underlying theme of the love of books, of words. When one encounters “The Cemetery of Forgotten Books”, I felt my hands itching to go there, to see the shelves and shelves of treasures. Books and the power of their words come up again and again, which is an idea I can certainly appreciate.
“Once, in my father’s bookstore, I heard a regular customer say that few things leave a deeper mark on a reader than the first book that finds its way into his heart. Those first images, the echo of words we think we have left behind, accompany us throughout our lives and sculpt a place in our memory to which, sooner or later – no matter how many books we read, how many worlds we discover, or how much we learn or forget – we will return.”
While being an engrossing story that kept me turning the pages more than taking notes, the story, whose main timeline takes place in Barcelona in 1955, offers a few very prescient views of the future:
“Television, my dear Daniel, is the Antichrist, and I can assure you that after only three or four generations, people will no longer even know how to fart on their own and humans will return to living in caves, to medieval savagery, and to the general state of imbecility that slugs overcame back in the Pleistocene era. Our world will not die as a result of the bomb, as the papers say, it will die of laughter, of banality, of making a joke of everything, and a lousy joke at that.”
(As a side note, the author does pull one of those plot tricks that I am VERY dubious about. One of those, “In seven days time, SOMETHING VERY IMPORTANT WILL HAPPEN” warnings. As an avid reader of Stephen King, I have become very wary of those dire predictions…and I still haven’t made up my mind whether they improve or harm the flow of the story, though I am leaning towards harm.)
The sense of history repeating itself comes up not only in the lives of the characters but in references to the world in general. “Nothing feeds forgetfulness better than war, Daniel. We all keep quiet and the try and convince us that what we’ve seen, what we’ve done, what we’ve learned about ourselves and about others, is an illusion, a passing nightmare. Wars have no memory, and nobody has the courage to understand them until there are no voices left to tell what happened, until the moment comes when we no longer recognize them and they return, with another face and another name, to devour what they left behind.”
“The Shadow of the Wind” was a wonderful book to curl up with these past few days. I liked getting to enjoy damsels in distress, mysterious figures in the shadows, deathbed confessions, duels at dawn, the constant struggle of love trying to overcome hate…and an actual villain with no redeeming qualities. So often the books that I read, because they are generally based in reality, examine all of the shades of grey that make up human beings. I’d forgotten what an escape it is to very easily identify the “good guys” and the “bad guys.”
It’s been a long time since I’ve read a book with a scene like this that I could enjoy instead of rolling my eyes, “When I peered into the corridor, I could already hear the footsteps below, near the staircase. I recognized the spidery shadow on the walls, the black raincoat, the hat pulled down like a hood, and the gun in his hand shining like a scythe. Fumero. He had always reminded me of someone, or something, but until then I hadn’t understood what.”
You can just smell the musty odors, see the dripping candle wax, feel the mysterious breeze go past your face, can’t you?
This book gives one the sense of a guilty pleasure without giving any reason to feel guilty. It is a wonderful story, one that should be dusted off time and time again.
The best summation of the book’s charms, such as they are, comes from the very first blurb on the back of my copy. It’s from Stephen King, who calls this lengthy tome (a subject on which King is undoubtedly expert) ‘a novel full of cheesy splendor’. Just so.
For this is a supremely cheesy story, blending over-the-top Gothic settings and atmosphere with Boys’ Own characterizations with Harlequinesque romance and erotic flashes. What mystifies me is the comparisons others (e.g. The New York Times Book Review) have made between this book and far superior works such as Umberto Eco’s. Yes, I suppose there is a big ol’ dark musty library in this novel, so it must be just like The Name of the Rose . . . well, perhaps not.
In short, The Shadow of the Wind follows the adventures of Daniel, a young boy in mid-20th century Barcelona. He grows up in a bookstore, and his equally bookish father introduces him to a mysterious library from which he’s allowed to choose one volume; it turns out to be an almost magical novel whose backstory Daniel traces out through the remainder of the plot.
And as we work through nearly 500 pages of florid descriptions punctuated by 'blinding' (but utterly unsurprising) revelations, epic are the adventures of the courageous men and ravishing women; pure and holy are their loves; smoldering are their passions; dark is the doom that hangs over them . . . oh man, I’ve had enough of this. Let’s just say that Ruiz Zafon overwrites shamelessly, then subjects his readers to a lengthy and startlingly prosaic dénouement that undermines whatever sense of mystery and dread he manages to build up in the book’s first three-quarters.
After finally finishing The Shadow of the Wind, I felt an immediate need to cleanse my reading palate with something cool, fresh and bracing. It’s time for some Raymond Chandler.
Entranced by the novel, young Daniel sets out to discover who this Carax was, and what else he wrote. Daniel’s father, the book dealer, has never heard of Carax. Together they consult other dealers. One offers Daniel a considerable sum of money for his copy of The Shadow of the Wind—but won’t say why he prizes it so highly. Daniel, though, refuses to sell the book.
Years go by. Daniel hears a story about Carax and his books. Someone is going from town to town, shop to shop, seeking out the works of Julián Carax—and burning them. But who would do such a thing—and why? As Daniel matures, so does the mystery.
Carlos Ruiz Zafón’s novel is a love story of several layers of significance. There’s the adolescent Daniel, coming of age in Franco’s Spain, and doing what young boys do: listlessly lusting after young women. Daniel’s relationships, first with the blind girl, Clara, and later with his best friend’s sister, Bea, are also bonds of literary friendship: books, like beds, allow lovers to share sheets. As Daniel tells Bea one evening over a couple of coffees:
…this is a story about books.”
“About accursed books, about the man who wrote them, about a character who broke out of the pages of a novel so that he could burn it, about a betrayal and a lost friendship. It’s a story of love, of hatred, and of the dreams that live in the shadow of the wind.”
But is the burner of Carax’s novels really Carax? As Daniel grows—both in life and into the investigation of his beloved The Shadow of the Wind—he discovers that Carax died years ago. It appears that Carax died, as Daniel has felt he surely would, of a broken heart. And yet, what if…?
“And yet, what if…?” is, of course, precisely what propels a reader through a great novel like Zafón’s. The wind of speculation keeps blowing shadows of mystery down the side streets, pulling us on into the labyrinth in pursuit of the story of the novel within the novel. Zafón is a great-hearted writer, keenly aware that books are bits of soul-stuff and just as prone to the vicissitudes of time and place as are their human authors and readers. Zafón sketches character and context beautifully, working in the political reality of Franco’s dictatorship with candor and humor, but without ever making a spectacle of life in a totalitarian regime. A bestseller in Spain, The Shadow of the Wind is craftily translated by the daughter of Robert Graves, Lucia Graves. Unfortunately, it hasn’t been very well received in the U.S., where the thriller genre has been stupefied by the likes of ignoramus Michael Crichton. The Shadow of the Wind harks back to an era when characters changed—not by growing an extra arm, but changed psychologically, seeing the world as the dangerous and potentially redemptive place it is. For fans of Jorge Luis Borges, Umberto Eco and other writers who craft twisting and turning plots with complex characterization, The Shadow of the Wind is not to be missed.
Originally published in Curled Up with a Good Book
I felt it was less a mystery, more that most of the characters were in dire need of psychiatric counselling. I think I was so disengaged because the novel was pushed forward by introduction of a new character time and again who related their story. And books that generally grab me are ones that 'show, don't tell'.
Can't for the life of me understand why this was a best-seller.
I loved the concept of the Cemetery of Forgotten Books when I first encountered it, and the opening chapter that bore it's name, but among the disappointments of the novel is I felt it went no where. Many people adore this book; a close friend whose tastes I trust, if not always mirror, told me she hated it, and that among those reasons is how Daniel betrays that secret. Well before that he betrayed his guardianship by at one point giving the book away to a woman he has a crush on. But what I couldn't forgive was how the whole concept was developed, or not developed. Who chooses the books? Why aren't you supposed to tell anyone? To whom and for what purpose is the secret revealed? But you know when I really wanted to throw this book across the room? When Daniel takes someone back to that "Cemetery" of Forgotten books, he tells her to choose one, just as his father told him to choose one. And what does she choose? Thomas Hardy's Tess of the d'Urbervilles! In what alternate universe is that a forgotten book? In that one choice, Zafon transformed a magical mystical place into... a used bookstore.
A petty point, I know, but it's hardly the only hole or improbability in the book. I've seen reviewers defend those lapses as "magical realism." I see nothing magical or realistic in this convoluted tale. I haven't read Marquez or Borges, whom I've seen Zafon compared to, but I have read Isabel Allende, Laura Esquivel, Joanne Harris, Toni Morrison, and Alice Hoffman, and when they insert magic into their narratives, you know it--it's not an excuse for a muddled or implausible plot.
I've also read the events are meant to be a tribute to the Gothic tradition. Stephen King calls the book "full of cheesy splendor." Well, I'm all for that kind of cheese. I found Matthew Lewis' The Monk and Wilkie Collins The Woman in White and Diane Setterfield's The Thirteenth Tale and even some novels of Stephen King great fun, but this novel fell flat to me.
I also wasn't wild about the style. Here's a typical sentence from a random page: The steely sun snatched copper reflections from the roofs and belfries of the Gothic quarter. It's the kind of prose some might see as poetic and lyrical, and others as florid and purple. I'm on the purple side of the fence, and I don't think you can blame the author's pile-on of adjectives on the translation. Or the chunks of narrative in italics--an effect by itself I find cheesy and annoying. Or the soft porn sex scene early on.
I'm afraid when it comes to this one, I'm in the decided minority of detractors--even if I at least I can console myself I'm in good company with my friend.
I fell in love after 10 pages. His writing style is gorgeous and captivating. I felt myself get lost inside his world of words.
His storytelling was incredible. I loved the way he would intertwine all these people's stories to make one amazing journey.
I felt so connected to Daniel and his search to solve the mystery of Julian Carax. I loved the connection with Victor Hugo's pen. That was so ingenious.
His story writing is just so amazing. I didn't want it to end. I'm so glad I decided to pick this book up. I want to read more of his books.
What a novel! This book was so good that I rationed myself to one or two short chapters twice a day in order to prolong the ecstasy of living in my imagination within the dark and twisting streets of 1950s Barcelona. "The Shadow of the Wind" is ultimate escapist fiction. Ultimate magical realism. Ultimate mystery. Ultimate political indictment of Franco’s Spain. Ultimate adventure.
And it's also a delightful self-referential literary novel that begins in “the cemetery of lost books” where young Daniel Sempere is allowed to select a single volume to take home. He picks LA SOMBRA DEL VIENTO by Julian Carax, a mysterious figure who haunts Daniel and whose life seems a parallel or echo of his own. With the book in his possession, Daniel's imagination is captivated as he descends into it and the adventure that will last into his maturity begins.
Zafón can weave a tale and an atmospheric spell of equal quality. Unexpected plot turns kept me in suspense and the sarcastic witty punning of the heroic Fermín Romero de Torres made me fall in love with Daniel's faithful “sidekick.” [Some readers will be reminded of "Gentlemen of the Road" by Michael Chabon.] The two worthy heroes are opposed by arch foe, Francisco Javier Fumero, a murderous and corrupt policeman, determined to make their life hell as he pursues a program of private and official revenge. The reader who is in the least bit familiar with Spanish history will recognize the symbolism of Daniel’s journey in pursuit of the free-spirited yet tragic Julian Carax as that of Spain’s history under Franco.
Fortunately for the people of Spain and we readers, both emerge from darkness to achieve a happy outcome.
YES! YES! YES! I read this book for my real word book club and for each book we read we vote and post whether we’d recommend our books to other book clubs. We vote either YES, MAYBE/NOT SURE, or NO. This book I will vote YES. There is a lot to discuss.
Magnificent! It’s beautifully written; the writing is gorgeous. I think the translation is excellent but since I can’t read it in the original Spanish, I can’t vouch for it. There were so many passages that I wanted to write down, so many fabulous quotes I wanted to note, way too many to share here. Besides, I think it’s best for readers of this book to discover them for themselves.
The Cemetery of Forgotten Books really struck my fancy. This is the story of a boy who's the son of a bookseller. He finds and reads a book and becomes obsessed with its history and its author.
This historical fiction literary mystery has so many twists and turns. It’s very suspenseful. It’s quite dark. It was a bit too scary for me. It’s an interesting story, with many sub-stories and a story within a story, having many characters that show character development, and a plot that has amazing complexity. Much to my chagrin, because I often do guess correctly, I figured out very little of what was going on until it was revealed.
It’s not even close to a perfect book though. Even though I kept getting sucked right back in, I felt a lot of irritation when everything kept getting so very drawn out. Also, I had a difficult time understanding most of these people, even though I loved/enjoyed many, especially Fermin, who’s wonderful and memorable!; I simply don’t recognize most of these people. The level of the persistent obsessive behavior was over the top, I thought.
I did appreciate the way the power of story and books and storytelling was illuminated in this book’s story.
What one character does at the end, after what he’s been through, well, I sort of get it, even though a part of me has a hard time understanding.
My paperback copy has a “Walk in the Footsteps of The Shadow of the Wind” section in the back with maps and photos of Barcelona.
I took a very long time to read this book, partly in order to savor it, but I did stay up late to finish this. It became more and more compelling reading as the book continued.
I could honestly rate this book anywhere from 5 stars (the stellar writing, the brilliance of the storytelling) to 3 stars (some unbelievable aspects of the people and mistakes(?) in the plot.) It’s very hard for me to rate. I’m tempted to give it 4 stars as a compromise, but even though I didn’t enjoy parts of it as much as I could have, it’s very hard to not give it 5 stars. 4 ½, I guess, which (even as I’m obsessing) I’ll up to 5 stars. Even though I felt tricked at one point and didn't appreciate it.
I'd hoped from the blurb that it might feel a bit like a long Borges work, what with the secret library. It wasn't really like that - I haven't got a good handy author comparison, but it was much more about the twists and turns of the plot and the history and the atmosphere - the atmosphere of Barcelona specifically and of post-Civil War Spain generally.
The only quibble I'd have is that this author doesn't do particularly well by his female characters - the love interest is not very fully delineated and although the "good end happily, the bad unhappily - that is what fiction means" that is noticeably less true for the women in the story.
At the age of 11, Daniel wakes up in terror because he can no longer remember what his dead mother looks like. On this day Daniel's father, an antiquarian bookseller takes Daniel to the Cemetery of Lost Books and tells him to pick one book. The Cemetery of Lost Books is the place books that have been forgotten by the world go to reside, and the book Daniel is drawn to is The Shadow of the Wind by Julian Carax.
Daniel is so taken with the book, he stays up all night to read it and then begins on a journey to find out more about the mysterious author.
Set in Barcelona, the story of Julian Carax is one of deeply held secrets, rumors, scandal, and things that go bump in the night. Four boyhood friends who meet at boarding school and whose lives are affected by adults with deeply held grudges. The friends drift apart after school but continue to unknowingly play important parts in each other's lives.
Daniel and his intrepid sidekick, Fermin Romero de Torres - a homeless man whom Daniel pleads with his father to employ at the bookstore - delve deep into the mystery of Julian Carax and The Shadow of the Wind. Along the way, they meet a policeman with murderous intent, love in all shapes and sizes, histories which were meant to remain buried and the one book which ties it all together.
I could go on and on about the wonders of the way this story is told and about the intricacies with which the solution to Daniel's quest for Julian Carax is revealed. But even having written what I have seems as though too much has already been revealed. The Shadow of the Wind deserves multiple readings.