Status
Available
Publication
New York ; Toronto : Scribner, c1995.
Description
In City Life, Witold Rybczynski looks at what we want from cities, how they have evolved, and what accounts for their unique identities. In this vivid description of everything from the early colonial settlements to the advent of the skyscraper to the changes wrought by the automobile, the telephone, the airplane, and telecommuting, Rybczynski reveals how our urban spaces have been shaped by the landscapes and lifestyles of the New World.
User reviews
LibraryThing member jcbrunner
Reading Rybczynski is like spelling his name. Fascinating and frustrating at the same time. His rambling style, excursions and personal anecdotes are interesting but ultimately distracting from the topic at hand. Most vexing are the omissions in his narrative. Does he not know or does he not
The book at hand deals with the development of the American city. His key question is: Why aren't North American cities like European ones? Frustratingly, he does not answer the question, presenting a history of urban development of the US in nine chapters: Kevin Lynch's types of cities (ch. 2); Spanish, French and English roots, grid and space (ch. 3); US individualism and aversion to public space (ch. 4); urban parks (ch. 5); railroad stations and public infrastructure (ch. 6); skyscrapers (Ch. 7); suburbs and public housing (ch. 8) and malls (ch. 9). The tenth chapter sees him moving from the Canadian border to Philly's suburbs.
The reader is left to distill the answer to Rybczynski's question himself among the morsels and underdeveloped themes. Most elements that feature prominently in his chapters are present in Europe (and the ignored rest of world) too, so they can not be the answer. As Rybczynski writes himself covered shopping malls existed in Milano and Paris before the US started building them (although the Americans upped the scale). Barcelona has a grid. The love of private space is not uncommon in England and elsewhere ... My explaining factors are geography, energy and government. The availability of unbroken, empty land and cheap energy were enablers. The major cause why US cities look so different from European ones is weak government which could not prevent the worst (broken ghettos and insufficient public infrastructure) and the best (skyscrapers) of US cities.
Overall, a rather weak book by Rybczynski.
Show More
care?The book at hand deals with the development of the American city. His key question is: Why aren't North American cities like European ones? Frustratingly, he does not answer the question, presenting a history of urban development of the US in nine chapters: Kevin Lynch's types of cities (ch. 2); Spanish, French and English roots, grid and space (ch. 3); US individualism and aversion to public space (ch. 4); urban parks (ch. 5); railroad stations and public infrastructure (ch. 6); skyscrapers (Ch. 7); suburbs and public housing (ch. 8) and malls (ch. 9). The tenth chapter sees him moving from the Canadian border to Philly's suburbs.
The reader is left to distill the answer to Rybczynski's question himself among the morsels and underdeveloped themes. Most elements that feature prominently in his chapters are present in Europe (and the ignored rest of world) too, so they can not be the answer. As Rybczynski writes himself covered shopping malls existed in Milano and Paris before the US started building them (although the Americans upped the scale). Barcelona has a grid. The love of private space is not uncommon in England and elsewhere ... My explaining factors are geography, energy and government. The availability of unbroken, empty land and cheap energy were enablers. The major cause why US cities look so different from European ones is weak government which could not prevent the worst (broken ghettos and insufficient public infrastructure) and the best (skyscrapers) of US cities.
Overall, a rather weak book by Rybczynski.
Show Less
LibraryThing member FKarr
informative, somewhat dry, look at the forces and trends which have historically influenced the evolution of American cities and suburbs
LibraryThing member annbury
Cultural history about the development of cities in the U.S., with specific reference to several, from Boston to Williamsburg. As ever, Rybczynski's prose is a delight.
Subjects
Language
Similar in this library
Last harvest : how a cornfield became New Daleville : real estate development in America from George Washington to the builders of the twenty-first century, and why we live in houses anyway by Witold Rybczynski
A clearing in the distance : Frederick Law Olmsted and America in the nineteenth century by Witold Rybczynski