Any Empire

by Nate Powell

Other authorsNate Powell (Artist)
Hardcover, 2011




Top Shelf Productions, (2011)


"[A] group of small-town kids find themselves bound together by geography, boredom, and a string of mysterious turtle mutilations. Years later, with Army tanks rolling through the streets of their hometown, these young adults are forced to confront painful questions of privilege, duty, betrayal, and courage" -- from publisher's web site.

User reviews

LibraryThing member zzshupinga
I’ve been a big fan of Nate Powell’s work since I read “Swallow me Whole” and saw his artwork for “The Silence of Our Friends.” The illustrations that he does for both works blew me away and his storytelling for “Swallow me Whole” was captivating and thought provoking. So I eagerly
Show More
picked up “Any Empire” and wasn’t disappointed (although it made my brain hurt a little bit more.) “Any Empire” is a coming of age tale that examines youthful fantasies of war and the realities of the real world.

Lee is a typical young boy growing up in a small town in the midwest in the 1980’s. He’s a quiet kid, who daydreams of GI Joe and heroes like his father, whose in the air force. He meets Purdy, a young boy who lives down the street, who also dreams of war and fighting and being a better warrior than his dad, although Purdy will tell you he’s a SEAL and an Army Ranger. Also entering their world is Sarah who struggles to find out whose mutilating local turtles and…making the villains suffer. Together they grow up, apart, and back together and have to answer questions about choice, war, hope, and belonging.

With Nate’s work it isn’t really possible to discuss his art and story telling in two different paragraphs, in part because in many places the illustrations are the story. And while that should be the same for any graphic novel/comic it really hits home with Nate’s works. In many places there are long stretches where the panels tell an evocative story of growing up and attempting to make friends. The main protagonist in this story, Lee, really resonates with me. Not because I would day dream about soldiers and war all of the time, but because I would day dream. I’d sit in gym and imagine something else going on, I’d go outside and my imagination would run rampant. And I also had friends like Purdy. Who would dream of being a solider and who would exaggerate the accomplishments of their father to fit in. Nate has accurately captured the feeling and mentality of real life with his story telling. I can relate to each and every character that Nate has crafted and feel like I really know them.

And his illustrations are pitch perfect and his ability accurately capture the expressions of the human face is amazing. I really love the expressions on Lee’s face when he is younger and that feeling that Nate captures, such as when Lee is sticking his tongue out while hauling a piece of lumber. It’s just a natural gesture that you can imagine yourself making and Nate captures it so effortlessly. The characters movements on the page are natural and fluid and it feels like we’re watching something from real life as it happens. These aren’t stale and static pictures.

The biggest issue I had with really understanding this work is right at the end of the book. And part of my problem is that I expected the reality to consider (yes the characters day dreamed so it was fantasy, but it was still reality.) But Nate surprises us with weaving together multiple daydreams/time lines together. And the understanding problems aren’t really Nate’s but mine. My expectations diverged and I had to read the book a couple of times to fully appreciate and understand what was going on. I also found help in reading an interview that Nate did with Graphic Novel Reporter about the book and the insight he offered about what he was thinking with the ending. I do wish that there was an afterward or perhaps a foreword that these types of events that Nate depicts in the last part of the book…are real. It would have gone a long way to clearing up some of the confusion I had.

Clearly this isn’t a book for everyone. It’s one that requires a couple of reads and most likely a bit of time to process what you’ve read. And yet…it’s still a book that I think everyone should read at least once and it deserves a place on many bookshelves. Nate Powell is a master illustrator and a fantastic storyteller. And I for one can’t wait to see his next work. I give the book 4 out of 5 stars.
Show Less
LibraryThing member yeremenko
This book was ambitious and is brilliant in places but tries too hard to be different and loses the narrative.
LibraryThing member akmargie
A little chaotic and somewhat hard to follow but an interesting story on war and violence and our perceptions of justice.
LibraryThing member Sullywriter
Many interesting ideas underlying this story but disappointingly developed.
LibraryThing member thisisstephenbetts
Just kinda disappointing really. Everything was just a touch flawed, and the combination of those flaws really sink this book. It's undoubtedly ambitious, but in this case it couldn't save the comic.

The art is very attractive, but is not clear enough. This means, for example, that the jarring
Show More
juxtapositions (of small town life and war) don't work well. Similarly the characters aren't distinct, and the sense of location is poor. This all makes the plot hard to follow.

The actual comic-craft - the selection and pacing of panels - is off. The timing seems wrong, and the things that are shown in the panels seem slightly odd choices. Again, this just makes the story too much work to follow.

The dialogue is sparse, and I think perhaps is supposed to be naturalistic, but ends up sounding awkward. This part could have worked without changes, but with the confusion caused by the other flaws it didn't.

The plot itself is interesting, and the themes are worthwhile (if a little too worthy). But again problems with pacing, and the temporal jumps, and some unexpectedly unrealistic parts at the end... well, it just wasn't handled very well.

It's a shame, as I think there could have been a good comic lurking here. The comic is certainly ambitious, but unfortunately in this case that was not enough to make it enjoyable.
Show Less


Original language




Similar in this library

Page: 0.2213 seconds