Narrator Jack and his mother, who was kidnapped seven years earlier when she was a 19-year-old college student, celebrate his fifth birthday. They live in a tiny, 11-foot-square soundproofed cell in a converted shed in the kidnapper's yard. The sociopath, whom Jack has dubbed Old Nick, visits at night, grudgingly doling out food and supplies. But Ma, as Jack calls her, proves to be resilient and resourceful--and attempts a nail-biting escape.
Jack has just turned five years old. He lives with his mother in Room, a cozy space isolated from Outside. He is happy, as he knows no other life outside of Room. He was born on Rug, reads books and plays with toys that are brought by Old Nick, the only person who visits them. Old Nick comes at night, and Jack must hide in Wardrobe until the man finally leaves his mother in Bed. Jack spends his days playing with Ma, and he loves her deeply, although he is troubled whenever she is Gone, those times where she spends the day in bed.
Jack and Ma escape from Room, and he must adjust to Outside, a place he has only seen on television and heard about from Ma. Doctors poke him, strangers fawn over him and ask him odd questions, and he must adjust to these new strangers that Ma insists are his family. Although everyone insists he will be happier Outside, Jack wants nothing more than to return to Room with Ma.
"Room" is a fascinating look into the life of a young boy as he tries to understand his place in the world, one that is unfamiliar and unsettling. The novel was triggered by the infamous Josef Fritzl case in Austria, in which a man kept his daughter isolated in a basement for 24 years and fathered several children with her before she was eventually rescued. This novel is markedly different from the case, especially in the use of Jack as the narrator throughout the book and the downplaying of the more disturbing aspects of the story. Donoghue does a masterful job in her portrayal of Jack, and his lovable and maddening personality is one that I won't soon forget.
As they are forced to live in this Room as prisoners, Jack's mother is tireless in building a life in Room that entertains, fascinates and educates her son as best she can, while fiercely protecting Jack from the man who has imprisoned them. While Jack doesn't understand yet that they are prisoners, he's a happy child, but his happiness is contrasted with his mother's occasional quietness as she remembers the life she used to have on the Outside.
Mother and son find a way to escape and what follows is an interesting psychological study in how Jack, having his entire world destroyed, has to learn how to socialize and communicate with others, while learning about the real world they have escaped to. At times he misses Room and wants desperately to return to the place his mother hates. He remembers Room with fondness and it represents his security, while his mother remembers Room the place of her imprisonment, abuse and fear.
This is a page turner, no doubt about it. It makes you contemplate the evil that dwell in some people, the strength and love of a mother for her child and the will to survive.
Old Nick is a psychopath who kidnapped Ma seven years earlier, held her hostage, and subjected her to repeated acts of rape. Ma is a survivor, largely because of her fierce devotion to Jack. She is determined to give him the most normal life possible, carefully rationing his TV time and using the most ordinary events as educational opportunities. And she never lets Jack know they are captive. But one day, as the result of a minor slip-up, Jack catches on and begins to ask a lot of questions about Outside. The way Ma explains the world, and her response to Jack's growing knowledge, turn this story into an intense survival tale.
Emma Donoghue has been widely praised for Room, especially for her ability to create such an authentic narrator in Jack. The reader sees Outside through his eyes, where everything is new -- a completely different perspective from Ma, who lived Outside before. Jack's voice makes even more clear the stark contrast between confinement and freedom.
Room is a suspenseful novel, but also a story of the profound bond between mother and child. A wonderful book.
The world that Jack calls home is not very large, but it belongs to him and Ma. Old Nick sometimes comes at night with a beep beep, but Jack stays very quiet and still in the wardrobe so he never sees him. Everyday is a slightly different from the day before and because it is all he has ever known, he is comforted and content, except sometimes, he does get a little bored. The outside is not real until one day his mom asked him to play a pretend game of be dead in Rug and then once outside, his goal is to find help so he can free his Ma. The world beyond his Room is larger than he could ever have dreamed and above all, more scary than he imagined possible, but he is now five and that means he is a big boy and big boys pretend to brave, even when they are scared.
Told from the perspective of five year old Jack, the book was disturbing on so many levels. Scary, because sometimes I couldn't tell if I was reading a story straight from the news, or reading a fictional book. Scary because it comes too close to mirroring the realities of our world. Scary because I am a mom. If this book was only about the horrific evils that exist in our society, I know I would have been left with nothing but a sick and queasy lump in my stomach. Surprisingly, what I walk away with is not a hyper need to bar my windows or barricade my doors from the dangers lurking beyond my doorsteps, but rather an appreciation for the love and lengths a mother will go to protect the only thing she deems precious enough to live each agonizing day for. Room was not an easy book to read, but it was a story of devotion and survival worth telling.
1) Room is narrated by a five-year-old boy who only knows an 11x11-foot room as his home. He doesn't understand that rain falls from the sky, that cars stay in their lane and that bees can sting you. All the things we understand to be true in our lives would be new experiences to a boy who never spent a day outside. Donoghue did a good job writing about these new experiences - and coming up with all the "little things" that seem to be common knowledge, but not for a boy who lived in seclusion.
2) The American media's treatment of Jack and his mother's story was spot on. Their insistence to not grant this family any privacy reminded me of true media coverage in other heart-wrenching stories. Equally compelling (and so aligned with what happens) is how the media digs at the story from all angles in an attempt to "outscoop" each other. There is little regard for what's best for Jack or his mother.
3) This book was a real page turner. During one section of the book, I did not move from my seat. I was worried that something bad was going to happen, and the suspense was jarring. Few books have that effect on me.
This isn't my typical review, but I hope reading it helps persuade you to give Room a try. It's a compelling, provocative book that makes you think about your life and what you would do in a similar situation. It's worthy of its literary accolades, and I predict that it would make a good movie with the right director and actors. What do you think?
When these two finally escape and emerge into the real world, Jack must learn to cope with unlimited boundaries. Everyday things we take for granted need to be explained and learned, Jack needs constant guidance but his Mother is also dealing in her own way with freedom. These two who have been inseparable now find they have different ways of looking at things, and different levels of acceptance. While Jack remembers Room as a place of comfort, the very idea of that place upsets the Mother to the point of nausea.
I found Room is be a very unique read and it told such a compelling story of human resourcefulness and resilience that it was very hard to put down. I was very moved by Jack’s mother, who overcame such difficulties and showed such devotion and care in the raising of her son. This is a book that truly moved me, and one that I will long remember.
ROOM is Jack's world. Jack is a 5 year boy, imprisoned in an 11x11 shed with his mother. Ma was abducted 7 years ago by Old Nick who visits periodically bringing supplies, and especially the "Sunday Treat." Because Jack knows only what is in ROOM, his world image is limited. They have rug, mattress, chair, table, shelf, stove, toilet, bath, wardrobe and rocker, to all of which Jack attaches almost anthropomorphic characteristics. They watch TV, but, with the exception of Dora the Explorer, he views that as "OUTSIDE" and scary, and mostly not real. He cannot conceive of 'others' as real people. The pair bonds in an extraordinary fashion, and while Jack's intellectual development and vocabulary bloom from all the games they play and the TV they watch, his social development is non-existant. He has never spent a minute separated from his mother.
Reading this book is a chilling experience, but one that is very, very satisfying in the end. Having the story told from the viewpoint of a 5 year old whose only experience of the world is through the prism of TV, the five books his mother has managed to con out of Old Nick, or whatever memories his mother chooses to share is what really makes this such an incredible story. I really don't want to give away anything because the tension needs to build for the reader (or listener) to enjoy the full impact. I listened to the audio where Jack's voice is perfectly done. The cadence is perfectly for a five year old. I intend to get a print copy to add to my permanent collection, but feel this is one book that is just as good in audio (if not better) than print. It is my first 5 star read of the year.
Told entirely from Jack's point of view, Room is unlike anything that I have read. To look at life through the eyes of a child who has never experienced anything beyond the 11 x 11 foot dimension of his confines is amazing. Things that we would take utterly for granted are utterly new and strange to him. It is a sometimes refreshing and frightening perspective, and one that is entirely unique.
Sometimes I found Jack to be a little too intelligent for never having experienced anything outside of Room and Ma (we never discover her real name) seems to have a little bit too much insight on how to care for Jack and the things that he needs to stay healthy for someone who was kidnapped at 19 and no contact with the outside world or guidance on how to raise a child. For instance, knowing that they need time to sunbathe from the light coming through the skylight so that they have a tolerance for sunlight or having Jack focus on things close and then far away (the roof) to help strengthen his eyes seem, at least to me, a little too far fetched for someone in Ma's situation to inherently understand.
These technicalities aside, Room is still an astounding book and one that I couldn't put down. Ma's love for Jack, even when she is at her wit's end with him, and Jack's returned love for Ma, even when he is angry with her and doesn't always understand her reasons for what she does, is evident on every page. Emma Donoghue balances just the right amounts of hope, pathos, suspense and relief to make Room an engaging story without taking any of these elements too far.
I really found this book a drag. It took me by surprise as I was very concerned that I wouldn't cope with the emotional aspect of this story however I found it imotionless. I felt like I was reading a childs imagination of what might be but really wasn't.It was on the very rare occasion that I caught a glimpse of what life might have been like for Ma.
I found Jack's speech annoying. I am a parent and I can't imagine teaching my children to speak the way Ma did. It's a little hard to be critical of Ma as this is not a normal situation and I really can't even imagine how I, personally, would handle it but I just wasn't convinced by this story. It didn't draw me in at all. It felt so very unrealistic much of the time. Funny, that some of the more boring parts of story, such as the medico's at work, seemed the most realistic to me.
I'm afraid I wouldn't recommend this to anyone and I'm very surprised by how many people love this book.
Welcome to Jack’s World. He lives with his Ma, in a small enclosure, they call “Room”.
They are prisoners, being held captive by a man Jack knows only as Old Nick. Since the boy was born here, this is the only place he knows and feels comfortable in. Yes, this is a dark, disturbing premise (loosely based on an actual event) but the story offers so much more, including the importance of love and motherhood. It’s also about resilience and survival. This may not be a book for everyone but for this reader, it worked perfectly. Highly recommended.
Donoghue's concept is a good one and the pacing of the narrative is decent, but that's all I can recommend about this book. Having five-year-old Jack as the narrator is a cute gimmick, but I don't do cute. Also, Donoghue doesn't even do it particularly well. Jack speaks in baby-talk much of the time, despite the fact that he watches television every day, can read 'Alice in Wonderland' and has an advanced vocabulary. The inconsistency is jarring and really prevented me from finding his character believable.
As others have said, it would have made more compelling reading had the story been told from Ma's point-of-view, or from a combination of Ma's and Jack's. Or perhaps, in the second part of the book, from the grandparents' - I actually found then to be the most interesting characters in the book, so it's a shame they weren't much of a focus. The real grandfather, in particular, and his reaction to Jack would have made for some fascinating reading.
The characters aren't developed all that well, the BIG ACTION SCENE isn't all that exciting and the denouement seems a bit sudden. This could all be because of the limiting nature of Jack's narrative.
However, I thought I'd absolutely hate 'Room,' so I suppose it's something to be said that I polished it off in about three hours. It's definitely a page-turner, but I generally see page-turners as "airport books" rather than Booker short-listed books. How that happened I still haven't figured out.
A 26 year old woman has been kidnapped and held captive in a soundproof, escape-proof 11 x 11 foot Room for 7 years. She has a five year old son, Jack. She cares for him fiercely and has created a world for him out of that Room, giving him everything she possibly can that he needs to grow properly, physically and emotionally. They do daily exercises, she teaches him, etc. This is their story, of their day-to-day life, their escape and how they cope on the Outside. A truly fascinating story to start with is only topped by the fact that it is told in the first person narrative of five year old Jack.
I'm going to start by saying this is a hard review for me to write. I agonized over my rating. There is not doubt that Room is a wonderful piece of writing. The subject matter is enticing and the reality of the situation has been explored to such detail that one is amazed the author could have thought of some things without having actually experienced captivity herself. The book is divided into distinct sections, each one focusing intensely on a certain stage of Jack and Ma's story. Donoghue has managed to write about a horrific situation without ever actually putting in print any scenes that show the obvious s*xual violence that was perpetrated. In the hands of a lesser author this could have become a much more graphic story thus losing Ms. Donoghue's perceptive touch. The book reads fast, is compelling and is tremendously well written.
So why is this review hard to write? I didn't love the book. Yes, it was good. Good enough to keep me reading, and reading quickly too. The second half was better than the first, as in enjoying the story and the characters. I really enjoyed the introduction of Grandpa Leo, Steppa. He was the most real character in the whole book. I often found myself annoyed while reading the book. The child's narrative just didn't win me over. I didn't hate it but it felt detached somehow and thus I felt detached from the characters. I never had any great emotional response to the boy and his mother, which *really* wanted to have. None of the other characters were fully developed, even Steppa , but he at least had the behaviour of a real person and came to life for me.
As you can see I had problems with the book, while appreciating it. Now that I've finished it, my immediate response is "Yeah, it was good." I wouldn't grab people and say you *must* read this book, but if anyone asked me I'd recommend it with my reservations as noted above. I may feel differently about my rating a month (a year) from now but it's been 6 days since I've written this review and I still feel the same way. Very well written, but only good, not great.
The genius of this book is that Jack's voice is entirely believable, and his story of the life he has with his mother, who designs each day to keep them healthy, active, interested and entertained, is phenomenal. Perseverance, love, motherhood, and trust - all are explored in ways which enthrall the reader. This book was hard to put down and will be impossible to forget.
By writing this review, I am in no way attempting to trivialise, poke fun at or glamourise the serious nature of the crimes committed within the story. This is simply a review concerning the writing itself, and the plot. Indeed, the more people who read this book the more people will become aware that these events are not as rare as we think. Anything that increases awareness regarding such horrific abuse is a good thing in my book.
Considering I'm currently suffering from a highly acidic hangover of the most mind-numbing kind right now, I'm just going to list the main points of contention I have with this book rather than provide a huge essay.
1. Jack's narrative. I can understand that a child who is so severely limited in essentially everything will rely on his mind and imagination more than most. I can even understand him coming to view inanimate objects as friends. However, the manner of writing style that the book is written is simply, well, nauseating. It would have been far, far better had the story been written from Jack's perspective when he was older. There are plenty of examples within the reviews of others as to how he speaks, so I won't provide any samples. But, it's grating and irritating. And goes on for 300 pages.
Although the language used still manages to hit home the events, it's completely off-putting to read sentences that make my cat sound more intelligent. If the point of this was to make it more 'horrific' to hear this story from a five year olds perspective, I have to say that Emma Donoghue missed the mark entirely. I felt more fear waking up this morning, and realising my depleted vitamin B12 levels were going to cause chaos then I did reading the whole book.
2. The main annoyance being spoken about, I'm now going to enter into 'trivial irritant' territory. Ma's constant use of saying 'yeah' all the time. It's totally irrational of me to hate it, but I do! It almost makes her sound sulky, childish and slovenly. I'm not sure if this is a deliberate action to remind us that she was abducted when she was 19, and hadn't had the chance to develop further, but it really does come across as annoying. I'm not saying I expect my characters to speak perfect english all the time, but it would have been nice to see not as many 'yeahs' and maybe something a little different. There are 114 'yeahs' in this book. That's about 50 more than necessary. Sheesh, even a 'Ma looked at me with her sad-eyes, and nodded her head yes' would have been better than '"Yeah", said Ma with sad in her eyes'. Maybe I'm just being too pedantic.
3. Yes! Another trivial irritant! It needs to be asked, but what is Emma's obsession with poo? Poo appears 57 times in the book, and frankly, it's not something I wish to read about every third page. Yes, for the purposes of scene setting the toilet, er, arrangements should be explained. Even when Jack is 'sick', it's necessary to detail Ma's actions in creating a sick atmosphere. What I really don't want to read are things like: "...not sliding out in my poo yet", "...to Toilet and do more poo", "...I sit to poo", "...a bit of poo squirted out my bum", "...poo bag", "...pooed a bit by accident", something about his "poo being too hard", etc etc etc.
Emma is either taking Freud way too seriously, or she has some kind of scat fetish. 'Poo' is everywhere throughout the book, references to poo, poo on the rug, poo in the sea, hard poo, soft poo, broken poo. Everywhere a poo-poo! Again, I understand that Jack is five and narrating the story, but...seriously? I'm surprised that he didn't have another friend - Poo, to go along with Plant, Rug, Rocker et all.
4. I can't help that feel as though Emma has undertaken to write this book in order for it to be mass-produced, all whilst riding on the coattails of the actual victims of similar circumstances. True, it's not based on a particular event or crime, but it really does feel as though it's borderline abuse exploitation, in order to make a few people a quick buck. I certainly hope that she donated some of her payment to the very survivors whose stories run parallel to Jack and Ma's.
Honestly, I haven't researched this book. I don't know whether Emma Donoghue was 'advised' to write the book, whether she was inspired to so that others could learn of these crimes, if she was paid, if she did indeed donate money to a foundation. So, I could be completely wrong. However, to me, the book gives off the impression that it's more to entertain rather than educate. It comes across as though hardly any, or minimal, research was conducted (yes, I've read the thanks & acknowledgments). Or if she did research, it was only to grasp the 'basics', if I can describe it as such.
It feels rushed, cheap, superficial, and incomplete. I will not be reading any further books by the author, after this mangled assault on language. I cannot believe it received a nomination.
On the bright side, given that this book is quite popular, hopefully there are now thousands of people who are somewhat more enlightened concerning the hidden surface of our world, and the evil that humans are capable of. Hopefully, the people who liked the book with lend it to others.
But you still might not like it.
One of the reasons for that is the narration -- though that very narration is a major contributing factor to the elevation of this story to something beyond the everyday. The entire novel is told through the eyes and voice of five-year-old Jack, whose whole world consists of Room (an 11' x 11' windowless but skylit cell), its furnishings and objects, and Ma. The narration never shifts from Jack's understanding, even as his world shifts beneath his feet. That perspective is compelling -- it's part of what kept me turning pages -- but it also takes some getting used to. Jack's grammar is particularly articulate for a five-year-old, but has unusual structure and vocabulary. The way Jack thinks about some things can be disturbing -- what he finds commonplace may be squirm-worthy for the reader -- and that too contributes to the way this story sinks under one's skin.
If you can get into the narration and let Jack's eyes be your own for a while, the novel rewards. I won't spoil it all here, because that would be mean, but things change -- as they must -- and part of the glory of this experience is watching Jack try to change too (some of his change-related moments are funny, some cringe-worthy).
I had the good fortune to attend a recent reading of Emma Donoghue's and she described her novel as "celebratory of motherhood" -- I found it to be so, of course, but perhaps even more celebratory of childhood -- both of its charms and its limitations. Jack is our focus, and in many ways he is our hero, though not in the archetypal way. He is also a very real five-year-old boy (apparently Donoghue had young children in the house while writing the novel, so listened in and took advantage of observational opportunities). I appreciated Donoghue's realism throughout the novel, as well as her focus on staying away from sentimentality -- even in the face of significant temptation, given the subject matter. Using a circumstance more suited to a thriller or horror novel, but with no "seen" violence, Donoghue has crafted a work that escapes our voyeuristic tendencies and substitutes a more satisfying focus. Where one might expect to be shocked, one finds delicacy; where one might expect to feel dirtied, one emerges cathartically cleansed.
Bottom line: this is an amazing book. It's probably the most uniquely rendered piece of fiction you will read all year. Though some may not like its narrative style, give it a chance to impress you.
The book divides roughly into two halves, which take place in Room and in "Outside", respectively. The first half introduces us to Jack's life and his views about reality, and there's certainly a lot of interest there. I have to admit, though, that I found this part a bit slow; there's a sense of waiting, and I became impatient to get on with the story. But once Jack leaves Room, the story really picks up. His views of life in Room were interesting, but his attempts to reconcile his former view of the world with external reality are really fascinating. I'd recommend this book to anyone, and I think it would make a great discussion book. There's lots to think about, and it's told in a way that feels completely new.
Because of her love, Jack's mother gives him rules for managing his world: TV can only be on for a hour at a time or his brain will turn to mush; hiding in Wardrobe when Old Nick comes keeps him from his anger; looking into the skylight when God's full face is there will make your eyes stop seeing. But the songs and games, the careful schedule, the stories about Old Nick all become shaken when the electricity is suddenly shut off.
Jack's profound descriptions allow us into Room, a world of beauty and subtle truths. We learn of his misconceptions and what looks like real. His mother is his sole source of his knowledge and she keeps feeding his curiosity with her carefully planned bits and pieces of truth until she cannot hold onto their fragile existence any longer.
Sweet, earnest Jack and his unique perspective makes "Room" a gem of a book. The tragedy seen through his eyes is generous, warm, nurturing, and full of faith. Baby Jesus and John the Baptist teach him about friendship and being cousins. The insects are his secret companions. His mother is all-knowing and seems to even be connected to him.
Though the horror in 'Room' is gut-wrenching, the love and life force between Jack and his mother is awe-inspiring. I was captured by the relationship of this mother and son, the writing was simple, astute, and revealing. I saw glimpses of every mother's love in the actions that take place, her sense of survival and her creative and detailed plotting. I read Jack's reactions to his world and remembered raising my own children and their views of an ever-widening world-consciousness, simple yet wise. His character also accurately defines the process of dealing with suffering and the realities delivered to each of us in our lives.
Emma Donoghue deftly creates Jack and Ma’s world within an eleven by eleven foot room. Their days are surprisingly interesting, with Ma creating imaginative games for them to play together. But there is an underlying tension, made more poignant by the fact that it is through a five year old’s eyes that we see the story unfolding. Jack is no longer an infant. He is a smart, curious boy who asks a lot of difficult questions. His mother has allowed him to believe that the world does not exist except for the room in which they live, an alternate reality which eventually must be corrected if they are ever to escape Room.
I must admit that the first 40 pages or so of this novel took some getting used to…Jack’s voice is odd. But once I allowed myself to be fully inside Jack’s world, the book began to resonate with me. The daring escape attempt is perhaps one of the most suspenseful and nerve-wracking scenes I’ve read in a long, long time. Ma’s inner turmoil is perfectly captured through the eyes of her observant son – even though he does not fully understand it. What begins as a story of captivity evolves into a deeper novel of mothering, love, hope and the resilience of the human spirit.
It takes a talented writer to write entirely from the point of view of a child – and Donoghue pulls off this feat seamlessly. The relationship between mother and child is beautifully revealed on every level. Donoghue’s ability to draw the reader in and emotionally invest them in the story is brilliant. Room was recently shortlisted for the 2010 Booker Prize…and it is a well deserved nomination. Original, enthralling, haunting, and memorable Room is a novel I highly recommend for readers who enjoy literary fiction.
I laughed out loud at the scene when Jake catches a talk show on television that is about him --- and the intellectuals on the show are discussing the post-modern meanings of Jake's experience. Donoghue's not-so-subtle poke at this level of meaning in her novel is a nice touch. And the thing is, the novel is worth discussing on that level, but it's also worth enjoying as a touching, humorous, exciting, and very well-written story about a boy who encounters the world after spending his first five years in a room.
Ma and Jack are bound to be close, given their constant interaction in the small room, but the interdependency has become pathological in ways. For example, Jack is still breast-feeding at age five. One imagines that Ma wants to make sure he gets sufficient nutrients, since they are dependent on what Old Nick brings them, which is not a lot. But it is clear that Jack is too old for this activity which he initiates by either lifting Ma’s t-shirt or announcing “I want some.” He seems to have an implicit understanding that breast-feeding represents more than just nourishment (oh no! he thinks while in Wardrobe, “Old Nick better not be having some!”) and he already has a problematic penis, which rises each morning with the sun. The Freudian repercussions down the road seem frightening, but Ma is as little interested in stopping this practice as Jack.
Likewise, Ma is fully complicit in the desire to bathe and sleep with Jack. Jack is too dependent on Ma, but he’s five. Ma is too dependent on Jack, and it seems quite unhealthy. But there isn’t much about their situation that is healthy. And Jack is Ma's only reason to keep living.
When Old Nick loses his job, Ma becomes afraid Old Nick will have his house repossessed and therefore need to kill both her and Jack. She comes up with an escape plan that depends on Jack for its success. But he’s just a little kid, and easily distracted. The chances of his messing up are huge. Ma's insistence on his central role makes him scared and angry. He doesn’t have a clue about how desperate their situation really is. The tension is palpable as the plan takes shape; everything is riding on its' success.
Discussion: Emma Donoghue was inspired to write this story by newspaper reports about the actual case of Josef Fritzl, in Austria. Fritzl locked his daughter Elisabeth in a concealed cellar/prison measuring 600 square feet and only 5’6” high. He kept her there for 24 years and raped her repeatedly. She had seven children by him, three of whom stayed imprisoned with her and never saw the light of day. A keyless entry code provided the only access to the secret room, so no one could come or go but Josef. If Josef felt “punishment” was warranted, he would shut off the lights to the room or not deliver food for several days. When the group finally escaped (by the use of a plan similar to that used by Ma in Room), Felix Fritzl, aged five, saw the world for the first time. Donoghue says she was seized by “that notion of the wide-eyed child emerging into the world like a Martian coming to Earth.”
In most ways, I think the author does an excellent job of creating a story that comes entirely out of the head of a five year old boy. Some of Jack’s observations exhibit creative writing at its finest. But some aspects of the story are disconcerting.
Jack has an excellent vocabulary and uses adult words. Disconcertedly, however, his grammar is markedly deficient, especially given the care that Ma shows in nurturing his intellectual development. (Emotionally, however, Jack’s character seems just right; he is at turns loving, funny, self-centered, babyish, helpful, impatient, immature, generous, and eager to please. Ma has the patience of a saint, although every once in a while she “shuts down” for the day and doesn’t get out of bed. Who could blame her?)
The escape plan struck me as very flawed. Old Nick was not exactly trustworthy, and there is no reason for Ma to have expected that he would do what she asked him to do and not do what was easiest for him. She, after all, would never have known the difference. Plus, she knew how nervous Jack was about helping, and how confused he got when he got scared. That it didn’t turn out worse is miraculous.
Evaluation: This book tells a nightmarish story, and yet, since it comes entirely from five-year-old Jack’s perspective, it is much less disturbing than it could have been. Jack is usually more concerned about seeing Dora the Explorer on television than worrying about survival. And the abuse of his mother by Old Nick is something he describes in a confused way without understanding what he is saying. On the other hand, this just makes it all the creepier and suspenseful for the reader. I had a few nightmares from this one, but I’m glad I read it all the same!
There were parts that I just found it a little farfetched **no spoilers** and also parts I thought I couldn’t see the character doing that. Jack‘s narration gives us an insight into the mind of a 5 year old completely and I thought it was very well written. I think I may not have liked it as much as some but I didn’t hate it as much as others it is a very unique book and because of that I’ve rated it a bit higher.
I listened to this on audio and the narration was great!
The plot has strong similarities to the story of an Austrian woman who was held prisoner and repeatedly raped by her father for twenty-four years. She bore her captor several children, who were also imprisoned until their rescue. There are other similar cases as well.
Room is the story of a young woman, "Ma", who was kidnapped by a man they refer to as “Old Nick,” and imprisoned by him for seven years. She gave birth to a son during her time in the room. The story is told through the eyes of her son, five-year old Jack. The book begins with his fifth birthday, continues through their escape, and ends with their first weeks of freedom.
I realize the author wanted the reader to feel the frustration of daily life in an 11 by 11 room, and she did that, over and over and over, ad nauseam. I thought this section of the book would never end. The telling of the daily life in the “room” was overdone. It consumes a third of the book and fighting through this section was extremely difficult.
And speaking of the 11 by 11 room, something just wasn’t right. In this 11 by 11 room, was a toilet, a dresser, a television, a rocking chair, a bathtub, a sink, a stove, a refrigerator, a bed, a table, chairs and a lamp. Really? How did all that furniture fit in an 11 by 11 room? I know this is fiction, and some poetic license is allowed, but let’s have a little sense of reality. There is no way all that furniture could fit in such a small room.
Another issue was that the story is told from the perspective of Jack, the five-year old boy. The poor grammar and constant “baby-speak” of a 5 year-old made an already boring story an intolerable read.
Jack also has repetitive references to his penis. A five-year old aware of his penis? Really?
The character of Jack is inconsistent. One minute is talking baby-talk and babble. The next sentence he is making intelligent comments well beyond the capacity of a five-year old.
Probably the most difficult part to overcome was the constant emphasis on breastfeeding. Jack “wants it” over and over and over again. After saying this more than fifty times, we get it. Not only do we get it, we are tired of “it.” Jack is wanting “it” every few pages. He even prefers one side over the other. Enough of “it.”
I had to force myself to finish the book. Trudging through the first 100 pages was difficult and tiresome. The section with Jack and his mother in the room was way too long. Then, in just two to three pages, they were rescued. I would love to seen this section drawn out a little more. Give us some drama in the rescue. When the captor abandons Jack on the street and takes off, let us wonder if he is going back to the room to kill Jack’s mother or move her elsewhere. This section of the book was almost over before it started and failed to create any tension in the plot.
Donoghue made her story extremely tiresome and boring. A third of the book is spent inside the room. How much action can occur in a room? We are bored with the daily chores, such as taking a bath, eating, brushing the teeth, etc. How terribly boring!
The character of the captor, Old Nick, is not well drawn. He is almost non-existent. I would love to have known more about him and his motivation to kidnap a young woman and hold her hostage.
Even the final part of the book when Jack is taken places in the “outside,” is boring. Again, we are bored by his daily routine, shopping, sleeping, and eating. Being told every single detail of even the smallest thing that Jack does in a day is excruciatingly painful. It was a major effort to finish the novel.
There are many holes in the plot. The escape does not sound plausible; it is just not believable. Old Nick would have to be an idiot to fall for such a trick. Also, many difficulties of re-entering the world were never addressed by Donoghue. Re-entry seemed too easy and too fast. After just a few days, Jack, who has never been outside the room for five years appears to be adjusting and behaving normally. He has never associated or played with other children before in his life, yet adjusts to this social deprivation in just days. This is not realistic. Also, the mother’s suicide attempt comes out of nowhere. There were no clues to let the reader know it was coming.
The only enjoyable part was the book’s ending. I did like the ending and the closure it provided. Other than that, this was a boring and terrible book. Don’t waste your time with it.
Unlike some squirmish critics whose primary reaction was getting the heebie jeebies, I was not really bothered by the breastfeeding as it was presented realistically and in a dramatically clever and significant way. As a symbol running throughout the story it worked on a number of levels, and very successfully.
I didn't feel that way about the interview on the other hand. It seemed like a tabloid free for all rather than an interview with an Oprah-type, or even a Diane Sawyer-type - and let's face it, an Oprah-type is a success for a reason and would not risk alienating her audience by being insensitive and boorish to a damaged woman. I think the reason it failed for me lies with the problem of Jack the narrator needing to witness to it for the readers and to propel the plot.
And the clever little tyke returning to the Room with his mother back to for their mutual closure was rather irritatingly written. Too pat, too neat, too clearly articulated.
I wouldn't recommend this to everyone. Donoghue a cracking writer and the tension she creates is remarkable, but to be honest, I was surprised it was shortlisted for the Booker. It is quite accessible and populist, and is almost a "genre" work (if there is such a "domestic/trauma drama" genre) as much as it is "literary fiction" - (which is a greater criticism of the Booker panels than this writer). It reads like a slightly higher brow version of Jodi Picoult's work in many ways. Which is not a bad thing, as such, as it was free of the neo-pychological navel-gazing that plagues so much "literary fiction" and had a refreshing directness.