Lanny : a novel

by Max Porter

Hardcover, 2019




Minneapolis, MN : Graywolf Press, 2019.


"Not far from London, there is a village. This village belongs to the people who live in it and to those who lived in it hundreds of years ago. It belongs to England's mysterious past and its confounding present. It belongs to Mad Pete, the grizzled artist. To ancient Peggy, gossiping at her gate. To families dead for generations, and to those who have only recently moved here. But it also belongs to Dead Papa Toothwort who has woken from his slumber in the woods. Dead Papa Toothwort, who is listening to them all. Chimerical, audacious, strange and wonderful - a song to difference and imagination, to friendship, youth and love, Lanny is the globally anticipated new novel from Max Porter."--Publisher's description.

Media reviews

Despite reading it twice, I suspect Lanny will be a novel I will return to again, simply to absorb the strangeness of the story, the cleverness of the structure, the authenticity of the dialogue and the ethereal mystery that surrounds the book’s titular character. For those who are put off by
Show More
experimental fiction, and I confess to being one, this is a novel to shatter your prejudices, for Max Porter understands that even the most complex idea must have a decipherable meaning if it is to be of any worth to a reader.
Show Less
1 more
Max Porter’s second novel is a fable, a collage, a dramatic chorus, a joyously stirred cauldron of words. It follows his startlingly original debut, Grief Is the Thing With Feathers, the dark, comic, wild, beautiful prose-poem-novel that was a runaway success in 2015 and won the Dylan Thomas
Show More
prize. Lanny is similarly remarkable for its simultaneous spareness and extravagance, and again it is a book full of love. It plays pretty close to the edge over which lie the fey and the kooky; anyone allergic to green men may need to take a deep breath. But Porter has no truck with cynicism and gets on, bravely, exuberantly, with rejuvenating our myths.
Show Less

User reviews

LibraryThing member kidzdoc
Lanny is a young boy whose parents have recently moved from London to a village an hour's train ride away. His father works in the City, and his mother is a former actress who is trying to reinvent herself as an author of grisly mystery novels. He is an unusual child, who is wise beyond his years,
Show More
more than a little odd, and in touch with nature and his environment, especially in the woods at the outskirts of the town. His best friend is a well known artist, an older man who lives a hermetic existence and is considered to be "mad. The long time residents of the village are small minded, conservative and generally disdainful of the new residents, who they view as ostentatious and immodest, and Lanny and his mother struggle to find their place amongst their new neighbors.

Overlooking the village and its people is Dead Papa Toothwort, a somewhat malevolent spirit who lived there centuries ago and spends his days observing the residents in their homes and listening to their intimate conversations. The spirit, like the artist, is very fond of Lanny, who is aware of the legend of Toothwort, and both the boy and the spirit actively seek out the other, which results in a fateful meeting.

Lanny is a highly inventive, multilayered and daring work of experimental fiction that completely captured my attention from the first page to the last. This review is intentionally vague, as I want to avoid giving too much information that would spoil the plot and the book's surprising and imaginative ending. This novel would seem to be a shoo in for this year's Booker Prize longlist, and if it is chosen I'll read it again this summer. Highly recommended!
Show Less
LibraryThing member AmaliaGavea
‘’It would have been the head of a dolphin and the wings of a peregrine, and it would be a storm-watching beast, watching the weather while we sleep.’’

Max Porter’s Grief is the Thing with Feathers has been on my list for quite some time but for one reason or another, I never seem to find
Show More
the chance to read it. Lanny was recommended by my personal idol, Jen Campbell, in one of her outstanding videos. I wanted something dark, British and preferably short read to accompany me on my trip to the mountains and Lanny found its place by my side. It is now one of my favourite reads, even endorsed by my partner who is a devotee of Andrić and Márquez. If he is satisfied and I am impressed, Lanny must definitely find a place among your upcoming reads.

‘’You cannot fix the way the world is broken all on your own.’’

A family of three moves in a village of 50 houses within commuting distance from London. Robert works in the City, Jolie is an actress and an aspiring crime fiction writer and their son, Lanny, is a charismatic boy who loves Art and feels immensely close to nature. Their life is far from easy, though. Financial insecurity, career uncertainty, a father who is mostly absent and a community that is viciously cruel, firmly shut within their microcosm. Even being an actress is considered suspicious.
‘’What if we said what we really felt?’’
‘’There is no such thing as trust. It’s a pernicious myth.’’

In this eerie, beautiful, unique novel, Porter talks about trust, loss, isolation, estrangement. He sheds light on the millenia-old relationship between the human being and nature, between the past and the present, between assumptions and reality, appearance and truth. Lanny is a remarkable child, a boy who weeps over the possibility of another child dying. Jolie is a tender mother but she is also absorbed in her own aspirations and insecurities over her career and the suspicious villagers. Robert is a husband and a father who is simply not there. Troubled, cold, indifferent. He changes and changes and only for the worse. The family is not a shelter but a broken unit and trust cannot be found in this stern community. Those we think we can trust can potentially turn into the greatest threat…
‘’There’s a girl living under this tree. She’s lived here for hundreds of years. Her parent were cruel to her so she hid under this tree and she’s never come out.’’

Porter writes in a Post-modern style. His prose is dark, ominous, features of stream-of-consciousness are evident throughout. No matter the style, what makes Lanny such a powerful, impressive read is the theme of the nature’s influence in the life of a community. Nature acquires a persona, wise and vindictive, in the face of Dead Papa Toothwort, a tree demon. ‘’A man made entirely of ivy’’, the Green Man who reigns in British Folklore, representing the Old World that is now lost forever. The jewel of the book, in my opinion, the demon contrasted to Lanny who is the angel of our story. In raw, often violent, scenes, Porter makes use of a number of symbols. Skeletons of animals, a Christ without a cross, ghosts, tales and dangers born out of the forest and its lore. Magic, irrationality, bereavement. Darkness and silence are signs of the coming evil, when even the owls are unable to hoot…

In fear of saying too much, I will stop here. We often say that there are certain books one needs to read in order to experience the atmosphere of a story unlike any other and Lanny is a glorious example. The musings of the villagers will make you think of Saunder’s Lincoln in the Bardo . The second part of the novel is one of the most ferociously beautiful moments in Literature and the third part is haunting, unadulterated literary lunacy in its finest form. Forget mundane stories and find yourselves in Lanny’s mysterious world for a few unforgettable moments of literary greatness.

‘’Dead Papa Toothwort has seen monks executed on this land, seen witches drowned, seen industrial slaughter of animals, seen men beat each other senseless, seen bodies abused and violated, seen people hurt their closest, harm themselves, plot and worry or panic and rage, and the same can be said of the earth.’’
Show Less
LibraryThing member SandDune
This is a strange genre-defying, lyrical book. With one of its main characters being Dead Papa Toothwort, who is, well, dead (or at least not alive in the conventional sense) and is a sort of green man or local spirit (or maybe something else entirely), you might think that it should be classified
Show More
in the fantasy section. But much of it doesn't read like a fantasy at all, more like a critique of modern English rural society, while other parts are just strange:

'Dead Papa Toothwort wakes from his standing nap an acre wide and scrapes off dream dreads of bitumen glistening thick with liquid globs of litter.He lies down to hear hymns of the earth (there are none), so he shrinks, cuts himself a mouth with a rusted ring pull and sucks up a wet skin of acid-rich mulch and fruity detritivores. He splits and wobbles, divides and reassembles, coughs up a plastic pot and a petrified condom, briefly pauses as a smashed fibreglass bath, stumbles and rips off the mask, feels his face and finds it made of long-buried tannic acid bottles. Victorian rubbish.

Tetchy Papa Toothwort should never sleep in the afternoon; he doesn't know who he is'

Dead Papa Toothwort might be the resident spirit of the village where Lanny lives, but this isn't some mystical Britain - it's a village within easy commuting distance of London. Lanny's father Robert works in the City (and is a sight more interested in his flash car than he usually is in Lanny) and his mother Jolie, a retired actress, is writing a bloodthirsty thriller which she is anxious not to let Lanny read. Lanny himself, a young boy addicted to building dens in the woods and making collections of the things he finds, and who constantly hums and sings as he goes about his day, is considered slightly odd ... unusual ... different. Different enough to attract the attention of Dead Papa Toothwort...

I listened to this as an audiobook, but I have a feeling that although short, it could well be a little more challenging to read on the page, as the words of the villagers that Dead Papa Toothwort feeds on swirl about the page. I haven't read the author's [Grief is the Thing with Feathers], but after this I will add it to my wish list and get to it as soon as possible.

I've rated this four stars - it would have been four and a half but for the ending which was stranger than the rest and didn't quite work for me. But recommended for people who don't mind trying something a little different.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Eyejaybee
Well I guess I knew that my recent run of reading entertaining and rewarding books would have to end at some point. I really don’t know why I bothered with this book, and I really wish I hadn’t.

Sanctimonious, self satisfied and a dreadful essay in style over substance.
LibraryThing member PDCRead
It is a regular commuter village sixty odd miles from the capital. All sorts of mixed housing, a pub and a church and people trying to go about their lives as normally as possible. In this village is a young lad called Lanny, who is not quite the same as other children his age. He seems to have a
Show More
close affinity to the natural world, spending most of his time outdoors. His mother thinks the world of his, seeing his funnies little ways as a charming thing whereas his father struggles to deal with him. Lanny’s creative side is channelled by a neighbour called Pete who is an artist who sees the potential that he has.

Then there is Dead Papa Toothwort. In this place, he is as old as time.

He is the very essence of the land that the village sits in, he feels it every time they cut the soil to build, and watches as the village celebrates him by dressing up and the pictures that they try to recreate. He has seen the death of thousands of living beings. He is known as the Green Man now, but there is nothing benign about him. He listens to the words the people say in the village, they wash over him like rain, but he has heard Lanny’s songs and it has awoken something in him.

Then one day, Lanny disappears…

And I am not going to say any more than that, as I think you all should read it and make your own minds up. The book is split into three parts, the first is a whimsical introduction to the main characters. The second is as fast-paced as anything that I have ever read and the final part is dramatic, surreal and shocking. It is a story deeply rooted in the folklore of the landscape as well as brushing the edges of folk horror. I liked Porter’s first, Grief is a Thing with Feathers, but in my mind, this book is better than that. It has a much stronger plot, vivid characters and a dark undercurrent that pulls it all together. Great stuff.
Show Less
LibraryThing member chrisblocker
Lanny is an intriguing, brilliantly constructed little novel. It starts off with a poeticism that really grabs the reader, pulls them into the pace of this village, the voices of the individuals as well as the hum of the hive. It's lyrical without pretentiousness. The imaginative range of the
Show More
narrative is both ominous and magical.

As far as story, the first two-thirds of Lanny are wonderful. I was pulled into this village, and into the mind of the mythical creature known as Dead Papa Toothwort. The third part of the story lost me though, enough so I disappointingly felt the need to drop a star. I lost the thread of the story and the rhythm of its telling. Those with a more substantial attention span than I have may have a better appreciation for this section. I didn't follow.

Lanny is oh so comparable in subject and tone to several previous Booker Prize nominees. I don't know if that means it's more or less likely to receive a nod this July, but I won't be surprised if it's on the long list.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Carmenere
My second read from the Booker Long List and this one rockets to the top. Mystical and innovative, with a charming young protagonist, I could not put this book down.
Lanny is said protagonist, he is a thoughtful, caring and precocious kid who relates with nature and art. Lanny's mum hooks Lanny up
Show More
with a bohemian sort of artist in the neighborhood for after school art advice, gardening hints and as it turn out, even life lessons.
When Lanny doesn't come home one evening, a close knit community is quick to point fingers and a man who lives an unconventional lifestyle is deemed the perpetrator.
How the reader hopes and reads at a feverish pace to see the safe return of Lanny.
An unconventional novel that's a bit difficult to get into but well worth sticking it out.
Show Less
LibraryThing member maryzee
A wonderful read
LibraryThing member AAAO
Some struggled with this because of its experimental nature, it's a four hour read more or less. If you read through, this is one of the rare examples where stream of consciousness is constructive, appropriate, and worthwhile because of the subject matter. "Encourage the volunteers to think like a
Show More
child, like a very strange child...." says one of the characters in the novel. The long list being announced, for me, the 2019 Booker was between Porter and Lanchester.
Show Less
LibraryThing member TheEllieMo
Well, this one totally surprised me. I was approaching it with some trepidation, expecting to hate it. I’d hated Grief is a Thing With Feathers, I mean, really hated. All gimmicky. I picked up Lanny in the shop, curious to see what gimmicks Porter has adopted this time. Saw lots of swirling
Show More
sentences. Ugh, no thanks.

But then a couple of people from my bookclub, people who’s judgement I trust, said it was worth reading, that the swirly stuff had a purposes, made sense.

So, I decided to give it a go. I bought a copy, and then bought the audio version too, thinking having both may make it easier to take in.

I’m not sure I would have “got” this if I had just had a visual copy. The swirls may still have ended up seeming gimmicky.

But the audio totally brought the book to life. Dead Papa Toothwort (the spirit of the village) creeping around, listening in to snippets of residents’ conversations, the dull, the routine, the inane, the insulting. And then there is the story of Jolie and Robert, relative newcomers to the village, their son Lanny, considered a little odd by many of the locals, and Mad Pete, once a famous artist, who takes the child under his wing. This is a beautifully written book, evoking the essence of a rural English village, and individuals’ reactions to, and relationships with, their friends and neighbours. I wasn’t wholly enamoured with one particular section where it did get very weird and fantastical, so it falls short of a 5-star read, but it did completely blow my expectations out of the water.
Show Less
LibraryThing member RandyMetcalfe
Lanny is a little boy living in an English village outside London. His father, Robert, is an asset manager in the city. His mother, Jolie, was once an actress and now writes edgy psychological thrillers. Lanny is learning about art from Pete, a famous artist who resides in the village who has
Show More
agreed, at Jolie’s plea, to take on Lanny’s art tutelage. But deeper underground, or in the air, or in everything perhaps, is Dead Papa Toothwort, the elemental spirit of this land that sees all, feels all, and becomes all. And he’s taken a special interest in Lanny.

Max Porter’s writing captures the lives in this village in remarkably brief lines, like a charcoal sketch. But the village totally comes to life. He peoples it with the full range of village characters all of whom, of course, Toothwort himself embodies. It is a lively dance as the reader bounces across characters’ thoughts in the Toothwort sections of the novel. But the picture created of Lanny himself is always a bit vague. In part that’s because everyone sees him a bit differently. And in part because he is a bit different. He’s so in tune with his present moment, which in this case is also the ancient mythical Toothwort moment, that he is more naturally a resident of the village than anyone else there, and at the same time somewhat otherworldly. Enchanted would not be too much to say.

I found this novel entirely captivating. And it’s impossible not to be wondering even as you are reading, how did this novel find a publisher? It’s so unusual. Almost like an extended poem. And yet so dramatic (and sometimes traumatic). A wonderful, significant achievement.

Definitely recommended.
Show Less
LibraryThing member SandyAMcPherson
A few thoughts about Lanny, a novel which joins others in my DNF graveyard.
My main realization (which is strictly personal taste): I don't like reading about missing children. Evidently, my psyche and this novel did not mesh in the least.

Add in the fact that I rather detested Lanny's parents
Show More
(which was not due to marvellous authorship), and with the story interleaved by weird musings of the creepy Dead Papa Toothwort, you've got a recipe for just not engaging. Besides which, the author makes heavy 'magical' weather of the malevolent forces swirling around the village. The poisonous evil never seemed to tie in to Lanny and his situation. Though later this maybe was clarified, but if you lose your audience by constantly taking the reader out of the story, it matters not.

Also a matter of taste, but the swirly text sections were distracting and disruptive. Fancy fonts (imho) belong in art pieces, not novels. Two stars, because the concept Porter developed could have been promising.
Show Less
LibraryThing member SharonMariaBidwell
While it may not be for everyone, there’s no denying Max Porter has his own style. Written in an abstract, patchy way, Lanny reveals the story of a child gone missing, throwing an ugly light on the duplicities of human emotion and reaction. Though I found this style of storytelling a little too
Show More
fragmentary, the book’s ultimately unsettling and effective in parts. Yet I can see how the style will frustrate for many rather than artistic. Either creative or pretentious and difficult to choose which. Good for those who don’t mind the surreal, a departure from traditional narrative, though I would urge reading a sample before purchasing.
Show Less
LibraryThing member pivic
Finally, a fictional novel that combines modern-day Britain with non-Western thinking! This is both an existential and experimental book in one. I hate using the term "unputdownable", but I couldn't really stop reading this book.

The start of it threw me a bit. It's like reading Alan Moore's
Show More
"Jerusalem" and Peter Ackroyd's "Hawksmoor" while being as accessible as Sally Rooney's "Normal People"; the experimental bits didn't put me off, but actually made me instantly want to dig deeper into the book.

The dialogue might seem lackadaisical but is, to me, engaging:

She didn’t miss the acting work but she got bored sometimes, when Lanny went to school, when her husband went in to the city. She was writing a book, she said. A murder thriller. Sounds bloody horrid, I said. It is very bloody and horrid, she said, but thrilling.

The language is beautiful:

We trampled down the dog-walk path towards Hatchett Wood and it was ever so beautiful. The thick wall of green between the common and the wood bursting with life, clematis clambering through and over it, a properly paintable riot, the yarrow glowing a bit, the blackthorn and maple all hugged up together, foxgloves leaning out like thin beckoning arms and I was still wiping tears of laughter from my eyes and considering how surprising it was, me, an old man, tailend of a good career but a mainly lonely life, finding such a good friend in this little kid.

I can find no drawbacks with this book. It is a wondrous example of what experimental art can do. I really want to reread this book again, at once.
Show Less
LibraryThing member lesleynicol
Sorry, but I just didn't "get" this story, I found the style of writing quite pretentious and difficult to understand.
LibraryThing member alexrichman
Perfectly enjoyable but fell between the stools of two superior (to my mind) novels - the fantasy isn't as fantastic as Lincoln in the Bardo, nor the portrait of a village as compelling as Reservoir 13.
LibraryThing member LoriFox
Lanny by Max Porter is a magical book that tells the story of Lanny, a not quite typical boy, in a twisted, non-traditional and fable-like collage of words and images blown about by the winds of a shadowed folktale. I enjoyed it, and if you can abandon any expectation of a typically told tale, you
Show More
will enjoy it too. More folktale than novel, it is deep and dark in the way that the best folktales are. Enter the realm of the Green Man, here called Dead Papa Toothwort, and fall into the story.
Show Less
LibraryThing member roses7184
I can’t be the only one who occasionally picks books up on a whim, right? Especially lately, since I’ve been less and less up to date with new releases, I tend to just pick whatever catches my eye. So when the library had this book on their book picks for “getting lost”, I was very much
Show More
into it. A story about a Green Man character, a being as old as the forest itself, who is so aptly named Dead Papa Toothwort? Oh, you’d better believe that I was invested.

As it turns out, I was right to feel that way. This story feels like going back in time, to the days when stories were told around a fire. From the very opening, Max Porter builds this atmosphere that is hard to ignore. A tiny town, full of people going about their daily lives. A being in the woods, watching. Waiting. Dissatisfied in the lack of attention to nature and whimsy that people have developed. That is, except for one little boy. One spot of bright in the dark.

Lanny’s character is hard to describe. He of course has the quintessential “little boy” personality, but he is so much more than that. He is the child that all of us were at one point, before the world tried to convince us that magic wasn’t real. Porter weaves a story, with Lanny at the center, that is full of intrigue and enchantment. Here is a boy who still sees the beauty in things. A boy who doesn’t care about fitting in, because that’s not what is important at all. I loved that his two parents were on such different spectrums about how to act towards him, because it felt like the way all of us are looked at by the world. It was gorgeously done.

Alas, I have to stop here or otherwise I run the risk of spoiling things on accident. I will say that this story definitely took a turn that I wasn’t quite expecting, but I loved it all the more for that. This is my favorite kind of folk tale. A little dark, a lot magical, and brimming with atmosphere. I truly recommend the audio book! Take some time, and get lost in this wonderful story.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Castlelass
“I sit at work in the city and the thought of him existing a sixty-minute train ride from me, going about his day in the village, carrying his strange brain around, seems completely impossible. It seems unlikely, when I'm at work, that we have a child and it is Lanny. If my parents were here,
Show More
they'd surely say, No Robert, you've dreamt him. Children aren't like that. Go back to sleep. Go back to work.”

This is an experimental novel which incorporates magical realism to relate the legend of Dead Papa Toothwort. It is told in three parts. The first part introduces us to Lanny. He is an unusual child who “marches to his own drummer.” His parents, Jolie and Robert, ask neighboring artist, Peter, to tutor him in art, and Lanny responds. The second part is a series of observations about a period of time when Lanny cannot be located. The third part relates the outcome and is written in a more traditional narrative style.

Dead Papa Toothwort’s experiences are inserted in fragments of sentences that float across the pages in a wave-like pattern. The story takes place in rural England, where the villagers still retain many superstitions. The author examines parenting of a free-spirited creative child. The second part does a good job of pointing out how easy it is to judge others without all the facts. I found it extremely creative and a nice escape from reality, while still making relevant observations for today’s world.
Show Less
LibraryThing member therebelprince
Not going to rate, because this book clearly was not for me, but I appreciated the weird, unique talent that compiled it.
LibraryThing member Cail_Judy
Wow. I was truly spellbound by this book. Porter channels the fun and darkness of Roald Dahl's best work. Highly recommended for your summer reading list. Max is a goddamn trickster.
LibraryThing member Charon07
A strange and beautiful prose poem. A fable about the hypocrisy of life in a small community, a mother’s love, and the magic of unbridled childhood imagination.


Booker Prize (Longlist — 2019)
Gordon Burn Prize (Shortlist — 2019)
Books Are My Bag Readers Award (Shortlist — Fiction — 2019)
James Cropper Wainwright Prize (Longlist — 2019)



Page: 1.0438 seconds