Status
Call number
Publication
Description
I am Zhang, alone with my light, and in that light I think for a moment that I am free.' Imagine a world: a sinocentric world where Chinese Marxism has vanquished the values of capitalism and Lenin is the prophet of choice. A cybernetic world where the new charioteers are flyers, human-powered kites dancing in the skies over New York in a brief grab at glory. A world where the opulence of Beijing marks a new cultural imperialism, as wealthy urbanites flirt with interactive death in illegal speakeasies, and where Arctic research stations and communes on Mars are haunted by their own fragile dangers. A world of fear and hope, of global disaster and slow healing, where progress can only be found in the cracks of a crumbling hegemony. The world of Zhang. An anti-hero who's still finding his way, treading a path through a totalitarian order - a path that just might make a difference.… (more)
User reviews
In any case, Maureen McHugh deserves credit for being ahead of the curve on science fiction’s trending geopolitical prediction. China Mountain Zhang was published in 1992, just as the Cold War was wrapping up and before most people thought China might ever make something of itself. Set in the early 22nd century, it proposes that China is the world’s dominant power and the United States has undergone a communist revolution. China Mountain Zhang, the protagonist, is an “ABC” or American-born Chinese. Secretly, he is half Hispanic, but his mother had him genetically modified as a child to make him appear more Asian, which gives him a social advantage in a Chinese-dominated world. (“The Chinese are the worst racists,” his mother opines. Zhang thinks, “This is not surprising but nor is it helpful. Nor is it a good political thing to say but everybody knows it.”) Zhang also has a second, more troubling secret – he is gay. In the US this is socially unacceptable; in China it is a capital crime. The book begins with Zhang’s boss trying to arrange for him to marry his daughter, using the promise of studying in China as a reward, and the uncomfortable situation Zhang is dragged into as a result.
China Mountain Zhang is a deeply realistic science fiction novel, primarily in the way that it portrays the situation in the United States. Most American authors would depict a communist, Chinese-dominated USA as a nightmarish dystopia – and, indeed, Zhang’s America is far from wonderful, and despite America’s gross hypocrisy and myriad social problems, I would never seriously compare it to China. Yet the truth is that most people all over the world spend their time just getting by, and it makes not much difference to them whether they live under capitalism or communism, democracy or dictatorship. Just look at the hundreds of millions of new middle class Chinese who are happy to live under the Communist Party as long as they have running water and electricity, or the hundreds of millions of Americans who don’t much care if Obama is murdering American citizens as long as he does something about the economy. Or, as Zhang puts it, “I don’t believe in socialism but I don’t believe in capitalism either. We are small, governments are large, we survive in the cracks. Cold comfort.”
It’s clear from early on that this is not an epic sci-fi novel, not even on the politically realistic scale of one of Kim Stanley Robinson’s books. A miniscule amount of humans ever have any grand impact on the world they inhabit, and China Mountain Zhang is about exploring Zhang’s world and developing his personal story rather than chronicling some critical event in a well-developed future history. The “Cleansing Winds” are referred to throughout, and it only gradually becomes clear that this is the name for the American communist revolution. We learn that Canada is still a constitutional monarchy and Australia is on track to become the “next economic power,” but these things are only mentioned in passing. China Mountain Zhang is told from the bottom, looking up – not the top, looking down.
China Mountain Zhang is thus a slow-moving, character-driven book, and while I can’t say I hugely enjoyed it, I did find it compelling, readable and worth my time. It deserves its various awards and accolades. Even twenty years on from its initial publication, I found it to be notably different from most mainstream science fiction novels, and it’s certainly worth reading.
Whenever I read futuristic science fiction written during the Cold War that assumes the Soviet Union continued as a superpower, I find myself
This future is not dystopian, not really (although I'm sure many Americans would consider a socialist USA the worst thing that could ever happen). It's far too realistic for that. The characters are all ordinary people with ordinary concerns about work, success, love, and community. I think that's why I enjoyed this book so much--the story is told by real people with the minor concerns of real life, but it maintains a broad scope. The story begins and ends in New York City, but it travels to an Arctic research station, a rich and glittering Shanghai, even Mars.
The characters, however, are all people who don't quite fit into this new normal. The protagonist, Zhang, is gay and half Latino (which has been obscured by genetic manipulation) who must keep both these aspects of himself secret in order to get ahead. He chafes against these restrictions and longs for community, finally choosing to do something very American: he starts his own business. Other sections of the book are told from the points of view of characters that Zhang meets peripherally. One is a Chinese woman with a medical condition that has rendered her "ugly"; once she has that corrected, she unexpectedly faces the possibly worse problems of pretty girls. Another is a loner who has finally moved to a commune on Mars in order to be left alone, but yet finds herself reluctantly helping to build her new community.
These are quiet stories, and the events that take place are not big ones. Without the technological enhancements, all of these stories could take place today. Through her speculative premise, McHugh shines a light on the persistent tensions that characterize the human species: the tension between conformity and individuality, and the desire we all have to make our own lives and to truly be ourselves.
Read for female science fiction/fantasy month (June 2014).
Zhang, sometimes called Rafael, has strikes against him in this world. As an ABC ( American Born Chinese) he's at the top of the chain for being a foreigner, however the fact that he is only half Chinese (his mother is Latina) and is bent (homosexual) means that his prospects in the world are somewhat limited. The first could keep him from getting and keeping a descent job, the second could get him a trip to a prison camp or a bullet to the back of the head.
One of the things I loved about this book, along with the clean writing style, is how McHugh shapes a complex world, when she could have easily fallen back on socialism cliches. Instead she looks at the world from many levels and from many cultural points of view, while showing the intricate and subtle ways the dominate culture infiltrates everyday life. (I especially like that "Marx", "Lennon", and "Mao" are used as curse words, the way "Jesus Christ" is now.)
Part of how she accomplishes this is through the presentation of a variety of characters, who are all complex and interesting. Though Zhang is the main character and his quest to define himself is the main arc of the novel, in every other McHugh switches to a short story from the point of view of a different character. Each of these characters' lives intersects with Zhang's in some small way (a great, simple way to keep the story coherent), but their stories are their own and each, like Zhang, is trying to find a way to define themselves, to pursue their own passion and possibly achieve some measure of contentment and peace, if not outright happiness.
This is a beautiful book, one that's been sitting on my bookshelf for a long time, but that I am so thrilled to own, because it's definitely a favorite.
China Mountain Zhang is beautiful slice-of-life storytelling at its best. Even in such a speculative, futuristic world, people still get by and cope with everyday anxieties and issues (the Mars chapters are particularly well done). It's a world that looks a lot like our own. I was really surprised to discover that the novel was first published in 1992. A sleeper hit that is now a classic I hope.
The four stories only barely intersect: all of the characters are acquaintances of the gay man, China Mountain Zhang. Other than that, there is no connection between them, and you could remove any one of the story lines without affecting the others. I found this frustrating. The stories also didn't really seem to go anywhere, except for China's but even his didn't really have a satisfying arc. I was particularly disturbed by the storyline of the ugly woman: there is a long, detailed, and predictable chapter about her date rape, which is totally gratuitous.
The world building is pretty interesting, but there's a paradox here: I think the main point of the book is that people strive and struggle to find happiness in connections to other humans, and that people on the margins of society have to swim upstream to find their way. In other words, the point is that people are the same in any time and place. That makes the world-building totally incidental - if people are the same everywhere, then it doesn't matter what the world is, which means that the world is just background and doesn't really play a role in the story. This made the world-building unsatisfying.
I found this book very engaging while I was reading it, but then it was over and it was unsatisfying.
And then! The whole passage on Baffin Island! Totally polar fiction!
(mild spoilers ahead)
This book shifts narrative focus between loosely connected characters -- Zhang - a construction tech engineer who struggles with his in-between status as an American Born Chinese, Angel - a flyer in the kite races Zhang loves to watch, Martine - a military vet who has settled on Mars, raising goats and bees, Alexi - a single father at the bottom of Mars' hierarchy, San-xiang - an unattractive girl whose father tried to match her to Zhang (not knowing Zhang is "bent" or gay), whose life changes when her face is reconstructed. (Her story was physically painful for me to read. She has no idea how to handle the new ways people treat her, I wanted to scream at her through the pages.)
This is such an interesting world to live in through this book. I loved immersing myself in corner after corner of it, it was so well imagined. I kept expecting, though, for all the characters to come crashing together somehow in some crisis. In the final third of the book, I kept racing, faster and faster, turning pages expecting the crisis to come at any moment. It never did.
As I turned the final page, I exclaimed both, "What the holy crap was that?" and "Oh, dear Lord, I loved it!" Hugging the book to myself, even as it had defied so many of my expectations of what an sf novel should be, I was calculating and weighing whether I could bear to return this book to the library without buying a copy of my own.
The perfect mesh of literary fiction and speculative fiction. I adore.
The political dimensions were well rounded and gave a strong contrast to the
I got a lot out of the read, and was glad not to have it all tied up to an unbelievable climax, rather left as a fine example of daoist engineering.
In a near-future world, China is economically and culturally dominant and Mars is the new frontier. The United States is no longer an economic force and people there work and play and dream of living in China. But only genetically pure Chinese are allowed
The book is divided into chapters/sections that each follow different protagonists - three on Earth and two on Mars. The bulk of the narrative follows the titular character, Zhang but there is overlap between all of the storylines. None of these characters find much in the way of resolution and, in truth, not much happens with most of them. The conflicts are mostly (but not all) internal.
What elevates this book is McHugh's writing; it is evocative and her world-building is breathtaking. There is a melancholy and almost desperate feel to each character as they muddle along looking for improvement and envying others their status. With each step forward, they come to realize that, despite their advancement, there will be no escaping themselves. That seems to be the common thread here. It does not sound like very compelling stuff but, once I began this book, it was difficult to stop. China Mountain Zhang is not action-packed by any means but it is a very memorable and intriguing novel.
The protagonist (he's the ABC, American Born Chinese) likes to go watch the kite races, which is where tiny little humans that strap
This book takes place in what I believe is the 22nd century. Technology has advanced so much that everybody has these ports on their wrists, so that they can plug themselves into stuff. If you want to speak another language, you can be "augmented" for it.
Fliers..
"... A bunch of us go out to a place on LaGuardia where we can drink and make a lot of noise. It's called commemorative, and fliers hang out there. Cinnabar's picked up two guys; a blonde and an ABC, both clearly bent. So's cinnabar. They aren't fliers, of course. Cinnabar has the hots for the blonde, whose name is peter. He isn't tall, not for, you know, a non-flier, I'm not good at heights, maybe one-seven? And not heavy. But next to him Cinnabar looks like nothing but bone and hair. He's pretty, too. And scrawny Cinnabar is not pretty.
(5'6")
After the protagonist works for a year at Baffin Island (Arctic Circle), he gets the chance to get his 4-year degree in engineering at the University in Guangzhou. He feels so all alone there; he knows no one. But he gets lucky, because his tutor turns out to be gay, or what is known as "bent" in the book. He doesn't know how to dress so he notes how his tutor is dressing, as he is a real fashion plate.
The fashion in Gangzhouo:
"I dress in my new clothes; calf-high boots, black jacket with swallow Tails over red, and brushed gray tights like Haitao wore. Am I doing it wrong, I wonder? Have I chosen well? I could disappear on the street in a thousand similar outfits. Will he approve?
The male sex worker Liu Wen, who Zhang meets at Haitao's place:
"Escape is escape. And if I must be a bad element, I might as well allow myself the luxury of indulging as many categories as possible.
Bad elements. There used to be five categories of black elements; landlords, criminals, counter-revolutionaries, capitalists, and one other which I don't remember. We studied it in Middle School in political theory, that was a long time ago for me. Capitalists have been rehabilitated. I don't remember where intellectuals originally came in, perhaps counter-revolutionaries, but bent [gay] as we are, we are criminals. That has not changed in all the years since the revolution."
(Gawd I love this book)
They go to a club that is raided by the police. Haitao and Zhang escape, but only just. They climb floors and spend the night on a catwalk.
"The catwalk is too narrow for us to stand side by side. It's wider than an i-beam, of course, but we are high above the floor and it looks narrower. I take Haitao's wrist with my left hand and start across it. I can see the control panel on the other side and a set of stairs going down, but that side of the building is shadowed and I can't see if there is a loading dock. There should be.
'Hold on to the railing,' I say. Haitao does what he's told. I wish he would think a little for himself, I am cold and I ache and he's acting like a child. Damn it, I ought to leave him here, let him find his own way out.
Anger is good. Anger is better than what Haitao is feeling, than apathy or, what did Maggie Smallwood call it? Perlerorneq, the awareness of the futility of it all. Despair. Underneath my anger I am all too aware that I've been just as paralyzed as Haitao is now."
ZhaoXiezhi was the father of the revolution that destroyed capitalism
In addition to the struggles of the characters who deal with an oppressive government, relationships, gender issues, and beauty the novel also gives fanciful descriptions of a new sport where humans race with giant glider wings attached, zen architecture where your mind interfaces with a computer, and they ate lots of Thai food which made me very hungry.
I have to admit, I preferred "Mission Child" - but this was pretty good as well. McHugh is an excellent writer, with a real gift for creating vivid, complex and believable characters.
However, I felt the structure of this
Every so often, the story goes on a tangent, exploring the lives of people that come into contact with Zhang - a settler on Mars that he tutors, athletes involved in a dangerous sport (cybernetic hang-gliding, basically), and a girl that he reluctantly takes out on a few dates.
Each of these scenarios remarkably quickly comes to life - but remains tangential to the plot. Each dilemma faced by these sub-plot characters is only partially resolved. Much like real life - and I believe it was intentional on the writer's part - but it's still somewhat frustrating.
The book also has a tendency to, every so often, "jump ahead" a few years - so, although we see Zhang's growth from irresponsible young man to well-respected engineer, it seem to occur in a jerky, slightly disorienting rhythm rather than a flow...
Regardless of these small things, I'd highly recommend the book - it's a pleasure to read, and deeply insightful of human nature, with a thought-provoking look at a possible near-future...
In terms of actual content, though... On the one hand, it was nice to read an early-90s book about gay men in New York that didn't involve all of them dying of AIDS. On the other hand, combining communist China and early-90s attitudes towards gay people made this a painful read. (Not the author's attitudes, by any means - the societal attitudes described and extrapolated to this future culture.) I have very little context about the whole China thing, so I'm just going to assume that McHugh knows what she's talking about - it certainly seems like it, and both the American Chinese culture and the set-in-China culture were thoroughly developed, fascinating, and fascinatingly different from one another.
The non-Zhang vignettes varied in effectiveness for me - the ones set on Mars were great, the one about the flier wasn't bad but seemed unnecessary, and the date-rape one was agonizing in exactly the way it was intended to be. (I don't love rape as a character device, in general, but I have to wonder how common this sort of grimly honest portrayal was twenty years ago.)
I'm not at all surprised that this is regarded as an important book, and I'm glad I read it. I'm going to be chewing over it for a while.
It's a story about life in the future. Though it's sci-fi it stays simple, and stays true to the feelings of its characters.
This is part of my
Awards
Language
Original publication date
Physical description
ISBN
Local notes
Google Books
gift from SZ