Status
Publication
Description
From the Publisher: In Murder of a Medici Princess, Caroline Murphy illuminates the brilliant life and tragic death of Isabella de Medici, one of the brightest stars in the dazzling world of Renaissance Italy, the daughter of Duke Cosimo I, ruler of Florence and Tuscany. Murphy is a superb storyteller, and her fast-paced narrative captures the intrigue, the scandal, the romantic affairs, and the violence that were commonplace in the Florentine court. She brings to life an extraordinary woman, fluent in five languages, a free-spirited patron of the arts, a daredevil, a practical joker, and a passionate lover. Isabella, in fact, conducted numerous affairs, including a ten-year relationship with the cousin of her violent and possessive husband. Her permissive lifestyle, however, came to an end upon the death of her father, who was succeeded by her disapproving older brother Francesco. Considering Isabella's ways to be licentious and a disgrace upon the family, he permitted her increasingly enraged husband to murder her in a remote Medici villa. To tell this dramatic story, Murphy draws on a vast trove of newly discovered and unpublished documents, ranging from Isabella's own letters, to the loose-tongued dispatches of ambassadors to Florence, to contemporary descriptions of the opulent parties and balls, salons and hunts in which Isabella and her associates participated. Murphy resurrects the exciting atmosphere of Renaissance Florence, weaving Isabella's beloved city into her story, evoking the intellectual and artistic community that thrived during her time. Palaces and gardens in the city become places of creativity and intrigue, sites of seduction, and grounds for betrayal. Herethen is a narrative of compelling and epic proportions, magnificent and alluring, decadent and ultimately tragic.… (more)
Similar in this library
User reviews
And Caroline Murphy is fortunate that the sources are relatively good, and she makes the most of them. The Isabella De Medici she paints is free spirited, erudite, fun loving with a healthy disrespect for her buffoon of a husband. And while her father reigns and dotes on her, she is able to get away with an independence most Renaissance women could only marvel at. But with the death of her father and the ascension of her melancholic brother Francesco to the dukedom, things start to go badly wrong...
Murphy tells a great story. Instinctively you want to cheer on Isabella, boo her mean brother, and lament her woeful husband. The ending is inevitable and all the sadder for it. Recommended for anyone with any interest in Italy or the Renaissance
But all was
Carolyn Murphy is a master storyteller, drawing from the "vast trove of newly discovered and unpublished documents, ranging from Isabella's own letters, to the loose-tongued dispatches of ambassadors to Florence, to contemporary descriptions of the opulent parties and balls, salons and hunts in which Isabella and her associates participated. Murphy resurrects the exciting atmosphere of Renaissance Florence, weaving Isabella's beloved city into her story, evoking the intellectual and artistic community that thrived during her time."
In a genre that is filled with book after book written about the British and French Royal Houses - it is my hope that these newly discovered manuscripts provide the history necessary for more stories of the Italian Royals.
Born at once to privilege and repression in a relentlessly male-dominated society, Isabella was a brilliant woman, fluent in five languages, devoted to the arts, high-spirited and daring. While her father lived, her life was her own as much as any woman of the time could hope. But with his death, her brother and husband conspired to kill her in circumstances that have haunting echoes in today’s “honor killings”.
Murphy’s research is impeccable, as is her ability to bring a distant time to life. Isabella emerges as a living, breathing woman who blazed a dazzling path across the Renaissance sky and whose fall to earth casts light into the darkest corners of that complex time.
The book’s title is a bit misleading. The vast majority of the book is dedicated to Isabella’s life, as well as the fraught political situation in northern Italy at the time. Even so, there’s not much focus on what Isabella was like; yes, she loved parties and all of that, but we never see what Isabella was like as a person, really. However, she was known for having a sarcastic sense of humor. However, the author does a great job at describing 16th century life: what people ate, what they wore, and what they did for fun. It’s things like that that make history more interesting.
The murder, as such, disappointed me, however. Literally only 20 pages are devoted to the death of Isabella, and there’s not really much to go on here—how did Isabella really die? Who really killed her? The author doesn’t even try to hazard a guess here, so we’re left with more questions than answers; disappointing, in my opinion. I guess we’ll never know what truly happened at that remote country villa. In addition, the book is written in a very dry tone, and it doesn’t move at a smooth pace at times. Still, Isabella de Medici is an intriguing woman, unique in that she was able to make her own decisions in a world where women really didn’t have many options.
Sacrificed to the usual Medici 'marriage of convenience,' Isabella managed for
Murphy's portrayal of corrupt and compelling Renaissance Florence is both vivid and exact. But what may please the scholar/history student may not be what the general reader is looking for. And this is neither historical fiction nor a romance; it is a well-drawn scholarly biography which can be gritty and dry and pedantic as need be.
Murphy's Isabella is an interesting woman; she is unique, and it is up to the reader to decide if she is admirable.
Murphy's book is definitely admirable. But it is unfortunate that its market niche isn't a bit clearer.