Status
Publication
Description
Those who predicted the death of libraries forgot to consider that in the automated maze of contemporary life, none of us--neither the experts nor the hopelessly baffled--can get along without human help. And not just any help--we need librarians, who won't charge us by the question or roll their eyes, no matter what we ask. Who are they? What do they know? And how quickly can they save us from being buried by the digital age? This book is a romp through the ranks of information professionals and a revelation for readers burned out on the clichés and stereotyping of librarians. Here are bloggers, radicals and visionaries who fuse the tools of the digital age with their love for the written word and the enduring values of free speech, open access, and scout-badge-quality assistance to anyone in need.--From publisher description.… (more)
Similar in this library
Media reviews
User reviews
I thoroughly enjoyed (most of) this book. It's true that I'm a recent re-convert to library usage, after many years of avoiding them because of one old prune-faced,
But the many and various challenges that libraries face are completely transparent to the public that uses them. We just expect that they'll keep on being there, checking books out to us, providing online resources for our kids and grandkids, being waystations for us when our own Internet connections go down or whatever. We're not fond of paying for the libraries, either, as demonstrated by the readiness of governments of all sizes to cut their acquisition, staffing, maintenance budgets to the bone and beyond, to the point of amputation.
Fortunately, The Librarian is a resolute and resilient subspecies of Homo "sapiens", and has cleverly disguised itself in some very odd places...Google "Second Life" sometime and go for a walk on the Weird Side! Lots of librarians talked to author Johnson, and told her tales of woe; but she heard paeans of praise and odes to joy, too, and reports each and all of these classes of utterance with clarity and asperity.
Libraries and librarians have moved onto the World Wide Web with verve and enthusiasm...but back in RL, things aren't so rosy. The New York Public Library's iconic building at Forty-second and Fifth will, for the first time in forty years, house a circulating library. It comes at the cost of the Asian and Russian collections, but what the hell...the money from redeveloping the Mid-Manhattan Branch's site into yet another hotel will do some good, too, right? But...and this is where I get madder than hell...can any amount of material gain make up for the loss to the culture of the world that two collections of rare, irreplaceable material objects (the papers of the Tsarist government! the contents of a monastery's library!) properly curated and indexed represent? I presume the fact that I bother to phrase the question tells you what MY answer is.
I said in another review that "{h}istory is the beautiful, brightly lit foam on top of the annihilating tsunami of the unrecorded past. History books are the spectrographic analysis of the light glinting off that foam." Yes, but I left out a key component: Without a library to house, organize, cross-reference, FIND that book, what good does the damned thing do?
Support your local library in a PRACTICAL way. And go hug a librarian.
I expected this to be a book for librarians, written by a librarian, but that first impression had to be revised in numerous ways. Marilyn Johnson is not a librarian, but got the idea for this book when she was writing about obituaries and some of the more interesting ones she came across were the obits of librarians. Furthermore, the book is broad in scope, and reads more like a series of vignettes than an in-depth look at any one issue. My only real disappointment was that she spends a lot of time talking about the New York City libraries, and personally I am more interested in and find more relevant how small-town libraries with smaller budgets and fewer connections would serve their public. Many librarians have probably heard of most of the technologies, issues, and ideas that she covers. Does that mean that librarians won't like the book? No, but I would more readily recommend this book as perhaps being more helpful for folks who are thinking of going for a master's in library science - in fact, I learned about much of these topics in my M.L.I.S. program - and it's a great introduction for them to see the breadth of what librarians do, including the sometimes crazy balancing act between research, archives, traditional services and shinier things like blogging, Second Life, and circulation numbers. Alternatively, I would suggest it to those folks who think librarians are still in the shushing business to open their eyes to all that librarians can do, even in a wired world.
The problem is stated clearly and succinctly by
Her failure to "grasp the whole" has resulted in a book that is little more than a collection of anecdotes. Johnson has no thesis, no point, to tie these stories together. She jumps from a lengthy discussion about libraries and librarians on Second Life (and it occurred to me that it's been ages since I've heard anyone even mention Second Life!) to the serious matter of government intrusion into library records to decisions about archiving author records. (She actually spends nearly six pages on library blog entries about feces. Really.) She is uncritical about technology, so entranced by its usefulness that she cannot see its drawbacks.
And the book is too much about Johnson, her interactions, what she did, what she thought.
I'm not saying, "Don't read this book." You may find some of the anecdotes amusing or interesting. Just don't expect any serious discussion or analysis of the problems facing libraries and librarians today.
The book also provides an introduction to other parts of the field of library science, including archives and digital libraries, showing how these institutions too are morphing consistently to suit the needs of society. Perhaps this book should be sent to the politicians and corporate leaders who seek to close public libraries. At the same time, her research reveals new, innovative ways in which information users can be served by information professionals. Society is always changing, in one way or another, and information professionals must adapt to the needs of society. This is why information professionals exist, and without progress, information institutions will not achieve their ultimate goals. Every librarian and information professional should read this inspiring book so that we can learn, from the stories which Johnson so effectively illustrates, how to fulfill our users’ informational needs, whatever they may be, in the most efficient way possible.
“I was under the librarians’ protection. Civil servants and servants of civility, they had my back. They would be whatever they needed to be that day: information professionals, teachers, police, community organizers, computer technicians, historians, confidantes, clerks, social workers, storytellers, or, in this case, guardians of my peace.” (252)
Each chapter has a different topic. Some were more interesting to me than others, and although she explores many aspects of librarianship, especially in the modern and changing sense, it's not a comprehensive book (nor is it supposed to be.) It was so refreshing to have a non-librarian not only defend the profession but praise it. Sadly, when you tell people you're in graduate school in library and information studies, they often ask why. When I respond, "being a librarian requires a master's degree," people are often dumbfounded and shocked. The exception, usually, are the people who actually have a friend or family member who is a librarian. They exclaim with joy when you say you're a library student.
If you like books, technology or organizational models at all (hello, book bloggers!), you will like this book. My one complaint? The book is mostly about public librarians. As an academic librarian, I was eager for Ms. Johnson to point out how our jobs are different. It wasn't the scope of her book, but I'd love to see a follow-up go in-depth into academic librarianship. It's a fun, informative, and fascinating read. As a librarian, it was delightful to see an outsider take an honest look at the profession. As a reader, it was a delight to read Ms. Johnson's beautiful, descriptive language.
Books? That's so last century.
This Book is Overdue is about librarians on the frontier, the new frontier. It opens nicely by juxtaposing a library on the old frontier, the town library in Deadwood, South Dakota once a part of America's wild west, with the town library in Deadwood, Second Life, a virtual library in a virtual part of the internet's wild west. Both libraries exist to provide a service, a means for people new in town to find all they need to know to adapt to their surroundings, to learn the town's history, to pick up information or a new skill that will help them better their lives. One offers tourists information on local historical sites, the other gives avatar's advice on how to dress as a proper saloon girl. Second Life's version of Deadwood offers players a chance to become a gunslinger or a prospector or a saloon singer for a small fee. One player, a retired electrical engineer and railroad buff, becomes an librarian in a frilly 19th century dress to become town librarian in the virtual Deadwood. There are hundreds of professional librarians offering their services and training other volunteers to become virtual librarians in virtual libraries all over Second Life.
These librarians have seen the future, and they're going to catalogue it.
Marilyn Johnson takes the reader on a tour of library science's cutting edge. Libraries that give away single use audio books, internet catalogues that can tell you exactly how many miles away the book you want is, libraries with Wii rooms, 24-hour information systems open nation wide, and street librarians who wander among demonstrators at protests with wireless laptops handing out the latest updates on everything from legislative actions to police blockades. If you want to know it, there's a librarian somewhere who wants to tell you.
They're here to help.
It's not always a pretty picture. Champions of the old systems will not get much sympathy from This Book is Overdue. The days of the card catalogue are long gone and the movement to computerized data bases and on-line library catalogues has not been easy for some. It can be difficult to get one's head around the idea that the new libraries may not actually have all that many books in them. In an age where anyone with even a second rate computer can access more information that can be found in all the books held in a typical town library, Librarians must adapt if they are to survive. The librarians Ms. Johnson interviews for This Book is Overdue intend on not just surviving, but on thriving. Witness the virtual librarians in Second Life.
Though the general public doesn't often see it, librarians are front-line defenders of the Constitution in the United States. Freedom of speech, more precisely the freedom to read, has always been under some kind of assault in America. Ms. Johnson devotes a chapter of This Book is Overdue to the case of the Connecticut Four, three librarians and a tech specialist who were forced to sue the Federal Government in order to keep a patron's records private after the passage of the Patriot Act which intended to give the Department of Homeland Security the power to check anyone's library records without a warrant, without stating a reason why and without telling anyone about it. Maybe a patrons are looking up how to build a bomb. Or maybe they're looking up how to treat a form a cancer they have, or what to do if they suspect their child is gay, or how they can walk away from an abusive spouse, or how to press charges against someone who hurt them, or any number of other things they want kept private from family members, employers or the government.
Marilyn Johnson is hopeful about the future of libraries and librarians. They are a group of people she admires greatly and enjoys; her book is a successful tribute to them.
Definitely required reading for librarians, and hopefully everyone else in the reading world.
In case it matters, I picked up this book for free from the publisher at ALA Midwinter 2010.
That said, none of the stories delve very deep and there are a few glaring omissions. There is an entire chapter about librarians on Second Life but no mention of code4lib, and only very brief mentions of the Internet Archive and the Darien library's great work.
Nevertheless, this provides a good introduction to this rapidly changing profession. Would make for great beach reading.
In spite of this, I did not love This Book, and in fact fell just shy of actually
I think the author was going for a traditional vs new technology sort of book and that both have a place in libraries, but it misses the point by only briefly mentioning how a normal librarian uses technology to help the average person.
The book is well researched, has lots of interesting people in it. The author knows her subject and how to write.
Old-school librarians must feel as if the rug has been pulled from beneath their feet. Freshly minted librarians will be better prepared, but even they are having to scramble to keep up with the freight train bearing down on them. Marilyn Johnson’s This Book Is Overdue: How Librarians and Cybrarians Can Save Us All is probably aimed more at librarians themselves than it is at their customers, but heavy-duty library patrons should also take a look.
Johnson focuses on the changing roll of the librarian – and how librarians everywhere are directly involved in rewriting their job descriptions. Interestingly, despite the rapid fire changes that librarians are dealing with, what is perhaps their most important role is not really changing all that much: they are still the gatekeepers of the information being sought by library patrons. Librarians still, if they are good at what they do, know the best way to find the information being sought by their customers. They know not only how to find it fastest, but whether to trust what they find.
This Book Is Overdue takes a look at librarians themselves, not just at their job duties. What Johnson has to say about them might surprise readers whose only impression of librarians comes from what they see at the library. Johnson, while she does seem to agree that librarians are a bit of a “type,” wants her readers to know that there are some real characters in the ranks. There is a chapter on librarians who hit the streets during protests, offering information, via smartphones, that will be useful to protesters and those being protested, alike. Another highlights the efforts of a small group of librarians who set a national precedent by protesting the intrusion of The Patriot Act into the privacy of their patrons.
One of my favorite chapters is the one in which Johnson looks closely at the efforts of a group of professional and amateur librarians who have created working libraries within the popular Second Life software. What these men and women have accomplished is amazing – especially since what they do in Second Life is every bit as time consuming and difficult as what they do in their day jobs.
My other favorite is the chapter on librarians who blog – I’ve run across more than a few of these myself and have enjoyed both the irreverent ones and the more serious ones. Johnson’s point is that the blogging world is where librarians can be themselves (even to the point of sometimes having to hide their true identities) and can have real fun with their fellow readers.
This Book Is Overdue is for dedicated readers and the people we depend on to keep us supplied with the book-fix we need to make it through our week. It is not the easiest thing to read (I did find the author’s style to be a little dry, at times) but it is well worth the effort.
Rated at: 3.0
Marilyn Johnson's This Book is Overdue illuminates the things today's librarians are doing to combat misinformation, to keep up with the latest trends in technology, to fight censorship, to make a difference in their communities, and quite literally, to change the world. There is so much to take in, so many aspects of libraries that I had never thought about before - the amount of information Johnson gives is a little overwhelming. Nevertheless, I think librarians could benefit from reading This Book is Overdue if only to search out new ideas to make their libraries better.
The only negative I have after reading This Book is Overdue is a lack of solid organization. With so much information and research, it is important to have a level of focus that was not achieved here. If the chapters had been tied together a bit more tightly, it might have made for a better book overall. On the whole however, This Book is Overdue is an extremely engrossing and thought-provoking look at the future of libraries and librarians. I would recommend it highly to anyone interested in the ways technology has shaped and changed the face of libraries forever.