21 Lessons for the 21st Century

by Yuval Noah Harari

Paperback, 2019


Spiegel & Grau (2019), Edition: Reprint, 416 pages


History. Sociology. Nonfiction. HTML:#1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER • In Sapiens, he explored our past. In Homo Deus, he looked to our future. Now, one of the most innovative thinkers on the planet turns to the present to make sense of today’s most pressing issues. “Fascinating . . . a crucial global conversation about how to take on the problems of the twenty-first century.”—Bill Gates, The New York Times Book Review NAMED ONE OF THE BEST BOOKS OF THE YEAR BY FINANCIAL TIMES AND PAMELA PAUL, KQED How do computers and robots change the meaning of being human? How do we deal with the epidemic of fake news? Are nations and religions still relevant? What should we teach our children? Yuval Noah Harari’s 21 Lessons for the 21st Century is a probing and visionary investigation into today’s most urgent issues as we move into the uncharted territory of the future. As technology advances faster than our understanding of it, hacking becomes a tactic of war, and the world feels more polarized than ever, Harari addresses the challenge of navigating life in the face of constant and disorienting change and raises the important questions we need to ask ourselves in order to survive. In twenty-one accessible chapters that are both provocative and profound, Harari builds on the ideas explored in his previous books, untangling political, technological, social, and existential issues and offering advice on how to prepare for a very different future from the world we now live in: How can we retain freedom of choice when Big Data is watching us? What will the future workforce look like, and how should we ready ourselves for it? How should we deal with the threat of terrorism? Why is liberal democracy in crisis? Harari’s unique ability to make sense of where we have come from and where we are going has captured the imaginations of millions of readers. Here he invites us to consider values, meaning, and personal engagement in a world full of noise and uncertainty. When we are deluged with irrelevant information, clarity is power. Presenting complex contemporary challenges clearly and accessibly, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century is essential reading. “If there were such a thing as a required instruction manual for politicians and thought leaders, Israeli historian Yuval Noah Harari’s 21 Lessons for the 21st Century would deserve serious consideration. In this collection of provocative essays, Harari . . . tackles a daunting array of issues, endeavoring to answer a persistent question: ‘What is happening in the world today, and what is the deep meaning of these events?’”—BookPage (top pick).… (more)

Media reviews

It’s no criticism to say that Harari hasn’t produced a satisfying answer yet. Neither has anyone else. So I hope he turns more fully to this question in the future. In the meantime, he has teed up a crucial global conversation about how to take on the problems of the 21st century.
2 more
Wittgenstein schreef dat filosofie alles zou moeten laten zoals het is: de wereld beschrijven en ordenen, zonder die uit te willen leggen of conclusies te willen trekken en daarmee de werkelijkheid geweld aandoen. Historicus Harari lijkt zich in precies zo’n spagaat te bevinden. Hij wil de
Show More
geschiedenis beschrijven zoals die was, huidige wetenschappelijke en technologische ontwikkelingen weergeven zoals die zijn. Maar in zijn drang om conclusies te trekken en lessen aan te dragen, wordt zijn verhaal een theoretisch construct dat raakvlakken mist met de werkelijkheid.
Show Less
[T]his book sees Harari enter that class of gurus who are assumed to be experts on everything. The 22nd lesson of this book is obvious: no single member of the tribe Homo Sapiens can know everything. If this new age needs new stories, then we have to let more people tell them.

User reviews

LibraryThing member Iudita
Twelve hours of my life well spent. There are enough concepts in this book to keep you pondering for the rest of your life. Best read with a very open mind.
LibraryThing member writemoves
As I read this book, I was overwhelmed by the number and quality of insights, observations, predictions and analyses made about a variety of topics covering history, technology, business, science, medicine, psychology etc. This is a book that should be read by someone in their 20s who will live to
Show More
see if many of Harari's predictions will come true. His book will at least serve as a guide for the future. Harari's observations about careers and technology are well worth the price of his book and taking the time to read it. Some notes of interest below:

"By manufacturing a never-ending stream of crises, a corrupt oligarchy can prolong its rule indefinitely."

"During the latter part of the twentieth century, each generation—whether in Houston, Shanghai, Istanbul, or São Paulo—enjoyed better education, superior healthcare and larger incomes than the one that came before it. In coming decades, however, owing to a combination of technological disruption and ecological meltdown, the younger generation might be lucky to simply stay in place."

"What we are facing is not the replacement of millions of individual human workers by millions of individual robots and computers; rather, individual humans are likely to be replaced by an integrated network."

"Though they suffer from their own problems and limitations, and though some accidents are inevitable, replacing all human drivers by computers is expected to reduce deaths and injuries on the road by about 90 percent."

"The human care industry—which takes care of the sick, the young, and the elderly—is likely to remain a human bastion for a long time. Indeed, as people live longer and have fewer children, care of the elderly will probably be one of the fastest-growing sectors in the human labor market."

"The most successful ice cream vendors in the world are those that the Google algorithm ranks first—not those that produce the tastiest ice cream."

"In the twenty-first century, however, data will eclipse both land and machinery as the most important asset, and politics will be a struggle to control the flow of data. If data becomes concentrated in too few hands, humankind will split into different species."

"Humans have bodies. During the last century technology has been distancing us from our bodies. We have been losing our ability to pay attention to what we smell and taste. Instead we are absorbed in our smartphones and computers. We are more interested in what is happening in cyberspace than in what is happening down the street."

"There is a scientific consensus that human activities, in particular the emission of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, are causing the earth’s climate to change at a frightening rate. Unfortunately, as of 2018, instead of a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, the global emission rate is still increasing. Humanity has very little time left to wean itself from fossil fuels."

"Not only rationality, but individuality too is a myth. Humans rarely think for themselves. Rather, we think in groups."

"People rarely appreciate their ignorance, because they lock themselves inside an echo chamber of like-minded friends and self-confirming news feeds, where their beliefs are constantly reinforced and seldom challenged."

"We have zero scientific evidence that Eve was tempted by the serpent, that the souls of all infidels burn in hell after they die, or that the creator of the universe doesn’t like it when a Brahmin marries a Dalit—yet billions of people have believed in these stories for thousands of years. Some fake news lasts forever."
Show Less
LibraryThing member nivramkoorb
This is the 3rd book that I have read by Harari i. The first 2( Sapiens and Homo Deus) are among the best non-fiction books that I have ever read. They got me thinking about all aspects of our lives as he delves into our history as a species and the future of humans. This book is simpler and
Show More
probably a good introduction to Harari for first time readers. He deals with the present and deliver 21 essays in 5 sections 1. Technological Change 2.The Political Challenge 3. Despair and Hope 4.Truth 5.Resilience . Although he deals with lofty topics he writes them in understandable ways with lots of concrete examples. One of his main themes throughout all 3 of his books is the concept of the myths that we live with. To me his number one myth is religion. Being a historian and scientist he looks at things through empirical evidence. Religion as an accepted myth(after all do we really have proof of God's existence) unites most of humanity. As a unifying force it has done much good in the world but also much harm. He shows that what works for small intimate groups does not solve the big problems of the world. For me the best lesson was the one on humility. The idea that the world should be looked at through the rules set down by religion shows a certain arrogance about one religion having the truth. After all what do all the rituals and rules that all religions practice have to do with the central positive message of the religion. His book addresses truth and shows how Trump and Putin distort the truth to achieve their goals. He does not necessarily have answers to our most vexing problems but this book definitely gets you to think. For me reading his 3 books has caused me to view everything through the historical perspective that he lays down in his books. There quite a few youtube videos of Harari engaging with different moderators.Check it out. This is thought provoking non-fiction at the highest level. He will challenge your deeply held beliefs about nationalism, commerce, and religion.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Rex_Lui
Second best book I read this year. Only second to Steven Pinker's "Enlightenment Now". Highly recommended.
LibraryThing member Clara53
First of all, the reaction to this book might depend on the readership: is it a student right out of college, a person in his/her 40s, or a retiree - the mental impact might be different for each of them. "Sapiens" took me by surprise and was an eye-opener, and "21 Lessons..." doesn't fall short of
Show More
that at all, another eye-opener on many levels (I am yet to read "Homo Deus" - delaying it, thinking it might be a bit "over-my-head"...).

I do agree with other reviewers that Harari doesn't have all the answers (who has?!), but he highlights and pinpoints the societal problems in such a way that definitely makes us pause and think. At first glance, Harari might seem a super skeptic, but in fact, he makes a lot of sense. I have never written out so many quotes from a non-fiction book (or any book for that matter) like from this one, which shows how many mind-boggling, important, radical, and, to some, sacrilegious ideas he has.

In his essay-like chapters he touches on a variety of subject, "lessons" he calls them - and not without reason. (He lost me a bit in the chapter on science fiction - but it's not his fault). I especially liked how, instead of lecturing, he converses with the reader. Also, it has to be mentioned that, like in "Sapiens", Harari continues to be very consistent with his objectivity - he attacks the weak points of ALL religions/nations/philosophies, including his own (Judaism and Israel). A very welcome surprise in the last chapter - on Meditation: to think that an author who seems to be brutally critical of so many things that Homo Sapiens represent, embraces meditation so fully - it has to stand for something (both in his favor and that of meditation!).
Show Less
LibraryThing member tgeorge2348
A very thought provoking book, looking at the past but reflecting on the future.
LibraryThing member RajivC
This is a most intriguing book. To me, he starts where he kind of left off in "Homo Deus", with the discussion on the 'super-humans' of the future, and I could not help but think of "Brave New World" and "1984". Almost 250 pages later, he mentioned them. His postulates here are not that far removed
Show More
from being a plausible reality, because of the growth of AI. There may well be the growth of a 'useless' class. What is frightening and he does not address this, is that they will be concentrated in countries like India. What are the implications on law & order

To my mind, he seems on much stronger ground, when he talks of the pernicious effects of the way religion is practised, the state of education etc. this is where the book comes alive.

It's definitely a book worth the reading. There is much to think about.
Show Less
LibraryThing member nbmars
As the author explains, this book is “a selection of lessons” about current global problems. Each chapter doesn’t provide definitive solutions, but suggests different ways of thinking about and responding to such topics as equality, immigration, terrorism, the environment, education, and
Show More
other timely issues.

Harari begins by noting that liberalism is in danger as a dominant narrative in the world, having been vitiated by disillusionment, disaffection, and distrust. These reactions have in part been caused by the revolutions in biotech and infotech. Many people feel as if their lives have lost relevance and significance. Just as Hitler and Stalin capitalized on similar feelings in the 1930s to direct anger and anxiety toward scapegoats, so too are populists today trying to exploit alienation and anomie to build their own power bases.

Totalitarian movements have always been bolstered by the way they help people feel like part of something bigger - a community of like-minded others. Today in a society with less interpersonal interaction than ever (in spite of superficial connections such as having many “friends” on Facebook), connections offered by belonging to the right or left are especially powerful because “real life” interactions don’t occur as much as virtual ones. Nevertheless, now one can have a “group” and “identity” and “significance.” On a broader scale, people are also encouraged to identify more with their nations and exhibit a national pride, even though it is counterproductive to deny the global interdependence of the world now.

Climate management, for example, must cut across borders, because the activities of one state or one country affect all the others. Much of the mass immigration movements are in fact driven by ecological problems such as drought and the resulting food shortages. Harari opines: “We now have a global ecology, a global economy, and a global science - but we are still stuck with only national politics.”

Harari’s discusses the many pros and cons of immigration and then segues into a discussion of terrorism, because much of the opposition to immigrants is based on false data about how many terrorist acts are committed and how many are (or are not) committed by immigrants. The actual numbers of each are much lower than fear-mongers allege. Harari points out:

“Terrorists are masters of mind control. They kill very few people but nevertheless manage to terrify billions and rattle huge political structures… Since September 11, 2001, each year terrorists have killed about 50 people in the European Union, about 10 people in the United States, about 7 people in China, and up to 25,000 people elsewhere in the globe (mostly in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Nigeria, and Syria). In contrast, each year traffic accidents kill about 80,000 Europeans, 40,000 Americans, 270,000 Chinese, and 1.25 million people altogether. Diabetes and high sugar levels kill up to 3.5 million people annually, while air pollution kills about 7 million people per year. So why do we fear terrorism more than sugar, and why do governments lose elections because of sporadic terrorist attacks but not because of chronic air pollution?”

Terrorists think like theater producers, he says. They hold our imagination captive and use that against us. …Terrorists kill a hundred people - and cause a hundred million to imagine that there is a murderer lurking behind every tree.”

Thus we waste money, time, and political capital on fighting terrorism that could otherwise be invested in fighting global warming, disease, and poverty, inter alia.

But again, fear of immigrants can help bolster the power base of would-be dictators. Prejudice and racism have always had strong appeal, as they provide an easy explanation for why your life isn’t what you think it should be. Such appeals to baser instincts are both more potent and more surreptitious than in the 1930’s: today’s would-be dictators have tools Hitler could only dream about. Not only do they make full use of social media. They also co-opt the holders of much of the country's wealth by reducing taxes and marginalizing the poor. The wealthy in turn exhibit outsized influence on elections, and buy controlling shares in sources of news, enabling those in power to hide or distort their activities and cement their rule.

Promises by rulers such as Trump and Putin to make their countries “great” again are rooted in false narratives about the past and about the feasibility of denying the future. But they have no answers, Harari avers, to the biggest problems we face: ecological collapse and technological disruption, especially from the increasing use of artificial intelligence in both the workplace and at home, and in the construction of our desires. Even when we feel we have “free will,” in fact our wills are being increasingly shaped by social media, advertising, and a search for “simple” answers in the face of too much complexity.

Harari addresses human stupidity (which “we should never underestimate”) as well as changes in education that might help remedy the situation. Our educational practices, he points out, were designed to serve the Industrial Revolution. With the advent of the Technological Revolution, memorizing facts is not only not nearly as important, but not as helpful as learning how to make sense of it all, through critical analysis and creativity.

Without knowing how to sift through and interpret the bombardment of information, humans tend to opt for easy answers, either through religious systems or political dogmas. Neither necessarily leads to greater tolerance, compassion, or even morality.

Evaluation: While much of this book is a critique of the current limitations in analysis by many people, the author does not hesitate to suggest a number of helpful changes that could be made. Above all, there is no shortage of stimulating ideas for readers to discuss with others.
Show Less
LibraryThing member karmabodhi
Harari is also the author of Sapiens and Homo Deus, both successful works with rather high acclaim. I must say that his latest is not up to snuff. Although the "lessons," which are the chapters, discuss topics such as how we should perceive Big Data (my favorite chapter), they only provide talking
Show More
points rather than solutions. The ways to think about these issues promoted were very insightful and I was delighted to find the topics with many ponderings about issues I wouldn't have thought myself. All in all, a good book but I find Homo Deus and Sapiens better for what they discuss.
Show Less
LibraryThing member JhonnSch
note book #840
not as good as the 1st 2 books
LibraryThing member infjsarah
An interesting read but because it is individual short chapters on lots of different aspects of the world it is not as involving as Sapiens and Homo Deus were.
Final chapter could be summarised as "there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so" [Hamlet], the basis of all cognitive
Show More
Show Less
LibraryThing member julieandbeli
21 Lessons for the 21st Century touches on many subjects such as artificial intelligence, religion, fascism, meditation and more, the reader must decide whether or not to agree with Harari’s assessments. Although Harari doesn't offer much upside, at least if mankind can see our possible future,
Show More
maybe we can be vigilant and try to take steps to avoid what may be in store. These are the lessons. There is no real roadmap to a better tomorrow, rather warning signs along the way.
Show Less
LibraryThing member lilibrarian
Harari sets forth 21 conclusions based on his studies of history and philosophy in this collection of essays.
LibraryThing member Oberon
21 Lessons for the 21st Century by Yuval Noah Harari

Good but not great. I went into the book with high expectations given the reviews of Sapiens which I have yet to land a copy of. The book focuses on coming technological changes and how they will likely impact daily life and political life. One of
Show More
Harari's big points is that the pace of our technological progress has so outpaced our moral and political progress that disaster is almost inevitable. I kept getting reminded of Ian Malcolm's quote in Jurassic Park where he says the scientists were so busy trying to figure out if they could bring dinosaurs back to life that they never stopped to ask if they should.

Harari goes through technologies like biotech and big data and demonstrates how much progress is being made in doing jobs that we once thought could only be done by people. This begs the question of what those people will do when the jobs are no longer there? What happens when there are very few actual "jobs" left when machines and algorithms go more accurately perform the work than people. Harari talks about self driving cars but then expands into fields like medicine and law, making a compelling argument that those professions are at risk too. Meanwhile, our political structure is utterly unequipped to work through the consequences of such change.

Other parts of the book deal with issues like the survival of political systems and issues like religion, immigration and terrorism. They are well written and interesting. However, it is hard to read the book and escape a sense of impending doom for the species. Harari himself says that it was not his goal to leave everyone pessimistic but the only actual suggestion he proposes for the litany of problems is meditation. It felt like a very thin straw to grasp for in the face of so many issues.

Recommended but not life changing.
Show Less
LibraryThing member gmicksmith
Fresh off his critically acclaimed last work he offers reflections on what lessons we can learn from history. This is a big picture work that attempts to encompass the long perspective of evolution

year of pies lessons of history
LibraryThing member strandbooks
Reading Harari’s books reminds me of college philosophy classes that makes my head hurt while also wanting more. This book is more like a set of loosely connected essays dealing with a large spectrum of things like liberty, work, humility, to challenges like equality, climate change, immigration,
Show More
to chapters about religion, secularism, meaning and ending with meditation. I think Sapiens and Homo Deus are better but much denser in terms of historical context and research. I’d love to see a debate panel with Harari, Pinker, Sapolsky and de Grasse Tyson
Show Less
LibraryThing member SignoraEdie
I liked this book. While some of it was sobering, all of it was thought provoking. Harari describes the world today as he sees it and while offering no solutions, suggests what we might pay attention to.
LibraryThing member albertgoldfain
Harari has definitely developed a tell-it-like-it-is academically informed style. He is all-in for AI and "Big Data" transformation without, I think, actually realizing what the practitioners in those domains actually do. Still, after reading Sapiens, it is fun to see Harari situated at our current
Show More
moment, issuing a few warnings and predictions. The chapter on immigration was a masterpiece and several of these chapters would stand alone nicely.
Show Less
LibraryThing member browner56
How safe from obsolescence is the job you have now? Do you have the skills to adapt in the rapidly changing Big Data environment? How will the merger of infotech and biotech affect our collective future? How can we prevent climate change from irrevocably changing the planet? What will the next
Show More
global armed conflict look like? Is the recent rise in nationalism a threat to world security? How does “post-truth” (i.e., fake news) affect our thinking? Do terrorist attacks create more fear and suffering than they should? How do the stories we tell ourselves, whether religious or secular in nature, influence our behavior?

These are all questions that are clearly of concern to each of us in the here and now. They also motivate many of the “lessons” discussed in 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, a volume that once again combines Yuval Noah Harari’s unique blend of history, science, philosophy, and anthropology. Unlike Sapiens, which explored mankind’s past 10,000 years, and Homo Deus, which projects humanity’s long-term future, this book purports to assess the major issues facing us in the present. Unfortunately, this exploration is neither wholly successful nor is it nearly as compelling as the author’s previous two efforts.

To be sure, there is a lot to like about what appears here. In particular, Harari’s discussion of the economic, legal, and social challenges created by the ascent of Big Data is very illuminating. Who owns the information summarizing our lives—or, perhaps more critically, who controls it—is indeed likely to be one of the major issues defining our near-term future. I also thought that the author’s interpretations of nationalism and secularism were insightful. Overall, he did a nice job of connecting several disparate themes into a cohesive bigger picture (e.g., a discussion of the importance of developing a global community is followed by an examination of nationalist sentiment which leads to a consideration of the immigration problem and then to the threat posed by terrorism).

The main problem I had with all of this is that major portions of the book were not especially original and often seemed like slightly reworked versions of arguments used in the author’s previous studies. For instance, the rise of biotech was thoroughly covered in Homo Deus and humankind’s use of rituals and ability to create useful fictions were essential parts of Sapiens. As such, there are really far fewer than 21 distinct lessons presented here, despite the volume containing 21 different chapters. Finally, the last two chapters involving the role of personal stories and the importance of meditation were woefully self-indulgent and had an off-putting pop-psychology/self-help feel to them. So, while 21 Lessons for the 21st Century is not at all a bad book, the reader might be better served by considering the author’s earlier work instead.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Tytania
SAPIENS being the best book I have read in recent memory, and HOMO DEUS coming close behind, this had a lot to live up to. It had strong and weak parts. It could get repetitive. The structure was very good - one "lesson" leading into another, each one feeling complete and there for a reason. When
Show More
it was good, it was very good. I have no fewer than eight little sticky notes sticking out of it pointing to excellent quotes. Here are some:
"Panic is a form of hubris. It comes from the smug feeling that one knows exactly where the world is heading: down."
"We are now creating tame humans that produce enormous amounts of data and function as very efficient chips in a huge data-processing mechanism, but these data cows hardly maximize the human potential."
"[Facebook] and the other online giants tend to view humans as audio-visual animals - a pair of eyes and a pair of ears connected to ten fingers, a screen, and a credit card."
"We must realize that nothing the terrorists do can defeat us. We are the only ones who can defeat ourselves, if we overreact in a misguided way to their provocations."
"Apparently ape leaders developed the tendency to help the poor, the needy, and the fatherless millions of years before the Bible instructed ancient Israelites that they should [do the same]..."
Show Less
LibraryThing member datrappert
If you have read Homo Deus, many of the arguments in these 21 chapters will be very familiar. It appears Harari is in a holding pattern here, with little new to say. As such, it is even more pessimistic than Homo Deus. The problems of the world are too complex for any individual to deal with or
Show More
understand, and because each nation has its own agenda--based on its national myths--there is little hope of concerted global action to address problems such as climate change. In the end, all Harari can offer is meditation, which he says he does for two hours a day. I certainly don't disagree with his pessimism. The fact is that the world is full of stupid people, and in the age of mass media and social networks everyone has his or her prejudices reinforced time after time day after day. Oh well. Harari does offer an interesting take on the lack of importance of Judaism in the big scheme of world history, which I'm sure his readers in Israel took offense at--but again, maybe not. Harari's readers in Israel and elsewhere are certainly made up to a large extent of the secular people he presents as perhaps our best hope--secularism being defined not by a lack of religious faith in this case but by an openness to and tolerance of other ideas and ways of living.

I'm not sure what else Harari has to offer us at this point. He is too honest to pretend he has the solutions.
Show Less
LibraryThing member tnilsson
So many friends read and recommended Yuval Noah Harari’s first book, Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, that I finally purchased it (though I’ve been sidetracked by other books and haven’t gotten around to reading it yet). While none of my friends have told me that they’ve read
Show More
Harari’s second book, Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow, I’ve seen enough gushing reviews to realize that they’d probably like it just as much if they did. If Harari’s third book, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, is representative of his prior two books, I can see why he’s so popular with so many.

Harari’s third book discusses five challenges Harari believes to be facing our world (and our species) today: the technological challenge, the political challenge, despair and hope, truth, and resilience. Harari presents three to five essays as to each of these challenges, discussing them from various angles. It’s obvious from these essays that Harari is both a clear-eyed thinker and a good writer. He has obviously thought quite a bit about the challenges he presents. And he writes about them in an erudite, yet friendly and casual, style that seems virtually designed to appeal to today’s reader, especially those who “read” books via audiobook. And that’s both good and bad.

It’s good because too few of us spend much, if any, time thinking about the challenges our species may face in the future because of our actions today. We’re too wrapped up in the stress of our daily lives, and in trying to decompress and recover from that stress, to give much thought to the challenges we may personally face in the future, much less the challenges that may face our whole species. We need more authors such as Harari, more people alerting us to problems we may be creating before it’s too late to change course, more people getting us to think before we act.

But it’s bad because Harari seems overly cautious in his warnings, seemingly going out of his way not to offend anyone in his audience. He’s so inoffensive, even as to the groups he singles out as wrongly pursuing the irrational “solutions” to problems that have plagued our species since the dawn of time, and even as to the groups that he seems to believe to be creating the greatest risk to the future of our species, that I doubt that almost anyone whose actions Harari objects to will recognize themselves in his warnings. A prime example of this problem is evidenced by Harari’s popularity, and the popularity of this specific book, among the Silicon Valley tech elites against whom Harari warns his readers even more than he warns them about tribal religions or nationalistic political movements. Thus, the people who are (in Harari’s view) thoughtlessly creating the biggest risks for our species are also the ones who are most applauding his book, without recognizing themselves or pausing to think about the risks they are creating.

Perhaps Harari should have added a sixth section to his book about ego-centrism and how difficult it is to convince people to realize that they themselves, not just others, are a large part of the problem, that while they may view themselves as one of the good guys they are, in fact, one of the bad guys without realizing it. Perhaps Harari should have written a section that acts like Mitchell and Webb’s “Are we the Baddies?” comedy sketch, warning his readers that they, specifically, may be one of “the baddies” and need to slow down and more thoughtfully consider the consequences of their actions, both in their private lives and in their careers.

Harari may have been able to obtain the same result had he written more about potential solutions to the challenges that face our species and not just about those challenges themselves. And that, ultimately, is my gripe about Harari’s book. While he brings much-needed attention to a number of the challenges facing us, he doesn’t present any solutions. He doesn’t present the hard-choices we would need to make in order to avoid or solve the problems he flags. It allows his readers to view the problems as something either so large that there’s obviously nothing anyone can do about them, or as something for others to think about and solve. After all, if someone as intelligent, educated, and thoughtful as Harari – someone who has the luxury of spending hours each day thinking about these problems – can’t suggest any potential solutions, then what chance is there than any of his readers will do any better? Why bother trying at all. Let’s just wait to see what happens and hope for the best.

Harari writes in his introduction, “As a historian, I cannot give people food or clothes – but I can try to offer some clarity, . . . .” I think Harari has indeed succeeded in bringing more clarity to the challenges that face our species today. But I hope Harari won’t be as nice to his audience in his undoubted fourth book, that he calls his readers out in no uncertain terms for what they themselves are doing to put us all at risk, and that he presents concrete steps we can all take to avoid succumbing to the challenges that face us, hopefully showing us how to avoid altogether the outcomes he fears. That would be a book worthy of being read for more than entertainment purposes.
Show Less
LibraryThing member beetle_b
Someone once asked me if I had read Sapiens - one of the author's other books. I had not, although many have recommended it to me. People were surprised I had not read it, and one told me "Your views and ideas are very similar to those in Sapiens".

I read this book as part of a book club. This is a
Show More
difficult book for me to rate. It's an interesting book, and I didn't find it a waste of time. I think the reason I don't view the book as positively as others do is that, well, even I could have written the book. It really was true - my view of the world matches the author's fairly well.

So why would I list that as a negative against the book? Because the author is a well established academic, with a particular area of expertise, and I am not. Yet, even I could have written this book. I was hoping to gain insights from his position of expertise, but the book is really the author's perspective and opinion, and doesn't reflect any expertise. In that sense, I think the book has been oversold on its merits.

On the plus side, well, it really does jive with my world view, so I don't particularly mind recommending it. :-)
Show Less
LibraryThing member dpevers
I thought this weaker than Sapiens and Homo Deus.helped pull it all together for me A good summary at the end would have helped pull it all together for me.
LibraryThing member steve02476
A little uneven but I liked most of it.

Original publication date





0525512195 / 9780525512196
Page: 0.2408 seconds