Status
Genres
Collection
Publication
Description
Juvenile Nonfiction. Multi-Cultural. Geography. HTML: Winner of the 2020 Caldecott Medal A 2020 Newbery Honor Book Winner of the 2020 Coretta Scott King Illustrator Award The Newbery Award-winning author of THE CROSSOVER pens an ode to black American triumph and tribulation, with art from a two-time Caldecott Honoree. Originally performed for ESPN's The Undefeated, this poem is a love letter to black life in the United States. It highlights the unspeakable trauma of slavery, the faith and fire of the civil rights movement, and the grit, passion, and perseverance of some of the world's greatest heroes. The text is also peppered with references to the words of Martin Luther King, Jr., Langston Hughes, Gwendolyn Brooks, and others, offering deeper insights into the accomplishments of the past, while bringing stark attention to the endurance and spirit of those surviving and thriving in the present. Robust back matter at the end provides valuable historical context and additional detail for those wishing to learn more..… (more)
User reviews
Although quite aware of Kwame Alexander's work, The Undefeated is the first of his books I have picked up. Kadir Nelson, on the other hand, is someone whose beautiful illustrations I have experienced many times. Given Alexander's reputation, and my love of everything Nelson does, I was surprised to find that, despite the worthy aim of the book, and my great appreciation for the visuals, I was mostly unmoved by the poem itself. I appreciate the message, and certainly agree that there are many outstanding people in African-American history, people who have broken barriers of all kinds and confronted injustices great and small, but the text here just didn't speak to me. It felt almost like a list of statements, strung together. The reader's reaction to poetry is tricky of course, and highly idiosyncratic, so what I found pedestrian (despite the poignant topic), others might find very powerful. My favorite part of the book, textually speaking, was the detailed afterword, which gave information about all of the many people depicted in Kadir Nelson's artwork. That said, I did wonder a bit at Alexander's contention in his afterword that the subject(s) of his poem had been left out of American history, given the wealth of children's books published, just in the last few years alone, about the general historic themes of the book, and some of the specific people profiled. Of the subjects covered, and the people profiled, probably the only ones that are relatively unknown and/or neglected are the visual artists and painters. Everything else is well-trodden ground.
Despite my lackluster reaction to the text here, I did find The Undefeated a powerful reading experience, due to Kadir Nelson's gorgeous artwork, done in oil paint. Visually beautiful, emotionally expressive, immensely well-designed, the illustrative choices made here were brilliant. The choice to have a blank two-page spread, when mentioning those who did not survive, makes a powerful statement. Sometimes less is more. The final spread, showing today's young African-American children, is particularly beautiful, but all of the illustrations are lovely. This is one I would recommend wholeheartedly to Nelson fans, and, with the proviso that I didn't care for the poem itself, to anyone looking for picture-books which grapple with the African-American experience.
I'm not a fan of poetry, and this one fell flat the first time through reading it myself. I tried the free audio download offered online and was much more impressed. The art is gorgeous, and short
#BBRC #AtoZ
The magnficent oils by Nelson are mesmerizing by themselves, but the
It begins:
“This is for the unforgettable.
The swift and sweet ones
Who hurdled history
And opened a world
Of possible."
"The ones who survived
America
by any means necessary.
And the ones who didn’t.”
The poem, couched as a dedication, continues to pay tribute to people of color and the roles they played in American history. The final spread shows the faces of young black girls and boys with the words, “This is for us.”
It’s difficult to resist quoting the whole book - the poem is that good. In an Afterword, Alexander writes that he began this poem in 2008, the year his second daughter was born and Barack Obama became the first African American president. He says: “This poem was my tribute to both.” He notes that he wanted his daughters “to know how we got to this historic moment, or as the famous Mahalia Jackson spiritual says, ‘You know my soul look back and wonder / How did I make it over.’”
He also wanted his daughters, “all of you,” and even himself to be reminded:
“… never, ever give up, because, as Maya Angelou wrote, ‘We may encounter many defeats, but we must not be defeated.”
Following the Afterword there is a delineation of “Historical Figures and Events Featured in The Undefeated.”
Kadir Nelson offsets his outstanding paintings of notable African Americans on blank white pages, putting them in startling relief. The strength conveyed in his realistic oils are a fitting complement to the gravity and dignity conveyed in the book.
Evaluation: Both the poetry and the illustrations are magnificent. This is a must read, not only for Black History Month, but for any month.
The lovely flowing language poignantly recognizes the hard history of racism and oppression in our "imperfect Union" while hopefully
This book is Magnificent, Incredible, Inspiring, Hopeful and a host of other words that shine to affirm the awards received and the words writtten!
Filled with images of those who went before, this is a testament to the power of those who keep trying, crying, moving, doing, it truly is a stellar book to honor those who shall overcome!
This is a five star read! It is a book not to be missed!
Back matter goes into much more detail about
This a thoroughly engaging, educating, upsetting, engrossing, saddening, and uplifting piece of art. Every child and parent in America should be reading it together and discussing ways things have gotten better, ways things *need* to get better, and what they can do to help move progress along.
powerful combination of poetry and illustrations that should speak to everyone; this deserves ALL THE STARS. Backmatter includes thoughtful, if sometimes brief, descriptions of the stories contained in the illustrations of each spread.