Status
Available
Local notes
305.895 Kni
Collection
Genres
Publication
Tilbury House Publishers (2003), Edition: 1st, Hardcover, 40 pages
Description
Describes the new life of Nary, a Cambodian refugee, in America, as well as his encounters with prejudice. Includes some general history of U.S. immigration.
Subjects
Awards
Kentucky Bluegrass Award (Nominee — Grades 4-8 — 1995)
Physical description
40 p.; 11.31 x 8.86 inches
User reviews
LibraryThing member AbigailAdams26
One of those books whose didactic purpose really resonates with me, but which falls short in other areas, Who Belongs Here? is a picture-book with a dual narrative, following the true-life tale of a young Cambodian-American immigrant, while also presenting information about the history of
Unfortunately, this structure doesn't always work so well. Although obviously intended to reinforce the personal story being presented with general historical knowledge, its effect was one of dividing the reader's attention, making each component weaker. I felt that Nary's journey was strong enough of a story to stand on its own, and that the informational asides could have been presented in an appendix at the rear. I was impressed that Knight discussed the influence of the Iroquois Confederacy on the American form of government (adult readers interested in this subject should examine Donald Grinde's excellent The Iroquois and the Founding of the American Nation), but appalled to see that she listed potatoes amongst the food crops brought to the Americas! How on earth did that get past an editor? And what other mistakes didn't I catch?
A book with a good purpose - teaching respect for diversity, and for our fellow immigrants - and appealing illustrations, Who Belongs Here? nevertheless had some serious weaknesses. I can see that it might be useful in a classroom setting, if a teacher is involved in the reading (and able to correct that odd error concerning the potato!), but sadly, it isn't one I would highly recommend.
Show More
immigration in the United States. The story of Nary, who, together with his grandmother and Uncle Savy, manages to escape the murderous Khmer Rouge, finding his way to a refugee camp in Thailand, and then to America, is juxtaposed with passages discussing everything from Ellis Island to the United Farm Workers.Unfortunately, this structure doesn't always work so well. Although obviously intended to reinforce the personal story being presented with general historical knowledge, its effect was one of dividing the reader's attention, making each component weaker. I felt that Nary's journey was strong enough of a story to stand on its own, and that the informational asides could have been presented in an appendix at the rear. I was impressed that Knight discussed the influence of the Iroquois Confederacy on the American form of government (adult readers interested in this subject should examine Donald Grinde's excellent The Iroquois and the Founding of the American Nation), but appalled to see that she listed potatoes amongst the food crops brought to the Americas! How on earth did that get past an editor? And what other mistakes didn't I catch?
A book with a good purpose - teaching respect for diversity, and for our fellow immigrants - and appealing illustrations, Who Belongs Here? nevertheless had some serious weaknesses. I can see that it might be useful in a classroom setting, if a teacher is involved in the reading (and able to correct that odd error concerning the potato!), but sadly, it isn't one I would highly recommend.
Show Less
LibraryThing member lmbenji
Who Belongs Here is a book I remember my parents frequently read to me as it was a book that told of multicultural children and how they are all accepted and belong here. It was a fun story but also very important for kids to be read as it definitely teaches children to be accepting of all people
Show More
regardless of their differences. I LOVED the lesson it taught! Show Less
LibraryThing member Dportnoy
This multi cultural book is a must read! It is a story of a young boy who immigrated to the US from Cambodia for a "better life". After leaving behind friends and family, he struggles to adjust in the United States. Along with the true story text, there is additional text that gives straight facts
Show More
in order for the reader to paint a better picture. This story would really teach young readers about people of other cultures and what life may be like... Show Less
Similar in this library
Pages
40