Genres
Publication
Description
"Pulled into a deadly game of deception, secrets, and lies, a woman must find the truth in order to defeat a mysterious opponent, protect her daughter, and save her own life in this dazzling standalone psychological thriller with an unforgettable ending from the New York Times bestselling author of Woman with a Secret and The Monogram Murders. You thought you knew who you were. A stranger knows better. You've left the city and the career that nearly destroyed you--for a fresh start on the coast. But trouble begins when your daughter withdraws, after her new best friend, George, is unfairly expelled from school. You beg the principal to reconsider, only to be told that George hasn't been expelled. Because there is, and was, no George. Who is lying? Who is real? Who is in danger? Who is in control? As you search for answers, the anonymous calls begin a stranger, who insists that you and she share a traumatic past and a guilty secret. And then the caller threatens your life. This is Justine's story. This is Justine's family. This is Justine's game. But it could be yours"--… (more)
User reviews
Justine leaves London to settle in Devon with her family. After a demanding career she plans to do nothing at all. Daughter Ellen seems to be happy at school until her friend George is expelled.
Strange anonymous phone calls become increasingly threatening and disturbing, and Justine’s husband Alex insists on involving the police.
An intriguing story, well worth the read, with some interesting twists.
Justine has left her fast-paced career and moved her family to rural Devon, hoping to do nothing but putter around the beautiful estate they've purchased, Speedwell House, while her husband travels and her daughter attends school. But even on the way to their new home, Justine is struck by an affinity for an unattractive house along a busy road. Soon after arriving, her daughter becomes distressed by the expulsion of another pupil and Justine begins receiving threatening phone calls from a woman who thinks Justine is called "Sandie."
A Game for All the Family is certainly as complex and odd as any of Hannah's other books. Justine is an unlikeable character, being arrogant and high-handed in her dealings with others. She's also prone to not doing basic things that most people would do in her circumstances, while reacting strongly to much smaller events. It's a stand-alone novel, with out the usual detectives to do the work of solving the crimes and puzzles, and this is a weakness. Since the only view the reader has is from the inside of a biased and erratic narrator, there's no way to ground the story in any sort of objectivity. And Justine is consumed with her own opinions and personal bugbears that I'm still not entirely certain what happened. And some of the reactions of the people around the main character make very little sense.
Still, this is a rare misfire by an author who has so far been reliable in her crime novels. I look forward to reading the next one, which I am relieved to see is once again balanced by the usual detectives.
Justine Merrison has left London for Devon, along with her opera singer husband, Alex, and their 14 year-old daughter, Ellen. Justine, a former TV producer plans to do nothing at Speedwell
At the same time her daughter Ellen is writing a murder mystery story for school about the Ingrey family, who, from the story, may have lived at Speedwell House in the past. Justine is concerned about the events in the story and her daughter's frame of mind to be writing about such things. When she talks to Ellen, Ellen is more distraught that her best friend, George Donbavand, has been expelled from school for no good reason. When Justine asks about George at the school, she is told that no such student ever existed.
All the bizarre events meander down a twisted, convoluted trail with several implausible leaps of intuition to eventually interconnect in the end. While Hannah does an excellent job making you wonder about the reliability of Justine as a narrator, she also expects you to follow and accept Justine's implausible connections and impetuous behavior as normal perceptive actions. Many of them aren't. Additionally, there is a whole lot going on that you need to keep straight, including alternate chapters with the story Ellen is writing about the Ingrey family.
I'm in a quandary about this novel. While I basically enjoyed it, it also felt way too long, complicated, and entangled to be credible. No matter how how relaxed the school is, no head mistress of a school would give out any information about a family in the school. Additionally, most people would contact the police as soon as they received the first threatening phone call, and they would have been taken seriously until they had cause to doubt their veracity. In most cases the authorities would be called if a family was behaving like the Donbavands.
There were more problematic leaps of credibility for me. While I did enjoy the novel, I'm not sure the ending was worth it. For that reason it's only recommended.
Disclosure: My Kindle edition was courtesy of HarperCollins for review purposes.
Justine sets out to find the answers, but becomes entangled in a mystery she has trouble understanding. Will she find a way to bring her family safely through this inexplicable puzzle?
Despite the intriguing-sounding premise and some truly lovely writing, readers may find the gratuitous profanity off-putting and many will be hard-pressed to find any redeeming qualities in the snarky, self-obsessed Justine, her clueless opera singer husband, and her unjustifiably rude daughter.
Unfortunately, the increasingly-implausible storyline coupled with the plot twists and turns leading to a rather inane resolution make this a disappointing tale.
So the story starts off with Justine and her family, Alex (the husband) and Ellen (teenaged daughter) moving from a big city to a smaller one after she terminated her career in TV. There was a conflict in her career and she decided she was done with that. She notices a house on the way to her new home and it strikes some sort of unnerving core to her and it stays in the back of her mind even though it has no perceivable reason to.
After arriving at their new home, Alex goes off on tour (he's an opera singer) and Ellen is settling in at her school, when Justine starts receiving odd, threatening phone calls. Justine is sure these calls are a case of mistaken identity so tries to reason with the caller. At just about the same time, Ellen becomes moody and upset and won't confide in her mother about the reason at first. Justine comes across a story that Ellen is writing for school and finds the few pages extremely creepy and it starts to really bother her and she thinks it might be contributed to the sour mood she has been in.
As days go by, she slowly learns that Ellen's best friend, George, has been expelled from school over what Ellen explains is a misunderstanding. Justine goes to the school to try and straighten out the issue and is met with lies and shady behavior from the principal and staff at the school which sets her on high alert that this is much more than she thought.
Not being able to get that house out of her mind, and thinking that her daughter's school story is a true story, she begins to investigate all possible leads to connect these events all together. The house ends up being the home of a dog breeder and Justine comes back with a little dog, but no definite connection between the story and real life. The creepy calls continue and she has contacted the police with no resolution.
Alex comes rushing home to be with his family and together they begin to face the odd events that start taking place...the phone calls, the expulsion of the student and Ellen's sulky behavior, the labels over the house name that happen one night, the grave dug in their garden after one of the calls mentions that, etc.
Slowly the story ties together binding the writing project of Ellen's to real life and the ending is shocking in it's own right. A real psychological thriller.
**I received a copy of this book through a good reads giveaway.**
Sophie Hannah, in my opinion, is one of the few writers today who could pull a story (and a story-within-a-story) like this off.
Justine and her family
But then her daughter, Ellen seems to change before her eyes, becoming withdrawn and secretive. Ellen finally admits that she is upset because her best friend, George, has been unfairly expelled from her new school.
When Justine marches into the school to right this terrible wrong, though, she is told that George hasn't been expelled. George doesn't exist.
Woven into this wonderfully bizarre and intriguing tale is a story Ellen is writing for class, the story of a family with a murderer among them.
This is a book you will not be able to put down. The tension builds and builds until you have to stop everything else you're doing to keep turning those pages. While, for me at least, I don't think any ending could have completely lived up to the incredible buildup, the resolution packed an amazing, Hannah-caliber punch.
Having recently quit her stressful job in television, Justine is looking forward to doing Nothing. The first few months of life in their new house are idyllic but the first disquieting phone calls occurs on the same day she finds out Ellen is upset about her friend George's expulsion from school. When Justine tries to intervene on George's behalf, she is stunned to learn there is no George so therefore, there was no expulsion. Despite a few doubts, Justine believes Ellen's story and she is determined to get to the bottom of what happened and find out why the school is lying to her. At the same time, she continues receiving telephone calls that are increasingly sinister. She is also growing concerned about Ellen's writing project about a murder mystery that appears to be based on real life events but her search for more information leads to one dead end after another. Believing all of these events are somehow linked, Justine begins her own investigation but will she uncover the truth before it is too late?
The premise of A Game for All the Family is certainly unique but the execution of the story falls a little flat. The chapters alternate between the present day events and Ellen's story and while, initially both story arcs are interesting, there is little progression in either storyline. The dual storylines are written in two distinct voices but Ellen's murder mystery is so incredibly implausible that it eventually detracts from the main storyline. With each incredulous plot twist, the novel becomes a convoluted mess of highly improbable coincidences.
All in all, this latest release by Sophie Hannah's is an entertaining but overly long and somewhat bizarre mystery that readers will have to suspend disbelief to enjoy.
I can suspend disbelief with the best of them, however, a solid basis to get me started (relatable characters carrying out marginally believable actions, a dignus vindice nodus - problem worth solving), is that really too much to ask? It's not even that the writing was terrible, it was OK, even funny in places, it seems more that the author could not be arsed to make the effort to render a half-decent story. What a waste!