Galileo's Middle Finger: Heretics, Activists, and the Search for Justice in Science

by Alice Dreger

Hardcover, 2015

Status

Available

Call number

174.2

Collection

Publication

Penguin Press (2015), Edition: 1St Edition, 352 pages

Description

"An investigation of some of the most contentious debates of our time, Galileo's Middle Finger describes Alice Dreger's experiences on the front lines of scientific controversy, where for two decades she has worked as an advocate for victims of unethical research while also defending the right of scientists to pursue challenging research into human identities. Dreger's own attempts to reconcile academic freedom with the pursuit of justice grew out of her research into the treatment of people born intersex (formerly called hermaphrodites). The shocking history of surgical mutilation and ethical abuses conducted in the name of "normalizing" intersex children moved her to become a patient rights' activist. By bringing evidence to physicians and the public, she helped change the medical system. But even as she worked to correct these injustices, Dreger began to witness how some fellow liberal activists, motivated by identity politics, were employing lies and personal attacks to silence scientists whose data revealed inconvenient truths. Troubled, she traveled around the country digging up sources and interviewing the targets of these politically motivated campaigns. Among the subjects she covers in the book are the anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon, falsely accused in a bestselling book of committing genocide against a South American tribe; the psychologist Michael Bailey, accused of abusing transgender women; and the evolutionary biologist E. O. Wilson, accused of fomenting rightwing ideas about human nature. Galileo's Middle Finger describes Dreger's long and harrowing journey back and forth between the two camps for which she felt equal empathy: social justice warriors and researchers determined to put truth before politics"--… (more)

Media reviews

Clearly we need people like Dreger defending empiricism and calling out fraud. But how do we discern the charlatans? How do we collar the guilty without persecuting the innocent?

The easy (and correct) answer is that it’s incredibly difficult. Dreger ends by noting that we usually get it right —
Show More
but only after tempers have cooled, values have changed, the powerful have weakened and the stakes are less urgent. We get it right, in other words, only when we view such disputes the way historians do.

“We are almost always too late,” Dreger writes. “We can bear witness afterward, of course. And witnessing matters. But so many days, I find myself selfishly wishing that witnessing felt like enough.”

Dreger’s lament aside, I suspect most readers will find that her witnessing of these wild skirmishes provides a ­splendidly entertaining education in ethics, activism and science.
Show Less

User reviews

LibraryThing member rivkat
What is the role of the committed researcher who studies controversial topics or groups who’ve been historically oppressed? Dreger’s book, focusing on sexuality/gender, argues that the best course is always to tell the truth and be damned, and that social movements need to be more accepting of
Show More
research as long as it is conducted in good faith and not doing harm to the subjects, even if they fear harm to the general cause. Dreger’s a sharp writer with a background in these controversies: she started out doing research on the historical treatment of intersex bodies, but became an activist when she found out that treatment of intersex babies was no better and often worse than it had been historically. She describes partial success in getting doctors to understand that, though there are certain conditions that require surgical intervention to improve health, cosmetic/gender-assigning surgery on young children--on the grounds that the alternative is social stigma--should be avoided.

Then she spends a while defending a Northwestern professor’s research on transgender women; he came under fire for (1) saying some dumb things and allowing a really dumb, exploitative cover for his book, and (2) maintaining that one category of transgender women identifies as such because they receive sexual pleasure from understanding/imagining themselves as women. If that’s where the science takes you, she says, then you have to say that, even if it risks feeding into a narrative of sexual deviance against which transgender people are quite rightly fighting. She cuts him a lot of slack for being well-meaning in the dumb things he said, and I’m pretty sure that it’s not okay to sleep with the subjects of your books unless (at the very minimum) you disclose that even if they aren’t in any way vulnerable to your power. (He refuses to say whether he slept with one of his subjects because he says it shouldn’t matter; this strikes me as bullshit, though it doesn’t invalidate all his research.)

Finally she recounts her experience on the other side—trying to halt a doctor’s use of an unapproved treatment on fetuses at risk of being intersex, which was designed to prevent girls from having externally male genitalia and also to prevent them from being lesbians. She finds that the institutions that are supposed to protect vulnerable patients aren’t doing their job, because the doctor is able to say she’s not doing “research,” even as she gets grants to research outcomes in these patients. It’s an engaging but crotchety book, and hard to take larger lessons from.
Show Less
LibraryThing member DoingDewey
I thought this was a fascinating and well-written book, but it wasn't the book I had hoped for. The author starts with a story of medical abuse. She then briefly talks to several researchers who were attacked for their work and end with another story about medical abuse based on poor science.
Show More
Neither the beginning nor the ending story were particularly interesting to me, because they seem so clear cut. There wasn't any question of what needed to be done to resolve the science and the activism. I do think these stories were very worthwhile. The way intersex children were and sometimes still are being treated is shocking and we must be aware of it in order to change it. And individual scientists who were targets of personal smear campaigns because of their work certainly deserve a platform from which to spread the true story.

I also understood why the author would focus on issues relating to gender, sexuality, and identity; this is her field of study. I don't think this meant the story had to be as purely anecdotal as it was. I loved the author's enthusiasm for using science to find the truth and then build an ethical system based on the facts instead of nice, simplistic stories. I only wish I'd seen some of that here. For example, I'm very curious about the number of scientists experiencing personal attacks because of their work and how many of them are in different fields. For example, I would guess that scientists have been personally attacked for controversial research in genetic engineering (a topic I work on) as well. This wasn't a bad book, but in retrospect, I think the stock description did it an injustice. Had this been billed as a memoir about the author's science activism, I probably wouldn't have been disappointed when she failed to more generally address the interaction of science and activism. As long as you go into this with more accurate expectations, it's a book I'd recommend.This review was originally posted on Doing Dewey.
Show Less
LibraryThing member wagner.sarah35
As someone who works in academia and sometimes sees the kind of controversies discussed in this book from afar, Alice Dreger's work to pin down the truth is like a breath of fresh air. She's absolutely right that research which touches on sex, identity, and speaking for marginalized groups can
Show More
become fraught with emotions and theories which have little to do with scientific evidence. It's also a lesson important for the world we live in today, with an internet ecosystem that has little to do with facts and almost no patience for the hard work of investigating scientific processes. This is a book that really makes you think about science, truth, and what we know and don't know. It's a book I hope more people read and think about deeply.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Lindoula
Interesting, for sure, but after a while it just started to feel endless.
LibraryThing member soccerposeur
this provocative and refreshing book presents the very important problem of politically progressive activists challenging and even bullying scientists whose findings are unwelcome. Dreger is the perfect author since she has a background as an activist (fighting for rights of intersex infants and
Show More
their families) and also as a critic of activists ( attacking a scientist who found that some trans women were motivated by sexual arousal at the idea of themselves as women, not because they feel "trapped in the wrong body"). Dreger has a delightful prose style, as well. A book club with this book would be truly important and also difficult.
Show Less
LibraryThing member steve02476
Kind of an odd book. Learned a lot of interesting stuff. She tries to be fair to those she criticizes but I'm not always convinced. I mostly liked her writing but periodically there would be a clumsy cliche that bugged me ("Hello!"). But the basic issue she talks about is really important: what
Show More
happens when a quest for truth collides with a quest for justice.
Show Less
LibraryThing member skid0612
Ethics in science. What a concept. Factual research is ........ helpful.

I very much wish the majority of my fellow citizens would read this book.
LibraryThing member electrascaife
This one started out good, with the promise of being a deep dive into the history of how medicine has misunderstood and mistreated the trans population and what can and should be done to change that. But at some point it took a left turn into a sort of tell-all about a particular activist who went
Show More
off the rails and spread all sorts of slander and libel about a couple of researchers, including the author. It got weird. And while the scandal was sort of interesting, it felt more like it belonged elsewhere. *shrug*
Show Less

Awards

Lambda Literary Award (Finalist — 2016)
Society of Midland Authors Award (Winner — Adult Nonfiction — 2016)

Language

Original language

English

Original publication date

2015

Physical description

352 p.; 6.6 inches

ISBN

1594206082 / 9781594206085
Page: 0.577 seconds