Call number
Collection
Publication
Description
"A compelling portrait of one of the most interesting "forgotten" women of the twentieth century, the scientist who mapped, for the first time, the ocean floor. Until Marie Tharp's groundbreaking work in the 1950s, the floor of the ocean was a mystery--then, as now, we knew less about the ocean than we did about outer space. In a time when women in the scientific community were routinely dismissed, Tharp's work changed our understanding of the earth's geologic evolution. While her partner, Bruce Heezen, went on expeditions to collect soundings (records of sonar pings measuring the ocean's depth across its entire expanse), Tharp turned this data into beautiful and controversial maps that laid the groundwork for proving the theory of continental drift. Tharp's maps showed for the first time that the continents were moving and had always been moving and that what had happened over eons under the sea was as "visible" now as looking at the same phenomenon on land. Her maps have been called some of "the most remarkable achievements in modern cartography" and yet no one knows her name. The brilliant young writer Hali Felt captures the romance of scientific discovery and brings to vivid life this pioneering scientist who changed the way we view the earth"--Provided by publisher. "Until Marie Tharp's ground-breaking work in the 1950s, the floor of the ocean was a mystery--then, as now, we knew less about the ocean than we did about outer space. In a time when women in the scientific community were routinely dismissed, Marie's work changed our understanding of the earth's geologic evolution. While her partner, Bruce Heezen, went on expeditions to collect soundings (records of sonar pings measuring the ocean's depth across its entire expanse), Marie turned this data into beautiful and controversial maps that laid the groundwork for proving the theory of continental drift. Marie's maps for the first time showed that the continents were moving, had always been moving and what had happened over eons under the sea was as "visible" now as looking at the same phenomenon on land. Her maps have been called some of "the most remarkable achievements in modern cartography" and yet no one knows her name. Brilliant young writer Hali Felt captures the romance of scientific discovery, and brings to vivid life this pioneering scientist who changed the way we view the earth"--Provided by publisher.… (more)
Media reviews
User reviews
But the discoveries of Marie Tharp, which are often overlooked, and the credit for her discoveries are frequently attributed to the male scientists around her. This is also a good example about how small minded people, even in the sciences, can be cruel, jealous and bigoted.
The book is a bit slow in parts, and the footnotes are mising, although a notes section is given at the end of the book. Also, there is no index, which would be helpful, especially for named persons.
Recommended for people interested in the oceans, geology or cartography. Also for those interested in the biographies of women in science, and in the history of scientific ideas.
I particularly find this book fascinating, since I have a copy of her map of the ocean floors mounted in my library. She was an original thinker and clever cartographer, and I had not known her story, although I had known her map, until I read this book. It neatly fits a crack in the wall of the history of science.
Marie Tharp devoted her life to the study of the ocean floor. A region that was less understood than the face of the moon. She took
Pull up Google maps and take a look at any see bed. This woman mapped 90% of what you are looking at. On top of that she until very recently – after her death by the way – got very little credit for it.
This is a very good book. It tells in great detail the life of a brilliant woman and just what “following your dream” used to entail if you happened to be born female.
I recommend this book very strongly to anyone who has an interest in science or the history of social change.
A free copy of this book was provided for the purpose of review.
The author presents a detailed biography of her subject and her admiration for Ms. Tharp is evident throughout the book. At times, the author's insertion of herself into the narrative, as well as her use of a contrived Mission Impossible scenario detracts from the story which drags in places. This is a dense read, however, the material and the subject matter prevail to present a very complete portrait of an under-rated, under appreciated brilliant female scientist who deserves acknowledgement for her life's work.
Soundings – The Story of the Remarkable Woman Who Mapped the Ocean Floor, by Hali Felt.
I remember the first popularly available map of the ocean floor – it arrived in our home with the National Geographic magazine in 1967. I remember seeing and using other versions of it throughout my college and grad school studies. I also remember reading of Marie Tharp’s death in the New York Times in 2006. Of these events, Hali Felt shares with me only the memory of reading the recap obituary in the Times’ annual review of notable people who died in the previous year. She was sufficiently engaged by that obituary to thoroughly pursue the surviving information and tell Marie’s story in a book that is both biography and an exploration of cartography, marine geology and the birth of Plate Tectonics.
Ms. Felt has done a very nice job of telling both Miss Tharp’s personal story and the story of the development of the key maps that allowed development of the Plate Tectonics paradigm that is now the fundamental foundation of our understanding of the Earth. It would be easy to categorize Tharp’s career history as one more example of a woman doing significant work and the men taking all the credit and glory – but it is a more complicated and interesting story. It is very much a story that could not have happened in any other time and place – too many key opportunities, people and realities come together. By today’s standards Tharp was robbed of credit and career advancement, but that message does not dominate the other stories in the book. In very readable prose, Ms. Felt tells the story of Marie Tharp, the relationship between Tharp and her partner Bruce Heezen, and the story of a major change in scientific thinking. Soundings introduces the reader to many of the key scientists in this shift of thinking, at least to the degree that they interacted with Tharp and Heezen, and makes the complicated progress of science accessible to her readers.
The book is somewhere between a scholarly biography (it does have a notes section for each chapter and a comprehensive index, but not individual footnotes) and a profile of fascinating characters set in a unique set of circumstances. Like Marie and Bruce’s first maps, there are places where the author fills in some details with educated guesswork. As is the case for the maps, this improves the reader’s picture of a partially documented reality. Anyone who has made a geologic map from limited outcrop data can appreciate the process.
I particularly appreciate that the book presents a number of minor stories. Few people now have a grasp of the processes of ink and velum cartography and drafting and printing of large maps, but maps are an essential part of geology and allow visualization that then leads to understanding and development of new ideas. Most of us now working in geology have only stories from our predecessors about times when everyone assumed that appropriate roles for women with advanced degrees included being a human calculator, manually doing the tedious arithmetic to reduce geophysical data to useful form. Marie Tharp, like many geologists had early childhood experiences that prepared and encouraged her interests. Her father was a soil surveyor, moving frequently and spending most of his time in the field mapping, but also having responsibility for the final reports. Marie accompanied him in the field and learned about making careful observations and recording them accurately.
Felt had no particular science background before this project, but has done a commendable job of presenting many of the essentials of marine geoscience. Her training as a writer and experience in newspaper writing serves well in making Soundings both reasonably accurate reportage and an engaging narrative. This is a story anyone interested in the modern history of geology should know – and I am pleased that Hali Felt chose to write it.
The book traces her life and accomplishments
I was disappointed in the lack of visuals. The author describes photos, but doesn't provide them. She talked about the beauty of maps, but don't show them.
This well-researched biography provides insights into a little known woman who had a big impact on geology. However the informal almost conversational writing style doesn't always seem to mesh with the sometimes scholarly tone. Although the book contains a note section with references, I was looking for a more detailed set of citations and notes. Also, there were times where I wasn't sure where the factual information from interviews ended and the author's interpretation of events began.
To see the impact of Tharp's works, it's possible see her maps overlapped on Google Earth.
So it is with Soundings . . . and if you relish the work of Dava Sobel and Simon Winchester, read no further. Go out and get yourself a copy of Soundings, comfortable in the knowledge that you'll be enthralled and, along the way, learn a lot about the history of one of the twentieth century's great scientific accomplishments. My relationship with Sobel and Winchester -- and my feelings about Soundings -- are more ambivalent.
There's no question that Felt does Marie Tharp justice: The author clearly identifies with her subject, and the tone of the biographical material is that of a fond niece narrating the extraordinary life of a beloved aunt she knew only in retirement and old age. Working from difficult, fragmentary, sometimes contradictory material, Felt skillfully pieces together Tharp's childhood, entry into science, and emerging partnership (professional and perhaps personal) with Bruce Heezen. There's little question that this is the best biography of Tharp we're likely to get, and it's a good one. The scientific background is workmanlike, and covers all the bases needed to understand Tharp's story. It gets the big things right, and the things it gets wrong (conflating multiple senses of "uniformitarianism" and failing to articulate why the "method of multiple working hypotheses" so entranced early 20C American geologists) do not, by any means, upend the narrative.
And yet . . . I couldn't shake the feeling that, for all her good intentions and evident hard work, Felt has no feel for the background material: the science and the history of science. Geology, like astronomy, is the science of the unimaginably vast -- of time and space considered on a scale that most people, in their everyday lives, never do. The best geological writers can convey what it feels like to think on that scale, but Felt (who freely admits "I'm not a scientist") never manages it. Tharp's story also has extraordinary historical resonances with figures from Johannes Kepler (who derived the orbit of Mars from reams of numerical data the way Tharp conjured the ocean floor), through Charlotte Murchison (who served, for decades, as cartographer and colorist to her husband Roderick -- the most esteemed geologist of the Victorian era), to Tharp's rough contemporary Rachel Carson, whose early career trajectory was similar but whose impact was far more public. These, too, go under (or un-) considered, and it's hard not to feel that Felt simply wasn't historically aware enough to see them.
Soundings is a solid book on an important subject, but it left me longing for the story of Marie Tharp's life as told by a historian of science like Naomi Oreskes (chronicler of the plate tectonics revolution) or Martin Rudwick (who showed historians the primacy of maps and images in geology) . . . or, better yet, by John McPhee, whose Annals of a Former World tetralogy is a master class in interweaving the lives of geologists with the fabric of their science, and (along the way) making the vast seem comprehensible.
Marie Tharp is one of the people that was always behind the greatness - she drew the first maps of the
Marie did not work by herself - as a women in the 1950's, even one with a degree, she did no research herself, did not get her name on any papers, and her contribution to projects was usually as a drafter/illustrator - creating maps and graphs for the male scientists around her. As a result, she isn't well know outside of a small group of people. To confuse matters, it was only she was working with Bruce Heezen, was she able to add her own ideas. However, even then, she was not given credit and as a result, its impossible to figure what was hers and what was Bruce's
However, she is given full credit for the maps she made today. Unfortunately, the wider geological society assumed that she made them with Bruce overseeing the work, over time, the two scientists were seen as a duo, but once Bruce passed away, all his work was given to other scientists, even though Marie was doing the majority of the work on it.
This book is well written and well researched. The author clearly wanted to be respectful of the scientist, but at times, I felt took liberties with the scenery and conversation - by the authors own admittance, while she could place Marie Thorp in a certain place and time, she made up the conversation. This isn't always bad and in places, actually adds to the book. But other times, I found that it was more distracting than it actually was.
One last thing - I would have liked to see more of how scientific community was convinced of plate tectonic theory. Marie wasn't involved in this, but her maps had a lot to do with changing of minds. I suspect the author made a point to stick to Marie and Bruce in the book, but making it more clear would have cemented why this map is so important.
Highly recommended, but it can be dense.