The Best and the Brightest

by David Halberstam

Hardcover, 1972

Call number

973 H

Collection

Publication

Random House Inc., New York (1972), Edition: [1st ed.], 688 pages

Description

History. Politics. Nonfiction. HTML:David Halberstam�s masterpiece, the defining history of the making of the Vietnam tragedy, with a new Foreword by Senator John McCain. "A rich, entertaining, and profound reading experience.��The New York Times Using portraits of America� s flawed policy makers and accounts of the forces that drove them, The Best and the Brightest reckons magnificently with the most important abiding question of our country� s recent history: Why did America become mired in Vietnam, and why did we lose? As the definitive single-volume answer to that question, this enthralling book has never been superseded. It is an American classic. Praise for The Best and the Brightest �The most comprehensive saga of how America became involved in Vietnam. . . . It is also the Iliad of the American empire and the Odyssey of this nation�s search for its idealistic soul. The Best and the Brightest is almost like watching an Alfred Hitchcock thriller.��The Boston Globe �Deeply moving . . . We cannot help but feel the compelling power of this narrative. . . . Dramatic and tragic, a chain of events overwhelming in their force, a distant war embodying illusions and myths, terror and violence, confusions and courage, blindness, pride, and arrogance.��Los Angeles Times �A fascinating tale of folly and self-deception . . . [An] absorbing, detailed, and devastatingly caustic tale of Washington in the days of the Caesars.��The Washington Post Book World �Seductively readable . . . It is a staggeringly ambitious undertaking that is fully matched by Halberstam�s performance. . . . This is in all ways an admirable and necessary book.��Newsweek �A story every American should read.��St. Louis Post-Dispatch.… (more)

User reviews

LibraryThing member EdKupfer
"Contemporary history," Halberstam calls it. A surprisingly easy read -- I knocked it out in three days flat. Everyone knows what this one is about: how a group of policy makers in successive US governments lost their collective minds over a small Asian nation. I could not go more than three pages
Show More
without thinking, "Can you believe we're going through the exact same shit again?" The similarities between the JFK/LBJ approach to Vietnam and Bush's adventures in Afganistan and Iraq are arresting. And depressing. It seems we really are doomed to repeat the mistakes of our ancestors.
Show Less
LibraryThing member bontley
A difficult read based on the author's assumption of the readership's prior in-depth knowledge. Still, it was enlightening and horrifying and stunning.
LibraryThing member marcfitch
It can get mind-numbing at points with heavy exposition into lives that never seems to move forward, but overall this is one of the most prophetic and telling books about where America, both politically and culturally, went wrong. It should be required reading for anyone going into politics, but
Show More
since most of them can't even read it would be pointless to give them a list.
Show Less
LibraryThing member ecw0647
Read this years ago when it first appeared. As a result, I read everything Halberstam wrote. Whenever I hear anyone discuss hiring only the "best and the brightest" now, I shudder.
LibraryThing member cwhouston
This is an amazingly good political history of the machinations of the JFK and LBJ administrations and their involvement in Vietnam. Full of detail about the policy makers, military top brass, bureaucrats etc and contains a large amount of analysis of the decision making process and its influences
Show More
and outcomes.

The book is rather lengthy and yet does not cover the events following Nixon's election in 1968, which is a shame.
Despite this, however, the 'Best and the Brightest' is one of my favourite books and I have since bought other titles by the author and found them excellent, if not up to quite the same standard.

Belongs on the shelf next to 'Bright Shining Lie', 'Fire in the Lake', and Karnow's 'Vietnam: a History'. First class.
Show Less
LibraryThing member JBD1
An absolute must-read for anyone interested in the dynamics of government decision-making.
LibraryThing member DinadansFriend
A journalist tries to write history. It is not a bad job, and definitely has a competent chronology and lively writing style. It is more precisely, a history of the Kennedy/Johnson Years with special emphasis on the descent into Vietnam. This is the first mention that it could be seen as Kennedy's
Show More
War, not LBJ's.
Show Less
LibraryThing member ShadowBarbara
long historical account of the Vietnam War and how we got into it and handled it. Excellent profiles of the men and times
LibraryThing member SeriousGrace
Halberstam's The Best and the Brightest is a deep dive into the origins of the Vietnam War. It is a scrutiny of the policies and procedures crafted during the Kennedy administration that led to the consequences in Vietnam. The meat of the book takes place between the years of 1960 and 1965 but
Show More
flows back and forth to earlier and later times to give substance to the timeline. What really helps the narrative is that Halberstam was a reporter during this time. He was at the heart of the perfect storm: the fall of China, the rise of McCarthy and the outbreak of the Korean War. This trifecta of events had a profound and lasting effect on the White House and domestic politics of the time.
Show Less
LibraryThing member drsabs
This well written book covers the US decision-making on the Vietnam War from the 1940s through Nixon’s election. The focus is on the Kennedy team, which was then inherited by Johnson. It tells of the shift from the original, sound policy in the 1940s and 50s of avoiding a colonial land war in
Show More
Asia to new policy objectives, lacking a basis in Vietnamese reality, focused on stopping the spread of communism and avoiding a repeat of the “who lost China” debate. In the process key policymakers over and over again ignored warnings from those who had a better grasp of the realities in Vietnam. Capsule biographies are provided on all of the key players at the moment in the narrative when they assume a prominent role. A natural break comes with Kennedy’s replacement by Johnson and the lost hope that Kennedy’s skepticism about Vietnam would have led him to disengage after the 1964 election. Despite having been written at the end of the 1960s, the analysis is fresh and I am sure holds up very well against more recent scholarship. The literary qualities of the work give it an atmosphere of a Greek tragedy for the personalities involved, many of whom despite their talents get ground up by the escalations of the war. The capsule biographies take on an almost stream of consciousness quality as Halberstam evokes the personalities of his characters in this terrible chapter in East Asian history.
Show Less
LibraryThing member tmph
Re-reading; having read it shortly after it came out. Brilliant.
LibraryThing member Pharmacdon
I was interested in how United States involvement in Viet Nam started, partly due to the fact as I was in college everyone was wondering if they would in up in Viet Nam rather that graduating college. Secondly, after reading The Sympathizer
by Viet Thanh Nguyen and other books, I wanted to learn
Show More
more about the involvement started and why it was a failure. Unfortunately, it is another tale of how the government lied to the public and refused to listen to people in Viet Nam how poorly the war was going and that the government in South Viet Nam was weak as was the army. The title is ironic because JFK and LBJ had gathered the best and brightest, but had failed to see through the failures of the policy and ignoring the truth. The following is a quote from another review the explains the book better than I can: Halberstam gives us the inside story of how America entrapped itself in the Viet Nam War. He shows how the legacy of McCarthyism and 1940’s politics over China left a decimated State Department and influenced JFK’s and LBJ’s thinking. He details the many times JFK and others who doubted the war altered their positions out of fear of being seen as soft. He shows how the arrogance and overconfidence of Kennedy’s team and subsequently Johnson’s led the US into war. He takes us through the constant escalation ending with the Tet offensive of 1968 and the fall of the façade of competence, the public’s realization that its government, as well as the war, was lost and out of control. Along the way we learn the backgrounds, motivations and impact of key figures: Robert McNamara, Dean Rusk, John Paton Davies, McGeorge Bundy, William Bundy, Walt Rostow, Dean Acheson, George Ball, Averill Harriman, Clark Clifford, Roger Hilsman, John McNaughton, Maxwell Taylor, Paul Harkins, William Westmoreland, Robert Kennedy and of course JFK and LBJ.
Show Less
LibraryThing member kcshankd
Long tale that just got bleaker and bleaker. I am not sure what I thought I was getting in to, certainly delivers chapter after chapter of forlorn presumption.
LibraryThing member dsha67
I finished David Halberstam's The Best and The Brightest. A 5 star 800 page tome on the political decision-making and decision makers for the United States involvement in the Vietnam War.

Ho Chi Minh tried as early as World War I to gain recognition of Vietnamese independence, but likely had his
Show More
best opportunity for recognition of Vietnamese Independence at the end of World War II through Franklin Roosevelt's anti-colonialism. Sadly, this recognition died with the death of Roosevelt.

David Halberstam's touches on big picture military moments, but the crux of the book deals with the decisions that led to a slide into deeper involvement in a French Colonial conflict that ultimately led the United States to be engaged in a full blown war.

The cast of decision makers includes 5 presidents, Harry Truman, Dwight Eisenhower, John Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, and Richard Nixon. Other notable figures include presidential advisors, cabinet officials, ambassadors, and military leadership, including such notable individuals as Dean Acheson, John Foster Dulles, Dean Rusk, Bill and McGeorge Bundy, Walt Rostow, Robert McNamara, Robert Lovett, George Kennan, George Ball, Abe Fortas, Clark Clifford, Daniel Ellsberg, Henry Cabot Lodge, Maxwell Taylor. William Westmoreland, and Earl Wheeler Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

The essence of Halberstam's work is that the United States slowly and incrementally found itself sliding from financially supporting the French to providing financial and arm support to the Vietnamese, to military advisers to ultimately a full scale military involvement including airstrikes and ground troops.

This slide was led largely by Lyndon Johnson who was trying to avoid escalation into war to promote The Great Society but at the same unwilling to allow U.S. prestige to be undermined and by Secretary of State Dean Rusk and Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara. Dean Rusk consistently deferred Department of State responsibility to Robert McNamara and the Department of Defense.

McNamara tried to support the military while being supplied with deceptively incomplete or false information from military advisers and later commanding General William Westmoreland to help with incremental growth of the war by understanding needed resources to win and overstating the accomplishments of pacification programs such as the strategic hamlet program and the success of bombing and U.S. ground forces and the effectiveness of ARVN. The misinformation also included the downplaying of the abilities and resources of North Vietnamese forces.

It's a sad story of various advisers working st odds with each other and ultimately those who provided accurate information being isolated by those who pushed a pro-war agenda.

It was a tough read but a great one.
Show Less

Pages

688

ISBN

0394461630 / 9780394461632
Page: 0.1931 seconds