Call number
GRAPH N CRU
Collection
Genres
Series
Publication
Fantagraphics Books (2007), Edition: Illustrated, 176 pages
Description
What do I have in common with the Jews? I don't even have anything in common with myself.' Alienated from his roots, his family, his surroundings, and primarily from his own body, Kafka created a unique literary language in which to hide away, transforming himself into a cockroach, an ape, a dog, a mole or a circus artiste who starves himself to death in front of admiring crowds. Introducing Kafka helps us to see beyond the cliche 'Kafkaesque' and to peer through the glass wall at the unique creature on display there.
Subjects
User reviews
LibraryThing member dr_zirk
I have to admit to not being much of a Robert Crumb fan, which must make me something of a pariah among comics aficionados. I've always found his brand of intense autobiographical navel-gazing to be regrettable, especially given the huge influence it has apparently had on mediocre cartoonists of a
Now that my bias is clear, I have to come clean and say that I love Crumb's work on Kafka. With someone else (David Zane Mairowitz) handling the writing duties, Crumb is free to concentrate on the artwork, which is exceptional and extremely well-suited to the topic at hand. Given that Crumb's traditional weaknesses are his choice of subject matter and his explication thereof, Kafka presents him with an ideal forum in which to excel.
Mairowitz deserves much of the credit for his thoughtful, insightful, and well-reasoned analysis of Kafka and his works, and the marriage of that highly readable text with Crumb's slightly exaggerated black-and-white drawings couldn't be better. The excesses inherent in Crumb's pen work are entirely appropriate for visualizing Kafka's world and the parallel worlds of his fiction. Overall, this volume is both a great introduction to Kafka and a wonderful "mid-course" review for those who have already indulged in some of the Kafka canon.
Show More
younger generation, such as Gabrielle Bell, Jeffrey Brown, and Joe Matt.Now that my bias is clear, I have to come clean and say that I love Crumb's work on Kafka. With someone else (David Zane Mairowitz) handling the writing duties, Crumb is free to concentrate on the artwork, which is exceptional and extremely well-suited to the topic at hand. Given that Crumb's traditional weaknesses are his choice of subject matter and his explication thereof, Kafka presents him with an ideal forum in which to excel.
Mairowitz deserves much of the credit for his thoughtful, insightful, and well-reasoned analysis of Kafka and his works, and the marriage of that highly readable text with Crumb's slightly exaggerated black-and-white drawings couldn't be better. The excesses inherent in Crumb's pen work are entirely appropriate for visualizing Kafka's world and the parallel worlds of his fiction. Overall, this volume is both a great introduction to Kafka and a wonderful "mid-course" review for those who have already indulged in some of the Kafka canon.
Show Less
LibraryThing member V.V.Harding
David Zane Mairowitz thinks Kafka's writing has insufficient Jewish content, so too much of the text here talks about the Jewish situation in Prague in Kafka's time and adduces a lot of highly questionable and possibly discriminatory ideas about Jewish psychology (really? all of them with the same
However, this is a comic book, not read for the text but for Robert Crumb's drawings, which have long interested me. He is master of the horror-comic style, which here is aptly used to illustrate Kafka's stories (and perhaps depictions of his father), but also does attractive portraits of sympathetic characters and classic comic-book two-page spreads, especially of cityscapes, real or imaginary. When the text describes a character as a strapping young woman, we know the artist is home free: those familiar with his work will know that strapping young women are a special feature of his work.
The best parts are the retelling of Kafka's stories, which include various bits of information, painlessly delivered, about the circumstances of their creation and some bibliographic details. Max Brod seems somewhat slighted, though I have to say Kafka's original title for his last work, "The Man Who Disappeared," is a better title than Brod's "America." Because of the detailed drawings with many telling and funny details, this little book takes longer to read than you'd think -- but with the stories embedded in it, it's best, and most fun, to take it in slowly.
Show More
psychology?) such as self-loathing. Although the cover extracts Kafka's comment, "What do I have in common with the Jews? I don't even have anything in common with myself," and it appears in the text too, he is undaunted, and his regret that the only person Kafka seems to have truly loved was not Jewish is palpable. His excoriation of the city of Prague, which he has established meant little if anything to Kafka, for cashing in on its native son makes for a pretty flat ending.However, this is a comic book, not read for the text but for Robert Crumb's drawings, which have long interested me. He is master of the horror-comic style, which here is aptly used to illustrate Kafka's stories (and perhaps depictions of his father), but also does attractive portraits of sympathetic characters and classic comic-book two-page spreads, especially of cityscapes, real or imaginary. When the text describes a character as a strapping young woman, we know the artist is home free: those familiar with his work will know that strapping young women are a special feature of his work.
The best parts are the retelling of Kafka's stories, which include various bits of information, painlessly delivered, about the circumstances of their creation and some bibliographic details. Max Brod seems somewhat slighted, though I have to say Kafka's original title for his last work, "The Man Who Disappeared," is a better title than Brod's "America." Because of the detailed drawings with many telling and funny details, this little book takes longer to read than you'd think -- but with the stories embedded in it, it's best, and most fun, to take it in slowly.
Show Less
LibraryThing member mschaefer
A visual biography of Franz Kafka written by David Mairowitz and illustrated by Robert Crumb, including several (partial) adaptations of Kafka stories such as Metamorphosis and In the Penal Colony. Holds up excellently at all levels.
LibraryThing member downstreamer
Exquisitely appropriate illustrations from R. Crumb, and a very perceptive text by David Mariowitz make this the best intro to Kafka available.
LibraryThing member BenTreat
Crumb's drawings are great. Mairowitz doesn't include any sources for his claims, which weakens the text. A foreword or afterword referring to significant scholarly influences on his interpretation might have been helpful; even a "for further reading" bibliography would have bee nice. Instead, I
Show More
was left wondering what led Mairowitz to make some of the claims that he made about Kafka's point of view. This book is best if taken as art, rather than scholarship, and used to stimulate further reading. Show Less
LibraryThing member antao
Of course I do not know what would fix human beings individually or collectively, but of one thing I am fairly certain, that humans individually add up to the collective and that humans individually are way too stupid for our own good, and I suspect there will be possible genetic solutions to that
Kafka of course is dealing with non-eugenic humanity based on his knowledge and experience of the past and present. The Cosmos, or Nature, which we as organisms are part of and, if you like, are no more than that, does not in any way seem to care about us in terms of our individual subjectivity or mentality. It always kills us, if we are lucky it ages and debilitates us, and at any time can erupt into a sickness or accident or natural disaster etc. that kills us individually or en masse, regardless of innocence, age, or anything else. You get the picture. In Kafka's world even though societies were nowhere near the size, complexity, or as pervasively organized on a mass scale (that is villages might have intimately organized but not nations), he saw that society internally was becoming a mirror of Nature. That it could kill or harm us as impersonally as the Cosmos and that that was becoming the norm. Many factors contributed to it, industrialization, population growth, advances in communication and transportation and so on. In many ways it was good, but it had a dark side: depersonalization and alienation and social structures that fostered them. Bureaucracy represented this the best, the Court and the Castle are at least in part bureaucracies which have a life and purposes of their own and which are allowed to operate almost as secret societies which can do whatever they like and also have official sanction. In many countries the police and security agencies, even private ones, function like this. They can usually do whatever they want to you nor, as you say, does anyone need to be in charge really. Society is not just outside anyone's control, but it does not act indifferently. In fact Society arguably grows more perverse, permits more perversity, as it grows and evolves, although it may, on a mass scale, provide us, in larger and larger numbers with lots and lots and lots of goodies. It becomes full of twists and turns that are literally Kafkaesque, and the Kafkaesque is a kind of implicit zeitgeist that haunts us all. Kafka right at the beginning sensed the brave new world, and it was his artistry that turned it into our collective nightmares and anguish. It was his artistry that made him so unique and made his nightmares our nightmares, not just in thought but in feeling.
In particular he went to the heart of our existential crisis in a purely material way. We, within the vast and powerful social structures we have created, have become our files, ALL OF US. It was a whole new way to understand human marginalization or residualization, turning people into something less than a person, into their own shadow. Although perhaps not the first to see this, Kundera puts it very nicely which I attach as a separate posting.
Show More
although we are probably too near the end of our rope for it to happen on a large scale. Sooner or later the partisan politicization of issues like the Ebola outbreak are going to prove as fatal however politically successful. I don't think individuals (or small groups) in power have a lot of ability to do good, game changing good, but they do have the power to do bad, to make things worse. History is chock full of that. On a grand scale there is always Hitler, Stalin, and Mao, on a smaller scale the likes of George Bush. We do not usually get to choose between good and bad politics, only bad and worse, sometimes very much worse. So far our social institutions have been able to change and adjust and keep things afloat, but in our Western world the trend is bad and when someone like Bush comes along and gives it a push, that is the case of an individual President making a big difference.Kafka of course is dealing with non-eugenic humanity based on his knowledge and experience of the past and present. The Cosmos, or Nature, which we as organisms are part of and, if you like, are no more than that, does not in any way seem to care about us in terms of our individual subjectivity or mentality. It always kills us, if we are lucky it ages and debilitates us, and at any time can erupt into a sickness or accident or natural disaster etc. that kills us individually or en masse, regardless of innocence, age, or anything else. You get the picture. In Kafka's world even though societies were nowhere near the size, complexity, or as pervasively organized on a mass scale (that is villages might have intimately organized but not nations), he saw that society internally was becoming a mirror of Nature. That it could kill or harm us as impersonally as the Cosmos and that that was becoming the norm. Many factors contributed to it, industrialization, population growth, advances in communication and transportation and so on. In many ways it was good, but it had a dark side: depersonalization and alienation and social structures that fostered them. Bureaucracy represented this the best, the Court and the Castle are at least in part bureaucracies which have a life and purposes of their own and which are allowed to operate almost as secret societies which can do whatever they like and also have official sanction. In many countries the police and security agencies, even private ones, function like this. They can usually do whatever they want to you nor, as you say, does anyone need to be in charge really. Society is not just outside anyone's control, but it does not act indifferently. In fact Society arguably grows more perverse, permits more perversity, as it grows and evolves, although it may, on a mass scale, provide us, in larger and larger numbers with lots and lots and lots of goodies. It becomes full of twists and turns that are literally Kafkaesque, and the Kafkaesque is a kind of implicit zeitgeist that haunts us all. Kafka right at the beginning sensed the brave new world, and it was his artistry that turned it into our collective nightmares and anguish. It was his artistry that made him so unique and made his nightmares our nightmares, not just in thought but in feeling.
In particular he went to the heart of our existential crisis in a purely material way. We, within the vast and powerful social structures we have created, have become our files, ALL OF US. It was a whole new way to understand human marginalization or residualization, turning people into something less than a person, into their own shadow. Although perhaps not the first to see this, Kundera puts it very nicely which I attach as a separate posting.
Show Less
LibraryThing member catmampbell
A good introduction to Kafka. Crumb's style is really appropriate for his work.
LibraryThing member Big_Bang_Gorilla
In which celebrated cartoonist Crumb presents a graphic novel-style biography of the father of avant-garde fiction, together with a few mashups of scenes from the fiction. This is an interesting project, though, personally, I'd just as soon let Kafka and my head create my own pictures.
LibraryThing member ValerieAndBooks
In Kafka, Robert Crumb and David Zane Mairowitz presents author Franz Kafka -- himself and a discussion of his works -- in graphic novel format. I picked this volume up in a used bookstore thinking that it would be interesting. It was. I don't know much about Kafka beyond one work (The Trial) that
While this book is clearly not an extensive study, it does provide a solid background on Kafka and and also covers the meaning of "Kafkaesque". The authors make an interesting point: "Could he have become the powerful Adjective -- "Kafkaesque" -- if his name had been Schwarz or Grodzinksi or Blumenthal?" (p. 156).
R. Crumb is a well-known cartoonist and illustrator, and his artwork fits very well with the darkness that is Kafka's personality and works. Warning, though, some illustrations are very graphic when there are violent scenes -- so one would not want to hand this over to a young child.
Show More
we were required to read in high school. I do have one of his collections in my to-be-read pile, and will definitely pull it out now to read soon.While this book is clearly not an extensive study, it does provide a solid background on Kafka and and also covers the meaning of "Kafkaesque". The authors make an interesting point: "Could he have become the powerful Adjective -- "Kafkaesque" -- if his name had been Schwarz or Grodzinksi or Blumenthal?" (p. 156).
R. Crumb is a well-known cartoonist and illustrator, and his artwork fits very well with the darkness that is Kafka's personality and works. Warning, though, some illustrations are very graphic when there are violent scenes -- so one would not want to hand this over to a young child.
Show Less
LibraryThing member bibliosk8er
Great read. Great art. I dug.
LibraryThing member TomMcGreevy
Who was Franz Kafka? This book tries to answer that in a graphic novel format. For anyone curious about him, it is worth the read.
ISBN
1560978066 / 9781560978060