Collection
Status
Description
Miles shows us God in the guise of a great literary character, the hero of the Old Testament. In a close, careful, and inspired reading of that testament - book by book, verse by verse - God is seen from his first appearance as Creator to his last as Ancient of Days. The God whom Miles reveals to us is a warrior whose greatest battle is with himself. We see God torn by conflicting urges. To his own sorrow, he is by turns destructive and creative, vain and modest, subtle and naive, ruthless and tender, lawful and lawless, powerful yet powerless, omniscient and blind. As we watch him change amazingly, we are drawn into the epic drama of his search for self-knowledge, the search that prompted him to create mankind as his mirror. In that mirror he seeks to examine his own reflection, but he also finds there a rival. We then witness God's own perilous passage from power to wisdom. For generations our culture's approach to the Bible has been more a reverential act than a pursuit of knowledge about the Bible's protagonist; and so, through the centuries the complexity of God's being and "life" has been diluted in our consciousness. In this book we find - in precisely chiseled relief - the infinitely complex God who made infinitely complex man in his image. Here, we come closer to the essence of that literary masterpiece that has shaped our culture no less than our religious life. In God: A Biography, Jack Miles addresses his great subject with imagination, insight, learning, daring, and dazzling originality, giving us at the same time an illumination of the Old Testament as a work of consummate art and a journey to the secret heart of God.… (more)
Media reviews
Dieu se raconte-t-il? Quels
Contrairement aux panthéons antiques où l'on se bousculait, il n'a pas à se mêler à d'autres dieux ou déesses avec lesquels il nouerait des affaires sordides et compliquées. La grandeur du monothéisme tient à ce splendide isolement qui se renforce dans son face-à-face avec une créature qu'il a façonnée de ses mains et de son souffle mais qui lui échappe, pour son plus grand malheur, sans délai.
C'est donc le portrait de ce personnage - encore que le mot, à la limite du blasphème, soit ontologiquement inexact - que Jack Miles, un ancien jésuite qui a gardé une foi intacte, s'est attaché à dresser en relisant pour nous l'Ancien Testament ou plutôt le Tanakh, la Bible hébraïque. Entre le Pentateuque et les textes des prophètes, entre le Cantique des Cantiques et l'Ecclésiaste, Dieu se révèle tel qu'en lui-même, c'est-à-dire passablement humain, souvent animé d'une colère que l'on évitera de qualifier de jupitérienne, plus rarement de compassion. On fera la moue et on ne trouvera guère charitable le Dieu d'Abraham, d'Isaac et de Jacob.
Jusqu'au bout il cultive une ambiguïté fondamentale. Il parle d'amour mais ressent-il de la souffrance aux tourments de Job, de la joie à la délivrance du peuple juif? Là-dessus les Ecritures font silence. Et si l'homme ne le satisfait pas pleinement, pourquoi ne le change-t-il pas du tout au tout? A croire qu'il s'accommode de cette imperfection consubstantielle à la nature humaine. Au fait, ne l'aurait-il pas voulue? Et la morale dans tout ça?
Jack Miles n'en finit pas d'interroger Dieu au travers de sa Création. Il le fait avec un mélange d'ironie et de profondeur, de distance et d'acuité qui laisse songeur. Toujours est-il que cette biographie a ceci de rassurant qu'elle nous en apprend encore beaucoup sur un Etre aussi peu romanesque qu'il est possible mais dont un roman n'épuiserait pas l'infini mystère.
User reviews
Because of these combinations God often acts indecisively, erratically, prone to moodiness, and after he created mankind in Genesis, took it upon himself to destroy their descendants in an awful flood. This Creator-God saved Noah and animals by showing a sign of a rainbow never to destroy the world again. But God later showed up as a warrior as he led the Israelites out or Egypt from the clutches of the Pharos. But later he was vindictive when he punished them with years of wanderings in the desert often bringing death and destruction.
The redactors of the Tanakh were caught up in a polytheistic worldview when they endeavored to show the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob as monotheistic. This appeared to be the reason why Jack Miles’ God had multiple personalities. God had no other lives than to live through mankind who was the key to his existence. He didn’t realize when he told them to be fruitful and multiply that this blessing would fly in the face of what he himself envisioned. This book by its literary interpretation has brought to light original ways how believers and unbelievers alike could interpret the Hebrew Bible. Miles’ project was central in understanding the Hebrew text as opposed to the Christian Old Testament that is arranged somewhat differently.
Unlike Miles, I do not trace G-d progress from a roaring, false start to a fading conclusion. I agree that the Hebrews constantly back-slid into paganism. Our Cantor (basically a singing spiritual leader, but in this case beyond brilliant) posits, I think accurately, that in the Hebrews' early years there was "monolatry" or G-d being the first among other peer divine figures. As a history buff myself I trace the Hebrews' halting progress not to G-d's initial enthusiasm followed by loss of interest, as the successful creation of a society that decried "placing stumbling blocks before the blind", that mandated fair weights and measures, that directed leaving the corners of fields uncut and, most importantly for my profession, the periodic forgiveness of debts.
As a lawyer in that field I believe that the forgiveness was necessarily situational, based upon need and not occuring on a blanket basis. I see the seven years as a ceiling on how often a person or family could utilize the "debt holiday." That timeline was enshrined into bankruptcy legislation starting either in 1898 or 1938, and included in the 1978 Bankruptcy Reform Act. It was heartlessly extended to eight years by a cruel Congress, but the "seven" year figure was of Biblical origin.
On a positive note I learned a lot about the later books in the Tanakh (sp) that I didn't know. I found it necessary to read intermittently, indeed alternately with a book I am reading about John Adams' representation of British soldiers after the Boston Massacre, John Adams Under Fire: The Founding Father's Fight for Justice in the Boston Massacre, by Dan Abrams and David Fisher.
So I give it a "four" because of its uniqueness and novelty, despite my serious disagreement with parts of the book.