Status
Available
Call number
Call number
ML, WL, RS
Publication
Cambridge University Press (2010), Edition: Reissue, Revised, 604 pages
Physical description
604 p.; 8.5 inches
User reviews
LibraryThing member paradoxosalpha
In Harrison's first major work on ancient Greek Religion (Prolegomena), she innovated by applying archaeological data to support her conviction that Homer and the great tragedians gave only a very partial view of the religious life that they purported to reference. She explored a chthonian,
There is some curious irony in her judgment that the "first and foremost among the services Olympianism rendered to Greece" was to "purge ... [the] exclusively phallic" components from religion, claiming that such features are "an obvious source of danger and disease" in civilized settings where human culture centers on human activity rather than the rhythms of non-human nature. (460) This passage late in the book is the one in which she most clearly calls out the phallic elements that have been implicit in the daimon concept throughout her account of it. Hers is not a simply phallic theory of religious origins, however. With the reverence for the generative powers in her daimon concept, she mixes a gradually maturing sense of the cosmos, in a sequence that invariably progresses from plants and soil, to storms and weather, to the moon, and then to the sun. (390) (Qabalists will note a symbolic progression up the middle pillar, from Malkuth, through Yesod, to Tiphareth.)
The conceit of Themis is that it is simply an effort to explicate a ritual hymn in honor of the birth of Zeus. In the course of the book, however, the hymn is often far over the horizon, while the author expounds one or another feature of ancient Greek religion. At the book's end, she returns to the hymn, which itself ends with the imperative to "leap ... for goodly Themis." According to Harrison, Themis is a representation of human culture, "collective conscience, social sanction," and thus "the substratum of each and every god." (485)
The volume includes contributions from two of Harrison's peers among the Cambridge Ritualists, an early 20th century circle of classical scholars of whom Harrison--on the evidence of this volume at least--is certainly the most engaging. Gilbert Murray provides a very interesting analysis of the ritual infrastructure of Greek tragedy, illustrated a little too exhaustively with examples that presume the reader's familiarity with the works being related to the pattern. F.M. Cornford's chapter on the ritual genealogy of the ancient Olympic games depends on the reader to appreciate a rather generous amount of untranslated Greek. This is a tendency that Harrison herself tends to keep to her footnotes, although she does feel the need to finish the entire book with an untranslated Greek sentence. It should be remarked that this book is clearly the product of a scholarly culture, barely even addressed to the intelligent layman, despite the general interest of its topic. Harrison freely quotes Nietzsche in German and Durkheim in French, without feeling any obligation to assist the reader. (I could manage the former but not the latter.)
Harrison is refreshingly honest about her own religious perspective, in a field where a pretense of clinical detachment was par for the course. "[P]rofoundly as I also feel the value of the religious impulse, so keenly do I feel the danger and almost necessary disaster of each and every creed and dogma," she writes in her introduction. "As for religious ritual, we may by degrees find forms that are free from intellectual error." (xxiii) I certainly concur on both counts. As far as her theories of religious evolution are concerned, she sees magic as a necessary prerequisite for religion (215-216), and theology as a non-essential "phase" of religious articulation. (488) The first was a sentiment common to those who, like Harrison, saw themselves in sympathy to the work of J.G. Frazer. But the second was an uncommonly insightful and provocative position for a book published in 1912.
Show More
matrifocal, and magical stratum prior to, shadowing, and outlasting the Olympian cults. In the later Themis, she is concerned more precisely with questions of genealogy and development. She has embraced Emile Durkheim's ideas about the primacy of the social, to good effect. She traces several developmental arcs by which the reified forms of magical power (mana in the anthropological argot of her day) become individualized from ambient sanctities of natural forces and generic daimons of generative power into the persons of heroes and "high" Olympian gods. Her contempt for the latter is unconcealed; she finds them sterile, too removed from the vital numen which originates in communal feeling and pre-individual social impulses. There is some curious irony in her judgment that the "first and foremost among the services Olympianism rendered to Greece" was to "purge ... [the] exclusively phallic" components from religion, claiming that such features are "an obvious source of danger and disease" in civilized settings where human culture centers on human activity rather than the rhythms of non-human nature. (460) This passage late in the book is the one in which she most clearly calls out the phallic elements that have been implicit in the daimon concept throughout her account of it. Hers is not a simply phallic theory of religious origins, however. With the reverence for the generative powers in her daimon concept, she mixes a gradually maturing sense of the cosmos, in a sequence that invariably progresses from plants and soil, to storms and weather, to the moon, and then to the sun. (390) (Qabalists will note a symbolic progression up the middle pillar, from Malkuth, through Yesod, to Tiphareth.)
The conceit of Themis is that it is simply an effort to explicate a ritual hymn in honor of the birth of Zeus. In the course of the book, however, the hymn is often far over the horizon, while the author expounds one or another feature of ancient Greek religion. At the book's end, she returns to the hymn, which itself ends with the imperative to "leap ... for goodly Themis." According to Harrison, Themis is a representation of human culture, "collective conscience, social sanction," and thus "the substratum of each and every god." (485)
The volume includes contributions from two of Harrison's peers among the Cambridge Ritualists, an early 20th century circle of classical scholars of whom Harrison--on the evidence of this volume at least--is certainly the most engaging. Gilbert Murray provides a very interesting analysis of the ritual infrastructure of Greek tragedy, illustrated a little too exhaustively with examples that presume the reader's familiarity with the works being related to the pattern. F.M. Cornford's chapter on the ritual genealogy of the ancient Olympic games depends on the reader to appreciate a rather generous amount of untranslated Greek. This is a tendency that Harrison herself tends to keep to her footnotes, although she does feel the need to finish the entire book with an untranslated Greek sentence. It should be remarked that this book is clearly the product of a scholarly culture, barely even addressed to the intelligent layman, despite the general interest of its topic. Harrison freely quotes Nietzsche in German and Durkheim in French, without feeling any obligation to assist the reader. (I could manage the former but not the latter.)
Harrison is refreshingly honest about her own religious perspective, in a field where a pretense of clinical detachment was par for the course. "[P]rofoundly as I also feel the value of the religious impulse, so keenly do I feel the danger and almost necessary disaster of each and every creed and dogma," she writes in her introduction. "As for religious ritual, we may by degrees find forms that are free from intellectual error." (xxiii) I certainly concur on both counts. As far as her theories of religious evolution are concerned, she sees magic as a necessary prerequisite for religion (215-216), and theology as a non-essential "phase" of religious articulation. (488) The first was a sentiment common to those who, like Harrison, saw themselves in sympathy to the work of J.G. Frazer. But the second was an uncommonly insightful and provocative position for a book published in 1912.
Show Less
LibraryThing member gmicksmith
Related Texts:
1. Prolegomena to the Study of Greek Religion (Mythos Books) by Jane Ellen Harrison
2. Dionysus: Myth and Cult by Walter F. Otto
3. Ancient Mystery Cults (Carl Newell Jackson Lectures) by Walter Burkert
4. The Greeks and Their Gods by W. K. C. Guthrie
5. Homo Necans: The Anthropology
6. Structure and History in Greek Mythology and Ritual (Sather Classical Lectures) by Walter Burkert
7. Greek Folk Religion by Martin P. Nilsson
8. Psyche the Cult of Souls and Belief in Immortality Among Ancient Greeks by Erwin Rohde
9. Greek Religion by Walter Burkert
10. Greek Piety by Martin P. Nilsson
11. Five Stages of Greek Religion by Gilbert Murray
12. Dionysos: Archetypal Image of Indestructible Life by Carl Kerenyi
13. The Greeks and the Irrational (Sather Classical Lectures) by E.R. Dodds
14. Athenian Popular Religion by Jon D. Mikalson
15. Religions of the Ancient Greeks (Key Themes in Ancient History) by Simon Price
16. The Mycenaean origin of Greek mythology by Martin P. Nilsson
17. Delphic Oracle: Its Responses and Operations by Joseph Fontenrose
18. Festivals of the Athenians (Aspects of Greek and Roman Life) by H. W. Parke
19. Hellenistic Religions: The Age of Syncretism by Frederick C. Grant
20. Orpheus and Greek Religion (Mythos Books) by William Keith Guthrie
1. Prolegomena to the Study of Greek Religion (Mythos Books) by Jane Ellen Harrison
2. Dionysus: Myth and Cult by Walter F. Otto
3. Ancient Mystery Cults (Carl Newell Jackson Lectures) by Walter Burkert
4. The Greeks and Their Gods by W. K. C. Guthrie
5. Homo Necans: The Anthropology
Show More
of Ancient Greek Sacrificial Ritual and Myth by Walter Burkert6. Structure and History in Greek Mythology and Ritual (Sather Classical Lectures) by Walter Burkert
7. Greek Folk Religion by Martin P. Nilsson
8. Psyche the Cult of Souls and Belief in Immortality Among Ancient Greeks by Erwin Rohde
9. Greek Religion by Walter Burkert
10. Greek Piety by Martin P. Nilsson
11. Five Stages of Greek Religion by Gilbert Murray
12. Dionysos: Archetypal Image of Indestructible Life by Carl Kerenyi
13. The Greeks and the Irrational (Sather Classical Lectures) by E.R. Dodds
14. Athenian Popular Religion by Jon D. Mikalson
15. Religions of the Ancient Greeks (Key Themes in Ancient History) by Simon Price
16. The Mycenaean origin of Greek mythology by Martin P. Nilsson
17. Delphic Oracle: Its Responses and Operations by Joseph Fontenrose
18. Festivals of the Athenians (Aspects of Greek and Roman Life) by H. W. Parke
19. Hellenistic Religions: The Age of Syncretism by Frederick C. Grant
20. Orpheus and Greek Religion (Mythos Books) by William Keith Guthrie
Show Less