Status
Call number
Publication
Description
""If you control our sleep, then you can own our dreams . . . And from there, it's easy to control our entire lives." The bestselling author of All the Birds in the Sky returns with a strange, haunting, and deeply human tale. Sophie serves coffee at an underground cafe. She stays in the shadows and listens to the troubles of the parlor guests, but does not draw attention to herself for one simple reason: Sophie is supposed to be dead. When a nationalistic revolution forces Sophie from her safe haven, she must make a dangerous journey to a new city, one that revels in hedonism and chaos. After joining up with a band of smugglers, she finds herself on a long and treacherous path that will lead her far closer to the truth of her entire world---and to the dangers that lurk even in the light of day" --… (more)
Media reviews
User reviews
For the record, I disliked Bianca from the get-go. Her narcissistic, spoiled rich kid personality was so obvious. I had to suspend disbelief that someone as sharp as Sophie wouldn't see right through Bianca. Yeah, I'm (maybe too) hard
I'll admit I am not well read in sf. I spent most of my life roaming around and exploring the f in SFF. So it can take me longer to sink into sf worlds. Anders crafts a tangible new planet with January and really breathes life into it with striking imagery.
But there was a lot of time spent on the worldbuilding -- like 200 pages before the really good bits kicked in. Personally, I would've liked to have started with the Gelet and stayed with them far longer than 30 pages.
And, while I get the final pages, the ending is abrupt. I think the point was to end on hope, despite the planet's prognosis. At least that's how I choose to interpret it.
----------------
*Disclaimer: A major pet peeve is toxic relationships in which one partner continually gives into the other partner. Like the one partner has a secret power and the other partner is helpless against it or something. Yes, I realize this is part of what makes codependent relationships bad; I just can't stand to read from the POV of the push over.
Now, the character and relationship that fits the above does have a believable transformation, if not of the too-little-too-late variety. Kind of like, so much more could've been accomplished and avoided if the character had wised up sooner than later.
- it's about a tidally locked planet: one half will burn you to a crisp and the other half will freeze you to death. Humans are trying to survive straddling that tiny part in between. The push and pull of those two halves are reflected in many ways, in the narrative,
- Anders is so imaginative. I genuinely never knew what was going to happen next, because her ideas and tone are so fresh. The world-building is fun (and dark) and surprising and three-dimensional. And so much of it is delightfully weird.
- the characters and their relationships are so fleshed out, and it's so intimate and raw, and funny in parts.
- it's about trauma and memory, and how to heal (or not heal) and process trauma
- I cried a few times, and was on the edge of crying many more times, particularly in the midnight city parts, which were particularly deep and moving. I don't want to spoil it for you.
- this world is absolutely nothing like earth, but like all great science fiction, the story says so much about our contemporary world, and how humans think about the past and the future.
Xiosphant is rigidly autocratic, with very tight rules governing waking,
Argelo superficially appears to be without rules, and in reality is run by several Mafia-like families, and its own complex social conventions. There are no rules about when you can eat, work, or sleep, and the language lacks all the complex case forms, working entirely by word-order.
Sophie and Bianca are students at the Gymnasium in Xiosphant, a very distinguished school of higher education. Bianca is from an upper class family. Sophie is a scholarship student in this very class-conscious society. They are roommates, and very idealistic, and active in underground student political activities. This ultimately leads to Sophie being seized for a very minor crime Bianca committed, and forced out of the city into the night side, where she will freeze to death. Except, instead she meets the Gelet, and survives.
Mouth and Alyssa are members of the Resourceful Couriers, smugglers conducting illegal trade between Argelo and Xiosphant. Mouth is the last survivor of the Citizens, who were nomads traveling between the cities and whatever other patches of habitable places with useful things that they could find. They didn't consider themselves smugglers, but others probably did. They were wiped out in a horrible attack by blue things from the sky, when Mouth had been off gathering something. Alyssa is Jewish, a native of Argelo, and Mouth's sleep partner among the Resourceful Couriers--they watch each other's backs against the dangers of the road.
Sophie's encounter with the Gelet changes her, and when she returns to Xiosphant, she stays away from Bianca and other students, remaining in hiding and working for Hernan in the Illyrian Parlour. This avoidance of Bianca has consequences for both of them, later.
There's political intriguein Argelo, too, and these disparate sets of people come together, not exactly in harmony, and they, their cities, and the Gelet collide in ways both expected and unexpected. The humans and the Gelet can't survive without each other, and it's not clear they'll be able to come together in useful ways.
I'm not nearly doing justice to this excellent, absorbing book. I haven't said a lot about the Gelet because saying what I want to involves spoilers. They're fascinating beings, and it's not really a surprise that first contact didn't go all that well.
Highly recommended.
I received this book as part of the Hugo Voters packet, and am reviewing it voluntarily.
There was so much along the way that intrigued me - except the characters, and
There's so much world to explore, too, as Anders has developed a considered history of two races - but City is set in a time when most of this history has been forgotten, so we can’t know about it (until the end, when after the long build it feels like rushed exposition).
In the end the pace frustrated and the final act felt completely out of step. This is a book that I will probably find rereads better, now I know what to expect, but I can’t imagine I’ll revisit it.
Points for originality and world design, but not for me. Or not for me at this point in time.
"To join with others to shape a future is the holiest act." So fucking pointy here in the good year 2020, but also so touching and lovely.
The novel is set on a tidally locked planet, in human colonies in the planet's tiny habitable zone. Thus "day" and "night" are directions, not times, and there is no natural timekeeping system for the planet to adopt. We primarily see two different cities, one where a consistent time system is rigidly enforced, one where there is a complete absence of consistent time from person to person. I loved the worldbuilding, especially in Xiosphant, the rigid city. But like the best science fiction, it's not all about the world; it's also about the people, people who both feel like totally a product of their world and like people you could actually know. Following the adventures of Sophie and Mouth tells you something about their world, and something about yourself. The book has a real emotional truth that impressed me a lot, especially after reading the complete lack of truthful characterization (or worldbuilding, come to think of it) in Gideon the Ninth. Near the end, the worldbuilding feels less important, which was disappointing; I wanted more of human culture on the planet January than we ultimately got.
But this book feels real throughout, in terms of character and in terms of world. It does what great sf does: explores an idea both literally and metaphorically. I have four more Best Novel finalists to read, but this feels to me like the one to beat.
Now for my (non-spoiler) review.
The setting is a planet called January, many generations after the Mothership arrived from Earth. Nearly half of January is a cold wasteland where night never ends, while the other side of the planet is in perpetual, blazing light. The narrow temperate zone is the only place where humanity can survive, though travel between the two main cities is treacherous. I had some difficulties envisioning this and wished there had been a map. I love maps.
Sophie, the first person narrator, is an idealistic, quiet, naive, good-hearted college student enamored of her bunkmate Bianca. They have big dreams of changing the culture of the restrictive, regimented life in their city. Mouth, whose story unfolds in third person narration, runs with a group of smugglers after having been raised by nomads who never got around to giving her a real name. She's a hot mess, sarcastic, closed-off, unable to stay in one place for too long.
The plot is kicked off when Sophie is sent to an expected death in the planet's dark side after she protected Bianca from being caught in a minor theft, and ended up being the one arrested. But instead of dying, Sophie is saved by one of the creatures that lives in the planet's dark. And then....
If you're intrigued, the book is worth reading to find out what happens. Some fascinating questions are explored, such as how time works on a planet where it's always day or always night. The two cities treat time very differently, and have different languages and customs. There are the species native to January and a declining climate system causing a toxic rain. And there's a seemingly pretentious "Translator's Note" before the story begins, that makes more sense after the story is read.
So, this should've been a slam-dunk 5-star book for me, but it wasn't. It's mostly a small story set on a big science-fictional world, where the setting supports the character arcs. Which isn't bad, but I prefer a better mix. At its core, this reads like a YA novel, with Sophie and mouth coming to terms with who they are, what they want, and how best to get it. There are times I want to slap Sophie silly for her undying devotion to Bianca, a young woman so good at manipulating people. It takes the whole book pretty much for Sophie to realize and accept some truths about Bianca.
Bottom line, this is a good, enjoyable book. But it could have been much more.
The book follows two viewpoints: Sophie, a quiet student with a hopeless crush on her manic, popular university roommate, and Mouth, the hard-edged only survivor of a roaming culture that was obliterated by the harsh environment of the planet January. Humans have been on the world for centuries struggle to survive in massive cities that exist largely in isolation.
The worldbuilding truly blew me away here. This is hard scifi across disciplines, but the cultural aspect is what I loved most. I didn't find this to be a fast read-the tension has a slow build, but it was interesting all the way through.
The City in the Middle of the Night is set on a world which doesn't rotate on its axis. The side facing the sun is permanently scorched by temperatures of hundreds of degrees; the side facing away is locked in permanent night, covered in ice, hundreds of degrees below zero. Only the thin sliver of the planet located in permanent twilight is survivable for humanity, so that's where they all live.
Humanity arrived on this world many generations before this story starts, and life has been so hard since then that they live amidst technology that they no longer understand, desperately patching them with dwindling supplies of resources to keep themselves afloat. There are two major city-states – Xiosphant and Argelo – whose divisions go back to their early years on-world and even before, to major conflicts aboard the Mothership. Both are fleshed out in thorough, but not overwhelming detail.
Also on this planet are its native inhabitants – a tentacled species most humans pejoratively call crocodiles, but which Sophie – who becomes their ally – calls the Gelet. The Gelet have found ways to carve a sustainable existence for themselves out of the harsh environment, and they realise that the humans thus far have failed. A major theme of the story is the way humans continue to consume all their energy fighting each other, ignoring the looming catastrophe, and whether or not they can be convinced to change direction.
The main characters are two young women – Sophie, a university student turned outlaw, and Mouth, the last survivor of a band of nomads who's joined a smuggling crew. Each of them have a female friend with whom they're intimately close – Bianca and Alyssa, respectively. This core group of four are one of the definite strengths of the novel – in many ways none of them are super likeable (and they end up in conflict with each other at least as much as they're ever allied), but they're all empathetic characters whose personal failings cause trouble for themselves, again and again.
If I was dissatisfied with anything about this novel, it's the ambiguous ending. I think Anders intended for it to be positive – that humanity will find their way, but only incrementally over tens of generations, such that it can't really be made clear in the novel. But at the same time, there's no real evidence in the book that
There's so much I could talk about in relation to this book – the obsessive time-keeping of Xiosphant, designed to fluster people if they sense a single minute they could have spent better working; Mouth's pain over the loss of her people and misguided efforts to find her place in the world; the colonial arrogance of humanity towards the Gelet; Bianca and how her genuine eagerness to do good leads to quite the opposite, because of her self-centredness… there truly is so much packed in here and for lovers of character-driven, social science fiction I would whole-heartedly recommend this.