The Monkey Wrench Gang (P.S.)

by Edward Abbey

Paperback, 2006

Status

Checked out

Publication

Harper Perennial (2006), 480 pages

Description

Ex-Green Beret George Hayduke has returned from war to find his beloved southwestern desert threatened by industrial development. Joining with Bronx exile and feminist saboteur Bonnie Abzug, wilderness guide and outcast Mormon Seldom Seen Smith, and libertarian billboard torcher Doc Sarvis, M.D., Hayduke is ready to fight the power-taking on the strip miners, clear-cutters, and the highway, dam, and bridge builders who are threatening the natural habitat. The Monkey Wrench Gang is on the move-and peaceful coexistence be damned!.

User reviews

LibraryThing member RickHarsch
What fate befalls the cult classic over time? Forgotten is one option, trapped in time is another. Retention of status quo is probably the most pure, the book ‘rediscovered’ every generation or so. The other two I can think of relate to books that continue to attract attention: they become
Show More
considered gimmicks, cult classics remembered, often because of the movie based on it. And, probably but too rarely, they become part of the canon. Readers decide on these categories one way or another, which is a complicated matter it would be boring to explicate: suffice it so say that the reader is overburdened by the extraordinary number of great books available. In the 19th century you could read all the great books still. You would read Carlyle because you ran out of material. Now you read Carlyle, and maybe Braudel, but Montaigne will remain unread on the toilet shelf which you put there so you could look at your Toynbees, also forever unread. And why not, given that when you were 22 you dropped out of university to read Spengler. Your literature is extremely important, so you make sure you read at least one Dostoevsky besides Crime and Punishment, maybe the same month you add Middlemarch to Mill on the Floss, but maybe not, because you’ve decided you need to read at least a few of the great Latin American writers, meaning at least ten books and a half year of reading. And don’t forget German literature. You can say damn the Goethe and Hoffmannia, I will stick with this dramatic century, but after Berlin Alexanderplatz through Gunther Grass you find there are a billiard table of great works remaining. Maybe save time and go back to Goethe and Hoffmann.
It needed to be said.
The best of us remain on page 149 of The Anatomy of Melancholy and lie about Cervantes and Rabelais figuring we got the idea a couple decades ago when we dashed through the first two hundred pages of each. So over and over again we meet well-meaning literati who ask, not meaning to be impertinent: You haven’t read Angle of Repose? And we meet well-meaning literati who say, here: this is one of the great forgotten books, the author drowned himself in the Seine, and hand you The Blind Owl. And you have a glorious summer following some cat’s advice and read the Ching ping mei and the Monkey novel.
It’s not a bad life, but you probably have been missing out on about fifty books you had to dismiss in order to read as many as you have. You decided, for instance, that The Monkey Wrench Gang was a gimmicky book, probably a movie with Jon Voigt. I make such connections—Deliverance, wackiness and the out of doors—eco sabotage comedy…But luckily I can make other connections. By means interesting but elided here I came to meet the biographer of Aldo Leopold and no I have not read The Sand County Almanac. His name is Curt Meine, and he writes essays in the tradition of Leopold yet with current knowledge of how the United States rambles on over the best of historical ideas, at most having to fix a flat (Leopold was probably a broken bottle). I decided that perhaps better than filling the Leopold gap with the popular book, the classic, I would read the biography, and I have been and still am, slowly, as other books need reading as ideas come together. One of those books my brother bought for my 14 year son: Doug Peacock’s Grizzly Years, which was surprisingly thoughtful and well-written, and which had a great deal more to say to me than any book about observing bears is expected to. In the book, he mentions Ed Abbey a couple times, and I figured it was probably that guy Edward Abbey, author of Desert Solitaire and The Monkey Wrench Gang, but thought little of the connection until mentioning the book in a mail to Curt Meine who said Hayduke of Monkey Wrench Gang was based on Doug Peacock. Then my brother told me the same thing.
So now let’s go back. The whole mess started with something I tried not to mention in order to streamline this review: I decided I need to write one more novel, a giant one, about the US, this one to be called The Assassination of Olof Palme, this one to rid myself of all of my own autobiographical burdens and to go beyond the intentions of my most recent book about the U.S., The Manifold Destiny of Eddie Vegas, which tries to fictionally explain how the U.S. got the way it got. But there was, I realized after over a year, too little of the way it got, how it is. Before long I realized Nancy Reagan would have to be a character, Alzheimer’s a broader characteristic, and, to do it all right, C. Wright Mills would have to be a fulcral character in the novel. I don’t generally use real folk as characters, now I had two of them. So I got a biography of Mills and a new copy of The Power Elite, and then realized it could not begin there, at least not my research, or the spurring of my recollection. I would have to read the great and enduring biography of Thorstein Veblen by Dorfman. Soon after that book arrived in the mail the story with Meine began and it was clear that the third biography preparatory to beginning the novel was that of Aldo Leopold.
Imagine my surprise then when pressed by circumstance at its heaviest and most manipulative into reading The Monkey Wrench Gang that I found about halfway through the book a paragraph consisting of the words of one of the four main characters, Doc Sarvis, more or less explaining how the U.S. works, concisely eliminating the need for most people to read The Power Elite. Doc pretty much says it all. But by then I was not at all surprised at the intellect of Abbey, whose book seems to have gotten the reputation as a non-literary, near literary, important gimmicky cult book, mostly important for being ahead of the story on eco-activism. It turns out, though, that Abbey was also a terrific writer, and this book one of the best nature books, among other features, ever written. His relentless need to describe extraordinary landscapes is exceeded by his ability to do so. And his characters, though none of them written to match a Karamazov, are as real and interesting as can be, the dialogue smart, funny, dead on. And the mark of what I take to be the best comic writers—he’s willing to toss in the worst possible jokes, which, because they are literature’s fart jokes, actually are funny:
Bonnie Abbzug and Hayduke are arguing, Hayduke misleads the vultures of capitalism by using the nom de guerre Rudolf the Red. Hayduke felt rain. Bonnie didn’t.
“Am I Rudolf the Red or ain’t I?”
“So?”
“Well, goddammit, Rudolf the Red knows rain, dear”
“Say that again?”
I assume the story is well enough known, that the gang in question is a group come together deciding to sabotage disastrous ecological activity, sabotaging machines, blowing up pursuit vehicles like helicopters, shutting down hideously gigantic coal operations, with an eye on bridges and ultimately an absurdly placed dam, the Glen Canyon in case you don’t know. And I will tell you that this book has something to say, something to suggest, something to actively do to improve your life, which is rare among literary works (I think of Zorba, a book that can literally improve your life), and that thing is this: if you get the chance, blow up that fucking dam! Abbey himself apparently was coy about the effect his book had on a generation of activists tired of bourgeois Sierra Club environmentalism (Abbey takes an effective, funny shot at S.C. toward the end of his book), a faction of which took up lawless destructive eco-activism. Abbey clearly approved. And of course he did. This book makes its case and the case is that it is time to start the revolution without them, start sabotaging the techno future. I didn’t need that message, but I won’t go into my own night activities here, but had the message of Abbey been heeded and the mechanisms of the power elite headed off, global warming would have been a footnote by now. Instead, The Monkey Wrench Gang needs to be required reading for all humans before they reach puberty or the planet is doomed.
Show Less
LibraryThing member jveezer
I’m not sure it’s the best idea to read Edward Abbey in October of an election year. But then again, maybe it is. Direct action instead of indirect action. If you’ve ever loved a beach, a bay, a gulf, a canyon, a trail, a swamp, a desert, or some other part of the commons and then seen it
Show More
threatened or destroyed by development or greed, then you’ve probably felt the way the (anti?)heroes of the Monkey Wrench Gang felt. Most of us don’t act on those feelings in the way the Gang does; instead we might make our yearly donations to the Sierra Club or NRDC or some other environmental organization (that Abbey also lampoons) or maybe we just try not to think about it and call it progress. This book will definitely make you think next time you see cows on BLM (i.e., public) land or logging trucks or mine tailings in a National (i.e., public) forest.

Either way, this book is a good read about people who love their land enough to fight for it any way short of committing violence against other people. Abbey loved the southwest, and his Gang loves it too.

I love the Robert Crumb illustrations in the edition I read as well. Very fitting match to the text. For those who prefer their reading less subversive, I would also highly recommend his book Desert Solitaire.
Show Less
LibraryThing member lcrouch
Edward Abbey has the ability to make you laugh while breaking your heart. This tragicomedy about 4 unlikely individuals who decide to stop the onslaught of unbridled development, is a must-read for those of us who would understand why ecoterrorism exists.
LibraryThing member carlosemferreira
Violent in writing if not necessarily in the actions described, this book deals brilliantly deals with the difficulty of acting when the political system is seen not to be responsive to the problematic relationship between business and the environment. Humourous, topic and relevant
LibraryThing member Lindytoo
One of my all-time favorite books.
LibraryThing member stacyinthecity
When I was about 12 years old, my dad took my sister and me camping in Southeast Utah. We took my dad's Ford truck with four wheel drive to Canyonlands National Park and went on various roads, back roads, dirt roads, and roads that were barely roads at all. We bumped around the slick rock of Ernies
Show More
Country, and went up a narrow and twisty dirt road with a sheer cliff on one side. It terrified my sister and I so that we buckled into the middle seat together and sang hymns the whole way down. We camped underneath one of the needles, and slept in sleeping bags under the stars. Before night fell, my dad took us to the edge of the canyon and peered over the edge into The Maze. As we looked at it, he told me the story of the climax in The Monkey Wrench Gang. I knew I would have to read this book. Standing there on the light side of dusk, and in fact that whole trip, hymns and all, is one of my favorite childhood memories.

And so it was with a fond recollection of my times in Northern Arizona Southeast Utah I read The Monkey Wrench Gang, a book about the beauty of this unforgiving dessert and the environmental anarchists that love it.

The plot is simple - in the mid 70s, 4 characters unlikely to hang out together under normal circumstances - a young new age hippy woman, a liberal doctor/processor, a Vietnam vet turned wildman, and a Mormon polygamous white water river tour operator - have a chance meeting and hatch a plot to disrupt the building of dams and bridges, logging, and other industrial pursuits. Along the way they have various adventures while trying to evade the authorities.

The book is very comedic, and I found myself chuckling at various points throughout. At first I thought I wouldn't be able to sympathize with these characters who didn't seem much like me and were involved in destructive illegal activity. And yet I did find myself rooting for them all along the way.

The book kept me guessing til the end. Would they get caught or not? Would they evade the police? How would they do it? I wondered if the author would let them get caught to pay for their crimes or not. I found the ending to be very satisfying and it left me with a smile on my face.

I'd recommend this book to any person familiar with Southeast Utah. It really brought back some wonderful memories. This book is also for anyone who loves nature or hiking. Even if you would never dream of blowing up a dam, the characters' passion for unspoiled wilderness is contagious.
Show Less
LibraryThing member patl
There are two ways to review this book.

One, as a novel. Edwards Abbey writes a blazing, funny, madcap zany story of a group of four anarchist friends, hell-bent to stop the development of the southwest wilderness by crushing dams, bridges, power plants and anything else they can. On the run from
Show More
the local Mormon do-gooder Search&Rescue crew, the FBI, the National Park Service and anybody else they run into, the quartet is likeable, entertaining and extremely enjoyable.

The dialogue is massive. Dialogue drives the book, and it never clunks and is often wildly witty. There are more turns of phrase that make you gasp and laugh than anything else I've read.

The one female character is written perhaps a bit more sexist than you would find today, though she is certainly her own woman. The three men are all unique and grand personalities.

Monkey Wrench Gang compares well to Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas - less trippy, but just as grand and impactful. Less weird, more witty.

Second, as a call-to-arms for environmental anarchism: I suspect that to some, this novel is dangerous. The characters should be darker, less idealistic. The impact of their approach should be interpreted more brutally.

But.

I think the novel provides a challenging commentary on American consumerism and our unwillingness to stop and consider the cost of our lifestyle. That it's packaged in a fun adventure story with amazing dialogue makes it all the more subversive.
Show Less
LibraryThing member dypaloh
Edward Abbey has wit to burn and a hearty appreciation for the joys of wordplay. His voice is assertive; he’s a man with something to say! And he’s determined to have fun saying it, which is great good luck for readers of his novel, The Monkey Wrench Gang.

Aside from provoking laughs, Abbey
Show More
gives us a destructive fantasia. It is kin to the childish revenge fantasies even the most anodyne of adults can harbor, with a plot consisting of one demolition after another. Out of demolished machinery and wrecked infrastructure is fashioned his fictional polemic. The “gang” consists of an at times ill-disciplined group of saboteurs: Doc Sarvis, the money behind the enterprise; Bonnie Abbzug, love interest and spunky monkey-wrencher; a practitioner of plural marriage called Seldom Seen by his patient and widely dispersed wives; and ex-Marine George Hayduke. The gang ranges the red rock lands of Utah and Arizona to destroy the machinery that destroys the rivers and landscapes the author loves (and how can he not love them?). Hayduke, in particular, seeks vengeance with fire in his heart, and after spending time with him you get the feeling that a Hayduke in rut would boink an armadillo if doing so could help the cause somehow.

All in all, a novel that will be best enjoyed by people who display, have wish for, or remember having, a little anarchy in their souls.
Show Less
LibraryThing member greeniezona
Another book I have no idea when I finished it or why it didn't get a review. I liked it, of course. How could a crazy hippie like me not like this book? I have fantasies about keeping a chainsaw in the back of my car and cutting down billboards now. Note to Homeland Security: if billboards are
Show More
destroyed in my area, it's totally a coincidence. I have an alibi.
Show Less
LibraryThing member birdonthestreet
This isn't something I'd normally read, but I ended up really liking it. The characters are funny and larger than life, but the message is one that is very timely. It's one of the few books I've ever convinced my husband to read.
LibraryThing member Devil_llama
Perhaps if any book could be called THE Environmental Classic, this book should certainly be in the top contenders for the title. Abbey's gang of lovable misfits sets out to save the world, one fence at a time, and ends up in adventures both amusing and disheartening at the same time. Probably the
Show More
greatest of all Abbey's novels, and a rollicking tale of the new west.
Show Less
LibraryThing member hhudson
Utter dross. Environmentalists who litter the highway with beer cans? Really? The main character is a self righteous toddler. Don't waste your time.
LibraryThing member booknivorous
It’s fun, uproarious, insulting, and insightful. This is the book that spawned the modern get-off-the-sofa environmentalist/activist movement. It’s full of old school conservatism and pre-Earth First rage. It’s a rollicking story full of belly-laughs and pointed opinions. One page will insult
Show More
you, while the next is worth Xeroxing for friends. Take this book in context for the time it was written, laugh along with our heroes, and enjoy Cactus Ed at his mischievous best.
Show Less
LibraryThing member jbheffernan
This is one of my all time favorite books. The opening chapter is a classic and it certainly catches ones interest. There is an anarchic edge to the book which I appreciated. I believe that Edward Abbey's deep love for wild things and the desert shines through.
LibraryThing member o_nate
Even if you're not an Earth First! sympathizer, this is an excellent, rollicking adventure tale from a unique jaundiced perspective, with memorable characters and a naturalist's eye for the desert's austere beauty.
LibraryThing member Davidmanheim
"Few arguements are more dangerous thant the ones that simply 'feel' right, but can't be justified" -SJ Gould

In a phrase, this sums up my objections to "the monkey wrench gang" philosophy. The book, which is rather well written and an interesting read, I feel inspires entirely the wrong set of
Show More
ideas about the wrongs of environmentalism as radical culture. The essential underlying theme, spelled out in certain places, is that if you're "fighting the man" you need not think about the consequences of you actions.

Essentially the book details the adventures of 4 members of the monkey wrnech gang, their personal environmentalism avenger group, with requisite anarchic yet gentle and peace loving feelings and a love of nature. Their unlikely meeting ends with them inexplicably trusting one another, at which point they decide to wreak havoc on the evil corporations and governments who are despoiling their lands by... get this, destroying "The Man's" heavy machinery and spilling the oil and gasoline into the groundwater. Of course, this involves burning various toxic substances, causing all sorts of destruction, while driving around in their nice, gas guzzling Buicks and Cadillacs.

All in all, an interesting read to understand the essential moral bankruptcy of the anarcho-environmentalist movement. Their lack of integrity is only rivaled by, (and a reflection of) their lack of thinking about how to realistically cope with a world not of their own design.
Show Less
LibraryThing member gazzy
Entertaining story & interesting premise with attractive descriptions of the beautful desert country. Four different characters seek to put a monkeywrench in the churning of the western environment for the right reasons.
LibraryThing member Kaelkivial
Love the concept, love the story, love the ideals- but Ed Abbey isn't the greatest of writers. At times he literally just starts listing things and seems to rattle on until he realizes what he's doing and pulls himself back into the story. My only other gripe is with the Hayduke character- although
Show More
one of the heroes he's very hard to like. I'm a big fan of the "lovable rogue", but Hayduke is more of a "gross, sexist, redneck rogue" than a lovable one. The other three main characters are fantastic though and definitely pick up the slack!
Show Less
LibraryThing member mr._sammy
I can see the great writing, which is why it didn't get 1 star. The characters are flat and it reads almost like a manual of how to take down (badly) a system you don't like, though you use, which is a bit ironic. I couldn't force myself to finish reading the entire story, I was so bored.
LibraryThing member VashonJim
Zany characters and a zany plot make for a fun read.
LibraryThing member Mockers
Tag says it all really. Story of a bunch of ecoteurs travelling around the SW of the USA wrecking stuff. Well told in a kind of sort of ironicish way. Entertaining and inspiring.
LibraryThing member rsplenda477
I read this book in an environmental history class. It was very clever and witty, as well as environmentally concerned. A great read that is definitely worth anyone's time who is interested in environmentalism.
LibraryThing member jarvenpa
Oh, sure, there are a zillion things wrong and politically incorrect about this book. An ecological tale in which people strew the desert with beer cans and the only female character is best known for her fine ass? But...it is funny, and sad, and was a pivotal book for a generation of
Show More
eco-activists. So I still tell my young forest defender friends to go ahead and read it.
Show Less
LibraryThing member jgreenia
Who doesn't like a tale of a band of misfit do-gooders? Abbey does not really show off the same ability to write for the mind like with Black Sun, but the flawed characters and their "adventures" certainly do keep that itch going to read more.
LibraryThing member untraveller
The 4th or 5th time I've read the book....probably the last. Still an excellent read, full of one-liners, but sad all at the same time. Humans never learn and we continue to mess up our home for money/power. Most people alive on this planet, even the so-called environmentalists, don't seem to care.
Show More
This is a good book, but that's all it is, a book. Virtually nobody that I know is or has done a thing to make life on this planet a bit better....and I worked for the NPS for 15 years! Sad....
Show Less

Language

Original language

English

Original publication date

1975

Physical description

480 p.; 5.31 inches

ISBN

0061129763 / 9780061129766
Page: 0.1895 seconds