Status
Call number
Publication
Pages
Description
Pets. Nonfiction. Steven Kotler was forty years old, single, and facing an existential crisis when he met Lila, a woman devoted to animal rescue. "Love me, love my dogs" was her rule, and Steven took it to heart. Spurred to move by a housing crisis in Los Angeles, Steven, Lila, and their eight dogs-then ten, then twenty, and then they lost count-bought a postage-stamp-size farm in Chimayo, New Mexico. A Small Furry Prayer chronicles their adventures at Rancho de Chihuahua, the sanctuary they created for their special needs pack. While dog rescue is one of the largest underground movements in America, it is also one of the least understood. An insider look at the "cult and culture" of dog rescue, A Small Furry Prayer weaves personal experience, cultural investigation, and scientific inquiry into a fast-paced, fun-filled narrative that explores what it means to devote one's life to the furry and the four-legged. Along the way, Kotler combs through every aspect of canine-human relations, from humans' long history with dogs through brand-new research into the neuroscience of canine companionship, in the end discovering why living in a world made of dog may be the best way to uncover the truth about what it really means to be human.… (more)
Description
While dog rescue is one of the largest underground movements in America, it is also one of the least understood. This insider look at the cult and culture of dog rescue begins with Kotler's personal experience working with an ever-peculiar pack of dogs and becomes a much deeper investigation into exactly what it means to devote one's life to the furry and the four-legged.
Along the way, Kotler combs through every aspect of canine-human relations, from human's long history with dogs through brand new research into the neuroscience of canine companionship, in the end discovering why living in a world of dogs may be the best way to uncover the truth about what it really means to be human.
Collection
Language
Original language
Original publication date
Physical description
ISBN
Similar in this library
User reviews
The author uses stories in the dog rescue as a jumping off place to discuss everything from crime and poverty in Chimayo to Thoreau to shape shifting and shamanism. Some discussions worked better than others did. Toward the end, I admit to have done some skimming.
Dog lovers will find some items of interest and probably those readers who are themselves totally committed to dog rescue may especially like it. For dog emotion and behavior, a better author is Patricia McConnell. I do plan on making a small donation to their operation but the book itself just didn’t come together for me.
The tale of their efforts to found a rescue in the badlands of NM is compelling, and Kotler's prose is vivid and honest, sometimes heartbreakingly so. Unfortunately, for me at least, there wasn't enough dog rescue and far too much meaning of life. As the book progresses, it reads more and more like a term paper. Kotner trots out every scrap of research and analysis on dog-human interaction, and if you've read a lot of dog books (and I have) it's stale stuff. By the last third of the book, I found myself skimming over his long discourses on the metaphysical aspects of dogs and screaming inwardly, "What about Bella? And Igor? And Bucket? And how are you paying for all of this?" He does return to the dogs in the end, but it's too late. This is a book in need of an editor. Preferably one who loves dogs and knows how to tell a story.
The book begins when Kotler is 40 and wants to do something different with the rest of his life. He falls in love with a dog rescuer, Joy. Love Joy, love the dogs. So dog rescue turns out to be both the subject of the book and the “something different” that Kotler does.
Kotler moves from LA to New Mexico with Joy and her dogs. They live in a home with lots of property and lots of solitude.
Joy’s pack of dogs becomes Kotler’s pack as well. And the pack keeps growing as the local humane society gets more unadoptable dogs, i.e., dogs who are sick, maybe dying, retarded, ugly, etc. But freelance writing assignments are much harder to come by in the out-of-the-way place they now live. So money is always an issue, and they make their choices based on that: $20 or $60 dog food? medical treatment for the dogs or euthanasia? rescue 13 or 10 dogs? and so on.
Chapters of this book tell stories of their lives with their dogs, with Kotler’s thoughts on particular incidents. This leads to much philosophizing and a lot of research and examination. Some chapters are continuation of examination of issues from the previous chapter. But you could still say that A SMALL FURRY PRAYER does tell a story because the chapters are presented in chronological order.
Yet, each chapter of the book could stand on its own. This is a device many writers of nonfiction use, and it is often successful. John Grogan used it in MARLEY & ME. He put together the newspaper columns he wrote about his family’s life with their dog, and look how well that book did.
Although that type construction doesn’t entirely work with me, in both cases (both MARLEY & ME and A SMALL FURRY PRAYER) I liked almost every chapter. (In A SMALL FURRY PRAYER, I could have done without a whole chapter on dogs and sex.) But these books came across as what they are: many common but separate stories or (as in the case of A SMALL FURRY PRAYER) stories that lead to thoughtful examinations.
The common thread running throughout A SMALL FURRY PRAYER: has Kotler chosen the right path for the rest of his life? So he examines the path he chose: dog rescue. The separate stories of dogs that Kotler and Joy rescue are touching, Igor’s story especially so. You’ll see.
The book is not a single, detailed story, my preference. Just the same, I loved the individual stories, and Kotler’s examinations are excellent. His viewpoints are validated by much research that is so much like those of Wayne Pacelle, president and CEO of the Humane Society of the United States, I hoped that they knew each other. So I emailed Kotler to ask him. Unfortunately not, but I’m betting it will happen.
As for my comparison of A SMALL FURRY PRAYER and MARLEY AND ME, it ends with their construction. In my opinion, honestly, A SMALL FURRY PRAYER far outweighs MARLEY AND ME. While I enjoyed MARLEY AND ME because it was often laugh-out-loud funny, I prefer stories that are thoughtful as well as humorous, as those in A SMALL FURRY PRAYER are.
I received this book from the LibraryThing Early Reviewers Program.
The history and research on the dog and human bond brings so much to this topic. I found myself reading sections to my family members. Now, that's a good book! I enjoyed the book immensely and will recommend it to others. Well done!
Oh, and if you're ever in Chimayo treat yourself to a fabulous Northern New Mexico lunch with Sangria at Rancho de Chimayo on the tiered patio in the summer or near a kiva fireplace inside in the winter. Don't miss the Chimayo red chili.
The astonishing web he weaves stretches
Masterful and absorbing, the author shares life among his pack on Rancho de Chihuahua. A terrific read!
Kotler didn't set out to be a hero to unwanted dogs. That role came to him, first with a dog named Ahab, then with a woman who said that to love her meant loving her dogs. But this is more than a
It's a great read for anybody who has ever had loved a pet and a necessary read for anyone who hasn't. Neuroscientists might also find probably find this more compelling than they would have anticipated too. As a person who has volunteered at a wildlife rehabilitation center, I also appreciated the author explaining the differentiation between rehabilitators and rescuers since the general public often gets the two confused when seeking service opportunities. Add'l note to the publisher since this is an earlier reviewer copy: The last line of pg 200 and Line 3 of the last para on pg 266 have editing errors.
He studies and writes about dog-human relations from every angle and throughout time. He even looks at it from religion/spirituality and from the depths of neuroscience. But the best information comes from his stories and examples of the dogs themselves. Sometimes heartbreaking and frequently amazing, the work that Steve and Joy are doing is beautiful and something that most people could not do. I know I couldn't! His descriptions of morning wanders through his dark house and what comes to be known as "sh*t foot" would end my attempts to be a rescuer quickly. (One small example... but the "vomit mouth" experience was the real clincher!)
Inspiring, full of humor, and sad too, I can recommend this book to any lover of dogs or other animals. You will learn something new about them and gain respect for their intellect!
What I like about the book is that it contains a lot of humour, and the author tells it like it is, and does not romanticize his life, including a long period of depression and despair when a number of dogs died or had to be put down. The book is authentic and well worth reading. There is a good chance you will learn a lot as well.
I did skim through the rest of the book and read parts here and there, but I'm wondering what the reviewers who found humor here were smoking (or drinking) because I was highly disappointed in the lack of humor. Usually tales of dogs involve a good deal of it, but I only found one instance where I snickered a little at the description of what the dogs were doing. I have no doubt that these animals are getting lots of affection and have a better 'rest of their life' than they otherwise would have, but I didn't feel a real connection between Kotler and the dogs. Even when he declares that he loves Chihuahuas, there is little bonding between him and the individual dogs.
In fact, he keeps naming new dogs that he never introduces. I didn't get to know most of the dogs on any kind of level that would make me care about them - therefore, why do I want to read about them? Then again, the book isn't so much about the dogs as it is about Kotler anyway, which is OK, but not my thing. And the science stuff thrown in just makes it sound like a bunch of short National Geographic articles strung together in a book - usually not in any kind of way that made sense to me....not even an interesting stream of consciousness - just random and to me, incomprehensible.
So, while it is not common for me, I didn't read the whole book. I'm sure some people will like this combination of scientific and philosophical and memoir, but there was too little dog love and cuteness and hilariousness in there for me. Others who do dog rescue might find it more enlightening, but I was just bored.
Each section, however, used the author's observations of the dogs as a jumping off point to explore another area ... religion, spirituality, human-animal bonding, dogs' ability to feel emotion, etc. Within each section, the chapters were really quite short and easy to skim if that particular subject didn't capture your attention.
Overall, it was not what I expected, but I enjoyed it none the less.
The book's cover
Since his girlfriend-later-wife, Joy Nicholson, is deeply committed to the altruistic avocation - life calling? - of animal rescue, mostly dogs, Kotler quite naturally wants to join the club, wants to understand. So he does, he says, what he's always done - "ludicrous amounts of research." And that's where the "everything is connected" stuff begins to display itself. Because it seems he is research crazy, and everything he reads up on he somehow manages to drag into his narrative about their run-down and cash-strapped animal rescue ranch in rural New Mexico. I mean this is so NOT just a book about dogs. This is more about trying to make sense out of being a human being and how we relate to the other creatures around us. I would have exepected to see references in this kind of a book to, say, Patricia McConnell, Jeffrey Moussaieff Mason, and okay, Cesar Millan and even Aldo Leopold - and there they are, along with countless other animal experts. But we also get (and this is only a very small part of a much longer list): St Francis, Carlos Castaneda, Aldo Leopold, Arthur C Clarke, William James, DesCartes, Emile Durkheim, Eric Fromm, Aldous Huxley, Dr DOLITTLE, for cripesakes! And on and on and on, with many, many endnotes to back it all up. This is simply research run amok, interspersed with cute pop psychology and endless cleverness, utilized in the interest of drawing all this widely disparate information together. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. But to this reader it often became just too damn much, too over the top. So I will admit to plenty of skimming through literally dozens of pages that often seemed either a bit too esoteric or just plain irrelevant.
But maybe that was just me. After all, I only got a C+ in Intro to Philosophy in college, so maybe a lot of this is just over my head. Or maybe it was NOT all so connected.
All that said, I did find parts here and there that truly moved me, most notably Chapter 26, about bereavement and grief over the loss of a beloved pet. Been there. It's devastating. And Chapter 28, with its sad tales of dogs dying in spite of the attempts of Kotler and Nicholson to save them. I do not doubt for a moment that Kotler and his partner are dedicated dog lovers, and for that I salute him. But if you're looking for a simple 'dog book' to give you a 'warm fuzzy feeling,' this ain't the book for you. Try Marley and Me. It's less pretentious and a lot more entertaining.
Steven Kolter's writing is easily consumed, almost like breathing. Immediately, I could identify with Kolter, his situation in life and his love for dogs. It is
The real beauty of this novel lies in Kotler's quiet courage to willingly moved from Los Angeles to a remote, poverty strickened, drug riddled town in New Mexico to give these misfit, "lifer", unadoptable dogs grace and dignity. Sad, yes, because they die. But what a noble pursuit.
I loved reading about the dogs and how this started—the process he went through emotionally to embrace the life his wife choose. The scientific studies he quotes from are interesting and I’ve even seen some of the documentaries on PBS and read some of the articles in National Geographic, but the conclusions he jumps to don’t always add up. The quality of the writing is great and at times I laughed and cried, so it is touching. There is a take-away, the breakthroughs he made hiking with the dogs; that imagery will stay with me inspiring longer exploratory walks with our dogs. I received this book through Librarything.
A Small Furry Prayer doesn't have a conclusive ending, it really could have gone on as long as Kotler still had insights and anecdotes to share, and I get the feeling that he nowhere near exhausted his reserve in this book. I would have liked a more definitive structure and order - it felt too scattershot.
Kotler addresses sticky issues like the value of animal rescue as a cause (i.e. why save animals when so many people are suffering?), the "humanity" of animals, and the interconnectedness of all life. Still, the information is interesting and well-cited, the stories emotional, and the cause noble. A Small Furry Prayer is a must-read for dog lovers and animal rescuers, but be prepared for deep thinking and deep emotions.