Father Stubna's Recommendations - test note
Contains bibliographic references and index.
Status
Available
Call number
Publication
New York, Scribner c1972
Physical description
248 p.; 22 cm
User reviews
LibraryThing member tcarter
This book seems to be a counted as a classic, a touchstone for all who want to be taken seriously in their study of the parables of Jesus. The author obviously has a comprehensive knowledge of the material, and of the linguistic and literary context of the material. He also has a living faith and a
The first half of the book seeks to "recover" the "original" form of the parables, as the author believes that only by doing this that the "true" meaning can be recovered. I can find very little to commend in this methodology. Whilst I see the value of redaction criticism in exploring layers of meaning in the text, I believe that these layers are subordinate to that contained in the canonical form. I am even less comfortable with the casting vote often given to the Gospel of Thomas in arguments in this edition. In fact, the consistently positive attitude towards the Gospel of Thomas was one of the more confusing aspects of this book.
The second half of the book looks at ten key themes that underpin the majority of Jesus' parables. Whilst this work does, to certain extent, draw on the first half of the book, much of it does stand even when that derivation is disallowed. This fact does lead me to wonder further about the value of such circumlocutions. Whilst the first section appears dated in its attitude to first century Palestine and towards the text, the second section is still, I believe, a rich and worthwhile mine of resources for those looking to teach and apply the good news of Jesus in lives today.
Show More
prophetic voice that calls for authentic Christian living that both shine through his writing.The first half of the book seeks to "recover" the "original" form of the parables, as the author believes that only by doing this that the "true" meaning can be recovered. I can find very little to commend in this methodology. Whilst I see the value of redaction criticism in exploring layers of meaning in the text, I believe that these layers are subordinate to that contained in the canonical form. I am even less comfortable with the casting vote often given to the Gospel of Thomas in arguments in this edition. In fact, the consistently positive attitude towards the Gospel of Thomas was one of the more confusing aspects of this book.
The second half of the book looks at ten key themes that underpin the majority of Jesus' parables. Whilst this work does, to certain extent, draw on the first half of the book, much of it does stand even when that derivation is disallowed. This fact does lead me to wonder further about the value of such circumlocutions. Whilst the first section appears dated in its attitude to first century Palestine and towards the text, the second section is still, I believe, a rich and worthwhile mine of resources for those looking to teach and apply the good news of Jesus in lives today.
Show Less
LibraryThing member exinanition
I am obliged to refer you to the review written by Librarything member: tcarter. I believe tcarter has described this book fairly well.
Original publication date
1947
Original language
German