Status
Available
Call number
Call number
971 S38 2008
Collection
Local notes
Shelved in Aboriginal Collection
Description
In this startlingly original vision of Canada, renowned thinker John Ralston Saul argues that Canada is a Métis nation, heavily influenced and shaped by Aboriginal ideas: Egalitarianism, a proper balance between individual and group, and a penchant for negotiation over violence are all Aboriginal values that Canada absorbed. An obstacle to our progress, Saul argues, is that Canada has an increasingly ineffective elite, a colonial non-intellectual business elite that doesn't believe in Canada. It is critical that we recognize these aspects of the country in order to rethink it's future.
Publication
Toronto : Viking Canada, 2008.
User reviews
LibraryThing member bruchu
Flawed But Stimulates Discussion
This latest book by Canadian intellectual John Ralston Saul is a philosophical study about Canada, its identity, and its place in the world. There is probably no better person to write a book like this than Saul and the the boldness with which he writes and argues is
The best parts of the book are Saul's polemic on the enduring myths and legacies of Canadian history which have to some extent limited the cultural development of Canadian nationalism. One could argue that this may or may not necessarily be in fact a negative attribute, but any "patriotic" Canadian would argue otherwise. Back to the Saul, he is entirely right about the self-consciousness and lack of confidence which is projected by the established Canadian institutions and structures. He is also right to critique the legacy of colonial inferiority and complacency resulting from our mythologized ties to the western-liberal tradition.
Once Saul tackles all that is wrong with Canada, he attempts to develop an alternative blueprint for how Canada ought to be constructed socially and culturally. This is where he veers off the deep end. Saul decries the use of populism as a rhetorical tool whose sole purpose is manipulation of fear as an empty signifier. Yet Saul is guilty of the same manipulation he so critiques through his perpetuation of an imagined "aboriginal heritage" as an empty signifier to stand for a uniquely Canadian identity that values of fairness, good governance, and inclusion. This is not in any way directed as a criticism of First Nations, but certainly Canada in the postmodern age is far beyond a singular definition of an essentialized Canadianness built on an invented tradition.
Though I disagree completely with Saul's vision of what Canada "is," the book is most definitely thought-provoking and on that purpose alone the book is worth reading for any Canadian who has pondered these very same questions of identity.
This latest book by Canadian intellectual John Ralston Saul is a philosophical study about Canada, its identity, and its place in the world. There is probably no better person to write a book like this than Saul and the the boldness with which he writes and argues is
Show More
certainly to be commended.The best parts of the book are Saul's polemic on the enduring myths and legacies of Canadian history which have to some extent limited the cultural development of Canadian nationalism. One could argue that this may or may not necessarily be in fact a negative attribute, but any "patriotic" Canadian would argue otherwise. Back to the Saul, he is entirely right about the self-consciousness and lack of confidence which is projected by the established Canadian institutions and structures. He is also right to critique the legacy of colonial inferiority and complacency resulting from our mythologized ties to the western-liberal tradition.
Once Saul tackles all that is wrong with Canada, he attempts to develop an alternative blueprint for how Canada ought to be constructed socially and culturally. This is where he veers off the deep end. Saul decries the use of populism as a rhetorical tool whose sole purpose is manipulation of fear as an empty signifier. Yet Saul is guilty of the same manipulation he so critiques through his perpetuation of an imagined "aboriginal heritage" as an empty signifier to stand for a uniquely Canadian identity that values of fairness, good governance, and inclusion. This is not in any way directed as a criticism of First Nations, but certainly Canada in the postmodern age is far beyond a singular definition of an essentialized Canadianness built on an invented tradition.
Though I disagree completely with Saul's vision of what Canada "is," the book is most definitely thought-provoking and on that purpose alone the book is worth reading for any Canadian who has pondered these very same questions of identity.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Knud
A pleasant surprise of a book that makes a good argument why Canada should, and probably will, return to the aboriginal ideas and ideals as our society finally starts to become truly multicultural. Saul challenges the reader to think deeply about what he is saying, usually by his explicit or
Show More
implicit disclaimer that he's not being naiive is his perspective on past and present aboriginal culture. Though I'm not yet through the book, I know that I will finish it soon and that it will stay in my thinking about our country. Show Less
LibraryThing member TheBookJunky
“In the circle of life, the circumference nurtures the centre.” P 62. This describes the web of relationships of First Nations society of the northwest coast, in BC. Many nations, each considered themselves different, yet the relationships of stories, myths, economic roles linked them into a
Show More
larger more complex culture. Show Less
LibraryThing member AJBraithwaite
I think this book should be required reading for all new Canadians. Not least because John Ralston Saul says such nice things about new immigrants. And because it makes such a lot of sense. It gets very political in the middle, but the historical perspective on how Canada was forged out of the
Show More
Aboriginal approach to welcoming the 'other' is absolutely fascinating and I was nodding my head all the way through the early chapters. This man knows his history and has a clear vision of how it can be incorporated in a national vision for the future. Which is unfortunately a lot more than can be said for most of the current crop of leaders of the county. Show Less
LibraryThing member ted_newell
I was puzzled by this book. I admire the author as public intellectual who had years to gain a privileged view of the country at the side of the then-Governor General. I wait to hear more from him. For now, I was not persuaded that the founding generations of the country were much influenced by
Show More
Metis or First Nations thinking. To be frank, an English loyalist Protestant triumphalism dominated, and I say that counting myself as a hopefully chastened later member of the clan. The dominant (thankfully not exclusive) attitude to Native culture was a religious racism later seen in the residential schools catastrophe. I suspect the first generations looked down on the natives. Maybe Saul is not religiously sensitive himself and mislabeled an accommodating trait of Christianity in a context that was plural (Anglican/Catholic/Methodist/etc) from inception. Did I read aright that he implies in the first section that European thinking would be natural in Europe and transformed somehow by the geography when Europeans traveled to the New World? If so, not persuaded. I imagine the old thinking would be transmogrified in the new land and old traditions displaced, as was the case in New England, and begin its unique evolution, but the roots would remain in place. We are still celebrating Christmas though for most folks the religious aspects are, lets say, muted. Many interesting aspects, esp the accommodation of the Supreme Court to First Nations approaches in deciding their cases, orality over literacy, et.c., but the case overall fell short. Open to discussion. Show Less
LibraryThing member musecure
Saul's "A Fair Country" made me stop and rethink some of my assumptions about Canada, it's history and culture. There were a few moments when it all dropped into place and became so obvious. But there were also a few points were I felt Saul may have belaboured the point a bit much. Overall, the
Show More
book gave me a lot to think about. Show Less
ISBN
9780670068043