Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes

by Chris Crutcher

Hardcover, 1993

Status

Available

Call number

F Cru

Call number

F Cru

Barcode

3244

Publication

Greenwillow Books (1993), Edition: 1st, 224 pages

Description

The daily class discussions about the nature of man, the existence of God, abortion, organized religion, suicide and other contemporary issues serve as a backdrop for a high-school senior's attempt to answer a friend's dramatic cry for help.

Original publication date

1993

User reviews

LibraryThing member ewyatt
I just reread this book and like it all over again. Sarah Byrnes stops speaking and is placed in a psychiatric ward. Eric "Moby" her best friend since middle school visits her daily to try to get to the root of what has happened. Sarah has burn scars all over her hands and face that she got during
Show More
a household incident when she was young. When the truth comes out that her dad is the reason for her injuries, things start to escalate. Eric has tried to prove his loyalty to Sarah a number of ways. First he tried to stay fat for her even after he started swimming with the team and losing weight. He also has always refused any outing where Sarah was not welcome. The book traces the relationship of the two from the beginning of their friendship. There are also several interesting subplots and characters. There is Mrs. Lemry, the strong progressive teacher and swim coach, who serves as a mentor to Eric. The subplot with Mark Britton and his religious beliefs and suicide attempt. The Ellerby's, the power hungry assistant principal, and the CAT class.
For all that is going on in the book and the tidy endings despite all the messiness in the storyline, there is a lot of meat in this book to think about.
Show Less
LibraryThing member porch_reader
My older son read this in his eight grade English class this fall. It raised controversy from some parents who were concerned about some of the themes raised in this book (abortion, suicide, and religion to name a few). I tend to prefer that my son be discussing these themes in the classroom than
Show More
with an unsupervised group of friends, especially given my respect for his English teacher. But I also wanted to read the book so that I could have conversations with my son about these issues as well.

Despite my reasons for reading this book, I was barely passed the first chapter when I became completely enthralled in the story. The story is told from the perspective of Eric Calhoune (aka Moby). Eric was overweight when we was younger. He was also a bit of an outcast, and that is how he became friends with Sarah Byrnes, a girl whose face was terribly burned when she was three. Her father, a cruel man, didn't allow any reconstructive surgery, saying that growing up disfigured would make her tough. Sarah and Eric coped with the challenges of middle school together, and when Eric joined the swim team in high school, he ate even more so that he could stay fat for Sarah Byrnes. But as the story begins, Sarah Byrnes has been admitted to the hospital and is refusing to talk. With the help of his friend Ellerby, his swim coach Mrs. Lemry, and an old nemesis Dale, Eric has to figure out how to help Sarah Byrnes deal with a situation that seems unsolvable.

Crutcher captures the voices and trials of high school in voices that are authentic and complex. The issues that Eric, Sarah Byrnes, and others face are difficult ones, and Crutcher doesn't shy from the conflicting viewpoints that are raised in these debates. The story moves quickly, and for the final third, I could barely put it down. I wasn't surprised to learn in the author's sketch at the end of the book that Crutcher has worked as a family therapist and a child protection specialist. He clearly has firsthand knowledge of the struggles that he writes about.
Show Less
LibraryThing member LindaLundeen
Outcasts Eric Calhoune and Sarah Byrnes have been friends for years, but high school is changing both of them. As they endure their senior year, swimming is helping eighteen-year-old Eric lose weight and ridicule from classmates. At seventeen, Sarah faces her challenges every day as the scars from
Show More
an accident at an early age continue to haunt her along with her shattered family life. The novel deals with several serious issues including abortion, child abuse, bullying, and physical assault. The least likable character is Mr. Byrnes, Sarah's father, who is cast as the antagonist and the source of Sarah's pain. Recommended for upper high school grades due to adult language, topics and situations.
Show Less
LibraryThing member mjspear
A great look at the unlikely friendship between two students with "terminal uglies": HS senior Eric Calhoune, so fat they call him 'Moby' and Sarah Byrnes with a scar-torn face, the victim of a fire. As the book opens, Sarah is in the local mental hospital as a sudden mute. Eric must figure out why
Show More
his best friend has stopped talking... and why some secrets should remain silent.

The book is a little dated: the abortion subtheme, and stereotypical characters (Sarah's psychotic Dad, the religious principal and conservative do-gooder student) seem heavy-handed to this reader. Still, no one captures high school sports, male bonding and guy dialogue like Crutcher.
Show Less
LibraryThing member heathernkemp
Rating: A+

I think I could write a one-word review of this book (obviously I've exceeded that already, but I'm making a point here). The problem is that if I drop this one word on you, you'll be like, "What?!" It's a racy word, and I think it might be okay to use it because it's not like I go
Show More
throwing the sauce around on this blog all the time--I prefer to save my racy talk for when I hang out with my sailor friends. Anyway, here's my one-word review:

FAN-_ _ _ _ _ _ _-TASTIC. Seriously. I know a lot of people say that using foul language is the hobgoblin of little minds (along with routine), and that if you can't say it more creatively than you're a loser, but the situation called for it. Read this one-word review, and tell me which is better: FANTASTIC. The middle part of the first review had an impact, didn't it?

Here's why this book is FAN-_ _ _ _ _ _ _-TASTIC:

1. The characters are amazing. Crutcher used to be a child therapist, and he's got this stuff nailed down tight. I loved it, it was gripping, moving, heart-wrenching, and beautifully drawn. Everybody--Eric, Sarah Byrnes, his parents, friends, foes, everyone--was fully developed.

2. The plot is hands-down dynamite. There's angst, there's sports, there's all kinds of lovey-dovey beauty. Strong friendships, lies, fears, everything you need for a good hard-boiled story.

3. The themes are tough to handle, but complex and thought-provoking. I work at a camp for abused and neglected kids every summer, and I don't think I'll ever be the same. This book is reach-down-into-your-chest-and-rip-your-heart-out writing. I actually gave my sister a summary of what the book was about, I only got through two sentences before she broke me off and said she couldn't handle any more, it was too much. I said, "You read books where the protagonist is a rape victim, but this is too much for you?" (This was in reference to some books by Charlaine Harris). My sister said crimes against adults, although awful, are nothing compared with crimes against children.

Tough to read, but totally worth it. I'm going to have to go out and get every last one of Crutcher's books. The guy is FAN-_ _ _ _ _ _ _-TASTIC.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Joybee
Great book. Wonderful 'real' character and lots of controversial topics, this book makes you think about life and question your ideals.

Eric Calhoune is fat. His best friend is Sarah Byrnes who has a burn scared face from 'accidents' when she was a young child. Eric as a high school senior is the
Show More
narrator of this story. He reminisces about his past in middleschool, causing trouble with Sarah Byrnes, while trying to deal with his current problems.
Show Less
LibraryThing member george.d.ross
I was intrigued by the concept of this book when it was presented to me: fat boy and deformed girl have been friends since childhood, united by their outsider status. What happens to the friendship when fat boy slims down and starts to get popular?

But that wasn't what this book was about at all.
Show More
The formerly fat boy never really considers abandoning his friend, so instead the conflict revolves around a fairly ludicrous and melodramatic storyline involving horrific child abuse, catatonia, cross-country pursuit, and a knife-wielding villain lurking in dark shadows. I guess I can see why kids would be grabbed by that kind of drama, but it all seemed a little silly and far-fetched to me, frequently depending on HUGE coincidences.

Another thing that bothered me is the degree to which adults ultimately solved all the problems in the book. It's supposed to be a coming of age novel, about teenagers making their first forays into adulthood, but it seemed like in the end, all the characters were infantilizined by the adults swooping in to the rescue.

And finally, I was disturbed by the way that every Christian in the book (except the sainted Episcopalians) was portrayed as an amoral hypocrite. Laying it on a bit thick, perhaps?
Show Less
LibraryThing member annekiwi
I'm on a Crutcher kick right now. I read [Deadline] last year and loved it so decided to get the rest of his stuff and see how it goes. I enjoy the heroes a lot and the high school drama. I hate the reality of sexual abuse and death, and all the evil stuff that happens to kids just trying to figure
Show More
out life. I don't hate it as literature, I hate the very fact that it exists. Crutcher handles the topics very sensitively. I think the principals in each book are very similar. Mr. Mautz from this book is a clone to Mr. Caldwell in [Chinese Handcuffs], which I'm currently reading. But something that does bug me are the liberal politics interspersed in the books. I started to read [Whale Talk] and in all 4 of these books, I find that the bad guys are stereotypes ... conservative, sometimes Christian jocks. It's tiring. I could use a good story without any political soapboxing. It definitely detracts from the story.
Show Less
LibraryThing member theeclecticreview
Another great Chris Cutcher novel that touches on child abuse, obesity, abandonment and abortion. It's amazing how he can get all these subjects into one novel without it being too overwhelming
LibraryThing member 4sarad
Eric “Moby” Calhoune and Sarah Byrnes had been best friends for years. They were both social outcasts; Moby because of his excess weight and Sarah because of the fact that she had terrible scars all over her face and hands from a childhood accident. To prove his commitment to Sarah, Moby stayed
Show More
fat for her for a year; overeating on purpose to make up for all of the calories he was burning in swim practice. When Sarah Byrnes stops speaking and is put in a hospital, Moby does all he can to figure out why. When he hears a rumor that the burns covering her weren’t caused by an accident at all, Moby decides to do all he can to save her from being hurt again.

This book is fantastic. Crutcher is not afraid to go after big issues and to challenge people’s beliefs. Though this book is over ten years old, it does not seem dated and all of the issues discussed are just as pertinent to today’s teens.
Show Less
LibraryThing member readingsarah
This is one of my new favorite books. I read it in about one sitting and loved it, and cried, and laughed.
LibraryThing member biblyotekerin
Two long-time friends, originally bonded because of their "freakishness", he overweight, she scarred by a childhood accident, find their friendship in question when a career on the swim team begins to affect the boy's weight.
LibraryThing member anyanwubutler
After reading Draper’s drunk driving death, depression, suicide, rape, emotional and sexual abuse, grinding poverty, Crutcher’s humor about his teenage outcasts characters is refreshing.

Eric (the protagonist) also known as Moby and his best friend Sarah Byrnes have a deep tie: their status as
Show More
pariahs. He’s a former fat kid, now a HS swimmer. (Swimming has caused him to loose weight, but he thinks to still have Sarah Byrnes’ affections he has to remain fat, so he eats everything. She convinces him she’s not the shallow.) Sarah Byrnes is a smart, tough and horribly facially scarred who sits silent in a psychiatric hospital to protect herself from her monster of a father.
Show Less
LibraryThing member kdebros
Chris Crutcher's books are always quite hard-hitting, intense, personal...This is the story of two friends - the fat kid and the scarred kid, and how they cope in high school with the people that don't understand what its really like to be different. Incorporates themes of abuse, friendship,
Show More
vulnerability and putting up fronts.
Show Less
LibraryThing member pressingon
I found the book hard to get into at first, but after you make it past the first fifty or so pages it's hard to put down. The characters are believable and realistic, and the story flows beautifully.

It's well written and worth a read.
LibraryThing member Ynaffit27
Here comes another great novel by Chris Crutcher who writes about the real issues in teens lives--from abuse, friendships, relationships, religion, and self-esteem. Although this book is not as powerful as Whale Talk, I think there is a lot to like about this book. Crutcher deals with hardships in
Show More
a way that's relatable to people that aren't even facing that hardship. I find myself hanging on to his words and the characters' situations. There's always a moral and lesson to Crutcher's books and I admire that. This book looks into the fragility of human's psyche and the dilemma's people face from social, spiritual, or psychological situations. Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes dives into looking at the different perspectives of things and re-evaluating our lives and beliefs. I would have to say that the amount of issues in this book didn't quite seem connected--maybe I just didn't piece it altogether.
Show Less
LibraryThing member MelissaMarieL
This book is about two best friends names Sarah and Eric. Sarah is "ugly" bcause her face is burned due to a trajic incident. Eric is an overweight guy who feels if he stays overweight it'll keep Sarah happy. This book talks about their friendship and events that have happened in both their lives.
Show More
This book was a pretty good book in my opinion.
Show Less
LibraryThing member compjohn
The misleading title suggests something on the order of a romantic comedy to be made in 2012 starring a be-fatsuited Ryan Reynolds as an ad exec who must try his hardest not to lose weight so that his heft-conscious best friend, played by Sandra Bullock, can look comparatively slinky in time for
Show More
her wedding, yet she falls in love with Reynolds and—well, you get the point. At any rate, Crutcher’s novel is not a romantic comedy. A complex tale of suffering, abuse, love, and friendship, his novel concerns two best friends—the swimmer Eric Calhoune (cruelly nicknamed “Moby” because of his girth) and Sarah Byrnes, who has horrible scars on her hands and face because of a childhood incident the true nature of which is revealed later in the story. Eric tries to get Sarah Byrnes (who insists on the addition of her homophonic last name) to snap out of a sort of catatonia and eventually discovers the horrible, systematic abuse she has suffered at the hands of her satanic father, Virgil Byrnes. A subplot about a Christian fundamentalist boy whose girlfriend has an abortion (as it turns out on his urging) reflects the early-90sness of this novel but remains in its own melodramatic way moving.
Show Less
LibraryThing member sexy_librarian
Trying to write a synopsis of this book is difficult, because of the many issues that are approached in this book. There are themes of friendship, mentors, crushes, family, class difference, bullies, religion, abuse, trust.... and that's just the start of it. As an adult reading this, I was easily
Show More
drawn into the storyline, but unlike most other young adult books the action escalates to an almost unrealistic peak, but retains the usual happy ending.
I particularly like the fact that adults to play a pivotal role in this book. Most Young Adult books keep the adults in the background, so as to allow the young characters more freedom. Crutcher puts the adults back into a central, if not annoying role in the lives of the kids. This makes the book applicable to both adults and teens I think, considering adults can take this as a lesson on communicating with kids.
Show Less
LibraryThing member MVTheBookBabe
Due to copy and paste, formatting has been lost.

I guess I don't really care for the way that Crutcher writes. This is the second book I've read by him, and neither of the books I've read by him have really spoken to me. I just don't really like them at all. They're alright, but they always seem to
Show More
just drag for me, and I really dislike that in a book. I want some action! You know what I mean?

I'd say that Eric himself was a good character, but he had some flaws. For one, he was forever trying to get Mark's beef, and generally driving everyone in the vicinity insane. Not that Mark wasn't a total ass, but he made up for it, just a little, in the end. Now Eric though, he drove me insane the entire time. I could not get him to shut up. Really. It was that bad. His character's voice is literally in my head now. He won't shut up. But I guess some people look for that in a character. Not me. Never.

I really would have liked to have read some of the story through Dale Thorton's point of view, because it seemed like he could have been an amazing character. He was just so.....interesting. And that's what I look for in a character. One's that'll keep me interested. He did. I wish that this book had been as fast in the beginning as it was in the end, because I think that would've improved the book somewhat. Not that we'd ever get over Eric's voice in my head! But it might have helped a bit. Also, for being called 'Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes', Sarah Byrnes was not in the book near as much as I thought she would be. All in all, I'd say I was entertained, but not really fulfilled.
Show Less
LibraryThing member 321Gemstar
I probably wouldn’t have picked this book up myself, since it's written by a guy (yes, I know this is sexist) and there is an awkward picture of dude in a speedo on the cover. However, this book, or rather the author, was recommended. So I read it.

It ended up being a very good book. It's not
Show More
super long - only 295 pages - so I was able to read it rather quickly. I guess that's a good thing, but a short book always means that you get to the end faster and spend less time with the characters than you would have liked. That was definitely true for this book. The main character, Eric, is an athlete (not something I can relate to, having left behind the dread and exhaustion of middle school sports and summer swim teams 2 years ago). Though he is still overweight, he is a really good long distance swimmer and kicks butt. His best friend, Sarah Byrnes, has a really badly scared face, and is as tough as anything. As in any good book, there is more to them than either of their appearances. Their friendship is really interesting - not in the gossipy/secrets way, but in the I-need-your-friendship and lean-on-me way. Other characters include Eric's swimming coach (my favorite character), the guy who bullied Sarah Byrnes and Eric in middle school, and Sarah Byrnes' father.

Both Sarah Byrnes' scars and Eric's weight issues help me relate to their characters. Is there anyone who hasn't thought they looked fat or wished their face looked different? No, probably not. If someone's out there and reading this who hasn't, I envy you. Eric and Sarah Byrnes work through and despite of their physical appearances, gaining love and respect anyway; they are happy. I respect them.

I can't stand stories with sad endings, and stories with emotional not-sad-or-happy endings make me cry. Hard. For hours. I like this book's ending. There is drama and scary moments, emotional realizations and great stuff, but everything turns out okay in the end, with my favorite characters better for it.

I enjoyed this book and definately ecomend it.
Show Less
LibraryThing member cestovatela
I really wanted to like this book. The synopsis was so promising: Sarah Byrnes, whose face was disfigured in a fire at the age of three, befriends a boy who is an outcast because of his weight. As Moby, the boy, joins the swim team and gets in shape, the friendship is threatened. Except that's not
Show More
actually what the book is about. Moby is the narrator, and the book is as much about his life on the swim team, his current events class, and his clash with a Christian Fundamentalist at his school. The friendship and conflict with Sarah developed before the main part of the narrative, and though her mental breakdown fuels the plot, Moby's life and experiences receive far more weight. I was frustrated that just when the book developed some real emotional resonance, it devolved into a gratuitous action scene that strained the story's teetering credibility past its breaking point. This might be easier to forgive if Sarah had been more involved in the crazy denouement, but we hear her story mostly through others' words. The book really should have been her story, and I constantly felt that she had been displaced by the narrator's far less interesting character.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Marshahawkins
This was my second Crutcher book and I was a little disappointed to notice a similar formula as Deadline: discussions in class address major cultural issues, main character is sports star, an adult teacher serves as confidant, secondary antagonist is a fellow student that either dies or commits
Show More
suicide. Still, Deadline was such a great book because the main character was so intriguing. The formula worked because of the language and the relationships among the characters. I just couldn’t quite bond with this main character, Eric. His friendship with Sarah Byrnes was not believable enough for me and its setting lacked depth. I’m not going to let this book change my mind on Chris Crutcher, I think he is a great writer. I just hope this suspiciously similar formula is not his signature.
Show Less
LibraryThing member woollymammoth
I have no idea why I have this book. I brought it when I was into reading teen books because I was a teenager. I think it was quite good but I don't remember this.
LibraryThing member cfordLIS722
Moby is a highschool boy who has been overweight his whole life, until he joins the swimming team and slims down. His best friend is comotose in a mental hospital and won't talk to anyone. Moby tries to help his friend get better by talking to her. A very moving story about frienship and the
Show More
ability to change.
Show Less

Rating

(362 ratings; 4.1)

Pages

224
Page: 0.3176 seconds