Georgie Goes West

by Robert Bright

Hardcover, 1973

Status

Available

Call number

E Bri

Publication

Doubleday (1973), Edition: 1st, 43 pages

Description

On a trip West, Georgie the ghost and his friends help to foil horse thieves.

Media reviews

Kirkus
"When the Whittakers go west in a house on wheels and Georgie rides along in the traveling attic, everything out there in Big Country seems much too big for the gentle little ghost. But then Georgie finds and helps to capture the horse thieves who have stolen a little Indian boy's pinto, and he
Show More
ends up praised and proud and comfortable in a new feather bonnet. Proving yet again, for those who like it that way, that when Georgie is around even the West is cozy and tame." -Kirkus Review
Show Less
1 more
Helium
It was 1973, and Robert Bright had been writing Georgie books for over a decade. But in the last year of the Nixon administration, he returned to the old-fashioned family with the old-fashioned friendly ghost living in their attic. And he even returns to a nostalgic setting, since the family takes
Show More
a vacation to the American west. It's set in the present, but they still face a timeless showdown with bad guys - in this case, horse thieves who steal the pony of a little boy! "Now everybody knows," Bright writes - echoing the familiar first words of his earlier Georgie books. But this time he finishes it with an old-timey message. ("…that the pioneers went West in covered wagons drawn by horses.") The family with the ghost in their attic decides to travel instead in a modified motor car which is basically a house with a belfry…on wheels. This seems a little unlikely, but it's really just a device to provide the ghost a way to ride along with the family for the rest of their adventure. Bright describes the high mountains and vast plains. The ghost travels with an owl companion, but it's frightened by an enormous mountain eagle. There's also a cat named Herman with the party, and he discovers a big mountain wildcat. And the ghost thought he'd find a cow to be friends with - but it turned out to be a stampeding mob of hundreds! So the west is still a little rugged after all, and Bright emphasizes this with his illustrations. As always, he shades simple sketches using only a few colors - this time, using inky bluish-black lines filled with yellows and greens, to better represent the scenery in the western United States. Bright draws cheerful sketches filled with smiling people and animals. But he does some best to try suggesting the wilderness too! Georgie decides that the west "wasn't only too big but it was much too exciting for a little ghost." Then the family visits an Indian reservation, and decides they need to help the little boy whose pinto was stolen by horse thieves. They haven't found it by the end of the day, and assume the thieves had gotten away. The Indian boy also thought so, and wanted to cry, "But Indians aren't supposed to cry." That particular sentence feels wrong in a couple different ways - suggesting one of the problems of reading a book from 1973. But Bright is trying to set up a situation where the ghost can come to the rescue. Georgie's owl friend patrols the skies, and spots the missing horse with her night eyes. And then the ghost rides the horse back to its rightful owner….
Show Less

User reviews

LibraryThing member AbigailAdams26
Georgie - the shy and gentle little ghost whose adventures began in the eponymous Georgie, and continued in twelve other picture-books, published from 1944-1983 - heads west in this seventh installment of the series, accompanying his human "family," the Whittakers, on vacation. Intimidated, at
Show More
first, by the sheer size of everything out west, Georgie soon finds himself caught up in a mystery involving some stolen Indian ponies. Needless to say, he solves the case in his own inimitable style...

I have to confess that, although I have enjoyed the six Georgie books I have read thus far (there are thirteen altogether), I strongly suspected, going in, that I wouldn't care for Georgie Goes West. I was right. Not only does it have some of those stereotypical "Indian" images in it, the kind that scholar Debbie Reese rightly deconstructs, on her excellent blog, American Indians in Children's Literature, as examples of tribal confusion and homogenization - Kio, the little Indian boy whose horse has been stolen, looks to be living in a Pueblo-style village, but gives Georgie a full Plains-style war-bonnet - it also contains this gem: "Kio thought so and wanted to cry. But Indians aren't supposed to cry."

All Indian nations seen as interchangeable? Check! Indians portrayed as mythical uber-stoics who don't do all the normal human things? Check! Indians being helped along by benevolent whites? Check! Yes, you read that last one right. In 1973, the very same year that American Indian Movement activists were facing off against the FBI, at the Siege of Wounded Knee, this cheerful little picture-book was published, showing all the cowboys and sheriff's men racing off, in order to restore some stolen Indian property. Haha! The irony really is priceless! All of which is to say: this is decidedly not recommended: do yourself a favor, and skip this particular Georgie book!
Show Less

Awards

Language

Physical description

43 p.

ISBN

0385052715 / 9780385052719

Similar in this library

Page: 0.1732 seconds