Status
Call number
Genres
Publication
Description
Fiction. Mystery. HTML: Hardly a day goes by when nine year old Laurent Lepage doesn't cry wolf. From alien invasions, to walking trees, to winged beasts in the woods, to dinosaurs spotted in the village of Three Pines, his tales are so extraordinary no one can possibly believe him. Including Armand and Reine-Marie Gamache, who now live in the little Quebec village. But when the boy disappears, the villagers are faced with the possibility that one of his tall tales might have been true. And so begins a frantic search for the boy and the truth. What they uncover deep in the forest sets off a sequence of events that leads to murder, leads to an old crime, leads to an old betrayal. Leads right to the door of an old poet. And now it is now, writes Ruth Zardo. And the dark thing is here. A monster once visited Three Pines. And put down deep roots. And now, Ruth knows, it is back. Armand Gamache, the former head of homicide for the Sûreté du Québec, must face the possibility that, in not believing the boy, he himself played a terrible part in what happens next… (more)
User reviews
The Nature of the Beast just doesn't measure up to her previous books. Once again we have murders in Three Pines, a tiny village that's become the Cabot Cove of Quebec. Gone are her mouth-watering descriptions of meals eaten at the bistro. Gone are her insightful characterizations. Always before even the worst of her characters have been shown to have shreds of humanity. Here characters like John Fleming are simply evil.
In previous books, Penny would've broken our hearts with little Laurent's fate. Here he's little more than a plot device. I also experienced great anticipation knowing that my favorite character, Ruth Zardo, would have a larger role in this book, but her part fell flat. In fact, the entire book felt flat and slow.
In The Nature of the Beast, too many things stretched belief beyond breaking point-- even something based in truth like the "Whore of Babylon." I am familiar with Penny's current circumstances. Her beloved husband has Alzheimer's, and they've had to move from their idyllic life in the country to a condo in Montreal. Loved ones come before books. They always should. I've seen the deep affection her fans feel for Louise Penny. I am one of those fans, and I don't think I'm the only one who would rather she take some time off instead of risk causing irreparable harm to characters and to a village so many of us adore.
I want to make fun of this book. Penny’s plots are always complicated, but in this case one of the main clues, hidden in the script of a play, was downright ridiculous. The role played by an infamous serial killer was improbable. I suppose it is possible to hide a big-ass weapon in the woods near an adorable village with a bistro and used bookstore and B&B, but for me it strained credulity.
So, I want to make fun of this book, but it was so, so good! The story was riveting and all my dear favorite characters were on the case. In case audiobook fans are leery of the new narrator, who replaced the late Ralph Cosham – fear not, he’s very good.
This novel is set in Three Pines but is not a straight murder mystery. Once again Gamache must save the world singlehandedly - a bit far fetched and
Still it was an enjoyable listen but I am not sure I'll revisit this book anytime soon.
Armand Gamache has retired from the Homicide unit in Quebec, Canada. He and wife Renie Marie have moved to Three Pines, the small, well-hidden town that readers were first introduced to in the first book
However, Gamache cannot escape murder and his former colleagues at the Surete du Quebec. When a small boys turns up dead it is first ruled at an accident but Gamache isn't so sure and it turns out he is right. Who would kill a 9-year-old who had a wild imagination and loved to talk about space aliens, big guns and monsters?
The answers eventually lead back to one of the worst periods of Gamache's life. I had no idea the "who killed him" in this one but then, I seldom do in Penny's books. She is a master at giving multiple possibilities and putting out distractions that are much easier to follow than the true killer.
Now, to wait for a year until the next book.
Isabelle Lacoste and Jean-Guy Beauvoir, of the Sûreté du Quebec, are summoned to Three Pines to investigate. Aramand Gamache, former head of homicide, retired and living in the remote village, works with his former staff to solve the crime. What they uncover deep in the forest sets off a sequence of events, which leads to an old crime, an old betrayal, and another murder. And last but not least – leads to the door of the cantankerous old poet, Ruth Zardo. And now it is now, she writes. And the dark thing is here.
The Nature of the Beast is the eleventh Three Pines novel. Penny does not disappoint with a solid story line and her usual roundup of eclectic characters – the Three Pines regulars, and, in this case, two mysterious CSIS agents and an aging physics professor from McGill Universtiy. If you’ve read and enjoyed the rest of this series, you must visit The Nature of the Beast.
The story takes place here Three Pines village, Canada, where Inspector Gamache and a slew of others want to find out who killed a boy who discovered a "monster" in the woods. At first everyone thinks the monster is just another make believe creature, but they soon discover that it really exists, just not as they imagined it was. Once the secret gets out, all kinds of people show up to examine the monster and see what it turns out to be. Meanwhile there is a play someone wants to put on and the boy's murder is still under investigation.
Yes, I felt that there were a lot of sub plots all rolling around together in one giant knot of story, but it didn't put me off in any way and as in all interwoven mysteries, each character's story has its purpose for being there. The writing style is such that I honestly felt as if I could have been watching a movie, which helped me settle into what others might consider to be confusion. The characters and plot were all clear to me, thanks to a pleasant writing style and narration that made the hours pass by quickly as I listened.
I finished the book feeling intrigued and felt as if I might want to explore the rest of the series. I love to read mysteries, but I generally figure them out right away. This one kept me unsure until nearly the end.
I don't know how she does it. I keep thinking that there will be one book in the series that isn't quite as engaging. One book that I can put down for longer than a few minutes without wondering what happens next. But so far, each one is as good as the last. [The Nature of the Beast] combines a satisfying mystery with excellent writing and continued character development, especially for Inspector Gamache. If you haven't read any of Louise Penny's mysteries, I recommend starting with at the beginning of the series because the characters grow and develop over time. Also, if you haven't read any of Louise Penny's mysteries, I'm a bit jealous because I would love to have this whole series stretching out in front of me. As it is, I'll just have to wait for next August to revisit my friends in Three Pines.
For those who are looking for cafe au lait and brioche by the fire in the bistro, and quirky quips from Gabri and Ruth, they are there, but they are more solemn, more philosophical, and not as lighthearted as some readers may prefer.
No true Gamache fan would dare give away a plot, and it was for this reason that I even refrained from reading the little tidbits that Miss Louise doled out over the last couple months. I wanted to read the entire book cover to cover so that I could feel the building tension, keep my mind spinning with all the marvelous possibilities Penny builds into her stories, and sit back with a grand sigh of satisfaction when the last page is read. Once again , she does not disappoint. The characters are the same (but they continue growing), the setting is the same (Three Pines after all is another character), and there is a murder. But the plot, the motivations, the murder itself, and the side/subplots are just new and different enough to make the reader, and the true fan say "She's still at the top of her game." It's magnificent. Don't miss it.
And then there are the mysteries. Penny's mysteries are always unique,
In The Nature of the Beast, Penny explores the concept of the boy who cried wolf, and what it means for a community when that child is finally telling the truth and still no one believes him. Monsters are more real than the characters, or readers, want to believe, and history creates a trail that can cause destruction in the present.
Three Pines is the name of the quiet village that former Chief Inspector Armand Gamache and his wife Reine-Marie have settled down in, since his retirement. She had once had a career at the National Library. The small
In this, the eleventh novel, the new narrator does an excellent job creating the tension of the murder investigation and also of expressing the humorous aspects of the broad assortment of characters as they interact. I have to admit that I was so engaged with the story that I listened from beginning to end in one day. I couldn’t wait to discover how the mystery would resolve itself. All of the loose ends were eventually tied up, and I think the author may have set it up for the next one in the series, or perhaps for one later on down the road, since some of the characters seemed to have left a kind of fingerprint for the next one, indicating that they might someday return to resolve other issues. There will always be those demented creatures desiring to invent destructive weapons, once the door opens on the possibility; there will always be those who try to prevent them and protect society. Also, it was mentioned that Inspector Gamache has been offered the job as Superintendent of the Sûreté du Québec. One is left conjecturing about whether or not he would take the job offer or would both he and his wife go into more professorial pursuits, like Professor Rosenblatt, the authority on guns.
Briefly, the story revolves around a young boy who has a reputation for telling lies. He is found murdered only a short time after he came running into the town’s bistro and excitedly announced that he had discovered a huge weapon in the woods, a weapon with a seven-headed monster writhing upon it. Needless to say, his story was not believed until his body was found and the weapon was discovered. Former Chief Inspector Gamache had been close to the child and although retired, he was drawn into the investigation, aiding the new Chief Inspector, Isabelle Lacoste. The twists and turns take the reader into the world of Gerald Bull, Saddam Hussein, the Viet Nam War, and John Fleming, a mad serial killer resembling the likes of Hannibal Lechter.
The story is cleverly rolled out with a wide assortment of subplots which misdirect and confuse, so the reader is always wondering what will happen next The mystery concerns Project Babylon, a secret program to develop a supergun, a weapon of mass destruction. While I found the idea a bit implausible, at the end of the audio, I learned that the story is actually based on the real Gerald Bull, a Canadian Artillery Expert commissioned by Saddam Hussein to build real superguns which were called Baby Babylon and Big Babylon. Fortunately, the weapon failed to work, but there still may be madmen out there trying to recreate a working model. The story was exciting as the search for the murderer progressed and the history of the weapon and its designer became the focus of the investigation. Fingers were pointed in many different directions which only enhanced the mystery. Sometimes it even felt that something supernatural might even be lurking in the background.
I fell in love with Inspector Gamache. I connected completely with his mostly quiet and thoughtful approach to crime solving and his willingness to put his life on the line to do what was right, willing to make the hard choices necessary to protect the most people. He seemed to exhibit that thoughtfulness in his relationship with his wife and in his approach to his retirement, as well. Reine-Marie was the ideal wife, completely supportive; they seemed fulfilled and content, simpatico, which made me admire them both. No one minor character in the novel seemed to take precedence over another. It was mostly about the Inspector and his approach to solving the crime and the mystery of the murder and the supergun.
I wondered if the opening scene with someone running from pursuers in the woods was meant to be a part of the boy’s imagination, his version of how he discovered the weapon, or was it simply a merging of the first and last scenes of the book, the discovery of the weapon and the end of it. It was definitely a device used to indicate some clues and to misdirect the reader since the person running seemed older than a boy with a stick that morphed into a rifle.
The death of the 9 year old supposedly effects all the village residents but the reactions of the villagers seem to be more toward the massive threat from the rocket launcher than anything else.
I really didn't enjoy this one as much as the other Three Pines novels because the personal interactions didn't seem to be the same.
That said, it is still a pretty enjoyable mystery with
I find it interesting how much Yeats’ poem, The Second Coming, has become a staple reference of literature and commentary. I guess it feels totally apropos in this new era.