Status
Series
Genres
Publication
Description
A one-volume narrative history of the Mediterranean from Ancient Egypt to 1919. Written in the racy, readable prose for which author Norwich is famous, this is colorful, character-driven history. He tackles a vast subject--vast in time, from the oldest surviving pyramid to the First World War; vast in geography, from Gibraltar to Jerusalem; and vast in culture, including as it does the civilizations of the Phoenicians, the Egyptians, Greece, Carthage, Rome and Byzantium, the Borgias and the Medicis, Muhammad and El Cid, Napoleon and Nelson, Moslems, Jews and Christians. This book is not a dry record of facts; it is a rackety read about historical figures--dissolute popes and wily emperors, noble-hearted generals and beautiful princesses. Towns are besieged and sacked, kingdoms won and lost. The narrative covers the glories of Constantinople and Venice, and the stirring history of the islands of Malta, Sicily, Crete and Cyprus.--From publisher description.… (more)
User reviews
Negative points: the first half of the book, inevitably, often reads like a condensed version of his earlier books on Byzantium, Sicily and Venice. If you've read those, you will probably end up skimming quite a lot here. Norwich, oddly for someone supposedly writing the history of a sea, isn't particularly interested in ships or naval affairs - any Patrick O'Brian fan will spot a few minor howlers of a technical nature, and will be disappointed to find Nelson's pursuit of the French fleet and the battle of the Nile treated in a couple of paragraphs, while his relationship with Lady Hamilton and the Neapolitan court gets about half a chapter. Don't read this book looking for profound academic analysis - but do expect to find the author taking advantage of the privileges of age and showing clearly where his sympathies lie i.e. with Byzantium, Venice, Norman Sicily and Moorish Spain and against Catholic Spain, the Hapsburgs and the Bourbons.
The book comes with a lot of nice glossy photographs, most of them rather unoriginally selected. The maps are adequate, if a bit on the mean side, and the book includes a useful index, bibliography and some apparently randomly-selected family trees.
As a result, we're left with writing that looks something like this: Caesar conquered Gaul. He returned to Rome and entered an alliance with Pompey and Crassus. Crassus went to Syria where he was defeated and killed by the Parthians. Pompey and Caesar had a civil war. Caesar chased Pompey to Egypt where he seduced Cleopatra. He returned to Rome where he was killed in the Senate. Mark Antony and Octavian avenged Caesar, then had their own civil war. Octavian won, changed his name to Augustus and became Emperor.
There, the last twenty years of the Roman Republic in one paragraph, mission accomplished. If that's the kind of writing you enjoy, and you don't already know the most basic historical background, then have at it.
Added to the faulty concept, is a very informal and borderline inappropriate writing style which detracts from the work.
I must say that after the initial 100 pages, wherein the author tears through 3,500 years of ancient history, things do improve, however not to the point of presenting a rational, well presented view of regional history.
In the Introduction, the author himself states, "...how could the whole thing possibly be compressed into one volume?" IT CAN'T, and therein lies the problem. I've thought that perhaps it could be helpful for a junior high student with no background in history whatsoever, but upon reflection, any effort that attempts a history of Ancient Greece in nine pages, the rise of Islam and the succeeding Caliphates of Damascus, Baghdad and al-Andalus in 14 pages and, believe it or not, Ancient Egypt in two pages, should best be left alone.
This is the
For anyone who just wants an 'overview' - this is your book. For those who want in-depth it would be better to look elsewhere.