Dreams of El Dorado : a history of the American West

by H. W. Brands

Hardcover, 2019




New York : Basic Books, Hachette Book Group, 2019.


By the time he became president in 1801, Thomas Jefferson had already been looking west for decades. He saw the country's population expanding and he judged that America's territory must expand too, lest America become as crowded and conflict-prone as Europe. He started modestly, by seeking to purchase New Orleans from the French. Napoleon Bonaparte answered with a breathtaking proposal: would the Americans care to purchase all of Louisiana? Jefferson said yes and soon enough had dispatched two explorers, Meriwether Lewis and William Clark, to find a passage across the new territory to the Pacific. In Dreams of El Dorado, the bestselling author H. W. Brands captures the experiences of the men and women who headed into this new territory, from Lewis and Clark's expedition in early 19th century to the closing of the frontier in the early 20th. He introduces us to explorers, mountain men, cowboys, missionaries, and soldiers; he takes us on the Oregon Trail, to John Jacob Astor's fur trading outpost in the Pacific Northwest, to Texas during its revolution and California during the gold rush and to Little Big Horn on the day of Custer's defeat at the hands of the Indian general Crazy Horse. Not every American who went West sought immense wealth but most expected a greater competence than they could find in the East. Their dreams drove them to feats of courage and perseverance that put their stay-at-home cousins to shame; their dreams also drove them to outrageous acts of violence against indigenous peoples, foreigners and one another. Throughout, Brands explodes many longstanding myths, reorienting our view of the West and of American history more broadly. The West was often viewed as the last bastion of American individualism but woven through its entire history was a strong thread of collectivism. Westerners sneered, even snarled, at federal power but federal power was essential to the development of the West. The West was America's unspoiled Eden but the spoilage of the West proceeded more rapidly than that of any other region. The West was where whites fought Indians but they rarely went into battle without Indian allies and their ranks included black soldiers. The West was where fortune beckoned, where riches would reward the miner's persistence, the cattleman's courage, the railroad man's enterprise, the bonanza farmer's audacity; but El Dorado was at least as elusive in the West as it ever was in the East. A sweeping, engrossing work of narrative history, Dreams of El Dorado will forever change how we think about the making of the American nation.… (more)

User reviews

LibraryThing member santhony
Many years ago, I read a non-fiction book whose subject was a history of the Mediterranean world. I think most people would agree that this would be a subject hard to cover in a single book. Consider, we are dealing with Ancient Egypt, Ancient Greece, the Roman Empire, the Italian Renaissance, the Middle Ages, the Crusades, the Muslim Conquest, World War II, just to name a few.

The book was a mess. How do you cover Ancient Egypt in 14 pages? The Roman Empire got a whole chapter. It had no value whatsoever for even the most cursory review of the history of the region. I felt much the same, though to a lesser degree about this book.

There is a chapter on the Lewis and Clark Expedition; a chapter on the transcontinental railroad; one on the California Gold Rush; a couple of chapters on the Native American population; a chapter on Texas cattle drives and one on Texas Independence. You get the idea, far too little exposure to far too important topics.

Instead of reading this book, read Stephen Ambrose’s Undaunted Courage, a comprehensive treatment of the Lewis and Clark Voyage of Discovery. Read Ambrose’s Nothing Like it in the World, an outstanding book on the building of the transcontinental railroad. Read Lonesome Dove, though fictional, the best novel I’ve ever read, which paints a portrait of a Texas cattle drive and interaction between white settlers and Plains Indians. Read James Michener’s Texas if you want to know everything there is to know about that state (again historical fiction).

The point is, these subjects are deserving of a deeper treatment than afforded by a book of this type. I would not even recommend it for a beginner, as such a cursory examination cannot possibly give a reader any understanding of the subject. The author, H. W. Brand, has written many fine biographies and histories. In this case, his mistake was on the scope of the subject matter.
… (more)
LibraryThing member jmarchetti
Brand's work is a great introduction to American Western history for the general reader. The book is arranged in thematic parts, with individual chapters acting as vignetts to tell the story. Brand identifies a number of themes that run through the West: the evoking and shattering of dreams, violence against the Plains indians, and Irony as well. Especially important is his ability to draw aside the curtain on the individualistic West and notes how vital Federal support for the west was. Whether it was the Homestead Act, railroad land grants, or military power, Brands is correct to note that "federal power was essential to the development of the West.

The book covers the period from the Lewis and Clark Expedition to the closing of the Frontier in the early twentieth century. The book is well written, and an enjoyable read. Specialists will probably not find much new here, but this is a great starting point for those who have an interest in the subject
… (more)
LibraryThing member Tuke15
This book seemed like a good thing. It gave some of the history of the America West. It just jumped around too much for me.

I received this book from Goodreads and was under no obligation to leave a review.



Page: 0.4478 seconds