Closed in Silence

by Joan M. Drury

Paperback, 1998

Status

Available

Call number

PS3554.R82C58 1998

Collection

Publication

Duluth, MN : Spinsters Ink, 1998.

Description

Writer and reluctant sleuth Tyler Jones joins some old friends on an island in Puget Sound, and what begins as a purely nostalgic occasion suddenly turns into murder. A body is found and in their pursuit of the killer, the women share their stories breaking open the circle of silence that keeps women mute, separate and closed in silence.

User reviews

LibraryThing member csoki637
Alas, this is the last of Joan Drury's lesbian-feminist mystery trilogy. Where else will I find suspenseful novels filled with radical feminist politics and rest assured that the corpse the protagonist and her dog will inevitably stumble upon will likely be that of a deserving man?

Set on a secluded
Show More
island off the Pacific coast, the mystery unravels during a college reunion of sorts. Six friends meet up, for the first time in decades, to catch up and tie up loose ends. Finally, after two books of vague references to the woman who broke Tyler's heart, we get the scoop on Julie; we also meet some new characters from Tyler's past, rounding out the picture of her years at the University of Minnesota. The women have hardly settled down on the island when Tyler, as she is wont to do, stumbles across a dead body. Questions abound, exposing truths and lies. Is there a murderer in their midst?

As with her other novels, Drury uses her story to reflect on violence against women, exposing men's brutality and its impacts on women. She dabbles into the notable feminist debates of the time — here, the question of prostitution as sexual violence or a choice. You'll also find references to Andrea Dworkin and Kathleen Barry.

I'm glad to have read this book with the context of the previous two; Tyler is a familiar protagonist, and the final novel in the series builds on her past, while fleshing out unexplored aspects of her character. We've seen her in San Francisco, in northeast Minnesota, struggling with sobriety, joking with Mary Sharon, catching up with family members — and, now, reunited with the women she went to school with, it all comes together.

I do have a quibble carrying over from the previous books. Despite her otherwise feminist politics, Drury seems to have a thing for the word "slut"; Aggie the slut, Tyler the slut, and now, Mary Sharon, the "shlut." If it's meant to be a joke (and it is), it's not a very funny one.

In any case, I'm sad to see the series end, and if I'm ever in Minnesota, I will definitely pay Drury's bookstore in Grand Marais a visit.
Show Less

Awards

Minnesota Book Awards (Finalist — Mystery — 1999)

Language

Original publication date

1998

Physical description

195 p.; 8.2 inches

ISBN

188352329X / 9781883523299

Local notes

OCLC = 162

Similar in this library

Page: 0.4914 seconds