Publication
Allison & Busby, c2015.
Series
Status
Available
Description
Fiction. Mystery. Historical Fiction. HTML: Four years after she set sail from England, leaving everything she most loved behind, Maisie Dobbs at last returns, only to find herself in a dangerous place . . . In Jacqueline Winspear's powerful story of political intrigue and personal tragedy, a brutal murder in the British garrison town of Gibraltar leads Maisie into a web of lies, deceit, and peril. Spring 1937. In the four years since she left England, Maisie Dobbs has experienced love, contentment, stability�??and the deepest tragedy a woman can endure. Now, all she wants is the peace she believes she might find by returning to India. But her sojourn in the hills of Darjeeling is cut short when her stepmother summons her home to England; her aging father Frankie Dobbs is not getting any younger. But on a ship bound for England, Maisie realizes she isn't ready to return. Against the wishes of the captain who warns her, "You will be alone in a most dangerous place," she disembarks in Gibraltar. Though she is on her own, Maisie is far from alone: the British garrison town is teeming with refugees fleeing a brutal civil war across the border in Spain. Yet the danger is very real. Days after Maisie's arrival, a photographer and member of Gibraltar's Sephardic Jewish community, Sebastian Babayoff, is murdered, and Maisie becomes entangled in the case, drawing the attention of the British Secret Service. Under the suspicious eye of a British agent, Maisie is pulled deeper into political intrigue on "the Rock"�??arguably Britain's most important strategic territory�??and renews an uneasy acquaintance in the process. At a crossroads between her past and her future, Maisie must choose a direction, knowing that England is, for her, an equally dangerous place, but in quite a different… (more)
User reviews
LibraryThing member etxgardener
If this had been the first Maisie Dobbs book I've read, I would have rated it three stars for being a somewhat overwrought spy thriller. But since I have been a devoted Maisie devotee for 1 books, and since I waited almost three years for the next installment, all I can say is shame on you
Winspear opends this book in 1937, three years after ending Leaving Everything Most Loved and then proceeds to sum up what has happened with Maisie (sou searching in India, marrying James, moving to Canada and finally being happy, becoming pregnant and then losing James in a plane crash and her unborn child as a result of that crash) in 18(!!) pages all related in epistolary fashion through letters, telegrams and newspaper articles. I should have just tossed the book aside at this point, but no, I plowed on.
Maisie then has to go on some kind of grief pilgrimage, cutting off contact with everyone she knows, finally ending up, once again, in india. Maisie has always had an unfortunate habit of naval gazing, but in this book she takes it to the point or narcissism. Finally, a letter from her step-mother, Brenda, reminding her that Frankie, her much beloved father, isn't getting any younger, prods Maisie to book passage back to England.
But wait! The closer she gets to home, the more she's all a-twitter that she just cannot possibly face it, so she jumps ship at Gibralter. There, she literally stumbles over a dead body (there is always one of those, isn't there?) and even though the police tell her that the man has been killed by a refugee (one of many apparently) from the Spanish Civil War, Maisie decides that she must discover THE TRUTH, and in the manner of the best Nosy Parkers, starts to stick her nose in things that certainly are none of her business.
There are pages of ruminations about her old mentor Maurice - ruminations that have all been said in previous books - and for someone who is supposed to be intelligent, Maisie shows a singular lack of knowledge of what was going on in Spain. Perhaps in her self absorption she has neglected to ever read a newspaper?
There are new characters galore, most of whom I didn't care about. Robbie McFarland makes an appearance and if he is really with Special Branch, why doesn't he just arrest her & put her on the next boat home? She is in a British territory after all? But no, he just lets her take a joy ride into Spain where, of course, she meets another sainted nun who is thinking of nothing but helping the poor war torn Spaniards. The end of the book finds her sending messages back to England and going back to Spain to work with the nun.
Enough! At first I thought that Winspear, tired of her character was just fulfilling a book contract, but now I think that she's taking Maisie out of the realm of mystery stories and into the land of spy thrillers just in time for World War II. If that is so, may I suggest that she has her character bone up on world politics and start thinking about someone other than herself because I cannot take another mes of a book like this one.
Show More
Jacqueline Winspear! Plenty of spoilers to come as I elaborate on why I hated this book.Winspear opends this book in 1937, three years after ending Leaving Everything Most Loved and then proceeds to sum up what has happened with Maisie (sou searching in India, marrying James, moving to Canada and finally being happy, becoming pregnant and then losing James in a plane crash and her unborn child as a result of that crash) in 18(!!) pages all related in epistolary fashion through letters, telegrams and newspaper articles. I should have just tossed the book aside at this point, but no, I plowed on.
Maisie then has to go on some kind of grief pilgrimage, cutting off contact with everyone she knows, finally ending up, once again, in india. Maisie has always had an unfortunate habit of naval gazing, but in this book she takes it to the point or narcissism. Finally, a letter from her step-mother, Brenda, reminding her that Frankie, her much beloved father, isn't getting any younger, prods Maisie to book passage back to England.
But wait! The closer she gets to home, the more she's all a-twitter that she just cannot possibly face it, so she jumps ship at Gibralter. There, she literally stumbles over a dead body (there is always one of those, isn't there?) and even though the police tell her that the man has been killed by a refugee (one of many apparently) from the Spanish Civil War, Maisie decides that she must discover THE TRUTH, and in the manner of the best Nosy Parkers, starts to stick her nose in things that certainly are none of her business.
There are pages of ruminations about her old mentor Maurice - ruminations that have all been said in previous books - and for someone who is supposed to be intelligent, Maisie shows a singular lack of knowledge of what was going on in Spain. Perhaps in her self absorption she has neglected to ever read a newspaper?
There are new characters galore, most of whom I didn't care about. Robbie McFarland makes an appearance and if he is really with Special Branch, why doesn't he just arrest her & put her on the next boat home? She is in a British territory after all? But no, he just lets her take a joy ride into Spain where, of course, she meets another sainted nun who is thinking of nothing but helping the poor war torn Spaniards. The end of the book finds her sending messages back to England and going back to Spain to work with the nun.
Enough! At first I thought that Winspear, tired of her character was just fulfilling a book contract, but now I think that she's taking Maisie out of the realm of mystery stories and into the land of spy thrillers just in time for World War II. If that is so, may I suggest that she has her character bone up on world politics and start thinking about someone other than herself because I cannot take another mes of a book like this one.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Stroudley
Gibraltar is a stopping-off place for Maisie on her way home to England, and in some ways, this book feels like a stopping-off place - a stepping stone if you like - between the last book in the series and the next. The background of Gibraltar and particularly the Spanish Civil War (+ the Guernica
Show More
episode) are well described, and as several reviewers have commented, fill in some gaps in our general awareness of this period. I the final analysis though, I found that I didn't really care that much about what happened to the characters(!), and felt that things would be much improved if Maisie was back in the UK with some of the familiar characters around her. Show Less
LibraryThing member michigantrumpet
Maisie Dobbs finds herself in Gibraltar, licking her wounds after recent tragedy. Literally stumbling over a dead body, she suspects the police explanation of the murder is lacking. Not specifically hired by anyone and thus not an 'official' case, Maisie still feels the circumstances require her
Now, for a rant and why I doubt I'll read any further in this series (WARNING Spoliers abound!): Writers of series such of this have a certain compact of fidelity with their readers. Loyal followers have invested time, expense and emotion in the story and characters. In the lead up to this latest installment, we have suffered mightily with Miss Dobbs. We have watched the ever kind, handsome and patient James plight his troth over several books. When last we left Maisie, she has finally promised a 'yes' or 'no' answer to his proposal. So, what happens? Within the space of a few short pages related in cursory fashion, we are propelled forward four years, only to learn of their blissful wedding, happy marriage and blessed hopes as expected parents. Husband and child are summarily killed by plane and miscarriage. By page 18 or so we are washed upon the shores of Gibraltar.
What? We don't get to experience the answer to the proposal? The wedding? Some of their happiness? The answer to several books gone by of how she'll handle her work and marriage? Talk about a betrayal of those who have stuck around this long! And now we get more inner angst and navel gazing? Talk about pulling the rug out! I understand killing off major characters. Had we been there for the promised pay off, perhaps we could join more fully in her incredible grief.
On top of which, Maisie has become hideously self indulgent, selfish and petulant. She escapes off the grid, avoiding all contact with her elderly infirm father, whom she hasn't seen since her marriage -- and is clearly worried about her. She refuses to go to England, thus denying her dead husband's parents the chance to even hold a Memorial service as they await her return. They can't have the service without the daughter-in-law widow. And Maisie knows they can't but still doesn't go back. Who does this? And it gets fixed by blithe little letters with no return address assuming their understanding?
I am thoroughly tired of Miss Dobbs and I suspect Ms. Winspear must be as well to have had such an abrupt off-screen deus ex machina veering of plot. I give this two stars -- one for the author writing it and one for me for reading it.
Show More
intervention. Her investigation takes her into Spain at the height of hostilities in that benighted Civil War -- most definitely a 'dangerous place.' However, the title may also refer to Maisie's inner turmoil as she deals with her personal demons. Readers familiar with the first ten books of this series know Maisie has much practice in dealing with inner demons. Now, for a rant and why I doubt I'll read any further in this series (WARNING Spoliers abound!):
What? We don't get to experience the answer to the proposal? The wedding? Some of their happiness? The answer to several books gone by of how she'll handle her work and marriage? Talk about a betrayal of those who have stuck around this long! And now we get more inner angst and navel gazing? Talk about pulling the rug out! I understand killing off major characters. Had we been there for the promised pay off, perhaps we could join more fully in her incredible grief.
On top of which, Maisie has become hideously self indulgent, selfish and petulant. She escapes off the grid, avoiding all contact with her elderly infirm father, whom she hasn't seen since her marriage -- and is clearly worried about her. She refuses to go to England, thus denying her dead husband's parents the chance to even hold a Memorial service as they await her return. They can't have the service without the daughter-in-law widow. And Maisie knows they can't but still doesn't go back. Who does this? And it gets fixed by blithe little letters with no return address assuming their understanding?
I am thoroughly tired of Miss Dobbs and I suspect Ms. Winspear must be as well to have had such an abrupt off-screen deus ex machina veering of plot. I give this two stars -- one for the author writing it and one for me for reading it.
Show Less
LibraryThing member PhilipJHunt
I'm coming late to the Maisie Dobbs library expecting a mysterious whodunnit. But this is different. And the back story would help. Not that Winspear doesn't do a good job of bringing first readers up to date. She does. But the personal story of Maisie is such a big part of this book, that starting
The book is mostly about Maisie, rather than the detective work she does. Indeed, the mystery is rather a hook on which to hang musings about Maisie's struggles, and her continuing life adventures.
Show More
in the beginning would obviously be a different experience than dipping here so late in her journey.The book is mostly about Maisie, rather than the detective work she does. Indeed, the mystery is rather a hook on which to hang musings about Maisie's struggles, and her continuing life adventures.
Show Less
LibraryThing member cathyskye
Maisie isn't the only person at a crossroads. As concerns this series, I am, too. Longtime fans will probably be as stunned as I over the first few pages of A Dangerous Place. In a series of letters, Winspear deals with four momentous years in Maisie's life with what can only be described as brisk
Winspear does her usual marvelous job in giving readers a real feel for the setting. With the Spanish Civil War raging just over the border, with the build-up to World War II, Gibraltar's strategic position makes it extremely valuable to many countries, and it seems that they all have representatives in place, lurking around the corners of buildings and following Maisie wherever she goes.
The author has also created a strong secondary cast-- Salazar the café owner, Mrs. Bishop the owner of the guesthouse, and the dead man's sister among them. The more the story unfolds, the more it seems that no one is whom they first appear to be, and with the number of people spying on others it's a miracle they don't start tripping over each other. This is a presentiment of another problem I'm beginning to have with a series I've loved since its inception.
The closer to World War II the series becomes, the more the storylines are delving into the shadowy world of spies and double-dealing. I've never cared for spy novels, so I'm definitely not enjoying this foray into that world. But as a character told Maisie in a previous book, once those spy organizations get their hooks into you, they don't let you go. I really don't want to see Maisie go down that road.
Although the mystery is rather slow to unfold, it does pick up speed and becomes quite intriguing. I enjoyed watching Maisie solve a complex case, just as I enjoyed the author's depiction of Gibraltar at this very tumultuous time. I'm deeply invested in Winspear's character. Maisie's story has grown from being a rags-to-riches tale to something deeper and much more meaningful. But for the past few books, Maisie has seemed to take two steps back to every three steps forward. Her experiences during World War I have left an indelible mark upon her of which she seems unwilling or unable to let go. With her constant musing on the past, I just can't quite see her as a successful spy in the next calamitous war to come. I am at a crossroads, and I am actually wondering if I'll be continuing with this series-- something that would have been completely unthinkable in the past.
Show More
efficiency. I can understand her desire not to bog down the narrative, but since Maisie is already constantly harking back to time spent with her mentor or her service in World War I or her college days or what her best friend would say to her, what's a little more time spent on telling readers about those four years?Winspear does her usual marvelous job in giving readers a real feel for the setting. With the Spanish Civil War raging just over the border, with the build-up to World War II, Gibraltar's strategic position makes it extremely valuable to many countries, and it seems that they all have representatives in place, lurking around the corners of buildings and following Maisie wherever she goes.
The author has also created a strong secondary cast-- Salazar the café owner, Mrs. Bishop the owner of the guesthouse, and the dead man's sister among them. The more the story unfolds, the more it seems that no one is whom they first appear to be, and with the number of people spying on others it's a miracle they don't start tripping over each other. This is a presentiment of another problem I'm beginning to have with a series I've loved since its inception.
The closer to World War II the series becomes, the more the storylines are delving into the shadowy world of spies and double-dealing. I've never cared for spy novels, so I'm definitely not enjoying this foray into that world. But as a character told Maisie in a previous book, once those spy organizations get their hooks into you, they don't let you go. I really don't want to see Maisie go down that road.
Although the mystery is rather slow to unfold, it does pick up speed and becomes quite intriguing. I enjoyed watching Maisie solve a complex case, just as I enjoyed the author's depiction of Gibraltar at this very tumultuous time. I'm deeply invested in Winspear's character. Maisie's story has grown from being a rags-to-riches tale to something deeper and much more meaningful. But for the past few books, Maisie has seemed to take two steps back to every three steps forward. Her experiences during World War I have left an indelible mark upon her of which she seems unwilling or unable to let go. With her constant musing on the past, I just can't quite see her as a successful spy in the next calamitous war to come. I am at a crossroads, and I am actually wondering if I'll be continuing with this series-- something that would have been completely unthinkable in the past.
Show Less
LibraryThing member khiemstra631
The only book that I have ever read that book place on Gibralter, this book has stayed with me for that reason. Kudos to Winspear for coming up with a completely new version of a locked room mystery. World War II is drawing near, and Maisie is in a deep depression after major upheavals in her life.
Show More
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Show Less
LibraryThing member BooksCooksLooks
I don’t recall how many Maisie Dobbs books I’ve read at this point. I do remember falling in love with the character when I first discovered her and wanting to read everything I could in which she was the focus. Then for some reason the books changed and I became disillusioned with Maisie; the
That is not what I found when I read this tale. Instead Maisie’s trip and the major life changes that occur are compressed into a few short pages in the beginning and all of the build up from the previous book is basically over and done in two minutes of reading. I again felt betrayed and really didn’t want to continue reading but was committed to this review. So continue I did. Maisie is heading home to England but really doesn’t want to be going home. On the way she disembarks in Gibraltar to settle herself. While there she stumbles on a dead body and decides to find out who killed him and why. Her pursuit of this starts to give her life some substance. She also struggles to sort out the culture of Gibraltar and to try and understand the Civil War going on over the border in Spain.
There is a lot going on in this tale. Where did it leave me regarding Maisie? To be honest – meh. The story didn’t really draw me in. Maisie’s attitude baffled me and the story at times just plain bored me. I really hate to write this because I loved this character so much and I just don’t understand where the author is going with her. Ms. Winspear has a way of setting a scene that is very compelling and that has not been lost, it’s just Maisie that is confusing me right now. I’ll give the series one more chance but if the next book is as confusing I’ll be saying farewell to Maisie Dobbs.
Show More
character had changed so much and reading about her lost the thrill it had previously held. I was very hopeful for this new book as at the end of the last one Maisie had left England on a journey of self discovery. I was hoping the next book would share that part of her life.That is not what I found when I read this tale. Instead Maisie’s trip and the major life changes that occur are compressed into a few short pages in the beginning and all of the build up from the previous book is basically over and done in two minutes of reading. I again felt betrayed and really didn’t want to continue reading but was committed to this review. So continue I did. Maisie is heading home to England but really doesn’t want to be going home. On the way she disembarks in Gibraltar to settle herself. While there she stumbles on a dead body and decides to find out who killed him and why. Her pursuit of this starts to give her life some substance. She also struggles to sort out the culture of Gibraltar and to try and understand the Civil War going on over the border in Spain.
There is a lot going on in this tale. Where did it leave me regarding Maisie? To be honest – meh. The story didn’t really draw me in. Maisie’s attitude baffled me and the story at times just plain bored me. I really hate to write this because I loved this character so much and I just don’t understand where the author is going with her. Ms. Winspear has a way of setting a scene that is very compelling and that has not been lost, it’s just Maisie that is confusing me right now. I’ll give the series one more chance but if the next book is as confusing I’ll be saying farewell to Maisie Dobbs.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Twink
A Dangerous Place is the latest (#11) entry in Jacqueline Winspear's Maisie Dobbs series.
The opening first pages of A Dangerous Place were quite jarring - a great tragedy has befallen Maisie. I won't spoil it for you, but this loss devastates her. (And truly this reader as well - I'm saddened at
I've always enjoyed the slow building and piecing together of clues on the road to the final reveal in Winspear's novels. The path is never a straight line from A to B which is of course what makes a great mystery. In A Dangerous Place the route to the end is quite roundabout and busy - a bit too much in my opinion. Winspear has grown the series - and Maisie - with new directions taken in the past few books.
There is of course a dead body in A Dangerous Place (every mystery needs one!) But, the ensuing investigation is a political cat and mouse game with watchers watching the watched. And sadly, I became tired of it. What I really enjoyed was what I have enjoyed in previous Maisie books - the slow coming to answers with interviews, visits and Maisie's case map. This is still present in A Dangerous Place. But what I didn't like was the political cat and mouse games and the duplicity of almost every character. It was, well, just too much. This may just be my bias - I am not a 'spy novel' fan.
Winspear's descriptions of time and place are excellent. Maisie walks the streets of Gibraltar many times - I could vividly picture the old women mending their nets, Mr. Solomon's haberdashery and Mr. Salazar's cafe, as she visits these locations many times. (And it's always fun to see a mention of a place in Canada that I'm familiar with - however brief!)
It's always interesting to see why or when a title was chosen for a book. This one has a great quote from Albert Einstein in the epigraph....."The world is a dangerous place to live; not because of the people who are evil, but because of the people who don't do anything about it." And this completely defines Maisie - she is one of the people who 'do'. This quality is one of the main reasons I have come to enjoy this character so much - her determination, her intellect, her compassion, her curiosity and her inability to let injustice go unnoticed.
"...he taught me about duty, about doing all in our power to bring a sense of...a sense of rest and calm to those left behind. I was - I am, I suppose - an advocate for the dead."
I found the ending quite satisfying - it was a 'return to roots' for Maisie. I will be very curious to see where Winspear takes her character from here. I will definitely be picking up the next book in the series - this is a character and author that I do quite like. A Dangerous Place is a good read but isn't my favourite in the series. Readers new to this author will want to start at the beginning to fully come to appreciate this character.
The opening first pages of A Dangerous Place were quite jarring - a great tragedy has befallen Maisie. I won't spoil it for you, but this loss devastates her. (And truly this reader as well - I'm saddened at
Show More
this turn of events.) So much so, that she has no desire to return to England - instead she only gets as far as Gibraltar. It's 1937 and the Spanish Civil War is underway.I've always enjoyed the slow building and piecing together of clues on the road to the final reveal in Winspear's novels. The path is never a straight line from A to B which is of course what makes a great mystery. In A Dangerous Place the route to the end is quite roundabout and busy - a bit too much in my opinion. Winspear has grown the series - and Maisie - with new directions taken in the past few books.
There is of course a dead body in A Dangerous Place (every mystery needs one!) But, the ensuing investigation is a political cat and mouse game with watchers watching the watched. And sadly, I became tired of it. What I really enjoyed was what I have enjoyed in previous Maisie books - the slow coming to answers with interviews, visits and Maisie's case map. This is still present in A Dangerous Place. But what I didn't like was the political cat and mouse games and the duplicity of almost every character. It was, well, just too much. This may just be my bias - I am not a 'spy novel' fan.
Winspear's descriptions of time and place are excellent. Maisie walks the streets of Gibraltar many times - I could vividly picture the old women mending their nets, Mr. Solomon's haberdashery and Mr. Salazar's cafe, as she visits these locations many times. (And it's always fun to see a mention of a place in Canada that I'm familiar with - however brief!)
It's always interesting to see why or when a title was chosen for a book. This one has a great quote from Albert Einstein in the epigraph....."The world is a dangerous place to live; not because of the people who are evil, but because of the people who don't do anything about it." And this completely defines Maisie - she is one of the people who 'do'. This quality is one of the main reasons I have come to enjoy this character so much - her determination, her intellect, her compassion, her curiosity and her inability to let injustice go unnoticed.
"...he taught me about duty, about doing all in our power to bring a sense of...a sense of rest and calm to those left behind. I was - I am, I suppose - an advocate for the dead."
I found the ending quite satisfying - it was a 'return to roots' for Maisie. I will be very curious to see where Winspear takes her character from here. I will definitely be picking up the next book in the series - this is a character and author that I do quite like. A Dangerous Place is a good read but isn't my favourite in the series. Readers new to this author will want to start at the beginning to fully come to appreciate this character.
Show Less
LibraryThing member BrianEWilliams
Excellent work. It's good to have Maisie Dobbs back.
LibraryThing member Kathy89
This book however is not one of my favorites in the Maisie Dobbs series. We pick up three years since we last read about Maisie. She married James, who died in an airplane accident; she lost the baby she was carrying, left Canada and traveled to India to mourn and is now heading back to London but
I missed Maisie’s circle of friends and family who were only mentioned in letters in this book. I hope she’s not going to turn into Bess Crawford or Maggie Hope.
Show More
gets off the ship in Gibraltar. She accidently stumbled over a dead body in the dark while out walking and makes it her mission to discover what happened to the man who was a photographer. I missed Maisie’s circle of friends and family who were only mentioned in letters in this book. I hope she’s not going to turn into Bess Crawford or Maggie Hope.
Show Less
LibraryThing member hemlokgang
Oh, Maisie! This installment is heartrending and hopeful, historic and intimate, and as always....wonderful! Maisie finds herself in a literally and psychologically dangerous place in this tale. Set in Gibraltar, Maisie sets about solving a murder and also sets about seeking peace and hope for
Show More
herself. Jacqueline Winspear keeps pulling the rabbit out of the hat, and even after eleven installments, leaves the reader eagerly anticipating more! Show Less
LibraryThing member delphimo
I have greatly missed Maisie Dobbs, and this novel skipped a chunk of her life, but then filled in snippets here and there. The story begins tragically for Maisie, and her grief and sorrow follow the whole story. Winspear does an excellent job incorporating the pain and sorrow into the thread of
Show More
the story. Maisie embarks from India to England, but leaves the ship in Gibraltar for personal reasons only to discover the body of a murdered man. The story follows the raging war with different factions in Spain, and the intrusion of Italy and Germany into the moray. This battle brings back painful memories for Maisie as she must learn to follow the teaching of her mentor, Maurice. Winspear builds elaborate settings, but her characters lack of depth of personality. Show Less
LibraryThing member brangwinn
Maisie Dobbs returns in her 11th novel, and may they continue. She’s been married, had both her husband and unborn baby die. Distraught she looks for peace in India. On her return to England, she stops off in Gilbralter, where she stumbles upon a dead man. Searching for his killer helps bring her
Show More
out of her depression. This story is as much of a history lesson as a mystery. She finds herself immersed in the Spanish Civil War. The story ends with her staying on to help as a nurse in a small Spanish village and I can hardly wait to see where she goes in the next book. Or will she solve mysteries in Spain. Show Less
LibraryThing member bookchickdi
A Dangerous Place is the 11th book in the series, and we pick up the story in 1937, four years after the last book ended. Maisie and her husband James are living in Canada, where James is working on planes for the government.
After a tragedy, Maisie decides to return to India to heal. When her
Maisie discovers the dead body of a photographer, a Sephardic Jew, and feeling that the police aren't interested in finding the killer, Maisie uses her skills to solve the murder, and gets involved in a dangerous political situation.
Winspear always does a great deal of research for her books, and in this one, we learn a great deal about the Spanish Civil War, including the bombing of a marketplace in Guernica, where many women and children were killed by fascist forces. For someone who doesn't know much about the politics in Spain at this time, it is enlightening.
Since Maisie is alone in Gibraltar, we don't see many of our favorite characters from previous books- no Billy, no Priscilla, no Lady Rowan. I have to admit I miss Maisie's interactions with the characters I have grown to like. The only one who makes an appearance is Inspector MacFarlane, Maisie's sometimes nemesis, sometimes reluctant police partner.
At the end of the story, Maisie assists some nurses who are traveling to care for the men fighting the civil war. This part was most interesting for me, as Maisie seemed to come out of her funk, and was at her best organizing the makeshift hospital and helping the nurses care for the men under difficult conditions. It was a welcome callback to Maisie and her nursing days in France.
We'll have to wait until next year's book to find out if Maisie returns home and resumes her life as a private investigator. I can't say that this one was my favorite in the Maisie Dobbs series, but as always, I learned something about a time and place I knew little about, and that is always a good thing.
After a tragedy, Maisie decides to return to India to heal. When her
Show More
stepmother wires Maisie asking her to return home to England, Maisie decides to go, but ends up in Gibraltar, a British garrison town off the coast of Spain.Maisie discovers the dead body of a photographer, a Sephardic Jew, and feeling that the police aren't interested in finding the killer, Maisie uses her skills to solve the murder, and gets involved in a dangerous political situation.
Winspear always does a great deal of research for her books, and in this one, we learn a great deal about the Spanish Civil War, including the bombing of a marketplace in Guernica, where many women and children were killed by fascist forces. For someone who doesn't know much about the politics in Spain at this time, it is enlightening.
Since Maisie is alone in Gibraltar, we don't see many of our favorite characters from previous books- no Billy, no Priscilla, no Lady Rowan. I have to admit I miss Maisie's interactions with the characters I have grown to like. The only one who makes an appearance is Inspector MacFarlane, Maisie's sometimes nemesis, sometimes reluctant police partner.
At the end of the story, Maisie assists some nurses who are traveling to care for the men fighting the civil war. This part was most interesting for me, as Maisie seemed to come out of her funk, and was at her best organizing the makeshift hospital and helping the nurses care for the men under difficult conditions. It was a welcome callback to Maisie and her nursing days in France.
We'll have to wait until next year's book to find out if Maisie returns home and resumes her life as a private investigator. I can't say that this one was my favorite in the Maisie Dobbs series, but as always, I learned something about a time and place I knew little about, and that is always a good thing.
Show Less
LibraryThing member shazjhb
Very good novel. So like the character and pleased she is appearing in new books. After the last book thought it was the end of the series.
LibraryThing member shannon.dolgos
At the end of the last novel, Maisie had decided to expand her horizons with hopes of finding herself and deciding to accept or not accept James' marriage proposal.
Well, as the date of James' ultimatum approaches, Maisie sends him her response...and I can't really share any more details without
READ IT IF YOU LOVE MAISIE.
Well, as the date of James' ultimatum approaches, Maisie sends him her response...and I can't really share any more details without
Show More
spoiling the book.READ IT IF YOU LOVE MAISIE.
Show Less
LibraryThing member olegalCA
Winspear has completely rebooted Maisie Dobbs and it'll be interesting to see what happens to her. The mystery in this book wasn't very good and it got boring reading about Maisie being followed by different men but I'll still keep reading the series.
LibraryThing member jamespurcell
Seeking solace from the death of her husband and infant daughter, Maisie travels to India. On her way home, she tarries in Gibraltar, where she literally stumbles over a murder victim. As no own else seems to care, she pursues her own investigation. The Spanish Civil War and Guernica provide ugly
Show More
contexts for her quest but she does prevail. Show Less
LibraryThing member natazouf
Very disappointing book from such an interesting series. Little action occurs, besides Maisie going from one location to another and back and forth as she tries to connect information about a murder, while recovering from painful events. Too many irrelevant details and redundant dialogues.
LibraryThing member pennykaplan
Maisie Dobbs has suffered tremendous loss, most recently the death of her husband and unborn child, and is now trying to come back to life in Gilbralter amidst the Spanish civil war. The mystery is secondary to the setting and Maisie's recovery
LibraryThing member cygnet81
Less mystery than usual but a better back story.
LibraryThing member fromthecomfychair
I was initially alarmed to discover, at the beginning of this book (so no spoiler alert) that Maisie had finally married James and was pregnant with their baby when James suddenly died piloting a plane. As a result, Maisie miscarried the baby. Holy smoke! How much can one character be expected to
This episode started off a little slowly but built into a good story. I liked reading about Gibraltar, a place I had never thought about before, and the Spanish Civil War provided a suspenseful background for the action, such as it was. And I look forward to her next adventure in Munich.
Show More
bear? But then I considered: how could she go on investigating crimes as a new mother married to a wealthy aristocrat who is somewhat in the public eye? Obviously, she could not, so the husband and child had to go. But what a shock! I sure hope Winspear has a happy ending planned for Maisie somewhere in the future. This episode started off a little slowly but built into a good story. I liked reading about Gibraltar, a place I had never thought about before, and the Spanish Civil War provided a suspenseful background for the action, such as it was. And I look forward to her next adventure in Munich.
Show Less
LibraryThing member cbl_tn
At the end of the last book in the Maisie Dobbs series, Maisie hadn't decided whether or not to accept James Compton's proposal. Several years have elapsed since the conclusion of that book. Maisie did marry James and moved with him to Canada, where he worked in the aeronautics industry. James was
I had hoped Maisie had left the world of espionage behind in A Lesson in Secrets, but it wasn't to be. I don't think the style of this series is particularly well suited to espionage plots. Even Maisie admitted to another character toward the end of the book that the explanation for the murder had become convoluted. She tried out several explanations of the death in conversations with several different characters, and each successive explanation served more to obfuscate than clarify the circumstances of the murder. The tension peaked too early, andMaisie's foray into war-torn Spain is unnecessary to the plot (although it is within character for Maisie to put her wartime nursing experience to use when she sees a great need for it.) I don't think this book would work as well as a stand-alone as some of the other books in the series. The series shifted from a post-war First World War focus to a build-up to World War II focus with A Lesson in Secrets, and I would recommend that readers new to the series go back at least that far to catch up before reading this installment.
Show More
killed during a test flight, and Maisie's shock and grief caused her to lose the child she was carrying. Maisie has been unable to face returning to England and the home she had shared with James. Maisie has reached Gibraltar, and her discovery of a dead photographer shortly after her arrival gives her a puzzle to occupy her mind. Maisie's case map soon has threads leading to the Spanish Civil War, local communists, and intelligence agents (both British and foreign).I had hoped Maisie had left the world of espionage behind in A Lesson in Secrets, but it wasn't to be. I don't think the style of this series is particularly well suited to espionage plots. Even Maisie admitted to another character toward the end of the book that the explanation for the murder had become convoluted. She tried out several explanations of the death in conversations with several different characters, and each successive explanation served more to obfuscate than clarify the circumstances of the murder. The tension peaked too early, and
Show Less
LibraryThing member JanicsEblen
I have followed the Masie Dobbs series from book 1. I thoroughly
enjoy this series. The progression of Masie's life and the lives of the ongoing characters are enjoyable to watch. As a stand alone book I am not certain how a first time reader would judge it. The story line is a good one - but may
enjoy this series. The progression of Masie's life and the lives of the ongoing characters are enjoyable to watch. As a stand alone book I am not certain how a first time reader would judge it. The story line is a good one - but may
Show More
not inspire one to begin with book 1 and move up to this one. Show Less
LibraryThing member arielfl
I have read all of the previous books in this series and this one was a downer. After all of the build up in previous books Maisie's life is destroyed in a few pages. If anyone deserved a little bit of happiness it was Maisie but it was not to be. Winspear's ruthless handling of certain character's
Show More
fates has been a nit picking point for me in the past but this across the boarding sweeping of plot and characters was disappointing. I might have been able to forgive her if the mystery had been the least bit stimulating but I found it dreadfully boring. Part of the plot revolved around the Spanish Civil War which I had never heard of while previous books focused on the more familiar World War I setting. Consequently plot points in this novel were not as interesting to me as in previous books. I really had to drag myself through this depressing book. It is clear that this book marks a pivotal change in the series so I will hang on for another installment to see if things pick up. Hopefully Maisie will return to England for happier times with beloved characters. Show Less
Language
Original language
English
ISBN
9780749018870
Original publication date
2015-03-17