Publication
Status
Description
A story about a man's deception, a family's complicity, and two teenage girls caught in the middle. Set in a middle-class neighborhood in Atlanta in the 1980s, the novel revolves around James Witherspoon's two families, the public one and the secret one. When the daughters from each family meet and form a friendship, only one of them knows they are sisters. It is a relationship destined to explode when secrets are revealed and illusions shattered. As Jones explores the backstories of her rich yet flawed characters, the father, the two mothers, the grandmother, and the uncle, she also reveals the joy, as well as the destruction, they brought to one another's lives. At the heart of it all are the two lives at stake, and like the best writers--think Toni Morrison with The Bluest Eye--Jones portrays the fragility of these young girls with raw authenticity as they seek love, demand attention, and try to imagine themselves as women, just not as their mothers.… (more)
User reviews
The writing was excellent, and I suppose if the story had a different ending I would likely have gone for five stars, but the epilogue made me sad and cast a pall over the story for me (though other readers may disagree).
Dana Yarboro is a secret child, the daughter of a bigamist. Her father’s first family is the recognized one. His first daughter is the child who gets everything she wants
Dana’s voice is the first to speak:
My father, James Witherspoon, is a bigamist. He was already married ten years when he first clamped his eyes on my mother. – from Silver Sparrow, page 3 -
From the opening pages, the reader learns that James lives two distinct lives and it is his wish that his two daughters shall never meet. Dana is an outspoken, fearless child who is also vulnerable in her desire for her father’s love. The conflict between Dana’s wish for her father’s approval and her curiosity about the sister she has never met, drives the narrative.
The second half the book is narrated by Chaurisse who knows nothing of Dana’s roots. She is living her life with privileges which Dana can only dream about, unaware that her father is hiding a sister from her.
It is this imbalance between the characters and the eventual uncovering of truth which provides the tension in this novel about secret lives, sibling rivalry, and forbidden love. Jones beautifully develops her teenage protagonists while fleshing out the mothers of these girls into strong, female characters who the reader grows to respect. Honest, sharply written and with a sardonic humor, Jones reels the reader into the story and does not let go.
I thoroughly enjoyed Silver Sparrow that is both a coming of age story and a glimpse into contemporary marriage. Readers who enjoy meticulously crafted, character driven novels, will not want to miss this book. I know I will be looking forward to reading more of this talented author’s work.
Highly recommended.
Tayari Jones’ third novel, Silver Sparrow, is an unusual take on a not-entirely-unusual story. Plenty of people drift into (or deliberately choose to have) affairs. Sometimes those affairs result in children. It’s less common for the mother of one of those children to insist on marriage to the father while the father remains married to, and refuses to leave, his wife - who, by the way, is also expecting a baby. But marriage to James Witherspoon is what Gwen Yarboro wanted, and for years of Wednesday nights, she and her daughter Dana had James and his “brother” Raleigh with them as family; those were the nights that James’ wife Laverne and daughter Chaurisse believed the men were working. While Gwen and Dana are constantly aware, and frequently resentful, of James’ other family, Laverne and Chaurisse have no idea it exists.
Jones tells the first half of the story through Dana’s first-person narration, and then switches to Chaurisse’s voice before bringing the two girls - teens born just a few months apart - together. It’s an effective construct that allows the reader to have the same “secret” knowledge about Chaurisse that Dana has before meeting her; once we do meet her, that knowledge filters the reading of her side of the story. For me, that added both poignancy and a sense of foreboding to the second half of the book - it was pretty clear that before it was all over, everyone was going to know the whole truth.
Jones’ writing keeps Silver Sparrow from being as melodramatic as its plot suggests it might be, and telling the story through the daughters is one way she achieves that. She has also created memorable characters, each of whom can evoke the reader’s sympathy even when they’re not entirely likable, and given both of her narrators distinctive voices and perspectives without significantly changing her writing style when she shifts. Her depiction of 1980s Atlanta feels true to time and place. Silver Sparrow was an absorbing read, and I’d like to read more from Tayari Jones.
Dana and her mom Gwen, who came along after James was already married the first time, live in the figurative shadow of James’ “main” family, Laverne and Chaurisse. James comes to see Dana and Gwen once a week for dinner, but only has a little so he can eat again once he gets “home.” Gwen and Dana constantly contend with jealousy and the feeling of being "second." Dana says: "[Laverne] found him first and my mother has always respected the other woman’s squatter’s rights. But was my mother his wife, too?”
And what about Chaurisse? Dana says, "In my mind, Chaurisse is his real daughter. With wives, it only matters who gets there first. With daughters, the situation is a bit more complicated.”
Part One tells Dana’s story, and Part Two is narrated by Chaurisse. Dana and Gwen, the second set, know about Laverne and Chaurisse, but Laverne and Chaurisse are “under the impression that [theirs] was an ordinary life.” And it was just an ordinary cup of coffee that changed it all. Dana tells how her parents met and went for coffee together:
"And this is how it started. Just with coffee and the exchange of their long stories. Love can be incremental. Predicaments, too. Coffee can start a life just as it can start a day. This was the meeting of two people who were destined to love from before they were born, from before they made choices that would complicate their lives. This love just rolled toward my mother as though she were standing at the bottom of a steep hill. Mother had no hand in this, only heart.”
The only character of note besides the two families is Raleigh, the brother-for-all-intensive-purposes of James, who also plays a role in both families along with James for all the years of the two relationships. Both the girls know and love him as “Uncle Raleigh,” and the reader can’t help but feel the same affection for him.
James liked to say to Dana, “you are the secret,” thinking it might make her feel special, but in actuality, it makes her feel bad. As we listen to the girls’ stories, we see Dana acting out more and more, until finally the situation blows up, and all the secrets come roiling out in a poison brew.
Discussion: I struggled with my reaction to Dana (and I took this as a sign of good writing on the part of the author). I felt sorry for her, then I resented her, then I came back full circle at the end. It was hard for all of them, this shared love. And yet, within large families, love is by no means exclusive. It's a most interesting situation to ponder.
Evaluation: This is a very good story that stays with you long after you finish, as you try to grapple with all the issues it raises about love and families. Marketed as adult fiction, it can also be considered a young adult book, but be aware that for younger readers, the two girls are into premarital sex. With all the issues to think about, it's a great choice for a book club.
The story is beautifully written and explores the themes of what it means to be family, the destructive nature of secrets and lies, and how people use their imaginations to define others when truth is concealed. The author tells the story in meaningful scenes and illustrations of African American life in Atlanta from the early 1960's to the late 1980's. Sprinkled through the narrative are little aphorisms such as "pretty ain't easy".
Algonquin press has hit another home run in publishing this book.
The main portion of the story takes place during the 1980s in Atlanta, and is told from two points of view. The book begins with Dana, the bigamist’s secret daughter. The unfolding of the story with Dana's point of view, immediately put Dana as the sympathetic character. And as Dana told the story, I almost was able to believe that the father may have been doing somewhat right by her. Ms. Jones is such a skillful writer, in that she allowed me to buy completely into their life. The second half of the book focuses on Chaurisse, who is also a daughter of the bigamist’s, but by his first marriage – and thus his public relationship. From the beginning of Chaurisse's point of view, it becomes clear that what Chaurisse has is a true father and a much truer family experience.; poor Dana has the cast-offs. The contrast between each girl’s life becomes starker as the story unfolds. We learn that, incredibly, both Dana and her mother are invested in protecting the bigamist’s secret; they are invested in protecting their life in the shadows. I saw incredibly, because at some point shouldn’t they become frustrated with being pushed to the side? At some point will they have a need to bring it to light? And how does the “first wife” not guess about the duplicity? Does she not wonder why her husband is gone every single Wednesday? Does she not notice that money is missing? Both wives have their own careers and truly are able to support themselves and their daughters. They are not in a situation where they are dependent on their man – the bigamist – to support them financially. So where does the emotional dependence come from? Why stay? The story does not explore these points directly asked, but they are explored implicitly.
Dana and Chaurisse are the same age, however both girls do not possess the same level of knowledge about each other or about their father. Dana and her mother know all about Chaurisse and her mother; they live in their shadow. Every choice and step that Dana and her mother take is tempered by whether Chaurisse and her mother will be there or choose to do something similar. Dana is truly a “second”. Chaurisse and her mother have no idea that Dana exists. But Chaurisse “gets” her father on a daily basis, she lives with him and has the intimacy of a father-daughter relationship. Dana does not have any of this. Her father, while a weekly visitor, is a mystery and almost an intangible.
Through the telling of the story by Dana and Chaurisse, readers are also taken back in history and treated to a rich story telling of the adults’ lives as children. The characters in Silver Sparrow are richly developed, not only Dana and Chaurisse, but also the ancillary characters that assist in creating (and maintaining!) this situation – the mothers, the father, and the father’s best friend. Through the interplay of the various characters, readers are pulled into this beautifully told story. And let me tell you, it is an entertaining immersion, you will not regret it, but it is painful as well. There are some truly heartbreaking scenes where the characters hurt each other – hurt in a deep emotional way. Hurt in a way that as a reader, I did not know how they could survive such pain.
This is a wonderful story, a beautiful book and I highly recommend it!
Jones tells an engaging story, one that made me want to keep reading. I was truly disappointed by the Epilogue however, which left me with a bad taste in my mouth and less respect for the characters than I had previously held. I give 'Silver Sparrow' 3.5 stars - I'd recommend it, but be prepared for a little disappointment in your fellow man.
Dana tells us how her daddy was buying his first wife Laverne an anniversary gift, and he fell in love with the woman at the gift wrap counter of the department store, her mama Gwen. Gwen knew right away that James was married, yet she still dated him, fell in love and had his baby. She also insisted that they get married in the next state over, and James agreed.
When Dana was five, she drew a picture of her family in school, including her daddy's two wives and two girls. Her daddy told her then that she couldn't tell anyone about him or his other wife or daughter. When Dana asked if they were a secret, he told her "no, you've got it the wrong way around. Dana, you are the one who is secret."
That moment changed her life. Dana and her mother would go 'surveilling', following Laverne and Chaurisse around, spying on them. Every Wednesday, James would come to Dana's house for dinner, sometimes accompanied by his best friend Raleigh, who also knew the secret.
Gwen fought for her daughter, shaming James into paying for science classes, any extra she could get to make up for the fact that Dana did not have a daddy she could acknowledge publicly. Gwen worked long, hard hours as a nurse, resenting that Laverne, the other wife, got to work out of her own home in a beauty parlor she owned.
Dana resented Laverne and Chaurisse, especially when Chaurisse got things Dana wanted. She got a job at the local amusement park, but couldn't take it because Chaurisse got a job there too. When her daddy presented her with a beautiful rabbit fur jacket, she felt special, until she saw Chaurisse wearing the same jacket.
The second half of the book is narrated by Chaurisse, and I thought it was the stronger half of the book. Chaurisse is a sympathetic character. She is lonely, not pretty or smart like Dana. She didn't have any friends, and neither did her mother.
I found this intriguing; none of the women in this book had friends, they were all lonely. You might say that because Dana and Gwen were a secret, they probably wouldn't have many friends, but why didn't Laverne or Chaurisse have friends? Laverne was exposed to many women at her home beauty salon, but she seemed to have no friends. I wonder if this is a commentary on these women or on all women?
I didn't really have a handle on James as a character, he seemed to be an OK guy, but he always appeared a bit out of focus for me. Raleigh, on the other hand, was a fascinating character. James' mother took him in as a child, and he grew up like James' brother.
Raleigh had so many good qualities, but somehow he got swept into James' deceptive life. He always seemed to be the one who tried to make things right, to smooth things over for everyone. But he was lonely too, never having a family or love of his own because he had to keep the peace for James and his two families.
The author said that all stories are about secrets, and that what happens when the secret is revealed is the interesting part. Eventually, James' secret comes out, and the sadness and heartbreak that follows makes for gripping reading.
The writing in Silver Sparrow is just beautiful, and this story has a lot to say about the relationship between mothers and daughters and between sisters. One line really resonated with me. Chaurisse was a bit envious of the easy conversation between her mother and Dana, saying "it was like my mother was a newspaper that everyone could read except for me." I think it's true that we don't see our mothers in the same way others do.
This luminous story grabbed me right at the beginning, and I found myself caring so deeply about these characters, it was like they were people I actually knew. I rooted for them all to be OK, even though the situation dictated that it may not end that way. Tayari Jones has written a lovely novel, one that begs to read again and again.
I truly appreciate spending time in an understated novel. Tayari Jones writes with such a light hand about such weighty issues that I believe it
As always, I will spare you a recap of the storyline, since that's already provided just fine without any more help from me.
I will not hesitate to recommend this to my customers, especially those coming off a run of white-knuckle thrillers who want something with more heart.
I wanted this book to keep going! Don't get me wrong, it has a perfectly satisfying conclusion, but I wanted more Dana and Chaurisse.
It's so difficult for me to dislike anyone in this book even though so many of them did the wrong thing, but that also makes them
The father is a selfish, cruel man; no matter that he is described as different in the book. I REALLY didn't like him. The uncle is tool.
The mother is
A very gifted author and a very good book.
This story begins through the eyes of Dana Lynn, a young girl of color being raised in relatively poor circumstances. She and her mother don't live in poverty, but they are surviving
The book reveals Dana's life with her mother Gwen, and what she knows of the life of her father's other family with his wife Laverne and other daughter Chaurisse. It was fascinating to see the story through Dana’s eyes, and to build your impression of Chaurisse and her mother and everything else through Dana, and then to suddenly have that shift a little over halfway through the story, and see things from Chaurisse’s perspective. I loved that about this story.
Dana's mother Gwen married young, a boy she knew from middle school. She married him after graduation, and they divorced a couple of years later. Working a store counter, she met James Witherspoon one day while he was looking for a gift for his wife. Within a year after her divorce, she was living in a rooming house and pregnant with a married man's child.
So Gwen has her baby and puts herself through school to become a nurse. Shortly after Dana's birth, James and Gwen marry in a neighboring state. Dana is raised knowing from a young age about her father's other family, and getting the sense that she must spend her life playing second fiddle to sister Chaurisse.
However sister Chaurisse and the family know nothing of Dana and her mother. It isn't until grandmother Bunny is on her deathbed that her grandmother is finally told of Dana, and Dana is brought to meet her.
Bunny was my favorite character, as brief as she was in the story. She wished her boys would have told her sooner of Dana's existence, and that she'd had time to get to know her.
I read this one for my book club, and the consensus was that the characters weren't very likable. In fact, one woman in the group really disliked this book! It's one of those books that can just leave a bad taste in your mouth, because you are so frustrated with the characters and the way they handle the events in their lives.
And father James, while you give him credit for trying to be a part of his "illegitimate" daughter's life, you see the unfairness of it all. Dana is always given second best. She gets her father one day a week while here sister gets him every day. Throughout her life she has to sacrifice her wants for that of her sister (when her sister wants a summer job at the same place as Dana or wants to attend the same program, it is Dana that must forfeit her desire). And while her father and his wife Laverne make a good living and are able to provide their daughter Chaurisse with a comfortable life that include debutante balls, Dana lives in the projects, being raised on her mother's salary and whatever scraps her father tosses their way.
James' brother Raleigh is sort of likable, but his general inaction and silence in the face of what his brother is doing to Dana and her mother is infuriating at times. He is his brother's accomplice in his duplicity, and James could not have pulled off the dual lives (one public and one secret) without Raleigh, who is even named as Dana's father on her birth certificate.
Aside from the story content or writing style, I was surprised at the poor formatting of the ebook. There were a lot of typos and I could swear there were missing passages. There were strange stilted endings to chapters. Others in my book club agreed that some of the chapters ended rather abruptly.
My final word: This book was "okay". I enjoyed the unique dual perspective, I was intrigued by the concept. But when it came down to it, I just didn't like the characters very much. Bunny was the only one I really cared for, and the daughter Chaurisse and uncle Raleigh I liked a bit. The writing style was okay, but not thoroughly engaging. It gets an "eh" from me. Kind of intriguing, but the characters are ultimately unlikable.
I can honestly say that I loved this book. I didn't want it to end. I love how she placed it in both of the daughter's perspectives. I feel it added a more clarifying point to the whole situation. I loved how much I got sucked into the book. I felt for both of the girls. I have to be honest. I had more sympathy for Dana than I did Chaurisse. At the end, I started realizing how spoiled Chaurisse truly was.
I feel there were certain parts that could have been told in more detail. They were written out perfectly without the details though. I also would have liked to seen a few chapters from the mothers' perspectives. I think that would have been pretty awesome. I understand why it was written the way it was though.
I fully recommend this book to anybody. It's a very powerful story. I loved it, and I'm sure others will love it just as much as I did. If I had the money to do so, I'd buy a copy for all my friends and family to read. I can't tell you enough how beautiful and powerful this story really is. Get a copy and find out for yourself. You won't regret it.
Silver Sparrow is the
Tayari Jones did an exceptional job telling this story and I wondered if she was trying to convey it in a way that you’re more sympathetic to one character over another. However, the novel masterfully shifts points of view. The first half of the book is narrated by Dana Lynn Yarboro (illegitimate daughter) and the second part of the book is narrated by Bunny Chaurisse Witherspoon who doesn't know the truth but the friendship forces things to a heartbreaking climax and conclusion
This was one of the most difficult books to review. It’s a very interesting storyline. The whole premise of reading the novel was to discover how the story could possibly be resolved effectively and how all the tension and psychological strain is played out between the two innocent daughters who only wanted to be loved and valued. Someone or everyone would have to be hurt in this situation. I wasn’t sure who I wanted to come out on top. I came into the story expecting to hate the bigamist, but I came out feeling empathy for everyone involved. Amid the dishonesty and treachery, I felt loyal to both sisters and both mothers in this complex tale.
I loved the interjection of real life people, like Dr. Martin Luther King and the infamous Al ‘Grits’ Green and Mary Woodson White story.
I look forward to reading another novel by Tayari Jones.