A Modest Proposal

by Jonathan Swift

1997

Publication

Gutenberg 1997, original 1729

Library's rating

Status

Available

Description

Essays. Nonfiction. HTML: Jonathan Swift's A Modest Proposal is one of the earliest and most seminal satirical essays written in English. Having as an original title "A Modest Proposal for Preventing the Children of Poor People from Being a Burden on Their Parents or Country, and for Making Them Beneficial to the Publick," it expresses deep anger at the squalor and miserable conditions from which the Irish people was suffering in the eighteenth century. Swift ironically suggests that poor Irish families could sell their children to rich Englishmen as an ultimate solution to their miseries. The essay, which is generally characterized by a rather bitter, ironic and hyperbolic tone, provides details of how to convert the problem that Irish children represent into its own solution. He even dares to propose selling those children to meat markets to be served as food for the rich. He ironically gives a complete analysis about how this weird solution would help combat unemployment and overpopulation and boost the country's economy. What is worth noting, however, is that Swift does not put all the burden on the shoulders of English rulers, rich men and Irish politicians. Indeed, the essay also represents a work of self-criticism where the Irish masses are equally blamed for not being able to help themselves..… (more)

User reviews

LibraryThing member meggyweg
I do believe that if Jonathan Swift were alive today, he would be writing for The Onion. Which, coming from me, is highest praise.
LibraryThing member JorgeCarvajal


A most notable work of art whose only sin is that of brevity. An admirable solution in times of trouble which transcends space and time and should be seriously pondered by all great and not-so-great minds alike in order to solve the concerns of our modern society.
LibraryThing member Britt84
That was weird... I really had no expectations about this book and had sort of expected it to be a novel, but it was more like a pamphlet, an argumentative essay. And at first I thought it was serious and was quite appaled, until I came to the idea of eating babies and realised it had to be
Show More
satirical. Not surprising I guess, given the fact that it was written by Swift.
I think I should probably re-read it sometime now that I do have an idea what it is about; I didn't like it much, but part of that is because it was so different from what I expected, and that I really thought it was terrible at first, before realising it wasn't serious.
Then again, it is really well done, seeing as it did fool me at first...
Show Less
LibraryThing member Fledgist
Swift's satirical solution to the Irish problem. Still bitingly funny and pointed.
LibraryThing member AlCracka
I knew what this was about, but I didn't realize how savage it would be. Incredible stuff.
LibraryThing member charlottejones952
This is a surprising satirical essay which is about quite a disturbing subject but is really well-written and reads like a classic. I enjoyed this but I think I could get more out of it by reading it again so think if I ever reread it, the star rating might increase, but for now it's a 3 star read
Show More
:)
Show Less
LibraryThing member Kristelh
A satire on poverty in Ireland. The author proposes that the poor be assisted to fatten up the children which would then be sold for food to the rich. The pamphlet includes recipes for preparing the new meat. The author states that this will stop voluntary abortions and murder of bastard children.
LibraryThing member mlbelize
With the high costs of living, the expenses of educating, clothing, feeding and generally raising children to majority, the solution, as presented in Jonathan Swift's satire, A Modest Proposal, should perhaps be revisited again and given consideration. And please, before you get out the rope to
Show More
lynch me, realize this is said very tongue-in-cheek. A good read. Hmm, could use a little more salt.
Show Less
LibraryThing member steadfastreader
This is a fabulous little essay. There's no excuse that anyone shouldn't have read it. It's Swift's thoughts on the Irish Potato Famine. Masterful and dark satire.
LibraryThing member Bcteagirl
This was a short, satirical, dark, humorous, bitter proposal on how to deal with the Irish poor. It leads you slowly in by discussing how concerned they are with the poor and their suffering, and how they need a way to have honest work to support themselves, and how the suffering of children is
Show More
especially problematic. Then it offers a solution to the problem: If people are largely property of their landlords, and if they are going to be allowed to do nothing but suffer anyway, why not sell the babies as foodstuffs? The first allusion to 'renewable resources' I have come across. Funny, but at the same time sad and occasionally hard to read, at least for me.
Show Less
LibraryThing member MartinBodek
His proposal is WHAT? This is satire? Satire of what? I don't get it. Is the whole thing a setup for the final sentence? If so, still not funny. Whatevs, moving on to the next book in the 1,001 Books...
LibraryThing member Xleptodactylous
Satirical musings upon the state of Ireland in the 18th Century, wherein the author of Gulliver's Travels tries to provide ways in which the country could provide for itself in an unusual manner...

A mixture of satirical and semi-realistic essays with some poetry thrown in, A Modest Proposal
Show More
illuminates the writings of Swift quite well. He is obviously very concerned about the state of his country, Ireland, and deals out various ways in which the country can regain its footing again. Mostly concerning the ways in which children can become very helpful towards their state, it combines right-wing thinking with left-wing humour. There is one surprise you could not fail to notice, which is quite ridiculous considering how well written it was at first. I very nearly believed him.
Show Less
LibraryThing member MartinBodek
His proposal is WHAT? This is satire? Satire of what? I don't get it. Is the whole thing a setup for the final sentence? If so, still not funny. Whatevs, moving on to the next book in the 1,001 Books...
LibraryThing member ScoLgo
A perfectly written piece of classic literature. 'A Modest Proposal' is a slyly tongue-in-cheek discourse that shines an absolutely brilliant light on racist elitism.
LibraryThing member TheCrow2
Short satirical writings of Swift. The eponymous is simply great but I found the other two a bit boring. Or maybe I'm just not Irish enough for them....
LibraryThing member brakketh
A novel suggestion as to how to manage an overabundance of children.
LibraryThing member SashaM
This is interesting but I feel this one could have really benefited from explanatory notes as I really don't know much about the history of Ireland and England during this time in history
LibraryThing member lydia1879
Short, concise and biting in its wit and humour. Satire should be a vehicle through which we examine the uglier, more painful parts of life so I feel like Swift did this really well.

I did feel like, because of the time and context, some of the finer points of the satire went over my head but his
Show More
tone was almost perfect for this type of writing, because it was a little bit antiquated.

A neat and tidy example of satire.
Show Less
LibraryThing member DeltaQueen50
A Modest Proposal is a satirical essay written and published by Jonathan Swift in 1729. It’s full title is “A Modest Proposal for Preventing the Children of Poor People From Being a Burden to Their Parents, or the Country, and for Making them Beneficial to the Publick”, a title almost as long
Show More
as the essay itself. These writings are an ironical attempt to point out a cheap and easy method of turning the starving children of Ireland into a useful economic commodity.

This satirical essay is short, and straight forward in it’s implication. The humor and irony is both in the subject matter and in his style of delivery. He writes in concise, business like language which makes his proposal all the more shocking when revealed. He also backs up his proposal with specific data about the positive effects this practice would have, both on the poor families and on Ireland’s complex social, political and economic systems.
Show Less
LibraryThing member macleod73
Biting social commentary by way of satire.

Language

Original language

English

Original publication date

1729

Similar in this library

Page: 0.1961 seconds