Status
Available
Local notes
PB Mey
Collection
Series
Genres
Publication
HMH Books for Young Readers (2001), Edition: 1, 227 pages
Description
Mary Tudor, who would reign briefly as Queen of England during the mid sixteenth century, tells the story of her troubled childhood as daughter of King Henry VIII.
Subjects
Awards
Utah Beehive Book Award (Nominee — Young Adult — 2002)
Pacific Northwest Library Association Young Reader's Choice Award (Nominee — Intermediate — 2002)
South Dakota Teen Choice Book Awards (Nominee — 2000)
Grand Canyon Reader Award (Nominee — Teen — 2004)
Golden Archer Award (Nominee — Intermediate — 2003)
Evergreen Teen Book Award (Nominee — 2002)
Best Fiction for Young Adults (Selection — 2000)
NCTE Adventuring with Books: A Booklist for Pre-K—Grade 6 (13th Edition: 1999-2001)
Young Adult Favorites Award (2001)
Language
Original language
English
Physical description
227 p.; 4.19 inches
User reviews
LibraryThing member Cbutcher
An excellent book that is historically accurate but at the same time has enough fiction to keep you interested. Mary, Bloody, Mary, is a book about my favourite Historical figure Princess Mary Tudor/ Queen Mary I of England otherwise known as Bloody Mary Tudor because of the fact that she burnt 283
Show More
Protestant people at the stake in five years. It is nice to see a book that is not bias toward Elizabeth I but shows things from Princess Mary's perspective as she goes from the 'pearl of her fathers world' and the heiress apparent Princess of Wales to being separated from her mother, watching as her father marries someone else and she is named a bastard and sent away. It captures the mindset of the Princess perfectly as she goes from a pampered child to a abandoned teen, who has to deal with the fact that she has lost her father's love. Mary, Bloody Mary is a part of the Young Royal's series that is written mainly for preteen children who do not know much about these Historical figures. Therefore it is fairly short and is written in an easy to understand way. If you are not a fan of the Tudors or of Mary I in particular this book will not appeal to you very much but for all the people out there who are interested in reading historically accurate fiction concerning Mary Tudor then this is the book for you. It is much better than another Historical work about Mary I, The Queen's Fool by Philippa Gregory as Mary, Bloody, Mary is much more accurate. Show Less
LibraryThing member brokenangelkisses
I have always had an interest in history and a particular interest in Henry VIII, so when I spotted one of my students reading this book I was intrigued.
The premise
Written from the perspective of Princess Mary Tudor, this short novel for teens charts Henry’s separation from his wife Catherine,
My thoughts
I found the basic set up immediately interesting. First, we are greeted by a family tree. Often, these make me groan as I assume that there will be complicated events later on that mean I need to refer back to the tree, squinting at it as I make minor connections that often prove to be dull or irrelevant. Not so in this case. The Tudor tree is clear and simple and I felt that it helped to focus my mind on the story to come.
Next, there is a prologue in which Mary passionately denounces Anne as a witch and states explicitly why she hates her. Again, I thought that this was engaging as Mary’s passion immediately made me feel at once shocked by her attitude but also intrigued. What had happened to cause such hatred? Had Anne really corrupted Henry? The prologue is kept short, which I thought was appropriate as otherwise there might be too much detail about the story. As it is, the prologue effectively set up the ground that the novel would cover, which is (approximately) 1526 – 1536, or the ‘Anne Boleyn years’. Also, the prologue made me wonder whether Anne really could be the witch that Mary believes as many of Mary’s grievances are clearly against her father, but she believes they are caused by Anne. This seems a perfectly logical position for such a young girl, especially one who would naturally revere her father (given the context of the time and situation). This meant that I was attentive and interested in the following story.
Meyer plunges the reader into Mary’s world in the first sentences of the first chapter. “I inherited King Henry’s fiery temper – no one would deny that! And so, on the day I learned that he had betrothed me to the king of France, I exploded.” I thought this was a very effective opening as it was an interesting situation and not something I’d often thought about when studying history at school, the way young princesses – and princes – were betrothed at young ages to much older people for political or financial expediency. Although it is such a strange situation for a contemporary reader, I thought Mary’s furious response would help to bridge any distance created by the unusual event. The ten year old Mary is understandably angry that she is to be married to a fat old man and this helped me to like her and to feel empathetic. This is important as she is usually remembered as per the title of the book, but this shows the notorious Bloody Mary in a sympathetic light. I liked the mixing of fact and fiction here as I thought it was quite a reasonable response to her plight!
As can be seen in the above quote, despite the fact that Mary lived nearly 500 years ago, she is given a contemporary style of speech. I thought that this was a good idea, especially as this is fiction for YA readers. It also suits Mary’s confident and curious nature. Instead of trying to create an ‘olde worlde’ atmosphere through the syntax and vocabulary, Meyer creates a sense of history through the events, historical characters and minor details. The font style helps too – I do not know the name of it, but it has a definite ‘old-fashioned’ feel. I liked this as it did help to create a sense of an earlier time.
Chapters have titles throughout, which I often find irritating as they can give away the plot developments or seem daftly elliptical and there purely to show off the author’s clever mind. The titles here are usually one or two word notes that simply suggest the chapter’s focus (e.g. ‘falconry’ or ‘lessons’) and as such I thought that they worked well enough, although I didn’t think that they were really necessary.
In terms of the plotting, I found the earlier chapters most interesting as they focused on Mary’s experiences in the castle and, as she spends a lot of time listening quietly, there is much gossip about Lady Anne and King Henry. Later on, when the pair eventually meet as stepmother and outcast daughter, Anne seemed overwritten as the evil stepmother and didn’t seem very ‘real’. As the blurb reveals, Mary is declared illegitimate and banished to make way for the new queen. I felt that as Mary’s exile developed the story became slightly repetitive and lacked excitement. Mary is threatened and punished, threatened and punished, threatened and punished… However, I think that my lack of engagement here is probably because I am slightly (!) older than the intended YA audience. (I know that my student thought the book so gripping that she was rereading it when I spotted it.) Certainly, Mary is presented here as a sympathetic yet sturdy character. She is not a wimp and she is very human. I think this would be appealing to young female readers who would like a strong female role model.
I found the ending a little disappointing. After Anne’s inevitable displacement, the book seems to limp to the end and there is a rather obvious foreshadowing of future events. Given that King Henry would have several more wives, and that Edward would take the throne before Mary, perhaps this was inevitable: although Meyer ends her story in a particular place, Mary’s is nowhere near ending. That said, it doesn’t help that Mary is still rather outside events; this means that events are reported, through dialogue or through letters, so the novel lacks immediacy and drama, even though the events themselves are significant. I thought that this was a shame as, overall, I had quite enjoyed the book.
Perhaps more problematically, the prologue suggests that we shouldn’t judge Mary – presumably by dismissing her with the moniker ‘Bloody Mary’ – until we hear her story. However, despite her poor treatment, there seems little to justify her cruel acts when in power. The novel itself simply doesn’t adequately explain this, especially as most of her hatred is towards Anne and the role of religion is minimised (there isn’t even reference to Henry’s split from Rome). Instead, Meyer attempts to redeem Mary through presenting her as a vulnerable and rejected child, and then stating in a postscript that her reign was ‘no more brutal than those of many European monarchs’. Indeed the postscript summarises in a few pages Mary’s history following 1536 and, although clearly intended to be useful, I found it raised more questions than it answered. It does, however, provide a sense of conclusion that I did nopt feel had been established by the ending of the story itself.
A note on the historical accuracy
An opening disclaimer makes it clear that this is a work of fiction, although it is obviously based on figures and events. Meyer also notes that ‘some details have been altered to enhance the story’. If you are interested in these, Wikipedia notes a few.
As it is fiction, I think it would be unfair to read it expecting total accuracy – indeed, how can you be accurate when you are representing the thoughts of a ten year old girl who is long deceased? However, I did enjoy the fact that it was based in fact and I like to think I have brushed up on my knowledge of this period through my reading!
I liked that the historical detail was incidental. There was no tedious introduction to any of the events or characters, which is good as it would not have suited the style or audience of the book.
Conclusions
I enjoyed this book sufficiently to consider reading one of the others in this series (‘Doomed Queen Anne’) and I did find it fairly interesting until Mary’s exile meant it all became too repetitive. I think it is a good book for Young Adults and I would recommend it in particular to those who are familiar with King Henry’s notorious wife changing and like the idea of a new perspective on events. For adult readers, I suspect the author Philippa Gregory may be a better option for a historical read, but suggest that this is readable if you are looking for something that won’t tax your brain. It certainly doesn’t explain Bloody Mary, but it is a sympathetic account of her childhood.
The premise
Written from the perspective of Princess Mary Tudor, this short novel for teens charts Henry’s separation from his wife Catherine,
Show More
his fascination with ‘The Great Whore’ Anne Boleyn and the outcomes of his decision to marry his mistress. This is part of a series of novels for Young Adult readers in which Meyer writes about the life of a young royal from their perspective. I liked the idea even though the blurb made it sound quite ‘fairytale’ – a young girl is treated badly by a wicked stepmother and stripped of her rightful status. I have nothing against fairytales, it just gave the book quite a ‘young’ feel. In contrast, as the book centres around adultery and includes a passage where Mary is warned about the dangers of gang rape (which, of course, focuses on losing the public’s respect rather than possible damage to one’s sanity) the actual subject matter seems relatively adult. In that respect, I do think that the blurb is perhaps a little misleading in that it focuses on Mary’s physical discomfort, but in the novel she is in physical danger and, towards the end, several executions are described. I thought the premise an interesting one, although it is hardly unique, and I quite liked the idea of what promised to be an easy read (it has only 234 pages).My thoughts
I found the basic set up immediately interesting. First, we are greeted by a family tree. Often, these make me groan as I assume that there will be complicated events later on that mean I need to refer back to the tree, squinting at it as I make minor connections that often prove to be dull or irrelevant. Not so in this case. The Tudor tree is clear and simple and I felt that it helped to focus my mind on the story to come.
Next, there is a prologue in which Mary passionately denounces Anne as a witch and states explicitly why she hates her. Again, I thought that this was engaging as Mary’s passion immediately made me feel at once shocked by her attitude but also intrigued. What had happened to cause such hatred? Had Anne really corrupted Henry? The prologue is kept short, which I thought was appropriate as otherwise there might be too much detail about the story. As it is, the prologue effectively set up the ground that the novel would cover, which is (approximately) 1526 – 1536, or the ‘Anne Boleyn years’. Also, the prologue made me wonder whether Anne really could be the witch that Mary believes as many of Mary’s grievances are clearly against her father, but she believes they are caused by Anne. This seems a perfectly logical position for such a young girl, especially one who would naturally revere her father (given the context of the time and situation). This meant that I was attentive and interested in the following story.
Meyer plunges the reader into Mary’s world in the first sentences of the first chapter. “I inherited King Henry’s fiery temper – no one would deny that! And so, on the day I learned that he had betrothed me to the king of France, I exploded.” I thought this was a very effective opening as it was an interesting situation and not something I’d often thought about when studying history at school, the way young princesses – and princes – were betrothed at young ages to much older people for political or financial expediency. Although it is such a strange situation for a contemporary reader, I thought Mary’s furious response would help to bridge any distance created by the unusual event. The ten year old Mary is understandably angry that she is to be married to a fat old man and this helped me to like her and to feel empathetic. This is important as she is usually remembered as per the title of the book, but this shows the notorious Bloody Mary in a sympathetic light. I liked the mixing of fact and fiction here as I thought it was quite a reasonable response to her plight!
As can be seen in the above quote, despite the fact that Mary lived nearly 500 years ago, she is given a contemporary style of speech. I thought that this was a good idea, especially as this is fiction for YA readers. It also suits Mary’s confident and curious nature. Instead of trying to create an ‘olde worlde’ atmosphere through the syntax and vocabulary, Meyer creates a sense of history through the events, historical characters and minor details. The font style helps too – I do not know the name of it, but it has a definite ‘old-fashioned’ feel. I liked this as it did help to create a sense of an earlier time.
Chapters have titles throughout, which I often find irritating as they can give away the plot developments or seem daftly elliptical and there purely to show off the author’s clever mind. The titles here are usually one or two word notes that simply suggest the chapter’s focus (e.g. ‘falconry’ or ‘lessons’) and as such I thought that they worked well enough, although I didn’t think that they were really necessary.
In terms of the plotting, I found the earlier chapters most interesting as they focused on Mary’s experiences in the castle and, as she spends a lot of time listening quietly, there is much gossip about Lady Anne and King Henry. Later on, when the pair eventually meet as stepmother and outcast daughter, Anne seemed overwritten as the evil stepmother and didn’t seem very ‘real’. As the blurb reveals, Mary is declared illegitimate and banished to make way for the new queen. I felt that as Mary’s exile developed the story became slightly repetitive and lacked excitement. Mary is threatened and punished, threatened and punished, threatened and punished… However, I think that my lack of engagement here is probably because I am slightly (!) older than the intended YA audience. (I know that my student thought the book so gripping that she was rereading it when I spotted it.) Certainly, Mary is presented here as a sympathetic yet sturdy character. She is not a wimp and she is very human. I think this would be appealing to young female readers who would like a strong female role model.
I found the ending a little disappointing. After Anne’s inevitable displacement, the book seems to limp to the end and there is a rather obvious foreshadowing of future events. Given that King Henry would have several more wives, and that Edward would take the throne before Mary, perhaps this was inevitable: although Meyer ends her story in a particular place, Mary’s is nowhere near ending. That said, it doesn’t help that Mary is still rather outside events; this means that events are reported, through dialogue or through letters, so the novel lacks immediacy and drama, even though the events themselves are significant. I thought that this was a shame as, overall, I had quite enjoyed the book.
Perhaps more problematically, the prologue suggests that we shouldn’t judge Mary – presumably by dismissing her with the moniker ‘Bloody Mary’ – until we hear her story. However, despite her poor treatment, there seems little to justify her cruel acts when in power. The novel itself simply doesn’t adequately explain this, especially as most of her hatred is towards Anne and the role of religion is minimised (there isn’t even reference to Henry’s split from Rome). Instead, Meyer attempts to redeem Mary through presenting her as a vulnerable and rejected child, and then stating in a postscript that her reign was ‘no more brutal than those of many European monarchs’. Indeed the postscript summarises in a few pages Mary’s history following 1536 and, although clearly intended to be useful, I found it raised more questions than it answered. It does, however, provide a sense of conclusion that I did nopt feel had been established by the ending of the story itself.
A note on the historical accuracy
An opening disclaimer makes it clear that this is a work of fiction, although it is obviously based on figures and events. Meyer also notes that ‘some details have been altered to enhance the story’. If you are interested in these, Wikipedia notes a few.
As it is fiction, I think it would be unfair to read it expecting total accuracy – indeed, how can you be accurate when you are representing the thoughts of a ten year old girl who is long deceased? However, I did enjoy the fact that it was based in fact and I like to think I have brushed up on my knowledge of this period through my reading!
I liked that the historical detail was incidental. There was no tedious introduction to any of the events or characters, which is good as it would not have suited the style or audience of the book.
Conclusions
I enjoyed this book sufficiently to consider reading one of the others in this series (‘Doomed Queen Anne’) and I did find it fairly interesting until Mary’s exile meant it all became too repetitive. I think it is a good book for Young Adults and I would recommend it in particular to those who are familiar with King Henry’s notorious wife changing and like the idea of a new perspective on events. For adult readers, I suspect the author Philippa Gregory may be a better option for a historical read, but suggest that this is readable if you are looking for something that won’t tax your brain. It certainly doesn’t explain Bloody Mary, but it is a sympathetic account of her childhood.
Show Less
LibraryThing member LibraryCin
3.5 stars
This is a YA novel about Mary I, set primarily during the time that Anne Boleyn is in Henry VIII's life. It's been a couple of days since I finished, and I read it so fast, I have to admit that I already can't recall what I was going to rate it. Thinking back, though, I think it's a good
This is a YA novel about Mary I, set primarily during the time that Anne Boleyn is in Henry VIII's life. It's been a couple of days since I finished, and I read it so fast, I have to admit that I already can't recall what I was going to rate it. Thinking back, though, I think it's a good
Show More
book for young people or maybe someone with their first introduction to Mary. There wasn't much in the story that I didn't already know, but there were a few characters/people I hadn't really read much about As the book came to a close, I wondered if the author was planning a sequel, but she did any "updates" in the Historical note at the end. Show Less
LibraryThing member Hamburgerclan
When I picked this book, the next in line for my daughter's school reading, I groaned inwardly. "Not another renaissance book! I'm getting sick of the renaissance! The renaissance is overrated!" he said, swiping a line from Terry Jones. But dutiful homeschooling dad that I am, I read it anyway,
--J.
Show More
bracing myself for another tedious account of betrayals and beheadings and other such royal shenanigans. I was pleasantly surprised. Ms. Meyer did an excellent job of drawing me into the story of young Mary Tudor, daughter of King Henry VIII and heir to the throne... until ol' Henry decided that he really needed a son and tried to divorce Mary's mother. By viewing the court intrigues through Mary's eyes--the viewpoint of one getting screwed over by all this royal b.s.--the historical story is given an emotional punch that made me want to finish the tale and root for the young princess. (It's only in the afterword when I was pulled back to reality and discovered that poor Mary had her own bloodthirsty streak.) Anyway, this is a somewhat strong tale for the young'uns, but one that makes the reader care about the people involved. Check it out.--J.
Show Less
LibraryThing member theBkids
"Bloody Mary"
The name doesn't usually convey what this novel reveals.
When she was a girl she was gentle, but because of her brutal rule she is known as bloody Mary.
The name doesn't usually convey what this novel reveals.
When she was a girl she was gentle, but because of her brutal rule she is known as bloody Mary.
LibraryThing member t1bclasslibrary
This biography is fascinating because we get the perspective of someone we usually never hear from- Henry VIII's first daughter. We get to empathize with her in a way that we completely fail to in any Elizabeth I bios. The story begins when she is very young (the time frame of the beginning is
Show More
confusing) until a bit after Anne Boleyn is killed, and a historical note explains what happened after that. On a side note, I totally appreciate the blackwork on her cuffs in the cover picture. Show Less
LibraryThing member jrakeandlola
I really enjoyed this book because it had more adventure than some of the other books I read
LibraryThing member sgerbic
Reviewed Nov 2000 Another charming biography told from the viewpoint of a young Mary. The title is misleading as the authors slant is very sympathetic towards her plight. That author is cleaver at showing Mary’s antics and eavesdropping skills. As with all books about this history, all blame is
Show More
put on the women involved. Henry VIII is bewitched and can’t control himself. The author is pretty accurate to the facts. 23-2000 Show Less
LibraryThing member nm.fall08.j.bean
This book is about a girl named Mary and her struggles to become Queen. The good thing about this book is that it is a mistory what Mary will have to do toi stay in the good grace of her Father. The bad thing is that her step-mother is forcing her to do things for her sister Mary doesn't want to
Show More
do. If you like a book that will never let you down then this book is for you. Show Less
LibraryThing member Kaydence
How would it feel if you were a princess beloved by your father one day and then a servant to your half sister another? In Meyer's Mary, Bloody Mary, the reader finds out. Meyer is excellent at transforming people from history into characters that are real and interesting. The reader's heart breaks
Show More
as Mary struggles to understand what her place is in the kingdom when she is banished away from her place in the palace. Things seem to get worse and worse as the story continues, but Mary's spirit does not break. This is a wonderful book about courage, strength, and overcoming hardships. I recommend girls to read this type of novel so that they can find a role model that is worth looking up to. The narrative ends before Mary becomes queen, which probably is better because the reader doesn't lose the connection with the character, as Mary's character in the book is much different than what happens when she becomes queen. Show Less
LibraryThing member goth_marionette
This book was an enjoyable read and as far as my knowledge goes, historically accurate. This presents the point of view of a younger Mary Tudor. This could be a good contrast to a book on Queen Elizabeth in a classroom.
LibraryThing member khportlandclass
Although many people have given this novel high reviews, I did not enjoy it one bit. The plot was dull at times and then overly complicated at others. The negative events in the story, such as Mary's mother being banished and Anne Boleyn being beheaded, were not counter balanced with positive
Show More
events of the same weight. I was always painfully aware that I was reading a book without ever being sucked into the story. I realize that this tale is based on real events that were not very happy, but I still do not think the story was well written. I would not recommend this book to my students. Show Less
LibraryThing member meacoleman
Carolyn Meyer sympathetically weaves together vignettes from Mary Tudor's life in an attempt to explain how she grew into a harsh ruler. I've read stories and watched movies about Henry VIII but never thought about how much Mary's life changed with Anne Boleyn. I recommend this book for anyone who
Show More
wants a quick read to gain insight into one of England's most misunderstood rulers. Show Less
LibraryThing member Salsabrarian
A historical novel of Mary Tudor, daughter of Henry VIII and what she endures and witnesses as her father falls under the charms of Lady Anne Boleyn. His reign and behavior become increasingly erratic as Mary and her mother Catherine are banished to remote locations. Much suspense and intrigue as
Show More
Mary hopes desperately to be reinstated as heir to the throne and reunited with her mother. Show Less
Similar in this library
Lexile
830L
Pages
227