Publication
Original publication date
Collections
Genres
Subjects
Awards
Description
Fiction. Mystery. HTML: From the critically acclaimed, award-winning S. J. Rozan comes her finest novel to date-an explosive novel about the corrosive power of secrets and corruption in a small town. In the middle of the night, private investigator Bill Smith is awakened by a call from the NYPD. They're holding fifteen-year-old named Gary-Bill's nephew. But before Bill can find out what is going on, Gary escapes custody into the dark night and unfamiliar streets. Bill, with the help of his partner Lydia Chin, tries to find the missing teen and uncover what it is that led him so far from home. Tracking Gary's family to a small town in New Jersey, Bill finds himself in a town where nothing matters but high school football, where the secrets of the past-both the town's and Bill's own-threaten to destroy the present. And if Bill is to have any chance of saving Gary and preventing a tragedy, he has to both unravel a long buried crime and confront the darkness of his own past..… (more)
User reviews
This book already won the Edgar, and it's up for an Anthony, a Macavity and a Shamus. Rozan deserves all of them. Her work is stellar.
The book has several strengths - the writer has a good flow to the narrative, it usually does not get ahead of itself or bog down in unimportant areas of the story. She does try to juggle a lot of balls all at one time but it never becomes weighted down, though some of the story lines that start off with promise don't really go anywhere; but such is life itself. The flaws out number the strengths though, but only 2 of them actually detract from the overall effect of the book.
Warrenstown is a fictional town and is so one demensional that it is actually more like a caricature of small town America. There is not very much belivable about it. In contrast, New York City is very believable. All the characters from there have depth and seem three deminsional, even some of the minor characters from NYC are real. But there is much less of this in Warrenstown. The men are really angry and really ready to get in a fight with everybody that moves, or.... they are nerds. The women are even worse, almost invisible except for one 17 year old girl that writes for the school newspaper. The male Neanderthal act does get heavy handed by the end of the book. It drags on the story as a whole and is repetitive.
***Spoiler Alert***As the story comes to it's conclusion, there are several holes in the ending that are implausible and irritating. Not all the threads of the story are neatly tied off, but again... such is life itself. This is even the point the writer is making to some degree, things don't get cleaned up nicely in real life. The thing that does stand out glaringly as a flaw though is that the hero, Bill Smith, tries to get one of the bad guys in a "round about way" by telling his story to the 17 year old girl who writes for the paper. In an attempt to get at the bad guy, Bill tells her the sorry things the bad guy has done so she can write a story about him and get the court of public opinion against him. Bill feels pretty good about himself for having done this as the book ends; he may not have gotten him arrested but now everyone will know what he is really like. Only problem, the girl has already been beaten up and put in the hsopital for helping Bill. And he goes ahead and puts her back in harms way. Thanks a lot Bill.
I picked up [b:Winter and Night at a used book sale some time ago and left it on the shelf until I reached it in the progression of Edgar Best Novel winners. Normally I like to begin at the beginning of a series but for this reading project I decided to go in "cold" if the author was new to me.
First, Winter and Night was certainly deserving of the 2003 Edgar Best Novel award. Oddly, (and I gather the judges change regularly so this may be the reason), three of the four nominees who were runners-up were also series entries, which is somewhat unusual. I enjoyed the two I've read, and I would have had a hard time choosing between Manda Scott's No Good Deed and the winner, but I would find it hard to quibble with the judges' choice in this case.
Rozan set herself a difficult task in this book. She artfully mingles "ripped-from-the-headlines" topics (to tell what they are would introduce too many spoilers), a decades-old case whose resolution is in doubt, one of the most complicated revenge stories I've ever encountered, and a major revelation by one of her protagonists, private investigator Bill Smith, about his past. I was riveted from beginning to end. The secondary characters are well-drawn and nuanced even when they at first seem to be stereotypes. And of course, the relationship -- whatever it is! -- between Bill and his younger partner, Lydia Chin, is intriguing. I will definitely need to read the remainder of the series and hope it continues for a long time. Highly recommended.