Status
Call number
Series
Genres
Collections
Publication
Description
Galaxy "Alex" Stern is the most unlikely member of Yale's freshman class. Raised in the Los Angeles hinterlands by a hippie mom, Alex dropped out of school early and into a world of shady drug-dealer boyfriends, dead-end jobs, and much, much worse. In fact, by age twenty, she is the sole survivor of a horrific, unsolved multiple homicide. Some might say she's thrown her life away. But at her hospital bed, Alex is offered a second chance: to attend one of the world's most prestigious universities on a full ride. What's the catch, and why her? Still searching for answers, Alex arrives in New Haven tasked by her mysterious benefactors with monitoring the activities of Yale's secret societies. Their eight windowless "tombs" are the well-known haunts of the rich and powerful, from high-ranking politicos to Wall Street's biggest players. But their occult activities are more sinister and more extraordinary than any paranoid imagination might conceive. They tamper with forbidden magic. They raise the dead. And, sometimes, they prey on the living.… (more)
User reviews
This had all the elements of something I would love in a story. Dark Academia, rituals, magic, murder, vices, and a host of less than desirable characters. It was also backed with Bardugo's beautiful writting.
Where it failed was its many tiny meandering mysteries colliding and weaving
This read like a love letter to Yale and, oh yeah...oops I'm supposed to remember there is a plot here. Nothing about the characters, thier roles or motives is as grandly fleshed out as the buildings and streets that make up Bardugo's Ivy Alma Mater. Overall it just left me wanting.
The writing in this book tries very hard to feel pretentious, I think. It feels like Donna Tartt Lite, but I didn't mind the overly-descriptive nature with The Secret History, whereas some of the random details mentioned throughout the prose in this
As for the plot... this is a mystery wrapped up in low fantasy. The mystery has a lot of twists, almost too many, and the ending is a little underwhelming given how many Villain Monologues it contains.
Darlington is the only character I definitively liked.
Alex felt a little too 2-dimensional for me to really decide on. She's clearly a self-insert for Leigh Bardugo (from SoCal, went to Yale, supposedly a lot of Alex's background is drawn from Bardugo's own) and I normally dislike when an author has so clearly inserted themself into the story, but I don't think that was really my issue at all with Alex. There were parts of the book where I even liked Alex, but those were simply glimpses and overall she felt very bland to me otherwise, with the exception of her backstory. She has a backstory, but that doesn't really result in her having any depth as a character if that makes sense.
The Bridegroom interested me. Other than him the rest of the background characters were simply background characters. I wish we had gotten more of Dawes, but it looks like we'll be getting that for sure in the next one.
The magic system is another thing I can't decide about. It feels half-baked, and I have a hard time suspending my disbelief enough to really buy into it for the whole book.
What I found hard to buy into was the idea that magic belongs to the Ivy League and only the Ivy League and this how they run the world as if privilege on its own isn't enough to accomplish that (and yet, this book tries so hard to be woke.) It felt like The Magicians type magical privilege, but without any thought at all. For those of you who haven't read the magicians, the magical schools like Brakebills are the only way for magicians to access magic, but there's a whole ecosystem of Hedge Witches who try to access it on their own and fly under the radar of the powers that be. There was no Ninth House version of Hedge Witches, and I think that's a shame.
This book shines in its setting and general aesthetics. The atmosphere is, frankly, masterfully crafted. The essence of dark academia and occult magic lives in this book, and I really appreciated that.
Anyway, this was just an okay read for me. Not sure about continuing the series.
A double mystery, one surrounding a young woman’s death [and purportedly involving magic], the other a mysterious disappearance, lies at the heart of this slowly unfolding story that alternates between past and present. The setting is spot-on; the narrative is perfectly atmospheric and completely unnerving. The line between reality and magic is truly fluid, so much so that, at times, fact and fantasy truly seem to overlap.
But the huge information dump that begins this convoluted narrative presages what is to come. And it isn’t pretty. There are no particularly likable characters; the story turns on privileged entitlement, abuse, drugs, violence, rapes, murder, and more. Extensive overuse of a detestable expletive adds to the growing list of repugnant events spinning out in the pages of this dark and heavy tale that’s definitely not for the faint of heart.
There’s a cliffhanger ending, no doubt hoping to entice readers to read the next book in the series, but after this book’s assault on readers’ sensibilities, many are not likely to be looking to enter this dark world again.
> The air felt slightly balmy and she could smell orange blossoms on the air.
I love a kick-ass broad and that is what Alex is. She came up the hard way, got involved in drugs and other things. She figures maybe her life is starting to look up with a fresh start on the other side of the country at Yale. She has no idea of what she faces. She is smart and learns as she goes especially with Darlington gone. She follows her instincts. She is not above putting a little hurting on someone if need be. Dawes is interesting. Alex and she do not get along at first but eventually Dawes sees what Alex is. They have each other's back which is good because what is on the surface is not what is reality.
The story is fast paced when Alex begins to check out the murder. There is a lot of action. There is a lot of otherworldly aspects to the Houses as well as history of the town and the Houses. It kept my interest and I cannot wait for the next book.
I went to the BN Book club to discuss this book before I had finished it. I was surprised how many people didn’t like it. But then again it was an odd choice for BN Book Club that normally does mysteries and thrillers with a woman’s spin. If your normal meat and potatoes is general fiction, I can see how you might be turned off by this occult fascination. One woman only gave it 4 pages. I thoroughly enjoyed it and loved the discussions that we did have. This was right in my wheelhouse of things I love, and I eagerly await book 2. If only the wait wasn’t so long.
PS- Alex is my bad ass b!t@h, that's here to right all wrongs!!!
This was a pretty good novel. Not having read any other of this author’s novels, I had no idea what this author would produce.
I have to say it was pretty good, for the most part. There were some parts that
The supernatural parts of the novel were pretty good. But the characters (and a type) had me perplexed in these ways:
-Alex was embarrassed of her tattoos near the beginning of the novel, and it seems everyone and their mother has them now. I’m sure the author thought that this character would believe Alex didn’t think students at a major college like Yale should have tattoos, but I bet even some of the teachers at this esteemed school has one or two, these days. Isn’t this novel set in today’s time...?
-Darlington seemed and acted like a 30 year old man, and I had a difficult time trying to think of him as yet another college student, as he was supposed to be.
-Alex’s mom is portrayed by a hippie type. WHY ARE ALL THE MOTHERS IN BOOKS THESE DAYS HIPPIE TYPES? It’s SO annoying to have this happen time and again. Stop it.
-Alex didn’t act like a former drug addict. She didn’t go through rehab. She didn’t have any cravings.
-Alex didn’t act like she had “a little viper lurking in there, ready to strike” at all. If she had, she would have acted differently to everyone around her. I’ve known people like this. No one is safe, not even friends.
Anyway, I made it through this novel. I don’t think it deserves quite all the accolades it’s gotten, and now that I’ve listened to the audiobook, I’m surprised that it’s in Gr’s choice for the finals in Best Fantasy. I didn’t think it was *that* good, but maybe I’m one of the few around here who does. Whatever.
Oh yeah, Lauren Fortgang is one of the narrators of the audiobook. She is pretty great with accents and making everyone sound different. Michael David Axtell is another narrator in this novel, and he was pretty good also.
I’m just sad that I’d bought this novel, as I’m disappointed in myself for spending the money on it. It’s a good novel to lose yourself in when you need something to read, but I’ve no desire to own it, or reread it. I’m not even sure if I’m going to read the sequel that’s due out in 2021.
3 stars, and recommended to people who need something to do....?
Honestly, this book didn't really do quite as much for me as I was hoping. I am emphatically not a big reader of darker fantasy/horror/whatever this was, even if I was hoping a bit that I'd find this book wonderful, so I don't know to what extent my lukewarm-ness pertains specifically to this book or to the genre more generally. I will say that I liked the idea of the Yale setting (though sometimes it felt a little like ~*Dark Academia*~ to the extreme/some of the characters were awfully full of themselves), and by far my favorite part was the creativity of the various different secret societies' rituals and of the different magical potions. At the same time, though, I often felt as the book progressed that I wished that the magic system (if you will) were more fleshed-out from the outset. It felt sometimes that a number of the major plot points involved the sudden revelation of various new forms of magic--while I know that Alex is new to the whole world of the Yale societies and the related magic, I found it a bit frustrating that a number of major plot points seemed to hinge on totally unforeseeable uses of magic. Relatedly, though in a huge way the basic plot is the untangling of a mystery, looking back I don't see any possible way to untangle even a shred of the plot in advance.
With all that being said, I did like Darlington quite a bit (honestly, in a lot of ways more than Alex), so maybe I'll take a chance on the next book at some point once it comes out. We'll see. And though I've been fairly critical in this review, I can totally imagine people liking this book a lot--those people just weren't me.
But the main protagonist of Ninth House, Alex Stern, her back story and the overall tone of the novel and its magical world building layered over the secret societies of Yale was just so gritty, empowering and cool! So excited that this is just #1 in the Alex Stern series.
So, although not my cup of tea, give it a