Status
Call number
Series
Publication
Description
Magic is out of fashion. Good manners never are. Jemis Greenwing returned from university with a broken heart, a bad cold, and no prospects beyond a problematic inheritance and a job at the local bookstore. Ragnor Bella is a placid little market town on the road to nowhere, where Jemis' family affairs have always been the main source of gossip. Having missed his stepfather's funeral, he is determined to keep his head down. Unfortunately for his reputation, though fortunately for several other people, he falls quickly under the temptation of resuming the friendship of Mr. Dart of Dartington, Squire-in-training and beloved local daredevil. Mr. Dart is delighted to have Jemis' company for what will be, he assures him, a very small adventure. Jemis expected the cut direct. The secret societies, criminal gangs, and illegal cult to the old gods--to say nothing of the mermaid--come as a complete surprise. Book One of Greenwing & Dart, fantasies of manners-and mischief.… (more)
User reviews
This is the first book in the Greenwing & Dart trilogy. Although I liked it enough to buy the rest of the trilogy, it was my least favorite of the three. There are many things that are unexplained at the end; as well as many things that are either mis-understood or not understood at all by both the characters and the reader. I recently re-read it and found I still really liked it; I may even like it a bit more now that I understand what is happening a bit better....
She was right about the caveats, and it was a fun read.
The story takes place in an alternative universe I kept trying to plop into the UK because so
And speaking of this world, the author proves here, by it’s complete absence, that a little info dumping can be a good thing. I spend a third of the book trying to figure out what was going on and it kept me from getting lost in the book until pretty much the last third of the story. It’s alternate-universe fantasy – a little explaining would have been welcome.
So. much. sneezing.
The main character, Jemis Greenwing, has had a rather shitty life, in spite of having all the necessary ingredients for a charmed one. It takes way too long, but eventually you figure out that his father was branded a traitor, then a war hero, though nobody remembers that, and his mother a bigamist who went through her inheritance trying to support her and her son.
Both parents die when he’s still young and he goes to university, falls in love and excels at his studies, only to find out his true love betrayed him and his professor flunks him on his final paper. He ends up in hospital sick with a flu he can’t shake, and the confrontation he and his girlfriend had results in such an uproar, he’s run out of town, and while he’s on a walking tour (hiding), misses his step-father’s death and funeral. He’s back home, trying to hide from everyone who thinks he’s the son of a traitor, and working in a bookshop. His memory is hazy, he loses his train of thought, he’s certain he’s unworthy of any kindness, and omg, so much sneezing.
All of this is pretty much all the information you don’t get until about half way through the book, and only then in dibs and dabs. It made it very difficult for me to click with the main character. He was always unsure of himself, scattered, and, well, moist.
But once Mr. Dart arrived on the scene, and to a lesser extent Violet and Mrs. Etaris, things started picking up. By the halfway mark I was reasonable certain – as much as the plot allowed, which isn’t much – of what was going on. Mr. Dart was all the things Jemis wasn’t and it was a much needed boost to my enjoyment. The repartee between the two life-long friends made me feel like I could eventually like Jemis, and by the last third, I was completely hooked on the characters, if not the plot.
The plot came together all too chaotically and rapidly for my liking. I suppose that’s because Jemis was the MC, and not Mrs. Etaris. Had Mrs. Etaris been the MC of this book everything would have been far clearer, more organised, and events handled far more efficiently.
But in spite of all of that, there was something fun about this book. It was quirky, the dialog was smart and amusing, and interesting things happened at a fairly even pace. So, while I didn’t think I was going to like this book all that much at first, I ended it with a desire to read the second book.
All's well that ends with another book to read…
Jervis Greenwing is a bit of both - he's returning home, somewhat in ignominy after several years studying the culture and influences of magic at university. However a very public disagreement with a former lover resulted in his abrupt departure. He toured various towns and so failed to hear of, or attend, an important family funeral. This was the last straw and refreshed everyone's memory of his ill-fated father and so his quiet home-town is all agog. Jervis is trying to repair his situation with menial work in a bookstore, and the fascinating Mrs Eavis. Not all of his friends have abandoned him, and so he has a few invitations to evening events, one of which culminates in him finding a resurrection of the old beliefs. A cult is re-instating ritual sacrifice to the Old Gods. Jervis is pretty sure there isn't actually any such power, but he's not quite sure what to do about it.
The world is a little odd, with an almost amusing high adherence to a courtly manners present at all levels of society, hence Jervis discomfort at such a menial position. However he soon learns to embrace the ideals he ensconced at university of a more egalitarian society. Th eplot is very confusing with Jervis not actually knowing very much at any stage, and becomes somewhat embroiled without his knowledge. Sadly this means the reader is left unaware of many details too - there is somewhat of a grand denouement, but a several critical points are still brushed under the carpet. But there's enough joy in the sheer craziness that this can be overlooked.
This is a type of fantasy that I like. The setting veers between Georgian and Victorian, though the land and places are fictional. There is magic, but it's been banned, at least in some places. Oh, and there's smuggling. And some odd religions. And mysteries to solve.
This book reminds me of Alexis Hall's The Affair of the Mysterious Letter. It takes the reader on a wild ride, and I'm happy to continue it in the next book.
This is the first in the Greenwood & Dart series, which is more lighthearted than The Hands of the Emperor and its immediate sequels, and was also written earlier. The characters were great, though, and there are hints of a more complex world than we see at first blush. As a result, I was willing to forgive some of the flaws, such as a general lack of "things happening" except when a lot of things happen, and the confused ending that I didn't follow at all. But I really love Jemis and his friends, and I'm curious to see what mysteries they come across next.
Original publication date
Local notes
DDC/MDS
Fic SF Goddard |