Status
Call number
Series
Genres
Publication
Description
Stuart MacBride's Number One bestselling crime series opens with this award-winning debut. DS Logan McRae and the police in Aberdeen hunt a child killer who stalks the frozen streets. Winter in Aberdeen: murder, mayhem and terrible weather... It's DS Logan McRae's first day back on the job after a year off on the sick, and it couldn't get much worse. Three-year-old David Reid's body is discovered in a ditch: strangled, mutilated and a long time dead. And he's only the first. There's a serial killer stalking the Granite City and the local media are baying for blood. Soon the dead are piling up in the morgue almost as fast as the snow on the streets, and Logan knows time is running out. More children are going missing. More are going to die. And if Logan isn't careful, he could end up joining them.… (more)
User reviews
Logan Mcrae is our heoric DS. He's been off sick
There's plenty of humour along the way, as well as some well crafted interactions amoung the police. Whether its a bolshy Detective Inspector or a bunch of the 'lads' out for a drink to erase the memories of a hard day, the details seem to fit. The police work also feels equally realistic, plenty of assumptions about what could have happened, finding some evidence to support it, and later realising that other interpretations are possible - very human, unlike some police stories out there. The triggers that form these assumptions are also given in sufficient detail to make it obvious to the reader what is going on. The annoying habit some authors have of giving insights from the perpetrators point of view is completely avoided, which keeps the tension going right up to the end.
Some of the characters were a little bit overdone - if DI Insch really ate that many sweets he wouldn't have any teeth left, nor be able to fit through a doorway. Likewise DI Steel, and also Aberdeen's weather, which I'm sure can't be unrelentingly bad for two straight weeks.... most of the time. I didn't spot any obvious plot holes, which is another point its favour, and all the various investigative threads were eventually tidied up, not too neatly, but realistically.
Overal very enjoyable, and a name well worth looking out for more.
It is DS McRae's first day back on the job after a serious injury, and things start off bad. A young boy's body is found. As more bodies of children turn up, and others are kidnapped, it is a race against time to find the person who is responsible.
As a side note there is a possible budding relationship forming between Logan and a fellow officer, WPC Jackie Watson. And there are multiple 'gross out' points in the book as decomposing bodies and autopsies are described.
His new boss DI Insch doesn't suffer fools gladly and regards most people as fools. His ex-girlfriend
With several twists and turns this is an interesting story.
The author's great talent, I think, lies in the creation of atmosphere -- the hearty, well-lubricated police get-togethers at a local bar; the stench and slime of vivid crime scenes; the bleak interrogation rooms of the local police headquarters. American that I am, I had no problem fancying myself in Scotland, after reading MacBride's lucid descriptions.
And MacBride has limned some memorable characters, as well. From the pushy but likable crime reporter to the beautifully icy pathologist, MacBride's characters seem fully real. In fact, his protagonist, detective Logan MacRae, is almost the weakest character in the book -- not because of MacBride's descriptive talents, but simply because MacRae breaks the mold of the usual detective protagonist. He's not always in control, not brooding nor bitter, and it takes him quite a while to figure out what's going on beneath the surface of a number of similar crimes.
That said, I found this book heavy-going. I finished it quickly, but often had to force myself to pay attention to every page. That is my own personal weakness, though, not the author's. I am just not a big fan of police procedurals in general, though this one was a well-written debut.
A fan called this a "Tartan noir" but I must respectfully disagree. Though the weather throughout the book is bleak, the characters are not. MacBride sprinkles a generous dose of humanity into every character; even the villains are sympathetically painted.
Setting: present-day Aberdeen, Scotland
Series: #1
Relentless rain reflects the mood that permeates this début set in Aberdeen,
Scotland. DS Logan MacRae, just returned from a lengthy convalescence caused
by a suspect's vicious knife attack, is thrown
investigation of a murdered child. To make matters worse, the victim's
family learns of the death from a reporter before the police have a chance
to inform them. More children go missing, and soon the populace of Aberdeen
is screaming for blood. Juggling an exhausting caseload, the leak within the
department, a reporter who hounds him for exclusives, and a volatile city,
MacRae has to find the strength to eliminate all the distractions and try to
anticipate the killer's next move.
MacBride's strengths are his characterization and a raft of intriguing
subplots. I found Cold Granite almost impossible to put down and closed it
with a "Wow!"
Detective Sergeant Logan MacRae has returned from recovering from near-fatal stab wounds to the Grampian Police Force to face immediately a dead child and the possibility of a serial paedophile killer. Other dead
While not consciously a spin-off of Ian Rankin’s series, this is close enough to merit comparison. And comes up lacking in almost every respect. MacBride does a very good plot, but his writing runs the spectrum from pathetic to adequate to “precious”. Someone either told him or he learned in a writing course that you have to be clever with words to stand out from the crowd, and MacBride took this too much to heart. For example, there is the use of the verb, ‘to sulk”. A house sulked, the sky sulked, something else sulked. None of it worked. Another example: “she scrabbled backward”. Scrabbled?? No.
There are some good parts. MacBride does a good job in writing about the more or less adolescent interactions between members of the police force, which I found believable enough. He uses quite a few Aberdonian words, such as ‘shoogled’ (to scoot along a bench or seat) that lend a nice atmosphere to the story. His descriptions of the weather convinced me never to visit Aberdeen. His characters have potential but he simply does not know how to handle them. One character in particular was really well done, though—a female Detective Inspector who turns out to be quite a womanizer!
The denouement was weak enough, but the writing was so awkward and inadequate that it made the ending almost boring.
The "granite" of the title refers to the traditional building material of Aberdeen. The cover art bears no resemblance whatsoever to anything that occurs within the story.
This debut novel is so awkward that I have no desire to read any further in the series.
The writing is sometimes overworked I think, but there are good twists to the interwoven plotlines that will keep most readers guessing as to the resolution. It's a dark story of serial child killings, mob retaliation, and broken families, with gruesome descriptions of postmortems and the dead, but there is also some humor to lighten things up. There are perhaps too many coincedental plotlines involving children that create red herrings, but ultimately, I enjoyed the book and will read the next in the series.
I like the way the plot starts mid-story as it were, with McRae having returned to duty after a long time off duty recovering from vicious stab wounds to the stomach which almost result in his becoming addicted to painkillers. He is put to work with Detective Inspector David Insch, a large, irrascible man who constantly stuffs himself with sweets - anything from liquorice allsorts to fizzy cola bottles - but despite his appearance and manner, is efficient and bluffly likable. Logan is plunged back in the deep-end when he is set to work on a series of abductions and murders of little boys.
He meets former star reporter Colin Miller, exiled from Glasgow into the provinces after been threatened by crime boss 'Malk the knife': Colin seems to have an informant in the Grampian police team who feeds him information Logan wants to stay secret but it turns out his stoolie is none other than McRae's former girlfriend, the lovely and icily elegant Isobel McAlister, police pathologist.
MacBride is one of the few writers who has not had to improve with practise: he starts good, as evidenced by this books, and just goes on getting better [excuse the contradiction in terms] and I shall be looking for books 3, 5 and 7 in the series to fill the gaps in my collection.
This a very gritty,and no holds barred book, with a very unflattering weather picture of
He's the type of person that is assigned to cases that are difficult or need a speedy resolution and when a child's body is found, murdered and dismembered, he's given the case.
When
McRae works for a controlling, authoritative supervisor. Det. Inspector Insch is a large, bald man McRae compares to a well-dressed Buddah but not as friendley.
Insch also does pantomine at the local theater when off duty and tries to get other employees on the job to buy tickets to the theater.
Another body is found. This time it's a girl and killed in a different manner. The police are worried that they have two child killers at work in their small community.
McRae is eminently believable. He's the type of character the reader likes and believes that if they were in a similar position as McRae, they'd act as he does.
I enjoyed the story and the setting and look forward to more books about Sgt. Logan McRae.
It hasn’t put me off reading more of MacBride’s work, though.
Overall, a really good read and I will read more of this series.... but I think I need to take a bit of a break from dark reads like this one before I think about diving into book two in the series.
Logan is just so likeable , though he does have a lot of slightly
I'd forgotten about DI Steel. It is gritty, and realistic sounding. He's a very talented author. The victims are so ...pathetic in the proper sense and the outrage the police feel at the crimes is palpable.
Went and bought Dying Light before completion.
4 Stars
Following a year of recuperation, DS Logan McRae is hoping for a slow return to the Aberdeen force. However, with the discovery of the body of a 3-year-old boy, McRae is thrust into a heartbreaking and horrific investigation. As the bodies begin piling up and several children go
***Warning***: This book contains graphic and disturbing descriptions of child murder, and is not for readers offended by this type of story and writing.
The plot is comprised of several seemingly unrelated threads that MacBride ultimately weaves together to form a unified whole. While some of the plot twists are obvious, others come as a surprise and the finale is intense and satisfying. MacBride's writing is brisk with sufficient humor to offset the terrible nature of the crimes without being callous or cold-blooded.
DS Logan McRae is an appealing mix of experience and naiveté. While he is a skilled investigator with excellent instincts, he is almost childlike when it comes to personal and professional relationships.
The secondary characters are well-developed whether it is McRae's tetchy boss with his penchant for charity pantomimes or the smarmy journalist with his loathsome attitude or the feisty and capable WPC assigned to keep McRae out of trouble.
In sum, Cold Granite is a riveting police procedural with engaging characters and a complex and multifaceted storyline. Highly recommended for fans of British crime novels and the writing of Tess Gerritsen and Karin Slaughter.