What's So Funny?

Slightly below average for a Dortmunder novel. Not the laff riot I was craving -- but that may have had something to do with my mood when I read it, which was not good.

I don't like the reader's (William Dufris) interpretation. His women are weak.

another Dortmunder book. Complicated and fun.

Another Dortmunder caper. Successful but not as successful as some.

Amusing occasionally but this one just didn't grab me as much as some of his other Dortmunder stories have done. It seemed like it was just going through the paces rather than trying to be fresh and new.

An ex-cop pressures Dortmunder and his crew to steal a gold chess set for his client, a wealthy man from whose grandfather it had been originally stolen. Needless to say, the caper seems impossible, then possibilities open up, success is within their grasp and eludes them. A well worn, but ever

Show More

well used formula for the humorous caper novels that Westlake excels in.

Show Less

I find Donald Westlake's Dortmunder novels to be comforting. They're never earthshaking, nor among the best reads of any given month. But they're always good enough to finish and not regret having spent time reading them.

Not to much here. Lots of planning, great execution and then someone else benefits. The plan is to steal a solid gold chess set stolen during WWI by American soldiers and then to divide the spoils when they got home. That was the beginning of things going wrong.

Another great book in the Dortmunder series. Westlake is a master writer who doesn't waste a word in the book, creating such a breezy style that pages are turned without even realizing it.

What's so funny? I really did enjoy this caper. Donald Westlake dovetails all the pieces together so skillfully to enable his inept superhero Dortmunder and his circus of crooks from the bar-room to carve a golden catwalk all across New York. Wonderful stuff! OK, I now find myself seeking out more

Show More

Westlake titles.

Show Less

Not the best Dortmunder book, but fun none-the-less! John gets put up by a private-eye type, "17 months not a cop" says he, to steal a gold chess set from a bank's vault. And there is also a gold dome that might need some thieving! And, of course, the whole crew gets involved and it's typical

Show More

Dortmunder luck from then on! The story does go on a bit, but the ending is well done! Not so funny after all!

Show Less

Another fun Dortmunder story. Sadly, however, I bought the book by mail from a dealer who advertised the book as "NEW". When I got the book it had someone's name plate on the inside over and the page edges were greyish. But I decided to keep the book, since I love Dortmunder. Imagine my anger,

Show More

anguish and annoyance when I get to the part where you know something is going to go wrong (four pages from the end) and the page has been ripped out of the book!

Needless to say, the book is being returned. But I implore my fellow LT'ers... if anyone with this book in their collection would scan pages 355-356 for me I would be sooo grateful. I could make it a four star book instead of a 3.5, I'm sure, if I just knew what happened! I kind of know, but I would like to find out the how...

Show Less

What’s so funny?
At first reading this is a good, funny criminal romp. But it is different from all the other Westlake Dortmunder reads. For a start it’s longer, unusual for this brilliant author who liked to earn his money in as few paragraphs as possible.
Dortmunder often takes the backseat in

Show More

this book. He is surly, scruffy, preoccupied. In one chapter a young lawyer even mistakes him for a beggar and almost gives him a handout. He is not the slick “ideas criminal” we all know and love.
The people on the pages draw attention to the class divide in our society, they are very real and well drawn in the briefest possible way. Westlake takes delight in backhand swipes at big lawyers and officialdom throughout. The effect is Dickensian (Westlake even mentions this word four times in one paragraph towards the end of the novel).
It is as if DW intended this to be a social comment within a crime story from the very beginning. All the clues are there if you look for them, there is no other reason for the title of the book “What’s so funny?”
In conclusion, I think DW had fun showing us samples of the people who make up this complicated New York (or almost any town) and cleverly weaving them into the yarn. Go back and have another read, almost everyone you know is in this book.

Show Less

Another fun heist story :)

Westlake writes so smooth and as usual things don't quite work out for Dortmunder. A perfect read from start to finish