Status
Call number
Series
Collection
Publication
Description
In a world dedicated to pleasure, one young rebel sets out on a forbidden quest. Published for the first time in a single volume, Tanith Lee's duet of novels set in a hedonistic Utopia are as riveting and revolutionary as they were when they first appeared two decades ago. It's a perfect existence, a world in which no pleasure is off-limits, no risk is too dangerous, and no responsibilities can cramp your style. Not if you're Jang: a caste of libertine teenagers in the city of Four BEE. But when you're expected to make trouble--when you can kill yourself on a whim and return in another body, when you're encouraged to change genders at will and experience whatever you desire--you've got no reason to rebel . . . until making love and raising hell, daring death and running wild just leave you cold and empty. Ravenous for true adventures of the mind and body, desperate to find some meaning, one restless spirit finally bucks the system--and by shattering the rules, strikes at the very heart of a soulless society. . . .… (more)
User reviews
SPOILER, MILD
ends with some Nice Guy bullshit that I could really have done without.
In a world where the least desire is met, our heroine/hero is getting bored. They want something intangibly more that vast technological advances can’t meet. The questions becomes not whether they will find the answer they seek but whether society will let them.
My Thoughts
This is one of
The story also echoes the classic Brave New World, though from a slightly different angle. Where Huxley had an outsider appalled by what he witnessed in this supposed utopia, we have an insider who starts to see the sheen and glitter of their utopia tarnish. And in the most interesting way. Death is nothing in this world. Suicide is the norm, something people do so they can come back with a new body. Yet our narrator suffers loses. The path she takes (and most of her loses are suffered when she is in a female body) makes it so she witnesses death in a very personal way. So that by the time we reach part two of the story, she is now a he and pursuing an entirely different way of life than those around him. The heroine/hero’s narrative is so well-done that this transition feels entirely natural, and the character development is thorough and fascinating.
As you can see, this book is hard to sum up. It’s about a dystopia in sheep’s clothing. It’s about acceptance of the imperfect. It’s about facing death. It’s about gender identity. It’s also just an amazingly fun romp for all that. A future-world adventure with a narrator who starts out a shallow nuisance and becomes something their world has never seen before. It has a rich plot and a great main character. It’s worth the hype it receives.
Final Rating
5/5
This is a pretty familiar storyline now, and it was already a familiar storyline in the 70s. What Lee does with it isn't bad at all, though, and while there are definitely elements one can point to that are clearly a product of the 70s, it feels much less dated than a lot of SF from that era. I particularly liked her approach to world-building: it's very much of the kind that shows you a world from an inhabitant's perspective and expects you to figure it out without hand-holding. There are some interesting and surprising touches to the society she creates, too.
In fact, I think the fun of being immersed in that world and figuring it out as I went along was the best part of the book for me. Which, unfortunately, meant that once I had a good handle on it -- certainly by the time I got to book two -- I wasn't feeling quite as engaged as I was at the start. Which also meant that the things that didn't quite work for me started to bother me a bit more: a small but significant streak of religious mysticism, some ideas about gender that didn't sit quite right, one or two things that really could have done with a bit more description, and an important element towards the end that I found biologically improbable.
In the end, I can't say I found it completely satisfying, but it was worth the read, anyway.
This book was awesome on so many levels.
I believe that I read in
I suppose the idea of an ‘utopian’ city where everyone lives in pampered idleness is not at all original, but I doubt if many paint it as vividly or imaginatively as Lee. One of her great strengths is her ability to paint vivid and colourful images in the reader's mind.
The story concerns a heroine (basically a heroine – as so often with Lee, gender boundaries are fluid) who doesn’t fit in this utopia, and how she continually causes problems and eventually gets banished to the outside desert, and her life out there. I suppose it can be read as an allegory for the journey from dependent adolescence to self-reliant adulthood.
Obviously, from the above, I think this a very good novel, but the thing that is really astonishing me is that Lee can be so extraordinarily prolific an author and yet, as far as I’ve read so far, maintain her standards of quality and inventiveness. Good stuff.